|
22nd September 1881 The Fatal Mining Accident at HarringtonMr. Whiteside held an adjourned inquest at the Infirmary, in this town, on Monday evening, touching the death of Thomas Shepherd, a coal miner, who died on Monday, the 12th inst., from injuries received on the 2nd of August in No. 7 Pit, Lowca, the property of Messrs. J. Bain and Co. Deceased was a married man, 46 years of age, and has left a widow and seven children; and an action has been brought in the County Court against the firm, under the Employers Liability Act, to recover a sum of £195, being three years' wages at 25s per week. Mr. Helder watched the case on behalf of Messrs. Bain and Co.; and the Government Inspector, Mr. Atkinson, and Mr. Simpson, Harrington, were also present. Alfred Storey, coal miner, who was in the next working to deceased in the pit, detailed the circumstances of the accident. He heard deceased shout, and ran to his assistance. He found him partly leaning, and there were eight or nine large pieces of blue metal lying on him and about him. The fall was not from the real roof, but from what was called the "following." Witness thought the place should have been timbered, and it could have been timbered. This should have been done by deceased himself, but it was the deputy's place to see that timber was put in. Deceased's son and another young man worked with him; but none of them were there that day. By Mr. Helder: Only one stone fell, but it broke into several pieces. Deceased was working the top coal first, and then he had the bottom to take afterwards. Witness would have done it that way himself. By Mr. Atter: Had been a miner of seven or eight years experience. The deputy, Walter Gribbins, told him a week after the accident that it was deceased's duty to put in the props. Either the deputy or a man named Richard Mildren should provide the props. Mildren cut them. A man named John Hayes, who is a shiftman, should go round the workings every morning and see that they are safe; and he should report those that are unsafe. If Hayes had gone round his (witness's) working, he would take it as a guarantee that it was safe. Deceased would have to pass Hayes to go to his work. Did not see Mildren bring any planks or props to deceased's working. Did not hear Gribbins say, "Anyone might have been taken in." Did not hear deceased say, "Now Dicky, this is a nice job; you have got me my back broke." But he heard Mildren say, "If thee back had been broken thee wouldn't have lived." Mildren told witness he hadn't a plank ready for deceased's working. Mr. Atkinson also asked a few questions, and in reply to one the witness said he had never got a copy of the special rules, and never read them. He didn't know there were such things as special rules. He saw the rules at the pit top on Saturday for the first time; they had been put up since the man met with his accident. John Hayes, shiftman in the pit, said it was his duty to go round and see the workings. On Tuesday morning he saw deceased's working — before he went in. There was a little unsoundness or looseness in the roof; but it didn't seem dangerous. It wanted propping. He didn't speak to deceased before he went into his working; but if he had had the opportunity he would have mentioned the roof to him. Deceased passed him, and went to his working, about 400 yards away; and he could not go to speak to him, or send any message. Mr. Helder said witness's duties were only to go round and examine whether there was any gas. Mr. Atter: My instructions are very different. Mr. Atter questioned witness as to his duties. If he had seen deceased he said he would have told him to make ready for wood. It was Mildren's duty to find deceased wood, and the latter would have had to set it. There was wood not far off. By Mr. Helder: Deceased would know, from his experience of the working on the previous day as well as he (witness) did, what its state was. His duties were to examine the place for gas and other danger. Deceased should have taken away the bottom coal and metal first. (A diagram of the coal and fireclay strata's in the pit was here produced, and explained to the jury.) Witness said if he had thought there was danger, he would have reported to the overman, and left a signal. The Inspector: Have you read the special rules? Witness: No, not lately. The Inspector said that according to the special rules, it was the deputy's duty to examine the places before the men went down; and if witness did this, he was taking the overman's duty upon him. In reply to Mr. Atter, witness said the special rules were put up at the pit top on Friday or Saturday since the accident. He had previously read the rules in the engine house and the pay office; but men were not allowed into the engine house. Richard Mildren was the next witness. He said he was a shiftman at the pit, and went on duty a six o'clock on the morning of the accident. Deceased sent for him the day before the accident to set him some wood, as his roof was bad. Witness went in and examined the roof. It was rather unsound, but was not dangerous. He went to set it, but could not, as deceased had five feet of metal between the top and bottom coals which hindered him from doing so. He told deceased to lift this metal, to prepare for him next morning. He helped to bring deceased out after the accident. He had not worked the coal as he told him the previous day, and so loosened the stone which fell on him. He had taken away coal in the morning which had supported the stone over night. Witness got no message on the morning of the accident, and Hayes told him nothing about the accident. In reply to Mr. Atter, witness said he was not aware that he was named in the notice under the Act as one of the parties through whose negligence the accident happened; but he understood from the first he would be. Deceased told him at the Infirmary, the Friday before he died, that he (witness) was not to blame. Witness didn't tell deceased that he had no planks, or that he would take no hurt for awhile. Deceased never spoke to him after the accident. He was speaking to Gribbins, and telling him his back was broken and witness said that it was not so, or he would not be living. Deceased told him at the Infirmary, the Friday before he died, that it was not with his wish that proceedings were being taken; but no one was present at the time. Witness was then at the Infirmary seeing his brother. In reply to the Inspector, witness said his duties were to carry wood to the men and cut it, and if needed when he was in, he was to set it; otherwise the men set the props themselves. No short props were required in the working. It was left to the men's discretion as to working over the band; the distance varied with the state of the roof. The Inspector said there ought to be short props in such places. There might be a little danger in removing them, but they would be aware of that. Robert Shepherd, son of deceased, gave evidence as to the state of the working, and what his father told him as to the accident. By Mr. Atter: His father blamed Mildren; he never said Mildren was not to blame. His father wished proceedings to be taken. Mr. Helder said Mr. Simpson informed him the rules were always at the pit top. Mr. Atter said it was a surprising thing then the men had not seen them. Mr. Helder said the notices had got rather dark, and were freshened up a bit. Dr. Nance, house surgeon, said deceased was suffering from fractured spine when admitted, and he died on the 12th inst. He was sensible to the last while in the Infirmary. It was a hopeless case from the first, and deceased was of the same opinion. Witness had heard him give an account of the accident. This concluded the evidence, and the Coroner then summed up. He said there were two questions for the jury to consider. First, they must consider whether there was any criminal liability, and if there was any they must say so, and the law would deal with the parties. To find this, they must be satisfied that the officials knew this place was an extremely dangerous one, and had neglected some manifest duty to make it secure. But he would advise the jury that there was no evidence as to this. That being so, their duty ended in answering the simple question how deceased came to his death. The jury consulted a minute or two, and the foreman (Mr. Brownrigg) then intimated that they did not consider there was any criminal liability, and their verdict would therefore be "Accidental death." The proceedings, which lasted over two and a half hours, then terminated.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||