|
8th June 1882 The Fatal Explosion at William PitThe InquestThe inquest into the circumstances attending the death of the four men killed at William Pit by an explosion some weeks ago, and twice previously adjourned, was proceeded with on Friday last. Mr. W. W. Lumb was the coroner, and the following were the jury:— Messrs. William Strathern (foreman), John Casson, John Staker, Alexander Hardie, James Forster, Joseph Walker, John Dickinson, Will Mattinson, W. C. Atkinson, Alex Wilson, Thornber, and Captain Hill. Mr. James Willis (Newcastle-on-Tyne) and Mr. T. Bell (Durham) Government inspectors Coalmines and Mr. G. H. Foster mining engineer were present. Mr. A. Morley M.P. for Nottingham, barrister-at-law, appeared as counsel representing the Home Office. Mr. A. Sharp, miners' agent, Maryport, appeared to watch the case for the men. — The CORONER in opening the case, said: Gentlemen of the jury, we are met today to commence the inquiry into the deaths of Henry Finch, John McGuiness, Thomas Colvin, and James Geddes, who were killed by an explosion in William Pit here on the night of the 25th April last, and it is for you to say, after hearing the evidence, when, how, and by what means those men came by their deaths. With your assistance, I wish to have a full inquiry into this case and to endeavour if we possibly can ascertain the cause of the deaths of the deceased men. I am pleased to see Mr. Willis here, the Government Inspector for the district. He has had great experience, and on several occasions has given me most valuable assistance and I am also most pleased to see that the Home Office is represented here. I am sure they and all others appearing in this inquiry will assist you and myself in endeavouring to ascertain the cause of this occurrence. Gerrard Henry Liddell deposed that he lived at Whitehaven, and was Lord Lonsdale's resident manager at Whitehaven, but was not a certificated manager for this colliery. He had William Pit under his supervision. An explosion took place in that pit on the 25th April last, about a quarter-past eleven at night. He was informed of it at about two o'clock on the following morning. He immediately went and descended the pit. He produced a plan of a seam called the "Main Band," in which the accident happened, at a place about three miles north-west of William Pit. He also produced a larger plan, on the scale of eight yards to an inch, showing the site of the explosion and the workings immediately adjacent to it. The name of the district where the explosion happened is "The Countess District." It is a pair of winning places, to win a new district of coal, which lies 16 fathoms down through a "fault" running north and south. The coal on the east or landward side is called the "Forster District;" and to get at the coal beyond, they put a stone drift down through this "trouble." He produced a section of the "fault." At the time of the explosion there were two men, "haggers," Edward Martin and James Geddes, in a "thirl" or "stenton" in the furthest point seaward. About sixty yards from them nearly at the bottom of the stone drift is a pump where three pumpers were working to keep the main drift and the thirl dry from a quantity of water. When he arrived at the scene of the explosion about a quarter to three he found he could not get any further than a point he marked on the plan, at the top of the stone drift. The doors and steppings beyond that were all blown out. An enginewright named Connor accompanied him as far as the drift. They were then attempting to restore ventilation by putting in temporary bratticing. There were present William Harker, manager; John Rothery, overman; Joseph Wilkinson, master shipper; Thomas Williams, deputy overman; and a number of other men witness did not at this moment recollect. As to what happened before he arrived other witnesses would speak. At this point at the request of the jury, on the motion of Mr. J. Dickinson, the witnesses were all requested to leave the Courthouse until called. Thomas Williams deposed: I live at Bransty, Whitehaven, and am a deputy-overman in William Pit. On the 25th April last I examined that particular working about half-past seven at night, with a "Geordie" or Stephenson lamp, on the face, both high side and low side. I have been a miner for 21 years. It appeared to be perfectly safe. I can not tell what was the cause of the explosion. — Cross-examined by Mr. Sharp: I never before saw any gas in this locality. I put the reporting the book regularly. I never saw any standing gas in the place. It is making gas, but there is sufficient air to take it away. The ventilation was always good. The men had Geordie lamps for this locality. The pit found the lamps. — By W. Willis: I never saw the gas explode in the lamp. When I found gas there I entered it in the report book. I have the report book. [Book produced.] When I heard of the explosion I was in Robinson district, to the south. That was about twelve o'clock. The Robinson district is about a mile away. I went down the back cross-cut, and about half way down there is a travelling road, and before that I felt the "stife" very strong. I proceeded till I got to the workings where there was not so much "stife." At the top of the drift I found gas, and shouted as hard as I could but got no answer. I got some men to restore ventilation. Edward Martin came up of his own accord about twenty minutes to two o'clock. I asked him how it occurred, and all the answer I could get was, "Oh, I'm badly." Someone said Martin had stepped on someone. I gave my lamp to Thomas Shilten to hold, and went down in the dark and I found Geddes about 10 yards from the top of the drift. Mr. Rothery, the overman, was then there and started to put up bratticing. So far as I got down to Geddes the bratticing was blown down, having mainly gone over in the in-take side. I examined the working at