|
27th April 1882 Employers' Liabilty ClaimThompson v Bain And Co.This is a case which was adjourned from last court, that His Honour might decide whether the defendants had received proper notice of action, which was one under the Employer's Liability Act. The plaintiff's husband was killed by an accident in the defendants' pit, and she sued the defendants for compensation for his death. The Act requires that notice of an action shall be served on the defendants in a specified manner, but it gives the judges equitable jurisdiction in the matter, and if he is satisfied that the defendants have not been damnified or put at a disadvantage by reason of default in the legal service of a notice, he can hold an informal notice as good. His Honour now held that, inasmuch as the defendants were represented by a solicitor at the inquest on the body of the deceased man, and in a correspondence that ensued between the plaintiff and the defendants an action was spoken of, the defendants were not damnified in any way, and he held the notice good. — Mr. T. Brown said he appeared for the plaintiff, Margaret Thompson, who was the widow of Joseph Clementson Thompson. She claimed from the defendants, Messrs. Bain and Co., £212 10s. This claim was brought under the Employers' Liability Act, and the amount was the maximum that she could sue for, that was the amount of three years' wages at the rate deceased was receiving when he met with the accident, which was 4s 6d a day. His death happened on 9th November last. He was working with two men named Bell and Brownrigg, deepening a pit at Lowca, under contract ; but at the time of the accident they were not on contract work — they were not sinking but scaffolding; and they were then on the books of the company, and were working under the direction and control of the company's overman. The shaft was entirely protected by scaffolding — a scaffolding from the one side extending over half the area, being placed some little distance from a similar scaffolding from the opposite side. Thomas Walker, one of the overmen, went down and told them to take out the higher scaffolding and make holes in the sides of the shaft to erect some other scaffolding or a "jigger." The deceased, assisted by one of the other men, took this top scaffolding out. Bell and Brownrigg remained on the bottom scaffolding, and deceased was at the bottom of the shaft carrying this up and down by a ladder to Bell. Holes were made in the shaft and dynamite charges were exploded in these holes. Immediately after the fourth shot, the deceased, who came up the ladder, was standing on the ladder with his head and part of his body a little above the scaffolding; and he was struck by a stone which just missed Bell. Deceased was struck on the head and was never conscious afterwards. He died almost before they got him to the surface. This shaft did not reach to the surface. It was simply an air shaft, driven immediately under No. 7 pit, but between the two there were 28 feet of stone and shale; so that it was impossible that the stone could have fallen from the top surface. The sides of the shaft were of shale and stone and coal, and these sides were not timbered or protected in any way; and the shaft being an air shaft and having some water in it, the shale would be subject to the influences of air and water, which would rapidly decompose it. The vibration of the explosions would loosen the stone and bring it down. Another thing about this shaft was that there was no means of getting up and down. There was no rope in it, or anything to enable the men to get from the top to the bottom, or the bottom to the top. The consequence was the shaft was not examined, and the men, after firing the shots, had no means of examining the shaft to see if anything had been loosened. He (Mr. Brown) contended that the burden of protecting the men was clearly thrown upon the defendants and their servants. As to the amount claimed he did not want to excite the sympathy of the jury, but would simply state the facts. The plaintiff was a widow, a delicate woman, unable from illness ever to do any hard work, and she was left with three little children, the eldest of whom was five years, and the youngest one and a half years. The deceased was 28 years of age. — The following witnesses were then called:— Mrs. Thompson, the plaintiff; Wm. Bell, sinker; John Brownrigg, sinker; and David Ferguson, C.E., manager for the defendants. The latter witness said he gave the orders to the men, and he never authorised them to use dynamite, which ought not to have been used, the needle holes instead being simply drilled or picked. — His Honour (to the second witness, Bell): Bell, you have often made needle holes, I suppose? — Witness Bell: Yes. — His Honour: Have you ever been instructed to use dynamite, or forbidden to use it? — Bell: I would always take it upon me to use it, if required. — Mr. T. Brockbank (who was for the defendants): What do you mean by "if required?" — Bell : Where I could not use a pick. — Mr. Brown: was it necessary in this case to use dynamite? — Bell: Yes, or else I would not have used it. — Mr. Brockbank called one or two witnesses before addressing the jury. — His Honour thought the requirements of the Act of Parliament as to responsibility had not been complied with. It was the duty of Bell, before he used dynamite, to have obtained authority for it. But the man had been killed in the company's works, and everybody must see that it was a case for their sympathies. He hoped that Mr. Brockbank would see that something was done for the poor widow, for one of the company's workmen had been guilty of the indiscretion which had caused the poor man's death. — Mr. Brockbank said he would report to his clients what His Honour had said. — His Honour, addressing the jury, said that the question for them to consider would be whether this man Bell was carrying out the orders given to him in a discreet and proper manner, for there was no doubt the accident had arisen from this firing of dynamite. By the Act of Parliament it was necessary to show that he was doing this by the authority of some responsible person. His Honour briefly reviewed the evidence, and gave it as his opinion that the man had taken upon himself to use dynamite. He was very sorry for the poor young widow, who had thus lost her bread-winner, and if the jury wished to make any recommendation they were at liberty to do so. — The Foreman, after consulting the jurors for a few minutes, said the jury were agreed that no claim could be allowed in the case. — His Honour: It is quite right. I am sorry for the poor woman.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||