Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th May 1881

The Fatal Mining Accident at Dearham

A Doctors' Difference About Administering Narcotics

On Saturday last the adjourned inquest on the body of Robert Highmoor, aged 28 years, coalminer, who died on the 4th inst., after being injured in the Dearham Colliery, was held at the Globe Inn, Dearham, before Mr. W. W. Lumb, and a jury, of which Mr. George Pearson, of Dearham, was foreman.

The Coroner said the inquest had been adjourned for the purpose of having the evidence of Dr. Spurgin and Dr. Jackson.

Mr. Hobson, of the firm of Tyson and Hobson, Maryport, said: Before you go into the evidence, I think it right to hand in this letter:-

"Dearham. May 8th,

Sir, This is to inform you that your service is not required by Robert Highmoor, of Dearham, any more.

To Dr. Crerar.

T.H."

This letter was received by Dr. Crerar on Sunday morning. It had been placed under his door on Saturday night some time, and it was picked up by a servant and handed to Dr. Crerar.

The Coroner: Who is "T.H.?"

The Foreman: They are the initials of his brother. Is that so, Thomas?

Thomas Highmoor: Yes.

Mr. Hobson: Then that is a distinct dismissal of Dr. Crerar from further attendance.

William Henry Spurgin was then called and deposed: I live at Maryport, and am a duly qualified practitioner in Maryport. I knew the deceased, Robert Highmoor. I have frequently attended his family. I was sent for at seven o'clock on Saturday night, the 7th of May. A man came on horseback to ask me to go to see deceased. After a good deal of thought and consideration I thought it best not to interfere, so I said I was sorry I could not interfere, because — I did not wish to interfere with Dr. Jackson. About twelve o'clock at night I was rung up and again requested to go, when I again refused. About half past four or five in the morning another messenger came down, saying deceased would have me go to attend him, and was particularly anxious that I should go. I again said I had no wish to interfere, and that I would prefer not doing so. However, I began to think I should be continually called upon, and so I went.

The Coroner: Were you told that Dr. Crerar's services would not be required?

Witness: I said I could not go unless he were told that his services were no longer required. It was not etiquette.

The Coroner: Eventually did you go?

Witness: I went off almost directly, about five o'clock in the morning, and saw the deceased. I found him conscious, with his arm and shoulder bandaged. He knew me perfectly, and evinced considerable pleasure at seeing me. He was suffering from dyspnoea. His breathing was 80 respirations to the minute, and his pulse was about 125 — feeble and quick. His tongue was greatly furrowed; his expression very anxious; eyes very brilliant; in fact, he was in a general state of high fever. He had a cough and expectoration. The man appeared to be in a most critical condition. He said he had had no ease since the accident. I therefore administered a subcutaneous injection of morphia, a quarter of a grain strength, and gave him a stimulating expectorant mixture. I saw him again between eight and nine at night. He had been a great deal easier, but had not fallen into a real sleep — he only dozed. I then ordered him to take an anodyne pill. I forgot to say that I had previously ordered poultices to be applied on his chest. I did not interfere with the bandages on him, because I considered his condition too critical. I told them that I thought there was a very poor chance indeed for him.

The Coroner: Had he any ribs broken?

Witness: In my impression he had, but the man was in too critical a condition for me to examine him.

The Coroner: You could not say then?

Witness: I fully believe that one rib was broken. They said they had heard the grating.

The Coroner: Did you see him again?

Witness: No, not after that. I was going up when they sent to say he was dead.

The Coroner: What did he die of?

Witness: Of pneumonia, consequent upon the injuries; and in my opinion very likely the first rib was fractured, and it might have injured the lung, or it might have been injured by compression of the chest.

The Coroner: You considered it proper and judicious treatment to give him the morphia in the way you did?

Witness: Most decidedly I did.

The Coroner: And you did everything you considered could possibly be done under the circumstances?

Witness: Yes, I thought it was not right to go and take off the bandages. I just made a superficial examination, as I thought it was only increasing the danger to do more.

The Coroner: And that is your opinion of the cause of death?

