|
Northern Counties GazetteArticle from the Northern Counties Gazette, 12th February 1881 A Case Of Wrongful DismissalJohn Martin, James Leigh, Patrick Leigh, John Maddison, and Francis Roundy, sued Henry Rowen, manager of No. 2 Pit, Knockmurton Mines, Lamplugh, for £6 7s., being the money due on 134 tons of metal which was broken by them in the pit; and also for £1 5s., which it was agreed should be paid to them for putting in some wood, and a further sum of £2 13s., being damage for being dismissed without three days' notice, which was the rule of the pit. — Mr. Atter appeared for the complainants, and Mr. Chapman for the defendant. — John Martin said he had worked with the defendant in the pit — he thought for some four months. On the 1st January there was a new arrangement made as to the terms upon which they worked. Previously they had been working for 2s. 8d. per ton, and the price was agreed to be increased to 3s. per ton on the 17th January. The other complainants were working with him, and their names appeared on the books of the pit; they were included in the contract with him. All went well till the 24th or the 25th, when faults were found with the metal sent up, and four boggies were said to be all bad. The place in which they were working was very wet, and on the 24th ult. they sent up fifteen boggies. They kept back four of the boggies, as they said they were mostly rubbish. The men were not able to help it; they did all they could to keep the metal clean, but it was almost impossible. Witness was dismissed at once when this bad stuff was sent up; so also were those who were working with him. He did not know of any rule by which the men were to be dismissed without notice if they sent up bad or mixed metal. The usual course was to make a deduction. He had never heard of any one being dismissed for such a thing. The defendant put in a counter claim for some gear, which was lost in the mine through the falling of the "drift." That gear was not lost through any fault of the men. Their money had not been paid to them. They had all to leave at once; they should have had three days' notice to leave. If witness had wanted to leave he should have been required to give three days' notice. — In cross-examination, witness admitted that £4 12s. 6d. had been tendered, but he did not take it, as it was not the amount owing. He was to have taken that and let the matter go no further. — In a conversation which here took place between the parties, the complainants admitted 9s. 6d. deduction for doctor's fees, &c., and the defendant the 25s. for wood. — The other complainants were also called, and gave similar evidence. — The defendant, Mr. Rowen, said he was manager at the pit. He had been going his rounds underground, and his attention was called to where some rubbish had been taken away, as he thought, for the purpose of being sent up in the place of metal. The four boggies, which were sent up and rejected, were 10 per cent rubbish, and the most of the rest was slate rock. It was all wet, and the place where the complainants were working was dry. He dismissed the men at once. He believed he had a right to do so. There was an understood rule that if they did their work they should have three days' notice; but if they misconducted themselves they were liable to be turned away at once. He tendered the amount due, subject to the ordinary deductions for rent and doctor's fees. He admitted that some of the gear, which was said to be lost, was found the other day. He would give the men back their money when they found it all. — The Bench: Is there anything to prevent you finding the rest? — Defendant: We have found the half of it; we got part of it last Friday. — The Bench: If you got part of it, could you not get the rest? — Defendant: Because it is not there. — The Bench: And you expect the men to find it. (Laughter.) — Defendant: I don't know whether it is there or not. They may have removed it. I don't say they have, but we cannot find it. I said they would get back their money when we found the gear. The defendant called two other witnesses to support his statement. — Mr. Chapman submitted that the dismissal of the men was owing to their not having done their work as they should have done. — Mr. Atter said they were entitled to their contention, as no claim had been put in for the metal wrought on the 24th. They had not got a penny for the twelve boggies sent up and said to be good on that day. These were not included in the 134 tons. — The Bench made an order for £6 7s. 6d. Costs were not allowed, and the claim for wrongful dismissal was refused.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||