Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

14th December 1882

Fatal Accident To An Iron Ore Miner

Insufficient Warning

The adjourned inquest on the body of Daniel Vickers, a miner, who was fatally injured on the 28th of November last, by the firing of a shot in Messers. Ainsworth's Pit, Cleator Moor, was resumed on Monday evening last at the Derby Arms Hotel, Ennerdale road, Cleator Moor, before Mr. H. J. Whiteside, deputy coroner for the lordship of Egremont, and a jury, of which Mr. Peter Nicholson was foreman. — Mr. W. H. Atkinson watched the case on behalf of the Carron Company, and Mr. Mason on behalf of Messers. Ainsworth. — The first witness called was Thomas Haig, who stated he was employed at the Carron Company's pit. On the 28th November last, while he was at work along with deceased and some other men, a shot was fired in Messers. Ainsworth's pit. The two pits (Messers. Ainsworth's and the Carron Company) opened into each other, and the men could see each other working. There were about 111 feet between where the shot was fired in Messers. Ainsworth's pit and the place where deceased and witness were working in the Carron Company's pit. It was a general custom for the men to give a warning when they intended to fire a shot; and the fuse was never lighted until the men were going away to shelter. There were four men altogether in the place where witness was, including himself and deceased. They could see the men working in Messers. Ainsworth's pit. They were in the "fore breast," about 30 yards away. None of them could see the shot prepared. It was between eight o'clock and a quarter past in the morning when the shot was fire. The men were going to a place of safety, and had got as far as the "flat-sheets" when deceased was struck. The flat sheets were close up to the pillar, and the men would have to get behind this pillar to be in safety. Deceased was in front of witness making for the pillar when he was struck. In witness's opinion deceased was struck with something that came from where the shot was fired. Deceased did not fall. He complained of being hit. He said "Oh, dear, I think my arm is broken." He was taken out of the pit, and walked home all right. He made the remark to witness on going home that if it had not been him (witness) they might all have been in the place. Deceased meant by that that he never heard Messers. Ainsworth's men shout "fire." Witness heard them shout, and told his men to go away as soon as he heard the shout. He could see the fuse as soon as he looked up from the "lump" he was working at. Witness said, "Come on, chaps; they're firing off yonder." The other men with witness heard him shout, and came away, deceased leading. Immediately witness heard the shout "fire," he looked up and saw the fuse burning. There was no communication between the two royalties. The only means of giving warning is by someone shouting. When witness heard the shout he did not see any of Messers. Ainsworth's men. He could not tell from the sound whether the shout came from near the fuse. The men at the fuse might have shouted two or three times before witness heard them. There is an engine in the bottom of the pit, and they could not always discern where the shout came from on account of the noise. The engine was about 30 yards away from witness and his men. There was a bogie off the road at the time, and the engine had been stopped, and the men were shouting to the engineman. The men at the fuse might have shouted before, and witness might not have heard them on account of the noise. It was usual in giving warning of a shot to shout the number of the working. If witness was going to fire he would shout, "Fire in No. 18." The other workmen would then go into a place of safety. Witness would wait until he saw the men get out of the way before lighting the fuse. Sometimes when he had shouted, men had shouted back asking if they were safe in their own place. If he thought they were, he would tell them. If not, he would tell them to get away. When witness heard the shout "fire," he was stooping, working with a pick, and he immediately began to move away. A fuse was generally considered to burn about a foot to the minute. It would be less than a minute from the time witness heard the shout "fire" till the shot went off. — Mr. Mason: so far as the Carron Company is concerned, Messers. Ainsworth's is the only company on that side? — Witness: Yes, sir. — Mr. Mason: So that there is no need to shout the number in that case when they are going to fire. — Witness: These are companies on the other side. They have sometimes to shout to us, but not always. It is not on the same level. — Mr. Mason: How far had you to go from where you were working to get behind the pillar? — Witness: Between six and seven yards — Mr. Mason: How long would it take you? — Witness: About a quarter of a minute — Mr. Mason: How long before had you fired any shots in your company? — Witness: Not any that day. — Mr. Atkinson: Your instructions are to give warning, and you expect to get the same? — Witness: Yes. — Mr. Atkinson: When you turned round you saw this burning? — Witness: Yes. — Mr. Atkinson: Have you any doubt as to where this fuse came from? — Witness: I have no doubt but that it came from Messers. Ainsworth's. Mr. Atkinson: How far had you gone before the man was struck? — Witness: Between six or seven yards — The Coroner: Was there sufficient room for you all behind that pillar? — Witness: Yes, sir. — A Juryman: You say they might have shouted two or three times, and you may not have heard. Is it customary to fire a fuse before there is a reply from the other side? — Witness: No, sir; as a general rule, we wait for a reply. The fuse must have been lighted before I looked up. — James Conway was then called, and stated he was working with Thomas Haig's party. He never heard any shout from the Ainsworth side. Was stooping down at the