21st September 1880
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
The deplorable loss of life in this case, the frequent recurrence of such accidents in England, and your observation in The Times of yesterday, that "it is singular so very few theories are broached to account for the disaster," appear
to me, in the interest of humanity, to make it the imperative duty of any one to come forward who thinks he can aid in any way in preventing or even diminishing the recurrence of accidents apparently so discreditable to the age we live in. I therefore
feel compelled, after more than 20 years' experience of mining in Germany, and especially in the coal-mining of Rhineland and Westphalian provinces, to call the public attention of Englishmen to the difference in the systems of ventilation applied in
England and here, which in my opinion tends to prevent the frequent occurrence of gas explosions here.
I have had in the last 25 years five large collieries won and "exploited" under my direction, each capable of putting out 1,000 to 1,500 tons of coal per day — sinking and completing the shafts for coal works on the most approved English
system of the day, with special permission of the German mining authorities, and opening out the mines and carrying on the coal work and ventilation mainly in conformity with the established system and rules of mining in this country ; and, though
employing 800 to 1,200 men per day at each colliery, our loss of human life from explosions has been very small indeed, though the mines consist of gas, steam, and coking coal, yielding much of explosive gases.
At an early period, owing to the great number of the seams of coal (as many as 50 to 60 in some collieries) and the steep inclination of the seams in most cases, the Germans were led into a system, which became an established rule with the mining
authorities, of driving at a high level across the coal formation a sufficiently large stone drift or gallery on the so-called "wetter sohle," above which no coal is allowed to be worked, and up into which the explosive gases, being lighter
than air, naturally ascend, or, if I might use the expression, drain off, with the return air, and are carried off to day by the upcast shaft of the colliery.
This "wetter sohle" is placed at a prescribed depth below the surface of the coal measures, whether they crop out to the day or are covered, as in the northern part of this coal basin, with 300 to 1,000 or more feet in height of diluvium chalk,
or other formations.
Return air courses are, I am quite aware, driven in England, especially in the Durham and Northumberland collieries, through many of which I travelled more than 20 years ago ; but they were not then, nor are they, I believe, now, constructed on the
principles and general system I have referred to ; and I may add, to avoid all misunderstanding, my humble testimony to the great talent, skill, energy, and attention which at the time were, and still more now, no doubt, are devoted by the mining
engineers and colliery managers of the north of England to ventilation.
Still, as in the recent discovery of a very simple process of dephosphorizing iron, there may be, and I am quite sure there must be, a process or a system in the construction and working of collieries by which this deplorable loss of life and damage to
property may be avoided, or at least greatly reduced ; possibly, too, the very simplicity of the remedy causes it to allude attention in these days of complex and scientific research.
I do not presume here to propose a remedy, but, apart from any discoveries which may be made for chemically destroying the dangerous qualities of the gases with which we have to deal in coal mines, I wish to draw the attention of engineers and practical
men to the cardinal point of providing independent means, from the highest points of the workings to the rise of a colliery, by ascending passages and a "wetter sohle" drift, for the rapid and uninterrupted escape of explosive gases, not only
from the seams at work, but still more from the "goafs" and from old worked-out seams, which form, especially in the flat-lying seams of England, such dangerous magazines of gas.
I must not occupy your valuable space in discussing by anticipation the objections and questions of cost which such a proposition may give rise to, but come to the main practical purpose of this letter, merely remarking as a simple popular explanation
that, as water is heavier than air, we make descending passages for its natural drainage ; and the gases in question being lighter than air, ascending passages should be made for their natural escape.
I therefore take leave to suggest that the Secretary of State for the Home Department should at his earliest convenience appoint an English commission of practical and scientific men to inquire into and report on the whole question, which is of so much
importance not only to Great Britain, but to Germany, Belgium, France, and other coal-producing countries, and that this commission should be instructed in the first instance to visit Prussia, where I am convinced every information will with pleasure be
afforded by the mining authorities under the direction of the present able Minister of Public Works, and where, on the part of the Mining Association of this district, of which I have the honour to be a member of council, I can personally assure such a
commission a hearty welcome and access to every information.
For such an investigation, whether by a separate commission or by the Government inspectors of mines, and for affording to the public the most detailed information as to the coal-mining in this country, rarely has there been so favourable an opportunity
as that afforded by the present industrial exhibition at Düsseldorf, not only of all the coal products in every state of preparation, but plans and cross-sections of all the great collieries of the district, showing in the greatest detail all their
workings, system of ventilation, means and machinery for ventilation, and all other purposes connected with the workings of collieries and mines in general and their statistics.
Such a complete collection of practical information on coal-mining has to my knowledge never before been brought together in any exhibition, and is not likely for many years to come to be again produced.
The Iron and Steel Institute, in their late meeting at Düsseldorf, found this exhibition as regards the objects of their inquiries highly interesting and useful ; and in my opinion that of the coal will not, at least, be less so to the practical mining
engineers and coal-owners of England.
The Düsseldorf Exhibition closes at the end of this month.
Your obedient servant,
William J. Mulvany,
Member of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers, and formerly Commissioner of Public Works in Ireland.
Pompelfort, Düsseldorf, Sept. 12.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Mulvany, William J. | | | |