Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

15th June 1882

The Wiliam Pit Explosion

Prosecution Of The Agent And Manager

At a special court of the Whitehaven magistrates, on Tuesday (before C. Fisher, Esq. (in the chair), H. H. Watson, Esq., W. Jackson, Esq., H. Jefferson, Esq., and H. M. McKenzie. Esq.) Gerrard Henry Liddell, of Moresby Hall, agent of the Whitehaven Colliery, and William Harker, of Catherine-street, manager, where charged with neglect of duty in respect of the rules laid down for their guidance in the Coal Mines Regulation Act. The court was well filled by a respectable audience, the bulk of whom appeared to belong to the colliery. — Mr. Webster appeared for the prosecution; and Mr. John Edge (barrister, Manchester) appeared for the defendants, instructed by Messrs. Lumb and Howson.

Mr. Webster suggested that the case of Mr. Harker should be taken first, and this being agreed to, he continued to say that in this case he appeared in support of an information which had been laid by Mr. James Willis, one of Her Majesty's Inspectors of mines, and superintendent of the Newcastle district, which includes Northumberland, Cumberland, part of Durham and part of Lancashire. And the information was laid in respect of an offence committed under the 55th section of the Coalmines Regulation Act, rule 1, which he proposed to read to the Bench. It started — "The following general rules shall be observed, so far as is reasonably practicable, in every mine to which this act applies." That was the heading of the section; and then the first general rule is as follows:— "An adequate amount of ventilation shall be constantly produced in every mine to dilute and render harmless noxious gases to such an extent that the working places, and the shafts, levels, stables, and workings of such mines, in the travelling roads to and from such working places, should be in a fit state for working and passing therein." Now, it appeared that on the 25th April last an explosion took place in the Whitehaven Colliery, which was the subject of an inquiry before the coroner of this district, and certain gentlemen attended that inquiry, and certain reports were made to the Home Office, and inconsequence of these reports Mr. Willis was directed to take proceedings in the present case against Mr. Harker. Mr. Webster proceeded to describe William Pit, and to point out, by means of plans with which the magistrates were supplied, where the explosion took place, in what is called the Countess District. At the termination of what is called "Tait's Cross-cut," a fault was found by which the coal was driven down 16 fathoms; and in order to get down to it a drift was made in stone, and a brattice was put down the centre in order that they might have good air at the forehead of the drift, that was an efficient brick brattice. When they got the stone drift something like 184 yards in length, and a little beyond the pump marked on the plan, they got into coal, and then drove back again along what was called the "back drift," and so again through the fault, and into the main air course of the pit. There were thus two air courses running parallel to one another and by that means they were able to get two holes through the fault, and had a perfect system going down the stone drift and running back up the back drift. Then they thought it necessary at the bend or junction between these two drifts, to drive forward (the drifts ran north) in a direction west and then south; and it was at this extreme south-west point that it was supposed the explosion of the 25th April took place. What the prosecution said was that the mine should have been so managed that the ventilation should have proceeded down the stone drift and along the coal drift, and so out at the main air-course. Instead of which it appears that some two months previous to the explosion a fall had taken place in what is called the fault, and the ventilation was thereby impeded. Before that fall took place, he was instructed, a considerable portion of the brattice which was in the back drift had been removed, finding it was no longer necessary, but as soon as ever the fall took place in the "trouble," then it was found necessary to restore the brattice. The fall took place in the back drift. The coal was giving off a considerable quantity of gas, and in order to get that gas away it was necessary that the brattice should be restored so that the air should travel down the stone drift up to the place where they were working the coal, then down to near where the "trouble" was, and then along the back drift. The magistrates would find in the evidence that this fall took place, impeding the principal ventilation of the pit; and they would find also that in this back drift, in consequence of the fall, and in consequence of the inefficient ventilation, gas accumulated. It was not carried away in the same way as it would have been if the place had been open. Such had been the accumulation of gas that it had reached to within a distance of 15 yards of a canvas door near the bend or junction between the stone drift and the back drift. Notwithstanding the defendants were aware that the gas had approached to that distance up against the air, men were allowed to work in the south-west point already alluded to with all this gas behind them in the back drift? That the inspector would tell them was a most suicidal, policy and a great error of judgment on the part of the manager of the men. It was the duty of the manager to see that this air course through the trouble was kept open before he permitted people to work there, and that that was the best way of ventilating this particular district, called the Countess District. It so happened, as the Bench were all aware, that on the 25th April this explosion took place and no less than four men lost their lives by what the prosecution called the defective ventilation of the mine. But it was not for the Bench to determine where there was an explosion, but whether there was an adequate amount of ventilation kept up by the best practical means, and there the prosecution would satisfy them there was default. — Mr. Webster then proceeded to call evidence.

