18th December 1880, Page: 610, Column: 1
Topics of the week
Colliery Explosions
These great mining disasters, as at Seaham and Pen-y-Graig, excite universal sympathy; and yet, as an article in another portion of our issue points out, more lives in the aggregate are lost in mines by the continually recurring small accidents of which
the public never hears. Mr. Macdonald, who ought to be an authority in such matters, declares that all mining accidents are preventable, and that every death "is uncalled for and a crime." This is no doubt theoretically true, not only of mining
disasters, but of all accidents. There is scarcely a mischief which befalls life, limb, or property which may not be traced to the default of some human being. The practical question here is whether further legislation would render mining, which is an
exceptionally dangerous business, less dangerous than it now is. The question is not an easy one to answer. Mr. Macdonald holds that the responsibility both of owners and workmen should be more stringently enforced, yet apparently he does not propose to
ask Parliament for any additional powers in this respect. On the other hand practical men say that there are plenty of excellent regulations in existence, but that they are indifferently observed, and that, such is the apathy bred by familiarity with
possible danger, they will always be laxly observed. It is to be noted that the primary object both of coalowners and coalminers is not to preserve life, but to make money, and in the keen strife of competition life-preserving rules are pretty sure to be
neglected. If our coal-mines, like our electric telegraphs were the property of the State, they would probably be worked in a more easy-going fashion than now, and there would perhaps be fewer accidents, but we should have to pay dearer for our coals.
Are we willing to make the sacrifice?
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| MacDonald, — | | M.P. | |