|
16th November 1882 Egremont Burial Board V. The Egremont Iron Ore Co.[Specially reported for the Cumberland Pacquet] The hearing of this action for an injunction restraining the defendant company from making their mines under the Board's Cemetery, so as to cause injury by the subsidence of the surface, and for damages, was continued on Saturday, before Mr. Justice Fry, in the Chancery Division of the High Court of Justice. The hearing of the action was commenced on Wednesday, and the plaintiff case concluded on Friday. The plaintiff in the action were the proprietors of a cemetery, situated in the parish of Egremont, and the defendants, claiming under Lord Lonsdale the minerals under the land so appropriated, had carried on certain works, the effect of which had been to let down the surface of the cemetery to a very considerable extent and over a considerable area. The defendants justified their acts by alleging that they had a right by an instrument executed by a Mrs. Howgill in 1799 to injure the surface, paying compensation to the owners and occupiers for the damage done. Mr. M. Cookson, Q.C., and Mr. T. A. Roberts (instructed by Mr. Webster, solicitor, Whitehaven) appeared for the plaintiffs; and Mr. Glasse, Q.C., and Mr. Hope (instructed by Messrs Hoyle, Shipley, and Hoyle, solicitors, Newcastle) for the defendants. Mr. Glasse, Q.C., addressed the Court on behalf of the defendant company. He said one of the important elements for consideration in this case was what was the effect of the reservation contained in the lease granted to the defendant company. In connection with this question the case of Ashden v Little, reported in 10th Appeals, bore very strongly. In that case a piece of land on which a cotton mill was erected was sold, reservation being made of all mines and minerals under the soil with the right to take the same at pleasure, compensation being made to the grantee for all damage done. The defendant company also offered without having any knowledge of what the reservation was, to restore at their own expense to the satisfaction of the plaintiff's engineers, and also to make good any damage which might be done in the future. Mr. Justice Fry: That was an act of mere grace and mercy on your part? Mr. Glasse said that was so. The defendant company did not know of the existence of the reservation until the pendency of the present suit. Mr. Cookson, Q.C., said the plaintiff never had the documents. Mr. Justice Fry: I suppose this cemetery is only a small portion of the land comprised in the deed? Mr. Cookson: Yes. Mr. Glasse said the whole cemetery contained about 5 acres, but he could not say what was the total amount comprised in the deed. Mr. Justice Fry: If the whole of the iron ore were close to the surface it might be one thing, and if only a small portion of the ore were so circumstanced it might be another. Mr. Glasse said he had evidence as the iron ore being under this particular part, but he could not give any information with respect to the extent. If at any time more space should be required, it could easily be obtained by the purchase of additional land adjacent to the cemetery. The defendant company had no means of knowing the superincumbent strata above, as the roof of the drift was of ore. It was known, however, that they were near the surface of the ore, and there was nothing to indicate that the ore roof would not continue. The men were blasting on one occasion when the workings suddenly fell in, and were blocked up with sand to the extent of 10 fathoms. Immediately the subsidence took place, every precaution was taken to prevent further accidents, and the drift was stopped. In July of last year (1881) another small subsidence occurred on the surface in the direction of the cemetery wall, and, except as previously stated, there was no sign of damage. Mr. Vincent, who was the pit manager, was of opinion that the outcrop ore might be worked for sometime to come without material interference with the cemetery, by driving a drift of stone alongside the present drift, and sinking one or two small shafts in the cemetery. At the present time, however, the outcrop ore was not being worked at all, the drift having been abandoned. That evidence clearly intimated that there was outcrop ore in the portion of land which was taken in by the cemetery. The outcrop ore was not being worked now in order to comply with the suggestion of the Government Inspector sent down by the Home Secretary to inquire into the matter, the inspector advising that a pit should be sunk 49 feet lower. The evidence undoubtedly showed that if the defendant company went on working, further subsidence would be caused, and the question was whether the company had a right to go on working, or whether his Lordship would by injunction interdict them from doing so. It appeared from the evidence that the pit was sunk to a depth of 18 fathoms 5 feet when the drift was struck off, but the drift went upwards until it came within 80 feet of the surface. The learned counsel quoted a number of authorities in support of his argument, amongst them being the cases of Robart v Wilson, and the Duke of Buccleuch v Wakefield. He submitted that one effect of granting an injunction would be to stop the working of iron ore throughout the whole of the Egremont district, unless the consent of the owners of the surface of the land were first obtained. In the present case the defendant company are quite ready to give the plaintiffs every compensation that was mentioned in the reservation. The evidence proved conclusively that there was no negligent working on the part of the defendant company, and it was also shown that the damage which had been done could not possibly have been avoided. The working operations had been conducted in a skilful manner, and the subsidence of the surface which had occurred was the natural consequence which followed the carrying out of proper and authorised workings. If that was so the limit of the damage was confined to the damage for which compensation was provided by the reservation. The defendant company were very sorry for what had happened in respect to the graves in the cemetery; but the