Witness: Yes. Of course he was in a most critical state when I first saw him.

The Foreman: Was there anything else to lead you to suppose that a rib had been broken beyond the evidence of the nurse? Any spitting of blood or such as that?

Witness: No, I could scarcely say there was. What I wish to show is that the pneumonia might be made by compression of the lungs.

Mr. Hobson: Is it usual to administer morphia when a man is suffering from acute pneumonia?

Witness: Yes, sometimes; especially when a man has had no sleep for some days.

Mr. Hobson: Would you have followed the same plan of bandaging had you been there in the first instance?

Witness: I might have done it a little different. I should, have had his arm bandaged down to his side, and have used a "figure of eight" bandage.

Mr. Hobson: How did you find it?

Witness: When I saw him I think the arm was not bound to the side. The pad was applied properly enough to keep the clavicle right.

The Coroner: As far as you could see, had he been duly and properly attended to?

Witness: Of course, I differ in this little way — I should have given a narcotic at the very outset. That is what I should have done.

The Coroner: Independent of that, you consider he was properly treated as far as you could judge?

Witness: The arm should have been bound to the side.

Mr. Hobson: I think Mr. Adams said he adopted the "figure of eight"

Mr. Hobson: What was your opinion of the injuries that he had received?

I thought myself that the first rib had been broken on the left side.

Mr. Hobson: Did you conclude that from his difficulty in breathing?

Witness: And the great pain of which he complained.

Mr. Hobson: Why did you assign it to the breaking of one rib more than to another? How do you come to that conclusion?

Witness: I think if the clavicle were injured it would be more apt to cause that rib to be broken than any other.

Mr. Hobson: That is, assuming the pressure of the fall was upon the shoulders?

Witness: Yes.

A Juryman: In your opinion was the injury he received at the pit sufficient to cause death?

Witness: Decidedly.

Dr. Henry Jackson was next examined, and deposed: I live at Dearham, and am a duly registered medical practitioner. I have heard the evidence Dr. Spurgin has given, and in the main it closely coincides with my own opinion — that the deceased man died from the injuries he received from the fall of coal.

Mr. Hobson: Did you form any opinion as to the broken rib?

Witness: He was suffering from engorgement of the lungs. There is no question about that, but whether that was from a broken rib or not is an open question. I did not put him to inconvenience to examine him.

The Coroner, in summing up, said the jury had heard the evidence of Dr. Adams, Dr. Crerar, and Mr. Page, and also, that of Dr. Spurgin, and Dr. Jackson, and it appeared to him that all the doctors had done what they thought was best to be done under the circumstances. He thought the jury had done perfectly right in having the evidence of Dr. Spurgin, after Dr. Crerar had attended the deceased up to a certain time, and he considered Dr. Spurgin had given his evidence in a very proper way. Dr. Crerar too, he thought was perfectly justified in withdrawing from the case in the manner he did, and in saying that if they were not satisfied with his services, they had to get someone else. After that, the deceased's brother had sent Dr. Crerar the letter which had been produced, and after a medical gentleman had received that letter it was quite sufficient for him not to attend the man any more. Dr. Spurgin had declined to attend until after he had been applied to three times, and shortly after he did attend, the man died. It appeared to him that the deceased would have died of the injuries he had received, and if the jury were of that opinion, then their verdict would be one of "accidental death," but if they considered that he did not die from the injuries he received, and that they had nothing to do with his death, then their verdict would be that he died from pneumonia, but how it was caused there was not sufficient evidence to show. From the evidence of Thomas Sandham, there was no blame attributable to any one, and it was a pure accident and could not be avoided.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Highmoor, Thomas      
Highmore, Robert   28 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hobson, —    Solicitor  
Jackson, Henry, Dr.    Doctor  
Lumb, William Wilkin    Deputy Coroner  Whos Who Page
Pearson, George    Jury Foreman  
Sandham, Thomas      
Spurgin, William Henry, Dr.    Doctor  
Tyson, —    Solicitor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Dearham Colliery  Dearham Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print