Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd May 1881

Important Action Under the Employers Liability Act

Moore v. Whitehaven Hematite Iron and Steel Company, Limited. — This was an action brought by John Moore, miner, living at Hensingham, father of John Moore, deceased, aged 18 years, who was killed in one of the defendants pits, to recover the sum of £150 as damages. — Mr. Atter was for the plaintiff, and Mr. Brown for the defendants. — The case was tried before a special jury, the original draft of jurymen being, James Hinde, Robert Jefferson, Henry Crompton, Hamilton Dixon and W. B. Cowman. The two last-named jurymen did not appear, and the date of the service of the summonses having been stated, his Honour stated that they would have to be fined 4s. Henry Moore and George Birkett were substituted in place of the absentees — Mr. Atter, in opening the case, said this action was brought under the Employers Liability Act, which was passed last year, and came into force at the beginning of January. This action was brought to recover compensation by reason of the death of plaintiff's son. This was undoubtedly the first case tried under this Act in this court, and probably in this County; therefore, it was of great importance not only to the parties concerned, but also to the public generally. He would produce evidence to show that the accident was caused by the working of the defendant's machinery. The amount of compensation to be recovered was the amount of three year's wages, which the deceased was earning at the time he met with the accident. £150 was the amount they wished to recover. That was about an average of £1 a week he was receiving as wages. — John Moore, father of the deceased said he was a miner, and lived at Hensingham. The deceased was between 18 and 19 years of age; and at the time he met with the accident he was living with him, and at the time was in the employ of the Whitehaven Hematite Iron Company. He had worked there about eight months previously. He worked by "piece," and worked along with him (witness). On an average he received about £1 a week. Witness had to provide the funeral expenses, with the exception of a sovereign and the coffin, which were given by the Company. On Friday, the 28th of January, last they left for to go to work at Bowthorn Colliery, near Cleator Moor. There had been an amount of frost at the time; but for two or three days a thaw had set in. They were let down into the pit where they remained until about five o'clock; and when they left work there were six of them got into the cage. Edward Downey, the "hanger on" gave them instructions to get into the cage, and signalled to the top, and received an answer back that all was clear. They all — six of them — were in the cage about to ascend when a block of ice fell on the edge of the cage, the top of which was delved in, fracturing the deceased's skull. He immediately dropped into witness's arms and blood flowed from his nose. He only lived about ten minutes afterwards, and was conveyed to the surface. On the Thursday, the day before this happened a lump of ice had fallen down, and Downey had a narrow escape, he being in the cage at the time and having to run. Witness heard it remarked to one of the men named Emerson that if something was not done some one would be killed. The ice was removed the same night after witness's son was killed. The ice could be seen on the sides of the pit as they went up or down; and it could have been picked off easily during the thaw. — Cross-examined, witness said he kept the deceased in food and clothing, and received his wages from him and not direct from the Company. The cage in which his son was killed was an ordinary one. His son got in the wrong side of the cage up, but the "onsetter" saying he would not send the cage till one-stepped on the other side, he got over to the side where witness was. When Downey ran out of the cage the day before, the top of the cages was off, and there was no protection. — For the defence, Robert Lamb, a colliery viewer for the defendants, was called, and stated that he had been 52 years a collier, and had practiced 30 years as a viewer. The depth of this shaft was 97 fathoms. It was a down cast shaft, which feeds the pit with all the air, which went into it. It was lined with firebrick from top to bottom. There was dampness in the shaft, and they had rings cut out in it to catch the water when it percolated through the bricks. — His Honour: Do I and the jury understand that the ice fell from the top? — Mr. Brown: Nobody can tell where it came from. It is a supposition. — His Honour: Oh, no. Do I understand it came from the top or the sides? — Mr. Brown: It certainly did not come from the top. — The witness, continuing, said to prevent the ice gathering in the shaft they put a steam pipe in it and lit fires about it. — His Honour asked if they were going to show by this witness that they had means of accumulating