20th January 1882
Letters to the Editor
Barometric Pressure And Colliery Explosions
Sir,
A letter in The Times of to-day urging the importance of barometric warnings to collieries illustrates unintentionally the difficulty of the subject. Your correspondent considers that warnings should be sent at a time like the present — a
time of almost unexampled height and steadiness of the barometer. On the other hand the general opinion is that colliery explosions are especially liable to occur at times of low pressure and rapid fluctuations. It is true your correspondent grounds his
apprehensions on the prospect of a fall succeeding to the present abnormal height ; but if warnings are to be sent having reference to an indefinite future as well as to the present and immediate future, there is no time when they may not be sent, and
perpetual warnings we know are no warnings at all.
Moreover, it has yet to be shown that any practical connexion exists between barometric changes and colliery explosions. It is easy to maintain on theory that a diminution of pressure must favour the extrication of gas but an examination of the actual
facts lends little support to the idea that these changes constitute a factor of any appreciable importance in the production of explosions. Having observed this matter pretty closely for many years, I venture to express a doubt whether a single instance
can be adduced to one of the great barometric storms coinciding with a colliery explosion. It must be remembered, too, that warnings, if they are not useful, are apt to be mischievous, by giving a false sense of security at other times, and diverting
attention from more practical methods of safety.
I am, Sir, your obedient servant,
George F. Burder, M.D., F.M.S.
Clifton, Jan. 17.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Burder, George F. | | | |