time, and Thomas Haig came up to him and told him to go on, as they were firing. He said, "Come on, Jim, the hole is lighted." He was walking towards this place where they still went when the shot went off. That was the first shot fired by Ainsworth's men that morning. There was a great deal of noise at the time the shot was fired. If they had heard Messers. Ainsworth's men shout they were going to fire, they would have shouted, "Fire away." That was the rule. They could have heard the shout, notwithstanding the noise, if the other men had shouted hard. — James Holmes, another workman who was with Haig's party, said he heard Messers. Ainsworth's men shout "fire" once. He could not see the fuse. He walked away as soon as he heard the shout. — Mr. Atkinson: You have no doubt as to where the piece came from that struck deceased? — Witness said he had not. — To Mr. Mason: Did not see what stuck deceased. — Mr. Atkinson: Did he drop immediately the shot was fired? — Witness: He said "I think my arm is broken." — The Coroner: Could anything come from the roof immediately above where you were to do this? — Witness: No, sir; it must have come from the shot. — The Coroner: Were there any pieces came about you? — Witness: Yes, there was a small piece struck me on the arm. — To Mr. Atkinson: I was about four yards behind the deceased at the time — To a Juryman: Deceased's arm was towards the hole. We had not time to get away after we heard the men shout "fire." — Dr. Eaton said he was called to see the deceased on the 28th November, at 27, Ennerdale road. Deceased had a smash of the left elbow joint. The bones were broken into several pieces. There was a hole opened into the joint large enough to admit three fingers. The bones of the forearm close to the joint were splintered obliquely downward, and the bone of the upper arm obliquely upwards. It had bled rather freely. He took out the loose bones and placed the arm in splints, and stopped the haemorrhage. Deceased died on the 2nd December. The immediate cause of death was acute inflammation of the joint, and blood poisoning. A stone falling from the roof could not have come with sufficient force to shatter the bone to that extent. It must have been done by something coming very violently. — Charles McAvoy, 110 Long Row, one of the men who was working in Messers. Ainsworth's pit, near to where the shot was fired, stated that a man named John Williams fired the shot. Witness put the charge in the hole and fixed in the fuse. Could see deceased and the other men on the Carron Company's side. There were three of them shouted — witness, Williams, and a man named Joseph Robinson. They got no reply. He saw the people on the Carron Company's side go away after he had shouted a second time. Williams was lighting the fuse at the time. Witness shouted the second time as he was going towards the pillar, and Williamson was lighting the fuse. He got no answer to his shout. It was customary to fire without getting an answer. They very seldom got an answer. — To Mr. Atkinson: I heard nothing about the accident till after the man was taken up the pit. — Joseph Robinson, Cleator Moor, was also working at the place where the fuse went off. He heard Charles McAvoy shout, and witness shouted next, and then John Williams shouted. Witness walked about eleven yards out of the working and shouted the first time, and then he shouted a second time, when he had gone about another eleven yards. The fire had not been put to the fuse at this time. He could see Haig and his party working. They had begun to move before the light was put to the fuse. Witness had about 20 yards to go after shouting the second time before getting safe, and he got behind the pillar before the shot went off. — In answer to Mr. Atkinson witness said he travelled 30 yards while the fuse was burning. — John Cunningham, another workman on the Ainsworth side, said there were several shouts before the shot was fired. — John Williams, the man who lighted the fuse, was then called, and after being cautioned by the Coroner, stated that he shouted "fire," and when he was lighting the fuse he shouted a second time. — The Coroner then summed up, and said the evidence seemed to be somewhat conflicting. There were two royalties underground in which there were parties working. The royalties belonged to different people. Haig and his men were working in the part belonging to the Carron Company, and the other men in Messers. Ainsworth's. The men in Ainsworth's were preparing a shot, and it was a fair inference to draw from the evidence that a piece of stone went from that place to where the men were working in the Carron Company's side, and struck the deceased on the elbow. They would have to consider whether it was customary for the men to shout "Fire" when they were going to light the fuse, and wait for an answer from the other side. They had the evidence of the men in both employs that there was considerable noise at the time the shot was fired. If they were satisfied that those shouts had been given, then no person was to blame for the death of Vicars. — The room was then cleared for the jury to consider their verdict. After consulting some time the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death," but recommended that more care should be exercised in future.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ainsworth, —    Mine Owner  
Atkinson, W. H.    Solicitor  
Conway, James    Miner  
Cunningham, John    Miner  
Eaton, John, Dr.    Doctor  
Haig, Thomas    Miner  
Mason, —    Solicitor  
McAvoy, Charles    Miner  
McVicar, David   20 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Nicholson, Peter    Jury Foreman  
Robinson, Joseph    Miner  
Whiteside, Henry J.    Deputy Coroner  
Williams, John    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Jacktrees (Iron ore)  Jacktrees (Iron ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print