|
Northern Counties GazetteArticle from the Northern Counties Gazette, 30th July 1881 Mining Dispute at Cleator MoorDenis Doyle sued Andrew Russell, of the Cleator Iron Ore Company, for £7 10s, wages due on contract for a bargain at No. 16 pit, Cleator Moor. — Mr. Mason appeared for the defendant. — The plaintiff asked that the witnesses be order to leave the court, which was done. — Denis Doyle stated that on the 26th May Mr. Crawford, Mr. Russell's deputy, said he had a drift to let at £9 per fathom, 9 feet wide, 9 feet deep, in the shale rock; after that to be 6 feet high and 6 feet wide, at £5 per fathom, until they met the lime rock; there from to be £7 10s, for same dimensions. — The Chairman here suggested that someone should be fixed upon to decide the question, as it appeared to be one, which the magistrates could not settle. — Mr. Mason said it was a question, whether this was a contract or not. He had plaintiff's solicitor's letter speaking of it as a contract, which had been taken. — Plaintiff asked to be allowed to proceed, and said that on a change of ground there was to be a change of price, till they reached the old workings. It was a weekly bargain, and he agreed to it. There were to be nine men, three partners and six men, and he was to engage them. He took the work on Mr. Russell's own conditions. Witness had previously sent in a written tender, but defendant did not accept it. The terms agreed to were in writing. They worked Friday and Saturday, and on the Monday afternoon, as he and his mates were working, they saw an extra feed of water. They became alarmed, and went up. Half an hour after they put down a float, and saw the water was rising. Witness went on to describe the way in which the work was repeatedly interrupted by water — which rose 16 feet above the workings — until the following Thursday, when they went down and secured the shaft. The water again interrupted their working till the next Monday. They got paid on Saturday £9, less price of a packet of dynamite and some fuse and caps, altogether about 30s, apiece. The water interrupted them again on the following Wednesday, when he complained to Mr. Russell, telling him someone would be drowned. He said they must work when they could, and get away as fast as possible when they saw the water coming, and he would pay them their time. They afterwards proceeded, with several interruptions by the water, until they found the old workings. When it came to pay day he only received £3 17s, to pay nine men. He divided it amongst them, only keeping 3s, for himself. He saw Mr. Russell afterwards, and complained about it, Mr. Russell said they would be paid according to their work. He claimed £7 10s, the balance for work done. — Cross-examined by Mr. Mason: The names of the others were not on the summons as plaintiffs, because they looked to him for their pay. — Mr. Mason said Denis Doyle sued in his own name. If the men were servants of the Company and the claim was for wages they should each claim for himself. Plaintiff had written a letter by Mr. Braithwaite on the 5th June, claiming £33 10s. — Cross-examined about this the plaintiff said he did claim £33 10s, for working day by day, including the time they were stopped by the water. — Mr. Mason read Mr. Braithwaite's letter applying for £33 10s, for compensation for loss of time through water breaking in. That was replied to by defendant's solicitor, saying the liability was not admitted. They (defendants) also contended the water broke in through the men's own fault. On the 24th a reduced claim for £27 was sent in to the manager. Mr. Mason read this letter, and contended that it showed there was a contract between the defendant and plaintiff, and the claim was not for wages. The Clerk said that took the matter out of the hands of the magistrates. — After some discussion, the Chairman said the correspondence read seemed to show it was a matter in which the magistrates had no jurisdiction. The question of who was to blame for water breaking in was a disputed one they could not decide. Even if it came within their jurisdiction, it was a matter in which the magistrates were hardly in a position to form an opinion. They therefore dismissed the case, as one that ought to be brought before the County Court; but he (the Chairman) advised the parties to submit it to an arbitrator, who could go into the technical points raised.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||