|
19th May 1881 The Fatal Mining Accident at DearhamOn Tuesday afternoon an adjourned inquest was held at the Globe Inn, Dearham, before Mr. W. W. Lumb, deputy coroner, touching the death of Robert Highmore, 28 years of age, miner, of Dearham. Mr. George Pearson was foreman of the jury; and there were also present: Mr. Dacres, manager of the colliery, and Mr. Hobson, representing Dr. Crerar and the owners; Dr. Crerar and Dr. Adams, his assistant, and Dr. Page (of Carlisle), on behalf of the former; and Mr. A. Sharp representing the miners. The first witness called was Thomas Sandyman, coalminer, Dearham, who said he worked at Dearham Colliery. He knew the deceased. On the 4th inst., they were working together in a yard seam, about two feet high. About eleven o'clock in the forenoon the deceased was lying on his side in this seam. They had not been long at work when a "rattle" from above came down on to the top of deceased, who had touched it by bringing a piece down. The whole of it would be nearly half a ton, and the size of the piece would be about five feet broad and eight inches thick. It hit the deceased on the left shoulder and knocked him back, completely burying him. When he was extricated he said to him (witness): "Oh, Tom, it is a bad job;" and afterwards said it could not be helped. The roof was not propped, as they didn't think it was necessary. There was sufficient material to do so if they had required it. He (witness) saw the deceased that night, and he had a smoke and appeared quite lively. By the Inspector of Mines: I saw John Pattinson in the place before they commenced to work. He was examining the place, but he didn't fire a shot that morning. By Mr. Dacres: Witness said that there was a wall built on both sides of the seam, but not close up to the roof. John Moses Pattinson, deputy overman at the pit, said that on the 4th inst., he examined the place where the deceased was working, about five o'clock in the morning. The state of the place, as far as he could see, was quite safe. He would have had no hesitation in working there himself. Dr. Adams, assistant, who said he was sent for on Wednesday, the 4th inst., gave a description of the man's general condition, and that there was a dislocation of the collar bone inwards, which he reduced. The man had no general emphysema up to the last time he (witness) saw him; and he didn't consider the case a very bad one. He saw him on the Friday following, and he was in the same condition; and didn't see him again before he died. The bandages round the deceased's neck had been loosened by some women who attended him. Deceased had complained about the bandage that was round his body with his arm fastened in it, being too tight. On being asked by some of the deceased's friends, he refused to give him any narcotics, which would have made further depression. He could not say that the man died from the injuries he received. Cross-examined by a Juryman, witness said he did not think that it was because he bandaged the man too tight so that he could not breathe, that caused the man to pull the bandages off. There was no indication of any tightness. The deceased's brother saw him (witness) on the Friday and complained that the bandages were too tight. Dr. Crerar corroborated and agreed with Dr. Adams in every respect so far as he knew and observed. He saw the deceased on the Thursday, and found him very comfortable. The bandages, which had been put on him by Dr. Adams very skilfully, had been slackened, and the collar-bone displaced. He made an examination of his chest and found there was no apparent injury he had received. He suspected that the people had interfered with the bandages with the intention of relieving the man, but really they had made his condition worse. He (witness) put the bandage up in what was called a French mode, the efficacy of which would be to keep the collar-bone in its proper place, and to prevent any person from removing it. In the evening of that day he was sent for, because the man had been complaining about the bandages being tight. When he saw him again he found them slackened, and he had to renew them, leaving him so comfortable that he didn't think it necessary to go himself next day. But on Saturday he attended him, and had to remonstrate with the deceased and his friends about displacing the bandages, he being in a half unconscious state and excited. The bandages had been removed by a Mrs. Yeowart, midwife. The deceased complained about difficulty of breathing and discomfort, and Mrs. Yeowart wanted witness to give him something in order to make him sleep, and he said if he did give him the man something to sleep, the probability was that he would never wake again. He further told them that it appeared to him that they had no confidence in him, and it would be better if they would call in another medical gentleman. The man said he would like to see Dr. Spurgeon. Witness never saw him again; but he believed the treatment by Dr. Adams and himself, was appropriate to the circumstances. The reason why he interfered at this inquest was because he had heard very serious imputations afloat in this village about his unskilled treatment and that he had killed the man; and his object was to place the whole evidence before the public, so that the might see that the treatment given by Dr. Adams and himself was required in the case. In reply to the Foreman, witness could not say that the annoyance and excitement caused by interference by other people would cause death apart from the dislocation of the neck. It might have led to it if continued for some time. A Juryman: It is reported in this place that when Mrs. Yeowart came for you, you would not come, until Mr. Dacre went for you on horseback. Dr. Crerar: It is not true. He came twice and didn't ask me to come the first time; and the second time I came. I have had plenty of lies told about me in this case. The Juryman: Well, it's reported so. Dr. Page, on behalf of Dr. Crerar, gave his entire approval of the way in which Dr. Crerar and Dr. Adams had treated the man, and believed that the mode of bandaging was the proper course, supposing there were no injury to the ribs and lungs. Ann Yeowart, an elderly woman, residing in Church St, Dearham, said she went to nurse the deceased when injured. She was there when Dr. Adams and Dr. Crerar were there. They likely did all they could for him, but he (deceased) thought not. He thought he was bandaged too tight. When she loosed the bandage round his body — she didn't touch the one round his collar-bone — blood was running out of his mouth. By The Coroner: I didn't ask him if he would have a draught. Dr. Crerar: You asked me. Witness: Well, yes, I did. He (deceased) fretted a good deal about the bandages. On Saturday and Sunday he was like nothing less but dying. I can't say whether he died from the injuries he received. He always complained about these bandages, or else I would never have loosened them. Mr. Sharp: Did you hear his ribs crack when Dr. Crerar was bandaging him? The witness hesitated. By the Coroner: I said it to Dr. Crerar that I could hear his bones crunch when he was bandaging him. Dr. Crerar: You made no such statement to me. Witness: I did; and you said it was right. Dr. Crerar: I deny that positively. In answer to a Juryman, Mrs. Yeowart stated that the deceased had said some of his ribs must be broken, he breathed so badly. The Coroner: In this case, Dr. Crerar, you have heard all the evidence, can you tell us what was the cause of deceased's death. Dr Crerar: I could not give expression to that; because I have heard various reports, which have been brought out in evidence. In reply to the coroner as to whether deceased would have died if he had not received injuries, Dr. Crerar said he didn't think he would. The Coroner: Then you further say it was the injuries he received by the coal falling upon him. Dr Crerar: I don't say that. It put him into a collapsed state. I have been charged with his death, and I want to show that he did not die from any fault of mine. In further reply to the Coroner, Dr. Crerar said there was no doubt that the fall of coal was the primary cause; but with the secondary cause he had nothing to do. And he declined to have anything to do with it. In reply to the Foreman, Dr. Crerar said that he could not be responsible for anything done by anyone else. After deliberating for some time, the jury decided to further adjourn the inquiry until Saturday afternoon, in order that Dr. Spurgeon and Dr. Jackson, both of whom had visited the deceased subsequent to Dr. Crerar attending him, might be called upon to give evidence.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||