26th January 1882
Local Will Dispute
In the Chancery Division of the High Court of Justice, before Vice-Chancellor Sir C. Hall, the case of Spedding v. Dykes came on. This was an action for the execution of the trusts of a certain indenture of settlement, dated the 4th of November, 1852,
and also as far as might be necessary for the execution of the will and codicils of the will of the late James Spedding, relating to the Crossgill Estate situated in the county of Cumberland. The plaintiff is Mr. James Wyndham Harrington Percy Spedding,
the present tenant for life of the property, under the settlement, and he asked for a declaration of the rents of all persons respectively to the rents and royalties received in respect of the estate. The defendants were the trustees of the settlement
and the will and codicils of Mr. James Spedding, the elder. — Mr. W. Pearson, Q.C., for the plaintiff, said the questions upon which the decision of the Court was sought were first whether the trustees of the will and codicils of Mr. James
Spedding, the elder, had effectual power given to them to grant a running lease of the minerals under the estate; secondly, if such power was given whether the trustees had effectually executed that power; and thirdly, the right to certain accumulations
of royalties received under the lease which had been granted, and which had amounted to upwards of £10,000. If the lease was effectual, then there was no doubt that the accumulations belonged to the plaintiff, who renewed a lease of a rightfully
opened mine under the portion of the estate. The testator was equitable tenant for life under a settlement made in 1834, with powers of revoking the uses of the trust and appointing new ones. The testator by his will made certain provisions with regard
to the mines, and then gave, or purported to give, power, not to the trustees of the original settlement, but to the trustees of his will, to grant leases, and under that provision the trustees had renewed a lease of the mines. The testator on the 3rd
of December, 1855, purported to grant to Mr. Smith a lease of the mines under the Crossgill Estate 21 years, and that lease should have expired in the year 1876. The testator died in 1863, leaving the will and codicils upon which the questions now
before the court arose. The plaintiff succeeded as tenant for life to the property, and in 1876 renewed the lease of the mines. It was contended that the testator had not given the trustees of his will effectual power to grant leases, because the
proper course was to give that power to the trustees of the settlement. — Without calling on the counsel for the various defendants, the Vice-Chancellor said it was plain from the terms of the settlement that the testator might have given his
estate to the trustees upon any terms, which he thought proper. The power of leasing contained in the settlement had been cut down or interfered with to some material extent by the lease of 1855, and he apprehended that the power of leasing given by the
testator to the trustees of his will and codicils was virtually a superseding of the power of leasing which was contained in the settlement. Therefore it was as clear as could be that the testator was exercising his power, and the only question was
whether the intention to do so was sufficiently clear on the face of the instrument. It seemed to him that the intention of the testator to exercise his power was unquestionably clear. It appeared to him that the trustees of the testator's will had
effectual power to grant the lease and that they had effectually exercised that power to grant the lease. That being so he should make a declaration that the trustees of the testator's will and codicils had effectual power to grant the lease, and that
the trustees had effectually exercised that power, and the rights of all parties must be regulated consequent upon the view, which he had expressed in that declaration. The third question, being an alternative one, did not arise. — Mr. Pearson
said the accumulated rents amounted to about £10,500. He presumed that the costs of all parties would be paid as between solicitor and client of that fund. — The Vice-Chancellor: Yes.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hall, Charles, Sir | | Vice-Chancellor | |
| Pearson, W. | | Q.C. | |
| Smith, — | | | |
| Spedding, James | | | |
| Spedding, James Wyndham Harrington Percy | | | |