Edward Martin was the first witness called. He is a coalminer, aged 33, living at the Newhouses, one of the men in William Pit at the time of the explosion, and the only one of five in the particular part where the explosion occurred who escaped. They were working at the forehead, or end of the drift in the Countess district, with "Geordie" lamps, which are a safer lamp than the lamps generally used in the pit, because the coal was new and consequently more dangerous on account of giving off gas. They placed their lamps one on a "copy" and the other on the end of a bucket. They turned to "doff" themselves to set to work when they saw fire. If he could tell what caused the fire he could tell them all. He could not tell that. They would not be five minutes in before they saw the fire. They then ran out. When they saw the fire there was no explosion. It was not a flash. He did not know how long it remained; he did not stop to see. (Laughter) He had perhaps ran a distance of 30 yards, and was still in the coal drift, in the first "thirling," when he was knocked down. There was then a noise of an explosion from behind, and he was thrown forward. When he went into his work that night he found gas in the second thirling and the approach to the second thirling. He found the gas showing in his lamp. He did not find gas at the pump. They found it at the forehead; it never did extend more than a yard from the forehead. That quantity of gas would not have been sufficient to cause an explosion such as there was that could knock him down. He did not know how the explosion had occurred. — Mr. Watson said if the gas was properly mixed with air there would be plenty to knock a man down; the answer that it would not was only that of an ignorant man. The Chairman said some of these questions were of a scientific nature, and should not be put to an ordinary workman. — Mr. Webster said there might be some difficulty, because Mr. Liddell, for instance might claim privilege. — Mr. Edge said that was not so; Mr. Liddell was here to answer any question that was put to him. Both cases could be taken together, and Mr. Liddell could give evidence in Mr. Harker's case and Mr. Harker in Mr, Liddell's case. — Cross-examined by Mr. Edge, Martin said he and the men with him worked by the day and not by the shift, and had directions that if there was gas they had to come out. They tested for gas and did not find more than usual. The coal was always giving gas off, but there was no standing gas. Had there been any they would come out at once. There had never been any complaint at any time of want of ventilation. The overmen regularly tested the place for gas. When they opened up a new seam of coal, gas keeps coming off for some time and the air sweeps it away. There was plenty of good air to sweep it away.

