14th November 1882
High Court Of Justice
Certain parts of the Egremont Cemetery have fallen in, in consequence of workings of hematite Iron ore by the defendant company. The plaintiffs pleaded that considerable injury and desecration had occurred to vaults, tombstones, and graves in
consequence, and claimed an injunction to restrain the working of the ore so as to cause farther subsidence, and damages for past injury. Then was also a claim in respect of smoke nuisance, but that given up. The defendants justified their action as
being licensees from an agent of Lord Lonsdale, the tenant for life, with power to grant leases of the minerals on the ground that the original document reserving the minerals to the predecessor of Lord Lonsdale authorised the working of mines in
such manner as to cause subsidence, on paying merely agricultural damage. Both parties derived title under a deed of enfranchisement executed in 1799, which reserved to the lord of the manor "all mines and quarries of copper, lead, iron, coal, and
stone, and other mines and minerals whatsoever then opened and worked, or thereafter to be opened and worked within the lands and premises thereby enfranchised, or any part thereof, with full and free liberty to own and work the same, to lay the ore,
coal, stones, and rubbish when got on the said lands and premises, and to erect and make smelting homes and kilns thereon for the melting, refining, and burning thereof, and to make all kinds of shafts, levels, ways, and roads for that purpose. and for
the taking away such ore, stones, mines, and minerals, making a reasonable satisfaction for all damages to be thereby from time to time done to the corn, grass, or herbage on the said lands and premises to the owners or occupiers thereof." The
important question between the parties was whether that reservation gave a right to let down the soil. The plaintiffs also asserted that even if a lessee under a lease granted by the tenant for life of the manor in accordance with the power in the
instrument of settlement of the Lonsdale estates, had the power lo work in the manner complained of, the defendant had not got such lease.
Mr. Cookson, Q.C., and Mr. T. A. Roberts appeared for the plaintiffs; Mr. Glasse, Q.C., and Mr. Herbert F. Hope for the defendants.
His Lordship said the first question was what was the construction to be put upon the reservation of minerals in the deed of enfranchisement of 1799. Did it or did it not give the Lord of the manor, and these claiming under him, a right to let down the
surface? Prima facie, the owner of the surface has aright to support. That right may be abandoned; the question was, did that deed operate to take away that right? The surrounding circumstances at the time of the deed should be looked at. There was
no evidence that any mining operations were then being carried on, or that there was an established user in the district in favour of a right to let down the soil. His lordship considered the nature of soil, and observed that the ore could be largely
got without letting the soil down; for, in fact, it had to be so got before the in-fall took place. Upon the words of the reservation it was to be observed that the first part of it was a simple grant or reservation of mines, which did not give any
right to let down or destroy the surface. In the next place certain powers were given to the owner of the minerals to do certain works on the surface, for Instance, to drive shafts, erect smelting houses, and do other things which could not be done
without injury to the surface, and it was to such injury only that the provision for reasonable satisfaction for damages to corn, grass, or herbage, applied. It became, therefore, unnecessary to decide whether the defendants had authority to do what
they were doing as lessees or agents for Lord Lonsdale, and be must grant the injunction asked, with an inquiry at to damages.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cookson, — | | Q.C. | |
| Glasse, — | | Q.C. | |
| Hope, Herbert F. | | | |
| Lonsdale, Lord | | Land Owner | |
| Roberts, T. A. | | | |