half-past seven, and the men were due to arrive at nine o'clock. There was no gas. There was a good current, which has been measured, though I don't know what quantity of air passes. It would be about half-past nine when the men came in. John Storey, a joiner, put the bratticing up, and the bratticing was all good. I am sure the bratticing was all good. Mr. Willis: As a matter of practical opinion, you have been in the place, since it was restored, and you have considered it no doubt — have you come to any conclusions; where the accident occurred? — Witness: No, sir. Couldn't you point out a place in the thirl, in the stone drift, or in the back drift where it occurred? No, sir I couldn't. — Could you tell us whether it was in this high side of the trouble or in the Countess district? I think it would be in the Countess. And if it was in the Countess district, could it be in any other place than the fore drift, the back drift, or one of the thirls? No, sir. — And you have come to no opinion where it took place? No, sir. — What is the reason for your opinion that it took place in the Countess district? — Because the men were working there. — Yes, I put there were men working here — could it not occur on the high side of the trouble? I don't know how it happened, or where it happened. — You saw how the brattice was knocked out, where and in which direction; and did you also see how these stoppings were knocked about? Yes, sir. — Well, from those indications could you arrive at no conclusion then as to where it occurred? — No, sir. — And you have never seen any of these places fouled explosively? No, sir. — Supposing this place did become foul and explosive what sort of light do you think there would be to ignite gas there? Well sir, I don't know. It was tied to have a light to ignite. — But were there any lights admitted into the Countess district other than as safety lamps? — There were "Geordie" lamps. — Well, it is a safety lamp. — No other lamps were admitted into the Countess district than Geordie lamps? — No. — And these pumpers and haggers were all supplied with Geordie lamps? Yes. — You had a Geordie lamp when you examined the place. Did you usually carry a Geordie lamp in the Robinson district? No, sir. — You got a special Geordie lamp when you went into the Countess district Yes. — Could you hear gas giving off in the Countess district? Just a little — very little. — Making a hissing noise on account of the water? Yes. — Was it very loud at times? No, sir. — Has it been louder after the explosion than before? No, sir, just about the same. — Witness continued to say in answer to questions that he did not know of any fall of roof having occurred. The roof was middling good and did not require lumbering. There had not been any fall of roof in the return drift that he was aware of. Naked lights were taken into the pit a distance of two miles to the lock-up station, which is about a mile out-by from the place they were talking about. Beyond that there were no naked lights employed. He was not aware that they had had any trouble with the men smoking or carrying lucifer matches. He knew all the men employed at this place, and had no fault to find with them whatever. They were men picked out for the place, with the exception of McGuinness and Slattery, who were only sent there for that occasion because they were two pumpers short. He did not know whether they were likely to take advantage by smoking or anything of that kind. Some of them did smoke — outside; but he did not know whether any of them had a pipe or matches with him. Judging from what he knew of their character he would say they would know the danger there would be, and would not likely do anything of the kind. No man had a lamp key except the lamplocker and the deputies. — By Mr. Dickinson (a juryman): The reason why Geordie lamps were used was that Mr. Liddell thought they were safer than any other. He knew no other reason. It was not on account of gas in the place that he knew of. — By the Coroner: He could not tell whether any person was to blame for the occurrence. He had not heard any person say that anyone was to blame. — By Mr. Liddell: I saw martin and Geddes at the lamp station, when it wanted 20 minutes to 10. I told them I had been in the place and there was a little water in the place, and that they had to start and pump it out, and not to go in till the water was pumped out. It is the ordinary thing if there is a little water to start and pump to assist the pumpers to get this water out before they start — if it has accumulated a little. — By the Foreman: The reason for that is that it is better to work dry, because the water cracks the lamp glasses if it gets on them. — By Mr. A. Wilson (a juryman): I do not know that there is any truth in a statement that since the accident men have been turned away from the pit top owing to the glass of their lamps being cracked. — By Mr. Sharp: There were Davy lamps with the men at the pumps and Geordie lamps with those in the thirl. The men found their own Davy lamps. Edward Martin deposed: I live at the NewHouses and have been a coalminer for about 10 years. Went to work at William Pit on Tuesday, 25th April, about 9 o'clock. I had my own lamp with me. The whole of the deceased men, except McGuinness, went down in the same cage. I did not look at the others, but the lamps of me and my "marrow" were "Geordie" lamps, and they were locked at the station and were quite safe so far as I know about lamps. When we got beyond the pumps we took off our coats to start. I don't know what happened. Neither me nor my "marrow" had a pipe. I don't know about the other men, but they were all cautious. It was an explosion that occurred, but I don't know how it happened. I don't think anyone was to blame. So far as I know everything was perfectly safe. Our lamp glasses were good. We had not started back. As soon as