|
19th August 1882 Trimdon Grange Colliery ExplosionThe report of Mr. T. W. Snagge, barrister-at-law, on the explosion which occurred at Trimdon Grange Colliery, 11 miles from Durham, on Feb. 16, has been published in the form of a Blue-book. Altogether 69 persons were killed. The coroner's jury found that they lost their lives by an explosion of gas in the Pit Narrow Board Long-wall, in the Harvey Seam of the Trimdon Grange Colliery, but from what cause the explosion took place there was not sufficient evidence to show. They recommended that in future no shots be fired in the day time, or during the time the men are in the pit, within 40 yards of a standing or falling goaf, and they also recommended that more deputies be employed in the pit, and that a general report book be kept, and that each official's report book be copied into this daily book. Mr. Snagge's report states that the evidence of the medical witnesses by whom the bodies were examined was very clear and full as to the cause of death in every case. In the Pit Narrow Board district, for a short distance east, west, and north of the "Second South" way, no less than 11 bodies were found with injuries which left no doubt that death had resulted from burning alone. Only one other body in the pit presented the same appearance, namely — that of Maitland, which was found near his place at the end of the Headways Narrow Board workings and in close proximity to a burnt brattice cloth. In the other instances, where marks of burning were found on the bodies, it was stated by the medical experts that the immediate cause of death was either violence or after-damp. Two theories as to the cause of the disaster were put forward during the inquiry. Mr. Nicholas Wilkinson, who, as a pitman of 34 years' experience had taken an active and praiseworthy part in the exploration and search after the accident, thought there were two explosions, that the first commenced with the "flushed kitty" at Maitland's place, forced its way round to the Pit Narrow Board goaf, and drove the gas there on to the men's lamps, thus causing a second explosion. In this theory Mr. Bell and Mr. Willis, Her Majesty's Inspectors, did not agree — Mr. Bell pointed out that an interval would have occurred, had there been two explosions, and the men in the Cross Cut district would have felt two shocks, whereas it was in evidence that they felt but one. In the opinion of Mr. Bell and the other scientific witnesses there was but one explosion — namely, at the working face of the Pit Narrow Board, and the blast from this explosion rushed through the whole pit. With regard to the cause of the explosion, Mr. Bell, Mr. Willis, and the other scientific witnesses were agreed that the normal velocity of ventilation in the Pit Narrow Board working face would not be sufficient to drive the gas through the flame of the Davy lamp. The ordinary velocity in the long-wall working places would probably not exceed three or four feet per second, and it would take about seven and a half feet per second to send the flame through the Davy lamp. In Mr. Bell's opinion the explosion was to be accounted for by "a fall in the goaf, or what might be called a ‘squeeze,' which would bring the gas down with sufficient force to increase its velocity. The force of gas coming down, added to the normal force of the wind, would increase the force up to the point that would drive it through the gauze of the lamp." Mr. Bell added that, in his own experience, when watching deputies drawing timber, he had had his lamp blown out by the force of a fall of roof, a fact which satisfied him that "the force of a fall would be sufficient to blow the gas through the gauze." The report considers that there is no room for doubt that the explosion had its origin in the Pit Narrow Board district, and that it was caused by the diffusion of a sudden "squeeze" or outburst of gas forced, with accompanying dust, towards the working face by a heavy fall of roof over the northern edge of the Narrow Pit Board goaf, and driven out with a velocity which sent the flame through a miner's lamp. The result of the inquiry was a further proof, if further proof were needed, that the Davy lamp afforded no security whatever against the occurrence of grave disasters of a similar kind, and that its employment in dusty mines during long-wall working operations, carried on under conditions of ventilation and roof formation similar to those prevailing in Trimdon Grange Colliery, ought to be absolutely prohibited. The suggestion of the jury that a general report book, containing a digest of all the report books of all the subordinate officials, should be entered up daily and kept in the manager's office, was considered excellent. It was proved during the inquiry that report books, which by the special rules were required to be entered up daily, were kept by subordinate officials, who, though excellent pitmen, could neither read or write. In one instance the entries were made by the hand of the schoolmistress. Although the cause of the explosion could not be traced to "shot firing," it was proved during the inquiry that shots had been fired in working places where, in Mr. Bell's opinion, powder should not have been used, and that these were of the nature of the "blown out" or "cannon" shots mentioned by Her Majesty's Commissioners in their preliminary report as having apparently become "more frequent since the use of cartridges instead of loose powder was made compulsory by Act of Parliament," and as constituting "an especial danger" in pillar working or in the long-wall face. In conclusion Mr. Snagge reported that the Trimdon Grange Colliery explosion does not appear to him to be a case in which any prosecution should be instituted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||