Joseph Wilkinson, master wasteman, of William Pit, said his duty was to travel the return and intake as well of the Countess District, and to report daily with regard to what he saw. He produced his report-book. He remembered a fall in the return, or back drift, on the 23rd March, which stopped ventilation in the slope drift in the trouble, and he put 100 yards of air pipe to make ventilation. He made that report in his report-book. When he said "stopped" in his report, he did not mean that the ventilation quite ceased, but that it was "as near stopped as could be." At that time the coal was giving off gas to some extent, as new districts do. When the fall took place had removed the brattice, but in consequence of the fall put it back right up to the place. On the 13th of April a second fall took place. He entered that in his report-book. It was in the trouble, same place as the other. Kept up the brattice to the place. It was kept up to the 25th April. He knew that, because he went round and examined the air-course from the trouble right away to the end of the drift two or three days a week. He never went "choke up" to the trouble after the second fall. After the first fall he went "choke up" to the trouble twice or three times, and did not come back by the return. Therefore he did not know whether there was gas in the return or not; it was not his duty to do so. Sometimes he went only 15 or 16 yards to wards where the fall was. He did not go further, because he found a little "top" on his lamp. That meant gas. He did not go to see how far the gas extended, because they never travelled in gas; but he thought there was plenty of air to drive it away. — Mr. Webster observed that the witness was then travelling with the air, which had not yet reached the face of the coal; and therefore the inference was that all beyond was gas. — Witness, continuing, said he would then be about 80 yards from where the fall took place. The gas would get worse as he went further, because there would be so many "feeders." He thought it was not necessary to go further. There was gas there before the fall, and witness thought the brattice was quite as good as the air-course open. Wood brattices are given to leak. They are not as good as a stone brattice. There would be 96 or 97 yards of wood brattice; but it was plastered, and there was no danger of leakage when plastered. Witness produced his report-book, showing that he very frequently examined the district and found gas. He gave the report to Mr. Harker, who would be aware therefore that every day almost there was gas. The gas was not explosive. He never said it was explosive. Wherever gas was being made "Geordie" lamps were used. — Mr. Watson said for fear the witness should be misunderstood it was well to explain that any gas that will burn is explosive, but in order to be explosive it must be mixed with a certain proportion of air. — Mr. Edge said he would have witnesses of large experience who would explain that, if it should ever be necessary to call them. — Mr. Edge cross-examined the witness, showing that every precaution was taken to insure perfect ventilation. They were clearing away the fall of the slope pit when the explosion took place. The quantity of air passing round the working was the same now, and was passing round in the same way now, as before the explosion. The Government officials had been down the pit since the explosion, and no complaint had ever been made of imperfect ventilation. The air that was passing by the return had to return ultimately by the nine-foot pit, which he examined every time he went into the district. That enabled him to judge whether the air was sufficiently dispersing and diluting the gas that was given off in the return. He always found the air preserving its proper course, and the gas given off would be carried up the upcast shaft. — Mr. Webster read the rule as to keeping the working places and travelling roads clear of gas by the master wasteman, and asked the witness whether it was not his duty to have travelled the return. — The witness said when he found gas he travelled another way so long as he was assured that the place was properly ventilated. — Mr. Watson said it was not possible for the roads to be kept free of "noxious gases;" all that could be done to dilute them sufficiently, so that they should not be in a "noxious" state. — Mr. Webster said that was the expression in the rules, and he must abide by them. — Mr. Watson: Then the rules are wrong. (Laughter.)

John Rothery, overman, said he had daily supervision of the Countess district, and reported to Mr. Harker. In a new district near a trouble there was more gas given off than that in an ordinary place. He inspected — specially that dangerous district — almost daily. It was his duty to travel the air courses. He could not say how long it was before the 25th April, when the explosion took place, that he visited the return where the fall of the 23rd March took place. He knew that there was a fall and that the ventilation was interfered with. It might have been three or four days before the explosion that he was there. It might be a week. He did not think it would be ten days. It might be a week, or it might be shorter. The last time might be about the 20th; he did not go afterwards. He had reports from the master wasteman, and he reported to Mr. Harker. — Was it a safe thing for these men to be working at the face of the second thirl with all this gas behind them in the coal drift? — Witness said it was. — Mr. Edge said Mr. Webster was not treating his clients fairly. He was trying to put before the Bench several charges, which the prosecution had not dared to formulate after three months delay. — Mr. Webster said there was a report made by a certain person to the Treasury and the director of public prosecutions directing Mr. Willis to take these proceedings. — Mr. Edge said in that case Mr. Webster was trying to prove more than the public prosecutor wished him to prove. If they had formulated this charge, whether it was safe to have these men working where they were, his clients would have had half the viewers in the North of England there. He would not wish the Bench to think he wished any facts kept back; but Mr. Webster was steering clear of the charge formulated and going into others they had not taken. — Mr. Webster said he must show that Mr. Harker knew there was gas. — Mr. Edge said that was not denied. — Mr. Webster then continued his examination of Rothery. — He asked whether the ventilation would be as good with brattice as with stone open air course, and the witness replied that the stone course would be more efficient. — Cross-examined by Mr. Edge, witness said the fall of the 22nd March was clear in two days. The fall of the 13th April choked it again. Efforts were made to clear it, but there was a difficulty in doing so on account of the gas coming off. When this district was first opened and was giving off gas it was "laid by" for five months, the men being withdrawn. Witness never found gas "standing"" in any of these drifts; there was always sufficient ventilation to carry it away. There was never any complaint made to him. There had never been any complaint made since by the Government Inspectors, and it was the same now as before. Some days before and after the last fall witness found the gas nearly explosive at the "staple." It would perhaps be a week or ten days before the explosion. He reported it on the 16th April "showing a heavy top". Mr. Webster: Did you not say before the coroner that that was three or four days before the explosion? — Witness: Well I could not say to a few days.

