|
2nd September 1880 The Cleator Moor Local Board and the Carron Iron CompanyAt the Whitehaven Police Court, on Monday, before C. Fisher, Esq., (Chairman), and a bench of magistrates, a case was heard in which the Cleator Moor Local Board applied that the Carron Iron Company should pay £36 19s 1d, on the ground that the Company had damaged a portion of a road in the Board's district by throwing "extraordinary traffic" thereon. — Mr. Webster appeared for the Board, and Mr. McKelvie for the Company. — Mr. Webster stated that the Cleator Moor Local Board sought an order against the Company under the provisions of the 23rd section of the Highways and Locomotives (Amendment) Act, 1878, which is as follows:— "Where by a certificate of their surveyor it appears to the Authority which is liable or has undertaken to repair any highway, whether a main road or not, that, having regard to the average expense of repairing highways in the neighbourhood, extraordinary expenses have been incurred by such authority in repairing such highway by reason of the damaged caused by excessive weight passing along the same, or extraordinary traffic thereon, such Authority may recover in a summary manner from any person by whose order such weight or traffic has been conducted, the amount of such expenses as may be proved to the satisfaction of the court having cognizance of the case to have been incurred by such authority by reason of the damage arising from such weight or traffic as aforesaid. Provided that any person against whom expenses are or may be recoverable under this section may enter into an agreement with such authority as is mentioned in this section for the payment to them of a composition in respect to such weight or traffic, and, therefore, the person so paying the same shall not be subject to any proceedings under this section." Mr. Webster then went on to state that the claim was for damage done in the year ending the 25th March last, by reason of extraordinary traffic thrown upon a road lying between Jacktrees Pit and Cleator Moor goods station by the defendants carting iron ore thereon. With ordinary traffic only, the road could be kept for two years; but owing to the extraordinary traffic thrown on it by the company, great expense had been incurred in metalling it and otherwise making it suitable. Mr. Webster quoted a few figures from the certificate furnished by the Board's surveyor, whom he then called as a witness. — Mr. Malkinson, clerk and surveyor to the Cleator Moor Local Board, said he had made a calculation, and given in a certificate to the Local Board as to the additional cost which the road in question had entailed, owing to the extraordinary traffic thrown upon it by defendants carting iron ore from Jacktrees Pit to the Cleator Moor goods station. He produced the certificate. — Mr. McKelvie interrupted to say that he thought something else should be proved first — the formation of the district. — Mr. Brockbank did not think that was necessary. He asked Mr. McKelvie whether, if the question had been one of the highways under the old Highway Act, he would have had the appointment of the surveyors, with the legality of the vestry meetings and the notices on the church doors, duly proved. Mr. McKelvie said that in other cases in which he had been concerned he had to prove the formation of the Whitehaven Union, and produced the order of the Local Government Board forming it. The Chairman: Do you intend to press it, Mr. McKelvie? — Mr. McKelvie: No, I don't. — Mr. Webster: I can soon do it; I have a document down at my office. — Mr. Brockbank: Very well. There are certain things we are in the habit of taking for granted. — Witness, resuming, said the amount due to the Board for the excessive traffic thrown on the road was £36 19s 1d. There were 4½ miles of road in the Board's district. — The Chairman inquired whether this comprised the whole of the road used by the Company's traffic. — Mr. Webster replied that the portion of the Board's road claimed for was 493 yards; but there was another small portion, which belonged to the Whitehaven District Highway Board. This 493 yards was all that was in question now. — In answer to Mr. Webster, witness gave several of the figures from his certificate. The cost of repairing these 4½ miles of roads for the year ending the 25th March last was £172 7s 2d, or an average cost per mile of £20 17s 9d — leaving out the 493 yards affected. At this rate the cost of maintaining the 493 yards would be £8 7s 5d, and deducting this sum from £45 6s 6d, the sum it had actually taken to maintain the road, £36 19s 1d was left. This sum the Board now sought to recover from the Company. — In answer to Mr. Webster, Mr. McKelvie said he did not dispute that the amount had been incurred. Mr. Malkinson had shown it, and they had no means of contradicting it. — In further answer to Mr. Webster, witness said the wear and tear on this road had been caused by the Company's cartage of iron ore to the Cleator Moor goods station. There was nothing special from any other part of the district to cause the damage. — In answer to Mr. Brockbank, witness said he could say how many carts passed a day. — Mr. McKelvie: They have six carts in a day. — By Mr.Webster: The road was in good condition before this excessive traffic was thrown on to it. The whole length was metalled after the Messrs. Lindow ceased using it, during the winter of 1878-9. — Mr. McKelvie here put in put in books to show that up to the 25th March last his clients had only carted 9,296 tons of ore; whilst between 17th October, 1877, and the 25th March, 1878, Messrs. Lindow (the previous lessees of the Jacktrees Pit) had carted 16,935 tons. — Mr. Brockbank here said that the defendants must have had more than six carts a day; it was nearly 100 tons a day. — The Chairman: its 90 tons a day. — Mr. McKelvie: The six carts might have six goes a day (Laughter.) — Mr. Webster (jocularly): That's a Jesuitical way of putting it. — Mr. McKelvie cross-examined the witness as to a previous certificate for a less sum he had sent in to the Company; but Mr. Malkinson explained that this was owing to a mistake he had made in confounding yards and feet in a plan he had taken. He was also examined as to the traffic that went to the Co-operative stores in Jacktrees-road; and Mr. McKelvie also asked him whether it was not the case that iron ore had always been carted over this road? — Witness: Yes, and the ratepayers of Cleator Moor know it to their cost. — Frank Watson, a foreman in the employ of the Local Board, was next examined. He said he superintended the repair of this road in the winter of 1878-9, and it was put in good condition — three inches of metal being put down on an average. It was done while the Messrs. Lindow were carting over the road; and it was in good condition when they ceased carting, as the traffic had consolidated the metal. He (witness) had counted eight, ten, and twelve of the Carron Company's carts altogether on the road; and their traffic completely cut up the road. In consequence of this, they had to give the road an extraordinary repair, putting 140 yards of stone on it. — In cross-examination by Mr. McKelvie, witness said that with only ordinary traffic the road would do for two years together, or for three or four with a little patching; but as it was, he had had to metal it every year, and he would have to metal it again this winter if the present traffic continued. — For the defence, Mr. McKelvie contended that the traffic was not "extraordinary." If they consulted any dictionary they would find that "extraordinary" was something not ordinary — something wonderful, something special, something that occurred only once in a lifetime, or once in a hundred years.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||