Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

30th November 1882

The Mining Dispute at Birks

In the Chancery Division on Friday, the case of Dixon Wood came before Mr. Justice Pearson. This was an action brought by the plaintiff, Mr. Dixon, the owner of the surface of a mineral estate, called Birks Estate, Arlecdon, against the defendants, Messrs. Crosthwaite, John and Adam Wood, and Thomas Johnson, in order to obtain the decision of the Court as to the respective interests of the parties. The first plaintiff was the surface owner of the estate, and the second plaintiff, Mr. William Crosthwaite, was the tenant or occupier of the surface. The two first defendants, Messrs. John Wood and Adam Wood, were the lessees of the minerals in the estate, and the defendant Thomas Johnson was the owner in fee of the minerals. — Mr. Barber, Q.C., and Mr. Archibald Browne appeared for the plaintiffs; Mr. Eddis, Q.C., and Mr. Phipson Beale for the two defendants Wood; and Mr. Karslake, Q.C., and Mr. Grosvenor Woods for Mr. Thomas Johnson. Mr. Barber, Q.C., in his opening, said this was a case which raised some interesting questions of law which would have to be decided almost entirely upon the construction of ancient documents without the necessity of much oral testimony beyond what might be necessary for the purpose of the explanation of the present condition of things. The limestone, firestone, and clay belonged to Mr. Dixon, but the ironstone and the coal seams belonged to Mr. Johnson and the two defendants, Messrs. Wood. His Lordship would therefore see at once that they had got one of the those cases before the Court in which the ownership of the surface and bottom minerals became severed, which at once opened the door for all those questions as to what were the rights of each claimant. The substantial question raised, to put it very shortly, arose under an agreement, dated in 1840, which contained certain provisions with reference to the payment of compensation for damage caused by the getting and working of the coal and mineral underneath the estate. One of the questions which arose out of this was whether the houses having been built by the lessees on the surface of the land which had been damaged from underneath by former lessees, who had been compensated, the subsequent lessees were entitled to claim the houses as against the owners of the surface. Another question raised was whether, having regard to the terms of the mining privileges contained in the agreement, the mining owner or his lessee was entitled to compensation from the surface owner for any injury that might be caused. The plaintiffs asked to restrain the defendants, Messrs. Wood, from doing anything that would cause a subsidence of the land. It would subsequently appear from the evidence that there had actually been a subsidence of the soil in parts of the estate. The plaintiffs also asked for an injunction to restrain the defendants from working their mines in such a way as to cause damage on the surface. — The case was adjourned.

On the proceedings being resumed on Saturday the learned Judge intimated that if there was any dispute as to the acreage of the land in dispute he should take the evidence in chambers. — The question of acreage was, however, agreed, and evidence was accordingly called in support of the plaintiff's case, the first witness being Mr. Crosthwaite, one of the plaintiffs, who said he was a tenant of the surface of the Birks estate, under Mr. Dixon, and farmed about 200 acres. He had received compensation from the defendants, Messrs. Wood, for damage caused to his farm. Messrs. Wood had made eight boreholes on his land for the purpose of finding mineral. He had observed signs of subsidence on his farm, which took the form of holes and cracks. This subsidence made it very dangerous to drive a horse and cart over the land. — Cross-examination by Mr. Karslake, Q.C.: About 130 acres of his farm were meadow and pasture. The estate varied a good deal as to value for agricultural purposes. His farm was a sheep and cattle farm, and he had never had an accident to his beasts in consequence of the subsidence. Mr. Fearon, who was the predecessor of the defendants Wood, took up fresh land for mining purposes from time to time, and took some of the witness's land. The land that Mr. Fearon took was used to feed his horses upon, and subsequently to drain the water off from his mining operations. Whilst Mr. Fearon held the land compensation was paid to witness for damage to his crops. The defendants, Messrs. Wood, although applied to through witness's solicitor, had not paid him any compensation for loss or damage to his farm caused by mining operations. — Re-examined: Although witness had not applied personally to the defendants, Messrs. Wood, for compensation for damage to his crops, his solicitor had done so. — By the Judge: He had noticed a subsidence for seven or eight years on a certain part of his farm, but on another portion he had noticed a fresh subsidence during the last two years, which was daily getting worse. — Mr. J. N. Dickinson, land agent and valuer, of Whitehaven, deposed that he knew the estate in question in this action, and had made a survey of it in May, 1880. He had made this survey in order to ascertain the damage that had been done by the mining operations of Mr. Fearon. — This was the conclusion of the evidence on behalf of the plaintiff, upon which counsel addressed the Court, and the case was then adjourned until Monday.