ice. — Mr. Brown said he was going to show that it was impossible to keep the ice out the shaft. — His Honour: Well, go on. — Witness said they kept the fires burning night and day during the frost. They employed men to "hag" the ice out. He had seen ice in shafts during the whole time of his experience; and it was impossible to keep ice out. — Cross-examined by Mr. Atter, witness admitted there was ice in the shaft, and a large quantity of it. The whole bulk of it was removed the night after the accident. — His Honour: You said it was impossible to do it. How could you do it so quickly? (Laughter) — Witness explained that the same number of men were at work as before, but it was on account of the thaw. It was never intended to take the whole of it off, because it was not considered dangerous. — His Honour: Do you mean it never falls of itself when thawing? — Witness, continuing, said they made room for the passage of the cage; and in reply to Mr. Atter he said he did not know that the cage was forced down through the ice the day before the accident. The shaft was not considered safe, because the ice was too much; there was more ice in the shaft on Friday morning than he had seen that winter. — Mr. Brown questioning witness as to whether it was possible to get the ice out in one, two, or three nights, his Honour said it was possible to stop the men from going down the pit. — Mr. Brown: That would have stopped the pit altogether. — His Honour: Exactly. — Mr. Liddell, colliery viewer for the Earl of Lonsdale, and formerly one of Her Majesty's inspectors of mines, said he considered what Mr. Lamb had done were proper and reasonable protections — in putting a jet of steam in the shaft, and lighting fires to prevent the accumulation of ice, which was impossible. When the ice accumulated it was usual to cut it — it was impossible to cut it out entirely — to prevent it from interfering with the cage and to make it safe. — Adam Fairish, who had the care of the shaft, was examined, during which Mr. Liddell was re-called, and his Honour said that in the evidence being given it was stated that they took sufficient off the sides to allow the cage to go down: Wouldn't that make that which was left more liable to fall? — Mr. Liddell replied that it would if the thaw was going on; but it was like cement. — James Hookes, James Smith and Robert Downey, gave evidence of a corroborative nature to that given. — Mr. Brown said there were two alternative grounds of claim: one of superintendence, the other on account of negligence of the defendants themselves: and his (Mr. Brown's) contention was that the plaintiff could not bring forward that ground of complaint because he had not stated in his notice to the defendants that he brought the negligence directly against them. The plaintiff stated in his notice that it was by reason of their servants. In concluding, Mr. Brown said the money the young man made was really given in clothing and supporting him and if the father sustained any loss it would be very small. The real charges against the defendants was that of negligence by their superintendents. He held that they were not obliged to take more than ordinary care; but he had shown that they not only took ordinary care but extraordinary care to prevent loss of life during the frost. — His Honour having reviewed the evidence said the question for the jury were, ought the ice to have been removed, could it have been removed, and by evidence they heard it was removed after the lad was killed. — The jury awarded the plaintiff £72. The two jurors, who had been fined, Mr. Hamilton Dixon and Mr. W. B. Cowman, made an explanation through Mr. Webster in the course of the afternoon. Mr. Dixon had been detained in the morning till his foreman arrived, and Mr. Cowman stated that he had been working in the country; and both gentlemen, it is added, had remained in court till now to make this explanation to His Honour. — The fines were remitted at County Court, Whitehaven on Tuesday April 26th.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, —      
Birkett, George      
Brown, —      
Cowman, W. B.      
Crompton, Henry      
Dixon, Hamilton      
Downey, Edward      
Downey, Robert      
Emerson, —      
Fairish, Adam      
Hinde, James      
Hookes, James      
Jefferson, Robert      
Lamb, Robert      
Liddell, —      
Lonsdale, Earl of      
Moor, John   18   Deceased, Individual Page
Moore, Henry      
Smith, James      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Bowthorn Colliery  Bowthorn Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
08 Feb 1881  The Fatal Mining Accident at Cleator Moor (Cumberland Pacquet)
10 Feb 1881  The Fatal Mining Accident at Cleator Moor (Whitehaven News)
03 May 1881  Important Action Under the Employers Liability Act (Cumberland Pacquet)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Bowthorn
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print