fact that accidents had occurred could not, he contended, impose any additional servitude upon the defendant company. The plaintiffs themselves, in their affidavits, admitted that the ore could not be extracted without letting down the surface, and therefore according to the plaintiffs own showing the limestone between the sand and gravel and the ore was not an efficient protection; but that when the ore was worked to any great extent the limestone broke and gave way. That being so, and the defendant company's evidence showing that it was impossible that the mine could be worked without causing an actual subsidence, he took it that the defendant company was strictly within their right in doing what they had done. The defendant company said they were lawfully exercising rights which had been lawfully conferred upon them. In the exercise of those rights they had no doubt done damage, and they must compensate the owners of the soil, but they were only bound to give compensation according to the terms and limits which were found in the deed. Mr. Justice Fry: What is the reference to damages which you would submit to? Mr. Glasse: They have asked for damages for restoring the graves, and also for damages for restoring the walls. Mr. Justice Fry: That was why I asked you what reference to damages you were willing to submit to. Mr. Glasse: We would submit to a reference for the fair damage to the surface. Mr. Justice Fry: That is to say the corn, grass, and herbage? Mr. Glasse said the defendant company were quite willing to compensate for damage done to corn, grass or herbage; but he submitted that that was the limit of damage to which the plaintiffs were entitled. He submitted that the defendant company had fully made out their case, and that the injunction ought not to be granted. Mr. Hope followed on the same side, pointing out that the shaft was sunk to a depth of 18 fathoms and 5 feet before the drift was struck out, and the working was at a depth of 68 feet below the surface, under that portion of the cemetery which first subsided. Under all the circumstances of the case, he submitted that no sufficient case had been made out to justify the Court to stop the defendant company's working by granting an injunction. Mr. Cookson, Q.C., replied upon the whole case, arguing that, under the will of Lord Lowther, no right to work the mines had been conferred. The defendant company, therefore, had failed to make out their title. At this stage the further hearing of the case was adjourned until Monday. On Monday Mr. Cookson rose to commence his address, when Mr. Justice Fry intimated that he did not wish to hear him further. Mr. Justice Fry, in giving judgement, said the plaintiffs in the present action were the Burial Board of Egremont, and were proprietors of a cemetery situated in that parish. The defendants were an iron ore company who claimed under Lord Lonsdale, and who had carried on certain works underneath the cemetery, the effect of which had been to let down the surface of the cemetery to a very considerable extent, and over a very considerable area. The defendant company justified their acts by alleging that they had a right to work under the cemetery by virtue of an instrument executed in the year 1799. The position of things was this: The plaintiffs claimed under a Mrs. Howgill, who, in the year 1799, was possessed of certain copyhold property situated in the borough or manor of Egremont, and which was enfranchised in the same year. Whether the property which the plaintiffs held was the whole or only a part of the property which was enfranchised in 1799 he did not know. In 1799 Mrs. Braddyl was lady of the manor or borough of Egremont, and, as such, was undoubtedly entitled to the minerals under the land. In that year the lady of the manor, her husband, and her trustees entered into a deed, by which they enfranchised the copyhold land held by Mrs. Howdell, but with a reservation to which he would afterwards refer. The question mainly contested in this case arose upon the effect of that reservation, that question being, did the reservation, or did it not, give to the lady of the manor, and those who claimed under her, the right to let down the surface of the copyhold tenements? Before inquiring into the precise words of the reservation, he would state what he conceived to be the clear law on the point. It was plain that a reservation of minerals or a grant of minerals did not justify the owner of the mineral's in letting down the surface of the soil above; but the right of the owner of the land above to support might, like any other right, be renounced or given up; and the sole question, therefore, was, had the owner of the superincumbent strata renounced or abandoned that right? Before reading the words of the deed, he would inquire whether there was anything in the surrounding circumstances which it was important should be known in order to continue the reservation. It did not appear to him from the evidence that there was any user either throughout the manor or on the particular land now in question. Although there were some traces of there having been old workings somewhere in the neighbourhood, there was no evidence that in the year 1799 there were any mining operations going on, or any established user or custom with regard to getting iron in that district. Then it was important to inquire whether there was anything to show that if the minerals were got they could only be got by disturbing the surface, because it was obvious if that were the case the reservation might have a much larger effect. It appeared that the iron ore lay upon a strata of shale, and it had above it a strata of limestone. Then it appeared that all those strata's had been tilted up to the north, having a dip therefore towards the south, and they terminated in an outcrop towards the north, and were covered over by a deep bed of sand or gravel some 70 or 80 feet in depth. The iron ore therefore was not upon the surface of the land, but some 70 or 80 feet below the sand, or gravel. There was nothing, therefore, to show that the iron ore could not be largely and profitably got without letting down the surface; that