The adjourned hearing of the case was resumed on Monday, when the plaintiffs' case was continued, Mr. Archibald Brown arguing that the compensation due to the plaintiffs as surface owners from the defendants as the persons having the mining rights was not satisfied by one payment of £80 an acre under the agreement of 1840, but insomuch as the term of the agreement was for only 21 years, that the compensation was recurring and became due again when the 21 years granted in 1840 expired. — Mr. Eddis, Q.C., then opened the case of the defendants, Messrs. John and Adam Wood. He said that the real question at issue was whether or not the defendants had a right to let down the surface of the land. He did not deny that prima facie a surface owner had a right to support for his land from beneath, but he wished to point out in this connection that it had been the universal experience wherever the hematite ore had been won that the surface had been let down, and that therefore the plaintiffs must have known when they took the land that the surface would be damaged if the mining operations were continued. — Mr. J. D. Kendall, mining engineer, of Whitehaven, was then called on behalf of the defendants, and deposed that he knew the district in which the Birks estate was situated well. It was utterly impossible to work the hematite ore on that estate without letting down the surface. Small parts of a pit might not fall, but as a general rule the entire roof subsided when the iron ore was got out. — The case was then adjourned until Tuesday.

The hearing of this adjourned trial was resumed on Tuesday. — Mr. Henry Woolcock was the first witness called, and, examined by Mr. Eddis, Q. C., he said he was a mineral surveyor and engineer at Whitehaven. He had had 25 years experience of mining in the north of England, and had known the mines under Birks farm since 1861. It would be impossible to work the hematite ore in this district without causing a subsidence on the surface. Subsidence's were of constant occurrence in this particular locality, and the London and North-Western Railway Company and the Furness Railway Company had their lines let down by mining operations. Neither bore holes or pit shafts would cause a subsidence. The houses on the mining land at Birks estate were all necessary for the proper working of the pits. — Cross-examined by Mr. Archibald Brown: There were very few mines indeed in the neighbourhood that had no houses upon the mining land. If there were no houses over the mines it was because the pits were close to towns. Several of the mines near Egremont had no houses upon them, but then the miners lived in the town. — Mr. Isaac Hutchinson, land valuer, stated that he was acquainted with the district where Birks mines were situated. He had been a land valuer for between 20 and 30 years, and he valued the damaged land at Birks farm, for agricultural purposes, at about £2 an acre. — Mr. John Irving, Frizington said that he was 67 years of age, and had worked as a miner in hematite mines, amongst them in the Birks mine. In the case of hematite mines the land was very much let down in working them. He had never in his experience known of a hematite mine where the surface was not let down. It was utterly impossible to work the Birks mine without letting down the surface of the land. — Cross-examined: Witness had actually worked in the Birks pits. Timber was put into the mine in order to keep the roof up. The timber supports lasted sometimes only three months. It was part of his duty to keep the roof in order, and he considered he had succeeded pretty well. There were frequent accidents in hematite mines by falls from the roof. — This concluded the evidence on behalf of the defendants, and Mr. Phipson Beale then addressed his Lordship, arguing that as it was proved to demonstration that the hematite iron ore could not possibly be worked without letting down the surface of land above it, the other side knew perfectly well years ago what would happen, and yet had never made any complaint or taken any action. — Mr. Barber, replied on the whole case, and his Lordship deferred judgment.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Barber, —    Q.C.  
Beale, Phipson      
Browne, Archibald      
Crossthwaite, William      
Dickinson, J. N.    Land Agent  
Eddis, —    Q.C.  
Fearon, —      
Hutchinson, Isaac    Land Valuer  
Irving, John   67 Miner  
Johnson, Thomas      
Karslake, W. W.    Q.C.  
Kendall, John Dixon    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Pearson, —    Justice  
Wood, Adam      
Wood, Dixon      
Wood, John      
Woods, Grosvenor      
Woolcock, Henry    Surveyor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Birks (Iron Ore)  Birks (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print