Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd February 1882

Employer's Liabiltiy Action

Jackson v Mowbray Iron-Ore Company

This was a jury case, and the following jury were empanelled to try the facts:— Mr. Thomas Gordon, Mr. John Vincent, Mr. Henry Yeowart, Mr. Thomas McArd and Mr. John Davis. Mr. Achurch was called but did not appear, and his Honour said he would be fined £3. — Mr. Atter was for the plaintiff, and Mr. W. H. Atkinson and Mr. Whiteside for the defendants. — Mr. Atter, addressing the jury, said this was a case under the Employers' Liability Act. The plaintiff was William Jackson, aged 17 years, who sued by his father the Mowbray Iron-ore Company, who had pits at Mowbray, near Frizington. On the 11th December the plaintiff was in the employ of the company as fireman, and he had to attend to cleaning the boilers out. The master gave him orders on this day to go to No. 2 pit. James Eilbeck was the engineman there, and his orders the lad had for the time to obey. There were two boilers, one of which was working, and the other to be cleaned out. Whilst the plaintiff was in the one boiler cleaning out the scales the man, Eilbeck said he would send him in a little cold water, for the purpose of brushing the boiler out; but instead of cold water he let in hot water from the adjacent boiler. The lad hearing a rumbling noise knew there had been a mistake, and at once made for the manhole. He just reached the manhole when the water rushed upon him, severely scalding his back, the result being that he was laid up unable to work since, and had suffered very much pain. The only way this injury could have arisen to the lad was that the valve was not closed. If the valve had been properly closed no hot water could have come from one boiler to the other one; but through some negligence of this man this valve could not have been closed. There could be no doubt the plaintiff was in the employ of the company, there could be no doubt he was under the orders of Eilbeck and that Eilbeck told him to go into the boiler, and there could be no doubt it was in consequence of Eilbeck's negligence in not first trying the security of the hot water valve, that the injuries were received by the boy. He (Mr. Atter) did not know whether his friend Mr. Atkinson, who was for the defence appeared on behalf of the company or there was a third person behind the scene; for he had received a letter from the secretary of the company stating that as they were insured with the Employers' Insurance Corporation Limited, the case had been handed over to them. His answer to that letter of course was that the plaintiff had nothing to do with the Insurance Company, but that the Mowbray Company alone were liable and would be looked to. — Mr. Atter then proceeded to call evidence. — William Jackson deposed: I am 17 years of age, and am the son of John Jackson, butcher, Frizington. On Sunday, 11th December, I was in the employ of the Mowbray Company as fireman. I have been in their employ for three years. There are three iron pits belonging to the company, Nos. 1, 2, and 3. The manager of the company was Thomas Garden, who engaged him to work at No. 3 pit. I was first engaged at 10s a week as hanger-on at No. 2 pit, and was made fireman at No. 3 at 2s 6d a day. Once a fortnight I was able to work a double shift. On the 11th December I was sent to No. 2 pit where James Eilbeck was working as engineman. Eilbeck told me to go into the top part of the boiler to clean it. I did go in and knocked off the scales with a hammer. He afterwards told me to go into the flues for the same purpose, and subsequently into the bottom part of the boiler to rake the scales out that had been knocked off. He then said I was to go in, and he would give me some cold water. I had a little brush with me. There is a hose that can be used to throw in water to wash the scales out, and the hose should have been used. He did not use the hose; and I heard a rumbling noise, and knew that something was wrong. I called out and turned round and made for the manhole. I just got to the manhole when the hot water came upon me and scalded me from below the shoulders downwards. The water was stopped when I called out, and James Eilbeck came to me. There was no one else there. If a valve pointed out on the sketch produced had been properly closed I don't think any hot water could have come into the boiler where I was. — Cross-examined: The boiler I was in was the one nearest the engine-house. James Eilbeck sent me into the boiler. Had cleaned the boiler before, but never did anything of the sort without being told. I never saw Mr. Garden that Sunday morning. — Mr. Atkinson: Was the usual course to supply water through the feed-pipe to flush the boiler? — Witness: Yes. — Mr. Atkinson: Then why did you say that a hose ought to have been used for that purpose? — His Honour: What does that matter? — Mr. Atkinson: Because, as I am instructed, it is not the practice to use a hose. — His Honour: Is it the point to use hot water and scald people? That is the point. (Laughter.) — Mr. Atkinson continued to cross-examine the witness as to his position in the boiler, and the dimensions of the boiler, when his Honour interrupted to say that Mr. Atkinson evidently wished to show that the witness did not get out of the boiler quick enough. (Laughter.) — Cross-examination continued: Mr. Eilbeck put some sweet oil on witnesses back, the skin of which was not broken. Eilbeck took him home and a doctor attended on him. Never said that this was an accident. — John Jackson, the father of the lad, said he was at home when the boy was brought home, and he was very much injured. Eilbeck said he thought a bit of chip or something must have got in the valve, and he did not know whether it would be properly screwed down or not. Saw Mr. Garden afterwards, and he asked what witness would take, as he had better take something than take a case to court, where the attorneys would go with it all. (Laughter). — Mrs. Jackson, the mother of the lad, was at home when Eilbeck came home with the boy. Witness was much put about, and was saying to the boy that he should have looked to himself, when Eilbeck said it was his (Eilbeck's) fault, and he was alone to blame. — Dr. Lace said he attended the boy, who was suffering from scalds, and gave a certificate of his inability to work. The scald might extend from ten to twelve inches on the back and then down the side. There was not a great deal of blistering. — Mr. Atkinson: Would the water be scalding hot? — His Honour: It must have been scalding hot. (Laughter.) — Mr. Atkinson: But there are degrees of scalding, I take it. Witness: The water would not have been hotter than 212 degrees. — Mr. Atter: It could not very well be hotter than 212, which would be boiling water. — Dr. Lace said that he attended the boy only for four or five days, and then stopped in consequence of a neighbour's prescription having been used in preference to witness's treatment. The scalds were not severe. There might be a good deal of discolouration from comparatively slight scalds. — This was the case for plaintiff. — For the defence, Mr. Atkinson first called Mr. Woolcock, of St. Bees, civil engineer, who produced a plan of the boilers and gave evidence for the purpose of showing that the boy had no business to be in the particular part of the boiler where he was, and that it was not possible for the boy to have been reached by the hot water at the manhole door. — His Honour thought these were immaterial points. It would be material if they could allow that the boy was not scalded at all. (Laughter.) — Mr. Woolcock said that there was no rumbling noise from hot water coming through a pipe, and he could not tell whether it was hot or cold. — Mr. Atter: Were you ever in a boiler to hear it? — Mr. Woolcock: Oh, yes, hundreds of times. — Mr. Atter: When hot water was coming upon you? (Laughter.) — Mr. Woolcock: Oh, no. His Honour said the object of the examination appeared to be to show that if the boy knew it was hot water that was coming he might have got out of the way sooner. (Laughter.) — Mr. Woolcock said the water could not have come from the other boiler, or it would have taken the flesh off the boy's back. It must have come from the water tank, which would not be very warm. His Honour: Don't talk such nonsense! Do you mean to come here to say that this boy was not scalded? — Mr. Atkinson: No, but we mean to question where the water came from. — Mr. Woolcock said the engineman had no means of saying what was the heat of the water in the tank. It could not have been very hot. Thomas Garden, manager of the company, said that he gave the boy orders to clean out the flues. He never gave him orders to clean out the boiler. It was the duty of the engineman to clean the boiler. Eilbeck, the engineman, had no authority from witness to order the boy to clean out the boiler. [Rules produced, which related that the fireman should look after the flues, and the engineman the engine.] — The boy, recalled, said it used to be his duty to clean out the boiler. The engineman was too big to get in. — Mr. Garden said he never made an offer of compensation to the boy. — Cross-examined: If Eilbeck had complained of the refusal of the boy to clean out the boiler witness would not have said the boy did wrong. Eilbeck ought to have done it himself. He admitted that he told the father he had better have all the money himself and not let the lawyers have it between them. He knew then that the company was sued for £40, and that was what he meant. — William Kermean, a workman in the Mowbray Company's employ, said when he called on the lad the mother told him that if the lad had not been in bad habit of body he would not be so bad. She also said nobody was to blame. The water that came on the lad, witness said, was lodged in the pipe in front of the cold water and the greatest engineer could not have known that it was there at the time. — James Eilbeck, the engineman, in answer to His Honour, said it was for the engineman to judge when the boiler wanted cleaning, out and the boy knew it was his duty to do the work without witness giving him any instructions. — . His Honour: He went in of his own accord? — Yes sir. — His Honour: And you never said anything to him? — Witness: Except it might be to get in and get done. — His Honour: Get in and get done! (Laughter.) This witness will not tell the truth. — Witness went on to say that he did not say to the boy he would give him some cold water, but the boy asked him for cold water. He heard the boy call out afterwards something, in which he could distinguish the words hot water, and he turned off the valve immediately. Witness could not remember what conversation passed between witness and the boy's mother when witness took the boy home. — His Honour at this point addressed the witness, and said that he appeared to be an intelligent man, and why did he not give his evidence straightforwardly? — Louis Murray, secretary to the company, produced the pay-sheets of the company, showing that on 11th of December, James Eilbeck was paid 6d extra for cleaning out the boiler. The fireman was paid specially for cleaning out the flues. — Mr. Atkinson addressed the jury for the defence. If the engineman and fireman were fellow servants, he held the boy was not bound to obey Eilbeck; and if the jury decided there was common employment, he claimed a verdict for the defendant. If, on the other hand, they were satisfied the boy was bound to conform to his orders, what evidence was there of negligence on Eilbeck's part? Then the question arose whether the boy should not have used diligence to keep out of the way of the hot water. Even supposing the water had been cold, the boy had no business to be in the position in which he was, and how far the boy contributed by his own negligence to the scalding he received it was for the jury to decide. The amount of this claim was most unreasonable, even supposing the jury found for the plaintiff. After the lapse of six or seven weeks the boy was quite fit for work again, and the wages he was earning were only 15s a week. v Mr. Atter shortly replied, remarking that there was nothing in the evidence for the defence to rebut, and that he thought the case would never have come to court nor have been resisted had it not been for the insurance company. — His Honour said he was sorry to say the evidence on the part of the defence had not been very satisfactory, and that he had great trouble to get Eilbeck to admit that he ordered this boy into the boiler. If the jury came to the conclusion that Eilbeck was authorized to order the boy to clean the boiler out they would find the company liable. On that point there could be very little doubt. A good deal had been said of the contributory negligence of the boy; but the boy would never for one moment consider that hot water would be coming, and if it had been cold water he need not have cared if he had his back under it — it would do him no harm. As to Eilbeck's negligence there could be no doubt. As to the damages, his Honour directed the jury that a proper assessment would be to consider loss of wages, the pain and suffering, and the extra expenses and trouble of nursing to which the family would be put. — The jury retired, and after consultation returned a verdict for the plaintiff. — His Honour: For what amount? — Mr. T. Gordon: will the amount carry costs? — His Honour: Costs will be for me to consider. — Mr. Gordon: Then we find for the plaintiff for £20. — His Honour: Then the Costs would be no more if it had been £40. — Costs were granted, on the higher scale.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Achurch, —    Juror  
Atkinson, W. H.    Solicitor  
Atter, —    Solicitor  
Davis, John    Juror  
Eilbeck, James    Engineman  
Garden, Thomas    Manager  
Gordon, Thomas    Juror  
Jackson, —, Mrs.      
Jackson, John    Butcher  
Jackson, William   17   
Kermean, William      
Lace, —, Dr.    Doctor  
McArd, Thomas    Juror  
Murray, Louis    Company Secretary  
Vincent, John    Juror  
Whiteside, —    Solicitor  
Woolcock, —    Civil Engineer  
Yeowart, Henry    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Mowbray (Iron Ore)  Mowbray (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print