we saw fire lifting we run for our lamps and got out, and it caught us on the road out. I don't blame any person, and have not heard anyone blamed. Everything was done for us we asked for. — Cross-examined by Mr. Sharp: The lamps were our own, and were kept and cleaned at home. They were given us, and any damage was made good for us. They were examined at the lamp station. We examined the place when we went in, but found nothing more than usual. There was no standing gas. Never found any standing gas before. If there was any standing gas we were not allowed to remain. The ventilation was always good. I never heard of a fall in the back drift where the up cast was. There were no particular instructions to be cautious at that time more than before. Their lamps were placed perhaps 18 inches from the seam, and about six feet from the face. — By Mr. Willis: I was in the drift twice. The first time there was too much water. We found no other workings vacant, and we went back to our own working. When I noticed "something" before the explosion I had my eye on my lamp. I cannot describe what I saw better than by saying I saw "something." What I saw was not connected with the lamps. There was no fire about the lamps when we got hold of them. I was knocked down on my face, away from the face of the coal. My partner was knocked down in the same direction. The lamps continued to burn until we were knocked down. So far as I can tell you my lamp had no special appearance when I first saw the lifting of flame, I don't know where the flame came from. I think my partner knew better than bring matches. There was no necessity for lighting a match. After we had got up and got to the pump I could not say whether the pump men had gone, it was in the dark. I can't say where I passed them. — By Mr. Morley: We would get 25 or 30 yards from the face of the coal before we were knocked down. My face was burned in getting my lamp. The burns on my body were done afterwards. The flame had commenced to lift before I saw it. There was nothing else for it to light from than from our lamps, but I did not see it lift from the lamps. The ventilation was good. — By the Foreman: I was outside the lamps. The lamps were between me and the face of the coal. — By Mr. Morley: I could not say where the explosion came from, but when I was coming out it was all right, and I was knocked down from behind. — By Mr. Liddell: It was on the roof the fire was. We did not wait to see how it spread. Henry Napier, lamplocker at William Pit, deposed that he had been lamplocker seven or eight years. On the 25th of April he examined the lamps of the deceased men, and they were in a perfectly safe condition. The lamps produced were the same, and four of them were locked. One was rather loose. It was Colvin's lamp. The four men were all careful men. They were not likely men to take pipes in-by. Three of them left their pipes at the lock-shop on that occasion. Colvin did not smoke. — By Mr. Sharpe: The men took the lamps to pieces before witness and put them together again, and witness locked them. — By Mr. Willis: Two of the lamps were private property of the men; the others belonged the colliery. — By a Juror (Mr. Dickinson): The loose lamp was locked and could not be opened without a key. It would unscrew a certain distance but would not open. (Witness illustrated with the lamp, showing that it could not be opened.) — By Mr. Morley: When witness took up the lamp it screwed close up. It was then agreed that the suggested experiment with the lamps should be tried. Mr. Willis, on the inquiry being resumed, said that the proposition had been made that the lamps, which the jury had now seen, should be repaired and tested in a box containing gas, which had been prepared for the purpose, in order to ascertain whether they would explode the gas or not. The foreman (Mr. Stratthern), suggested that the evidence as to the state of the lamps should first be given, and this course was agreed to. Thomas Shilton deposed that he lived at Parton and was a coalminer working at William Pit. He went to work at the pit on the 25th April at six o'clock in the evening. He saw Henry Martin and James Geddes about one o'clock next morning, after the explosion. Thought the explosion must have been caused by a light in some way. — By Mr, Sharpe: Had been in the Countess district. Never saw any gas in it and the ventilation was good. — By Mr. Willis: After the explosion met Williamson near the stone drift. Went to the stone drift. The brattice was knocked over into the intake drift. They went down the drift to the place where it was arched. Got thirty or forty yards down the drift. Went with out a light because an examination had been made and gas found there. Joseph Cowan, a collier, working in William Pit on the 25th April last, deposed that he was working in the Countess district near where the explosion took place at twelve o'clock, before the explosion. When he left the district it was clear of gas and perfectly safe. — By Mr. Sharpe: Witness worked after Geddes and the other men, and had worked there ever since the district was opened. There had been a hole in the air course in that district and the men had to be taken out on one occasion. The seam made a little gas, but witness never saw any standing gas. Was paid by the day and not by the ton. — Mr. Liddell: Was paid by the day so that he might do anything that was necessary. Was never found fault with for not getting sufficient coal out. David Slattery deposed that he was a driver in William Pit. On the 25th of April he went to work at six o'clock at night. Was in the Forster district. Geddes and Martin were with him. About eleven o'clock at night an explosion happened. Witness was at one of the pumps, and he was knocked down. None of them were smoking. Witness's lamp was hanging on a prop and it was locked. Witness did not know what caused