Gerrard H. Liddell said he was agent for the Whitehaven Collieries, and had been for over five years. Mr. Wm. Harker was the certificated manager of William Pit. He explained the object of the various drifts, and said they were the proper means of effecting ventilation. A method Mr. Webster suggested by which it might have been done, he said was equally good, but he would not admit it was better. Mr. Moore wrote to witness to London to say that a fall had taken place in the trouble on the 22nd March, and fouled both the intake and return but that the brattice was restored, and all was going on well, although there was still a great quantity of gas being given off. The second fall took place on the 13th April. Steps were taken on the two Sundays, the 16th and 23rd, to restore that, but they could not do it. The ventilation was never at fault after the second fall. After the first fall, although they had restored the communication, they left the brattice as well, in case of a similar mishap. Altogether they had bratticed over 300 yards. That was not the best mode, but it was the best under the circumstances. Considered it was reasonably safe, to have gas in the return behind these men working in the second thirl. — By Mr. Edge: No suggestion was ever made to him about deficiency of air. Mr. Willis never suggested to him that there was not enough air or that he should increase it; nor, after the explosion, did he make such a suggestion. No such suggestion was made at the inquest either. There were two Government inspectors at the inquest, but no intimation was given to witness that his plan for opening up this part of the colliery was an immature one. — Witness was cross-examined by Mr. Webster as to the means he might have taken to improve the ventilation, and the cost of cutting the necessary drifts for that purpose. He said a crosscut might have been made between the first and second thirls, at a cost of £200, for the purpose of making a permanent stone air course. Such an air course was not made, not because of the cost, but because it would require to have been blasted, and that was considered an extremely dangerous course.

The Court adjourned for ten minutes at half-past one, Mr. Edge announcing, in answer to the chairman that the case would be finished in a couple of hours.

William Harker deposed that he is the certificated manager of the Whitehaven Colliery since the Act of 1872 or 73. He was overman for 15 years before that. It is 37 years since he first commenced working in coalmines. He remembered making a communication to Mr. Moore, which was the subject of a letter from that gentleman to Mr. Liddell. He said that the fouling of the pit was only "so far" as far back as the pumps, in both intake and return. That was in consequence of the brattice having been taken down and the fall in the coal drift, right in the trouble. It would be fouled about 140 or 150 yards. He had word that it was fouled on the 22nd March. It would be reported by both Rothery and Wilkinson. He got the report from John Rothery, whose report-book was produced. There was such a quantity of gas giving off in this 150 yards of back drift as would fill it up in a few hours. He could not positively say, because he never measured the quantity of gas given off; but he thought it might have filled in three or four hours — it was only a small place and would not take long to fill. — Mr. Webster examined the witness to show that the back drift was not of small dimensions, and that a large volume of gas must have collected in it in a very short time. He replied that the capacity of the back drift would be about the same as that of the stone drift. — Witness continued that he had been up the back drift about 16 yards, after the second fall took place. He saw it on the 24th March. He was not in on the 21st April. He was in on the 20th, when he went 16 yards up the back drift. There was no gas to prevent him going further. He came across a little blue top on his lamp. It would be about 70 yards further than that that the fall had taken place. He did not go further because he knew there was a good draught of air. It was the duty of the master wasteman to see that the drift was not foul. — Mr. Webster wanted the Witness to say that he did not do his duty in this respect; but the witness held in his reply to the fact that it was not necessary to travel where there was gas when the fact that there was sufficient ventilation could be proved at another place, where the air after it had passed through the drift could be examined. — The Chairman said it appeared to him that no person had ever been through this back drift after the first fall. — Mr. Webster said that was what he wanted to show. — Examined by Mr. Edge: The only way to remove gas was by turning air in. It would not be prudent to follow where gas was showing. The object of rule 146 was to prevent men going where gas showed on the lamp. There was no means by which you could prevent gas coming out, and witness's instructions to the wasteman were that if he found the ventilation as good as usual he was not to go further when gas cap showed on his lamp. The second thirl was being driven round so as to join the first thirl and take the ventilation right round. They could not have an upcast shaft nearer than they had because it was largely under the sea. No complaint had ever been made of the ventilation, nor was it ever suggested that the Countess district was improperly opened out. It was perfectly safe for the men to be working where they were, because there was air to drive it round. — Mr. Webster: It was the duty of somebody to find that out. — Mr. Edge: That may be the public prosecutor's idea, but I should just like to have him here to cross-examine him. — Re-examined by Mr. Webster: It is the duty of a common workman to retire before gas. My duty when I find gas standing is to get it moved as soon as possible. (Laughter) The gas was not standing in this case. It was his duty to increase the ventilation if he thought it necessary. In this case he did not think it necessary. The gas was not explosive. There was an explosion. He never could ascertain that the ventilation had slackened any. There was any amount of ventilation and the gas was always on the move. He did not know how the explosion took place. — By Mr. Edge: From 10,000 to 11,000 cubic feet of air per minute was passing through the working. The last measurement was made last Sunday. The same quantity was passing before the explosion.