it could be so got largely without letting down the surface would appear from this case, because he gathered that large quantities of the ore had been got before any injury was done to the top. He paused there to say that that was merely a reservation of the mines, and as such certainly gave to the grantee no right to let down the superincumbent soil. The reservation went on "with full and free liberty to mine and work." Again he paused to observe that that liberty did not give in itself a right to work so as to destroy the rights of the owner of the soil above. Then the reservation went on to reserve the right "to lay ore, stones, or minerals, on the said lands and premises." And to "erect smelting houses and kilns thereon for smelting, refining or burning thereon, and to make on the said lands, shafts, levels, ways, and roadways, for the purpose of working and for taking away of such ores, stones, and mineral." The powers which he had just read were powers which clearly could not be exercised without injury to the surface. It would be impossible to cast coal, stones, and rubbish on the surface, or to sink shafts without injuring the surface. Then came this clause, "making reasonable satisfaction for all damage which may be from time to time done to the corn, grass, and herbage on the said lands or premises." That was to say, that whatever damage was done was to be reasonably compensated. Those words, in his judgement, did not enlarge the powers so as to render it lawful under that clause to commit damage which but for those words it would not be lawful to do. That appeared to him to be the true construction of the agreement taken by itself. He would now inquire whether there was anything in the decided cases to conflict with that conclusion or to support it. He did not forget the warning of the Master of the Rolls with the danger of construing one deed by another, but at the same time he felt that it was the duty of the Court to make the construction of the instrument as clear as possible. It appeared to him to be plain that the authorities went to show that the mere granting of the right to work the minerals would not justify the working of them so as to commit the damage. That appeared plain from the series of authorities commencing Herriot v Wright and continued by Morton v Smart, and it was shown still more emphatically by the recent case of Davis v Traherne in the House of Lords, that the mere grouping of the power to work with other powers, which in their nature must create damage to the surface, did not show that the power to work was to be increased so as to justify creation of damages. He came, therefore, for those reasons, to the conclusion that although the mines were reserved, the right of the owner of the soil above to support was never interfered with. Another point in the case was that if the owner of the soil above had a just right to support, the defendant company were not justified in doing what they did. It appeared to him that, taking the view which he did of the rights of the parties, Lord Lonsdale and those who claimed under him never had a right to let down the surface, and therefore he must grant the injunction with regard to the subsidence of the surface, and he must direct an inquiry as to the damage sustained by the plaintiffs in respect of that subsidence. The plaintiffs had claimed damages in respect of the smoke nuisance from the steam engines. That part of the plaintiffs case, however, had failed; and, therefore, he must dismiss so much of the suit as related to that matter with costs. Mr. Glasse said, on the question of costs, the defendant company had offered to restore the damage done, and had also offered to refer to arbitration the question affecting future damages. Mr. Justice Fry: But that offer was refused. Mr. Glasse said the offer was refused, but it was made by the defendant company so far back as the 11th of July 1881. Mr. Justice Fry: I cannot give you those costs. Mr. Glasse said that if that was his Lordship's opinion, the defendant company must pay that portion of the costs. He asked his Lordship to restrain the operation of the injunction for a time in order to give the defendant company time to consider whether the company should appeal. The damage was not a thing to be increased, as the defendant company were doing all they could to prevent subsidence. Mr. Justice Fry: The injunction will only go to restraining your working so as to do injury. Mr. Glasse said that was so, but he asked that the operation of the injunction should be restrained for a time. Mr. Justice Fry: One cannot help seeing that destroying the cemetery is to a certain extent a matter of public scandal. Mr. Glasse: There is not likely to be any fresh subsidence. Mr. Cookson: We received a telegram on Friday to the effect that a fresh crack had appeared right across the entrance to the cemetery. Mr. Glasse said no one regretted the scandal more than the defendant company. He asked the court to suspend the operation of the injunction for a month to enable the defendant company to consider whether they would appeal. If time was not granted, the works would be entirely stopped, and a number of workmen thrown out of employment. Mr. Justice Fry: I think I must suspend the injunction for a fortnight. I am not stopping your works, I am only stopping your working so as to injure. Mr. Glasse: We have a number of men now shoring up so as to prevent any further subsidence. Mr. Justice Fry: My injunction will not restrain that. Mr. Cookson asked if his Lordship proposed to dismiss the claim so far as the nuisance of smoke was concerned. Mr. Justice Fry: Yes, I must dismiss that. You did not press for an injunction, and you did not open any serious case upon that. Mr. Cookson said the form of injunction might be to restrain the defendant company, their servants and agents, from getting the minerals under the cemetery so as to let down the surface; and then an inquiry as to the damages sustained by plaintiff by reason of injury to the said cemetery or burial ground, and the buildings, walls, roadways, and places in the cemetery.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||