|
16th December 1880 Expensive Mining LitigationIn the Exchequer Division the cases of Smith v, the Parkside Mining Company and of the Parkside Mining Company v. Smith were on Friday last before Justice Hawkins and Stephen, sitting at Westminster. The actions raised important questions of mining rights in relation to some property at Frizington, near Whitehaven. — The Solicitor-General and Mr. Crompton appeared for Mr. Samuel Wagstaff Smith, and Sir John Holker Q.C., and Mr. Mybergh represented the Parkside Mining Company. — Sir John Holker explained that the cases had been referred to arbitration and he now moved, pursuant to notice, to set aside the award upon certain grounds mentioned in affidavits. The Solicitor-General mentioned to the Court he had a preliminary objection to the motion of his learned friend, to the effect that it was out of time. A motion had been made ex parle in the Queen's Bench Division, which, if properly made, would have been in time, but the motion should have been after notice to the other side, which was not given, and when a sufficient notice was given on the 24th November for the 27th November his learned friends were too late. The award was made in July and no application was made to set it aside until the end of November; there was no ground for any such delay. — Sir John Holker urged that the Judicature Act recorded that "a complaint" should be made against the award up to the day before the last day of term, and by the ex parle motion as well as by the notice of motion such a complaint had been made. — Their lordships, after some further discussion, decided against the objection, and the motion proceeded. — Sir John Holker explained that Mr. Smith at the commencement of the action was lessee of an iron mine at Crossgill, and the Parkside Mining Company were lessees of an adjoining mine. On the 22nd July 1876, Mr. Smith issued a writ against the Parkside Company to recover compensation for the removal of iron ore situated within his boundary, and to have it decided that a tramway had been laid down by the Company upon his land in respect of which he was entitled to a waylee or charge for conveyance of ore by the Company on the tramway. — The Company, in their statement of defence, alleged that the land from which Mr. Smith accused them of having wrongfully extracted iron ore had been granted to them by the owner, the Earl of Lonsdale, and that the tramway had been made by leave and licence of the plaintiff. The Company, in their action against Mr. Smith, claimed compensation for the alteration of a water course, as a result of which their mine was partly flooded, and damaged resulted to their mine and plant, and complained that Mr. Smith had trespassed on their property and extracted ore therefrom, and that the soil supporting their mine to which they were entitled had been removed by Mr. Smith with the effect of injuring their property. As to the watercourse the arbitrators had given their decision, but as the other matters Mr. Smith give a general denial, including the alleged right of the Company to support from soil in his mine. These actions having been commenced on the 12th February, 1877, an order was made to refer all the matters in difference between the parties to two arbitrators and an umpire. There were a large number of attendances extending over a period of two years at a considerable expense, the arbitrators fees alone amounting to £2,000. The real question, however, to be decided between the parties was one of boundary, and no finding had been given upon it by the arbitrators. — Justice Stephen: perhaps the arbitrators might have arrived at a decision on the question in their own mind there was nothing in the order of reference which required them to express their views. — Sir John Holker: Then if that is so I can only say that the arbitrators have made an award which is not the slightest use, and they had not given any decision at all as to the question of waylee and of support. — The solicitor-General said it was of very little difference to him whether or not the case was sent back except from the fact that a delay would ensure in the settlement of the matter. His learned friend had said that the award was not the slightest use, but he thought otherwise, inasmuch as an award had been made in his favour of £6,000, — and important questions had been decided involving a payment of £2,000 to the arbitrators alone. He hoped their lordships would not agree to send back the award upon grounds of such informality, which had been mentioned. — Sir John Holker: The award not having stated the boundaries is not of the slightest use to my clients. — The Solicitor-General: The award would have been ultra vires if such a course had been taken. The arbitrators had no power to do so under the order of reference. — Justice Stephen: The award appears to be perfectly good so far as regards the order of reference, although perhaps it does not state all that both parties might have wished. — Sir John Holker: In the course of reference the parties clearly stated their wish, and, in fact, the whole proceedings were based upon the enquiry as to the boundary between the property of the two parties. Surely the arbitrators should have been bound to act accordingly and give their decision upon the question. — The Solicitor-General: There was no such duty cast upon the arbitrators by the order of reference. — Sir John Holker: My learned friend seems to be particularly eager to get the £6,000, but he should not obtain it until the award had had been made a good one. I ask therefore now that before the company take the £6,000 out of their pocket the arbitrators shall decide the boundary question. — The Solicitor-General objected to the arbitrators being asked to consider the question any further, inasmuch as his client had ceased to be proprietor of the mine in question. He would however, if their lordships wished, agree to the request of his learned friend if the arbitrators consented to do so. The umpire joined with the arbitrators in the award, and therefore it had unusual force — Sir John Holker: The award may have unusual force, but it is unusually useless. If my learned friend agrees to amend the order of reference. I will agree to pay him the £6,000. — The Solicitor-General: It should be remembered that my client has no further interest in the property, and I would object to embark on another inquiry at the cost of £1,500. Would my learned friend open up any other questions than that of boundary? — Justice Stephen asked whether the question of waylee and support would be kept up? They were clearly within the order of reference. — Sir John Holker said he would like to do so, would they but grant him the costs of the present motion, as he had substantially succeeded. — Justice Stephen: Each party should pay their own costs. The one side has obtained £6,000 and the other has succeeded in sending back the award. — It was then ordered that the award should be sent back from the arbitrators to decide the question of boundary and other matters upon existing materials.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||