Mr. John Boland Atkinson said he was one of Her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines for Newcastle district. On the 3rd May, at the request of Mr. Willis, he visited William Pit, and examined the Countess district so far as he could at that time. Mr. Liddell, Mr. Harker, and the master wasteman were with him. They went down the stone drift to the pump. He saw the brattice had been thrown down — probably a quarter to a half of it. Of the brick brattice there was about 180 yards. They could not examine any further than the pump in consequence of gas and water. Witness saw that a considerable quantity of gas was coming through the water at the continuation of the stone drift which ends in coal. It was bubbling through the water in large quantities. He had no doubt gas would be coming off from other parts. The men working at the pumps had no lamp with them, but a man was some yards away holding a lamp for them. That indicated considerable danger. If that gas had exploded it would have been dangerous. — Mr. Edger: Are we charged with neglect on the 3rd May? — Mr. Webster: No, but we have no witnesses who were there at the time, and I wish to show if that was the state of the working then what it would be at the time of the accident. — Mr. Brockbank: But there had been an explosion then, and great damage done. Witness continued to say that he would expect a little less gas on the 3rd May than at the time of the accident. — By Mr. Watson: Ascertained that the gas was explosive because he saw it exploded in a lamp. — The Chairman said after the explosion they would work more carefully in consequence of the damage that had been done. That was no proof that the place was in ordinary circumstances so dangerous. — Witness continued to say that the gas showed within a yard or two of the brattice, so that there must have been a good deal of the gas giving off. — Mr. Edge asked whether they were there to show that they did everything they possibly could on the 3rd May. — Mr. Webster: Perhaps not. But this witness tells us what was the state of the pit on the first occasion it was inspected after the accident. — Witness continued to say that bratticing was not desirable where it could be avoided. It was, he thought, objectionable to have such a length of bratticing. It was the more so in consequence of the proximity of a trouble, which made the prevalence of gas the more likely. He thought the use of bratticing was unreasonable. He would have opened the hole up the trouble. There was no difficulty more than ordinary about that. A more than reasonable length of wood brattice was made use of. There were 166 yards of wood brattice, which was liable to leak. It was objectionable, seeing the quantity of gas given off. It was more liable to be displaced, liable to warp, and was generally not so substantial as brick. — Mr. Webster asked whether it was safe to have the men working where they were. — Mr. Edge said that was not the question before the court, and the Chairman said that question was disposed of by the coroner's inquest. — The Chairman said there was one question he would like to ask. Was it practicable to work a large mine like this without with out bratticing? — Witness: No. — The Chairman: Then it is a question of reasonable quantity. — Witness: Yes. — Mr. Webster proceeded to put a question on the assumption that there was an accumulated body of gas; and to this Mr. Edge objected, and the question was abandoned. — Witness continued: The evidence indicated that there was considerable gas coming off. That might be removed in different ways, but he thought the best would have been to open the place closed by the fall. The gas ought to have been cleared away, or men ought not to have been working there. — Did it show good workmanship to work forward when they had lost their air course behind? — Mr. Edge said they never did lose their air course, and there was no evidence to show that they had. — By Mr. Jackson: An overman should not follow gas up at once, but he should make it his first duty to see that it was clear afterwards — to clear it away so that he could follow it afterwards. — Witness was cross-examined with a view to show he did not know the pit. He admitted that he had never seen the "slope pit." He would not swear that Mr. Harker and Mr. Liddell told him that they were unable to clear the slope pit. Assuming that they could not clear the slope pit, they should have made another slope pit near to it, and not to have attempted to carry the air round by the bratticing. He did not know that he ever suggested to any of them that their design of opening out that district was defective. He did not inform his mind as to whether the ventilation was the same after the accident as before, so as to warn the persons in the colliery that there was danger. He had instructions what to do. He reported to Mr. Willis what he found, and beyond that he did not act. He told Mr. Liddell he thought it was an improper system. — Mr. Edge: Why did you not tell me that, when I have been pressing you for it for the last ten minutes. — Witness: I understood you referred to an official and formal warning. — Re-examined by Mr. Webster: I am aware that an opening could be made through a fault without having seen it; and there would be no difficulty about it. They told him they were going to adopt the very plan he thought would have been best, and, therefore, there was no necessity of calling their attention to the present plan as defective.

