Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Northern Counties Gazette

Article from the Northern Counties Gazette, 30th April 1881


The Employers' Liabillity Act.

Important Case

Jurymen Fined

Whitehaven County Court

Tuesday, April 26th.

(Before T. H. Ingham, Esq., Judge.)

Solicitors present:— Messrs. Webster, Atter, Atkinson, Whiteside, Brown, Mason, and J. Brockbank, of Whitehaven; and Mr. W. Paisley, of Workington

Moore v. Lindow and others. — This case was taken before a special jury, the following been sworn as jurymen:— Mr. James Hine, Mr. Robert Jefferson (Preston Howe), Mr. Henry Compton, Mr. Henry Moore, and Mr. Geo. Birkett. Mr. Hamilton Dixon and Mr. W. B. Cowman were fined for not appearing on their names being called. — Mr. J. G. Dee, engineer, had been summend as a witness, but did not appear. Mr. Brown explained that Mr. Dees had to meet Mr. Brunless, who had been telegraphed for in consequence of the accident at the dock, and both solicitors had told Mr. Dees he need not appear. His Honour said that Mr. Dees, having been summoned, should be there. — Mr. Atter appeared for the complaint and Mr. Brown for the defence. — Mr. Atter, in opening the case, said John Moore, plaintiff, sued defendants, trading under the style of the Whitehaven Hemitite Iron and Steel Company, Limited, under the Employers Liability Act, for £150, damage sustained by the death of his son, aged 18, who was killed by a fall office at the Bowthorn Colliery, Cleator Moor, belonging to the defendants, on the 28th January last. Deceased worked with his farther and lived with him, his wages being £1 per week. There was a large quantity of ice in the shaft of the pit, a mass of ice fell, delving in the top of the cage, and striking deceased, who never spoke again. At the inquest held the jury came to the conclusion that the proprietors of the pit had not taken proper and sufficient precautions to prevent ice falling. An accident had occurred the day previously from the same cause, and he considered that great negligence had been shown by the defendants. — John Moore, miner, of Hensingham, deposed that deceased John Moore, complainant's son, was at work in defendants colliery on Friday, 28th January, and with himself and four others, got into the cage on the instructions of Downey, the hanger-on. A block of ice then fell, delved in the roof of the cage, and fractured his son's skull, who only lived about ten minuates. A thaw had taken place the previous Tuesday. There was much accumulation of ice in the shaft, and had been a fall in the day previously, when Downey had a narrow escape escape, and Emerson, the bank overman's attention had been called to it. Witness received plaintiff's wages, who lived with him. — For the defence, Mr. Brown called Robert Lamb, colliery viewer for the company, who detailed the precautions taken to secure the safety of the shaft, a jet of steam being put down the shaft, fires lighted round it, and four men being put on to clear the ice away. — In the cross-examination, witness admitted that there was more ice in shaft than he had ever seen before, that there had been two accidents of the same kind this year, but he had never known of any previously during 53 years experience. The ice was cleared away the night after the accident. — Mr. J. H. Liddel, colliery viewer and superintendent for the Earl of Lonsdale, and formely one of her majesty's Inspectors of Mines, said that in his opinion the precautions taken as described by previous witness were reasonable and proper. — Adam Fairish, engine wright said that he was satisfied what had been done was all they could do. Had not heard of Downey being nearly killed the day previous by a fall of ice. He did not know the pit had been stopped for four days previously on account of its dangerous condition. — Mr. Lamb re-called, admitted that he had, stopped the colliery for four days previous to this accident, because he considered it in a dangerous condition. Fairish said no one had spoken to him about the dangerous condition of the pit. — Mr. Liddell; recalled, admitted that the picking of the ice round the inside of the accumulation might have the affect of the loosening the rest. — Jas Hookes, under-viewer at the colliery, said he had ice hewed from the sides of the pit night and morning for some time before the accident, and he saw no loose pieces of ice. He himself rode the shaft twice and the cage ran easily. — In cross examination, he said the ice might have been all removed had the pit been stopped long enough, but in re-examination said the ice formed as fast as cleared away. — Robert Downey, on-setter, in the defendants employ, said that deceased got in on his wrong side of the cage, and had to be told to get to the other side, which caused a delay of a minute, during which the cage might have been