the explosion. None of the lamps were opened, and they were all locked. Did not think anyone was to blame. — By Mr. Willis: There were two blasts, and witness was twice knocked down. The second blast was much the stronger. Both blasts came in-by. The second explosion was about a minute after the first. It gave witness time to get up before it came. John Rothery deposed that he lived at William Pit, and was an overman on the night of the explosion. Had examined the district on the Tuesday morning before, and it was clear of gas. It was examined on the morning of the explosion, and there was no gas that witness could detect. All the men used the greatest caution so far as witness knew. Witnesses had examined the lamps since the explosion, and were all good. — By Mr. Sharpe: Had never seen gas standing in the place, but it made gas. Had cautioned the men to be careful. The men knew there was gas. Could not say how gas had accumulated in Martin's place after Williams had examined it. — The Coroner: Do you think that if these men had thought there was going to be an explosion they would have stopped there? — Witness: I do not, sir. — By Mr. Morley: 10,800 feet of air a minute passed through the drift. Witness reported every day in his report. Poole and he examined the deputies' reports every morning. — By Mr. Willis: Witness had thoroughly examined the place, and could not say where the explosion occurred. There was nothing to show the exact place where it came from, and witness could not account for it in any way. Witness could not account for the gas being there in sufficient quantity to cause an explosion. The explosion might be caused if the lamp "clicked" at a feeder. If there was a feeder they had not been able to find it since. If it did the gas would probably burn along from one place to another along the face, and the explosion would probably be mild. There must have been an accumulation of gas. Was in yesterday, in the district to a certain point with Mr. Foster, and there was gas. If a feeder was lighted, and there was enough gas given off from the face of the coal to carry it to a certain point indicated on the plan (near the site of the explosion), it would cause an explosion. At places there was enough gas given off to be lighted by a Lucifer match, but at others it would not so light. There was a fall at the place indicated on the plan, but it was not, in witness's opinion, before the explosion, but was caused by the explosion. Mr. Hetherington then produced the lamps of the five men, which had been cleaned, and were now ready to be tested. On being placed in the receptacle of gas Martin's lamp exploded the gas, and the same result followed several trials. Subsequently it transpired that the gauge of the lamp had been exchanged for that of another one in cleaning them. It was tight when the lamp left the court, but all the gauges being cleaned together when the lamps were put together again, the gauges of two lamps were interchanged. Henry Napier, re-called, said he had examined the lamp and saw what had caused the explosion of the gas. He added that the new glass did not fit. Joseph Williamson deposed that he examined the place on the day of the explosion, about four o'clock in the morning, and found some gas at the back of the air pipe. — By Mr. Morley: The canvass door in the bratticing was nailed down. John Rothery, re-called, said the canvass door was nailed top and bottom, in the centre, so that anyone could get in at either side of it. William Harker, manager and overman of William pit, deposed that he examined the Countess district on the 21st April, and there was nothing wrong then. It was examined daily, three times at least in twenty-four hours, and was always safe for the men to work in. If the glasses of the lamps, or any of them, had been broken previous to the explosion, the men would come to the lamp station for new ones. If the men tapped any feeder or blower they were to come out. Mr. G. H. Liddell deposed that he got to the pit at half-past two on the morning after the explosion, and went down the pit. A defective lamp might cause the explosion, but he had no idea what had caused it. — By Mr. Willis: Witness thought the gas might light near Martin's lamp, that he then saw it, and ran, the flame, lighted the small feeders along the face of the coal until it reached an explosive mixture, when the explosion took place. The second fall of the other man he attributed to the rebound after the explosion. Mr. G. B. Forster, mining engineer, deposed that he had been down the pit, and examined the whole of the drifts. He found the place giving off a considerable amount of gas, but with a strong ventilation bearing on it was keeping it effectually in check. It was difficult to give s satisfactory explanation of the explosion, because the pit being a damp one there was less indication of where the fire had taken hold. His idea was that something had happened to the traffic, when no doubt the gas would come through and accumulate rapidly. There was no evidence that the brattice was injured; it was only an idea. — By Mr. Sharpe: If the wrong gauzes had been put in the lamps when the men put them together in the lamp-room the lockman must have noticed it. — Mr. Sharpe observed that the lamp when tested was put in the box by a practical man, and it was not noticed that the gauze was wrong then, and that it was loose. The room having been cleared, the jury deliberated. On the reporters re-entering, the Coroner informed the jury that there were ten more witnesses, and asked if they desired to hear them. The jury were of the opinion that they had heard sufficient evidence, and they then returned a verdict of "Accidental Death," and expressed an opinion that no blame attached to anyone. The jury handed their fees, £3 15s, to the explosion fund.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||