James Willis, the inspector for the district, said he had had 30 years experience as a practical miner, seven or eight years in this district, and previous to that in Durham district — altogether, inspector for eleven years. Investigated as to the cause of this explosion. On the 27th April he could only get as far as the nine-foot staple — not down to where the pump was. There was a disturbance of materials, and the gas was standing in the stone drift. The brattice had been thrown down. He did not think there had been a large quantity of gas, but it had considerable force. He judged of that from the damage done, which showed that the force of the explosion was in the return. On the 2nd May got into the second thirl, to the face. Had an opportunity of examining it pretty carefully. The back drift was not examined. It was not wise to go in, in consequence of the gas giving off. He had heard there was about 100 yards of brattice. The brattice must be used in the first instance, but as soon as the holing is made up that holing should never have been abandoned until it was thoroughly opened. Whatever the difficulties there were about the slope the difficulties should have been overcome. He would not have been disposed to use so much brattice. If he had been making these two drifts, the stone drifts and the coal drift, he would have been disposed to have had a thirl across between them at whatever cost — about half way. Even at £200 it would be a great consideration; but he could not think such a thirl would have cost £200. However, knowing the danger of this place, he would have had a cross cut even if it coast £200. — Mr. Webster wished to ask whether Mr. Willis thought there had been "reasonable means" to avoid an offence against the act. — Mr. Edge objected to Mr. Willis answering this question. He was an inspector of the Home Office, and the Home Office did not direct this prosecution, but the public prosecutor. If he answered the question he would be giving his judgment as to whether this was a reasonable prosecution or not. — The Bench thought the question was proper, and Mr. Willis said he thought the prosecution was reasonable. — By Mr. Edge: I would have prosecuted myself. I don't know that I thought of prosecution before the 12th May. I did not specially warn Mr. Liddell or Mr. Harker then, but at the first investigation I made inquiries why they had abandoned the slope and reverted to the brattice. Brattices are frequently used in deep workings, and I have seen up to 100 yards of it. I don't know whether there may be a difference of opinion about it, but gentlemen of skill avoid the use of brattice. Whatever were the difficulties as to the second fall, I would never have abandoned it until it was removed. It was said the gas was coming up. I would have introduced more air to get rid of it. I should have kept the ventilation open in the back drift in the same way as they were doing. But in the original winning, to reduce the amount of brattice, I would have introduced a thirling half way between the stone drift and the back drift. I have no reason to suppose that the brattice was not good. Professional views as to the best means of ventilation differed in the same way as views in the legal profession.

This was the case for the prosecution.