at the top. If he had been at the other side he would not have been injured. Cross-examined: Witness himself had had to jump out of the cage to escape being struck by a falling piece of ice the day before; if it had struck him he might have been killed. — Re-examined: The cage had no top on at the time. He would not have been afraid if it had been covered. — W. J Green, a miner employed in the pit, corroborated the evidence of last witness. — Mr. Brown, for the defence, explained the clauses of the Employers' Liability Act, under which the case was brought. The plaintiff grounded his claim both on the negligence of the defendants them shelves, but the plaintiffs could not bring forward the latter, as it was not stated in the notice. He contended that the defendants took not only ordinary but extraordinary care and precautions. The plaintiff had not brought one skilled witness to show that defendants had not done a single thing they might have done. In addition to the precautions taken, although defendants were only bound to examine their once a week, it was examined every day and the accident had happened in spite of great precautions. The unfortunate youth was himself the primary cause of his own death, through his getting in at the wrong side of the cage. He was a tall man and reached nearly to the top of the cage; had he gone to his proper side of the cage no one might have been injured, even had the piece of ice fallen. If it had not been for the delay he caused, the cage would have been at the top of the shaft or so near to it the fall of ice would have done no harm. — Robert Downey, here re-called by His Honour, said the cage never went up with more than three men at each side; and he caused some amusement by repeating, in the answer to questions, that the reason why not more than three men were allowed at each side of the cage, was, because it was against the rules. — Robert Lamb, re-called, said only three men were allowed on each side in order to keep the cage balanced. — His Honour pointed out that in that case the weight of the men might make a difference, and two stout men might be as heavy as four thin men. — Mr. Atter briefly replied, contending that the colliery ought to have been closed altogether owing to its dangerous condition, and that the accident was owing to the negligence of the defendant's servants, and to defects in their working machinery and plant. — His Honour then summed up, and explained that this was the first case that had been brought under the new Act of Parliament, an Act which was of a somewhat experimental character. In this neighbourhood the probability was these cases would frequently arise. They must judge of reasonable care by surrounding circumstances. The parties admitted that for days the pit had been dangerous in consequence of the ice, and that the danger had been increased by the thaw. The thaw having commenced, it became incumbent upon the proprietors to use greater care. But although the pit was stopped during the frost, it began to work again when the thaw came and the danger increased. The great accumulation of ice was admitted, and the said the ice could not be removed, but a few hours after the lad met his death the ice was all removed. The pit was 194 yards deep, and more precautions ought to have been used, owing to the increased danger from the deep fall. The jury must look at the state and depth of the pit, and consider weather, the thaw having set in, the defendants had done all they could to prevent a fall of ice. The amount claimed, £150. was the amount of three years wages, and full damages that could be claimed under the Act, but the jury must consider whether that would be fair damages. His Honour did not see much in the defence of contributory negligence that had been set up. — The jury retired to consider their verdict and after an hour's absence returned to court with a verdict for the plaintiff, damages £72. — At a later hour of the day the two jurymen who were absent, Messrs. Bowman and Dixon, presented themselves and having, through Mr. Webster, given a satisfactory explanation of their absence when called, his Honour remitted to fine upon them.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, —      
Atter, —      
Birkett, George      
Brockbank, J.      
Brown, —      
Brunless, —      
Compton, Henry      
Cowman, W. B.      
Dee, J. G.      
Dixon, Hamilton      
Downey, Robert      
Fairish, Adam      
Green, W. J      
Hine, James      
Hookes, James      
Ingham, T. H.      
Jefferson, Robert      
Lamb, Robert      
Liddel, J. H.      
Lonsdale, Earl of      
Mason, —      
Moore, Henry      
Moore, John      
Paisley, W.      
Webster, —      
Whiteside, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Bowthorn Colliery  Bowthorn Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print