Mr. Edge said: I have some scientific evidence to call; but sir, in the first place, I would submit with some confidence I have no case to meet. The charge against us is not a charge of breach of rule in not withdrawing men from a dangerous place. If that was the charge I would be prepared to meet it. The charge against us is not that the wasteman did not go down the back drift and make a report. The only charge formulated against us is under the first general rule, which is governed by the two first lines of the section. The section provides thus: — "The following general rules shall be observed, so far as is reasonable and practicable in every mine to which this act applies." "So far as reasonable and practicable." So that what the act says is this: You shall, so far as is reasonable and practicable, fulfil the general rules specified. It doesn't say: You shall under all conditions guarantee that you shall fulfil the general rules. These general rules are limited and the liability is limited, by the words "so far as is reasonably practicable." Well, what we are charged with is failing to have an adequate amount of ventilation "to dilute and render harmless noxious gases to such an extent that the working places, and the shafts, levels, stables, and the workings of such mines, and the travelling roads to and from such working places shall be in a fit state for working and passing therein." Well, now, sir, of course as I say — and I ask your attention to this — we are not liable because an accident happened in the slope pit which caused a disruption that would have stopped any system of ventilation. We are only liable if in your judgment we take unreasonable or improper measures which a reasonable man might not or would not properly have taken. What is the evidence on that point? I take the evidence of Mr. Willis. Mr. Willis tells you that that under the circumstances, after the fall of the 13th April, that is the last fall, what he would have done would have been to get on with the slope pit until he had cleared it away, and that until that had been cleared away he could not suggest any other system of ventilation than the system which was adopted by Mr. Liddell and Mr. Harker. Now it appears to me that that disposes of the whole case. Mr. Willis, who comes here with authority, as the principal inspector of this district, tells us that he can't suggest — after that slope got stopped — he can't suggest any other means which he would have adopted to have made the ventilation more perfect than it was. Well, then, we certainly cannot be liable if Mr. Willis's view in that respect is correct. Well, then, he says further: "I should have kept on to clear the slope pit." Well, the evidence has been called of Mr. Liddell for Mr. Harker, and Mr. Harker for Mr. Liddell, and their evidence is uncontradicted, and the master wasteman says the same thing — that they did attempt to clear that slope pit. They did clear it after the first fall, and on the second they attempted to clear it on two different occasions. They could not clear it from the bottom on account of the stones coming down; and they failed at the top, although they attempted to take the air in, on account of the air, which was coming up from the dyke or fault itself. Well, sir, what are we to be answerable for? We did what we could do, and what we only could do. If we had gone on and attempted to clear that fall in the slope pit whilst that gas was coming up from the fault in the volume that it was coming up when we made the attempt to clear that fall that was in the fault, we might have caused an explosion, and been here to stand on another charge altogether. We did as reasonable men were bound to do. We went there and tried to get the air into it to clear the gas. We found we could not, and we desisted for the time being, until we could take other measures for the purpose of clearing the fall. So that I don't see, and I say so with considerable confidence, I don't see what charge we are to meet. Because no matter what the charge is that is made by the prosecution, you have to look at the evidence put before you. The evidence of Mr. Willis is what I rely upon; and he says that "until you were able to clear the slope pit, then the system of ventilation you adopted was the proper one." If that is true, and it is not contradicted by my witnesses, who say we adopted the best measures we could for clearing the slope pit at the time, then there is no blame to be attached to us.

Mr. Webster: Well, I submit in reply to that, that there were only two days when attempts were made, and we don't know for what length of time the attempts were made. There were twelve days that they did not work but allowed the gas to remain.

The Chairman: But I suppose that all that time the gas was kept down to a considerable extent.

Mr. Edge: I do submit, before calling professional evidence — I do submit strongly and with confidence — that there is no case I am called upon to meet here.

The Bench retired for a few minutes. On their return the Chairman said: The Bench are of the opinion that there is no evidence in either of these cases upon which a conviction could follow, and we therefore dismiss them both.

The decision was received with a murmur of satisfaction and slight applause in court.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, John Boland    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Edge, John    Barrister  
Fisher, C.    Magistrate  
Harker, William    Colliery Manager  
Howson, —    Solicitor  
Jackson, W.    Magistrate  
Jefferson, H.    Magistrate  
Liddell, Gerard Henry    Colliery Agent  
Lumb, —    Solicitor  
Martin, Edward   33 Coal Miner  
McKenzie, H. M.    Magistrate  
Rothery, John    Overman  
Watson, H. H.    Magistrate  
Webster, —    Solicitor  
Wilkinson, Joseph    Master Wasteman  
Willis, James    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
27 Apr 1882  Fatal Colliery Explosion (The Times)
27 Apr 1882  Fearful Explosion at William Pit, Four Men Killed (Whitehaven News)
28 Apr 1882  Terrible Colliery Explosion at Whitehaven (Maryport Advertiser and Weekly News)
29 Apr 1882  Fatal Explosion In William Pit, Four Men Killed And Several Injured (Cumberland Pacquet)
06 May 1882  The Fatal Explosion at William Pit, The Adjourned Inquest (Cumberland Pacquet)
08 Jun 1882  The Fatal Explosion at William Pit, The Inquest (Whitehaven News)
15 Jun 1882  The Wiliam Pit Explosion, Prosecution Of The Agent And Manager (Whitehaven News)
16 Aug 1882  Charges Against Colliery Officials (The Times)
17 Aug 1882  The William Pit Explosion, Prosecution Of The Agent And Manager (Whitehaven News)
19 Aug 1882  Whitehaven Colliery Explosion (The Times)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Whitehaven
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Report Page  Text of the official report into the incident

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print