




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
18th March 1880
Man Kicked To Death at Moor Row
Verdict Of Manslaughter
At the Whitehaven Police court, last Monday, before H. Jefferson, Esq. (in the chair), the Rev. J. Rimmer, and Major Spencer, William Trembath, iron ore miner, Moor Row, was brought up in custody, charged with "causing the death of Martin Rowe, by
kicking him with a clog." On the case being called, Superintendent Bird said: The prisoner is charged with causing the death of Martin Row, at Moor Row, yesterday morning, by kicking him violently on the head. It appears that between nine and ten
o'clock a quarrel took place between a man named Jenkinson and another man named James Trembath, a nephew of the prisoner. It led to a fight between the two men, and Jenkinson was knocked down, and whilst lying on the ground James Trembath kicked
Jenkinson. Whilst doing so the deceased man Rowe interfered, and got hold of Trembath to prevent him using such violence. On doing this the prisoner rushed forward, knocked the deceased man down, and kicked him behind the head; and he died in a few
minutes, from the injury. The occurrence was reported to Inspector Smith, and the prisoner was taken into custody at once. I propose to call a witness to speak to the facts, and I will also call Inspector Smith, and I will then ask the Bench to remand
the case till Monday. Mr. Atter (for the prisoner) thought it unnecessary to call any evidence at present, as it would all be heard at the inquest to-morrow. Mr. Brockbank asked Mr. Bird if he had reason to suppose prisoner would be charged with
manslaughter; and Mr. Bird having replied in the affirmative, prisoner was formally remanded till Monday.
The Inquest
On the body of the deceased, Martin Rowe, was held at the Station Hotel (Mrs. Richardson's), Moor Row, before Mr. Webster, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, on Tuesday afternoon. The following composed the jury: Messrs. George Grey (foreman), Joseph
Robson, Christopher Burns, James Johnston, Charles Gowan, William Jackson, John Fife, John Bouch, John Wakefield, John Byers, Thomas Smurthwaite, Henry Hartley, James Stout, and Joseph Braithwaite — Mr. Atter watched the case on behalf of the
prisoner. — Superintendent Bird was present during the inquiry. — Ralph Vivian, miner, Moor Row, was the first witness called. He said: I knew the deceased Martin Rowe, who had been lodging with me for about ten weeks. He was 27 years of
age. He left my house on Sunday morning about seven o'clock, I believe ; and I saw him myself about a quarter past nine o'clock near to Mr. Stick's door, about 40 yards from my house. He was talking to Mr. Stick. A man named Isaac Jenkinson was in
company with him; and both men appeared very tipsy. About a quarter of an hour afterwards I saw deceased and Jenkinson quarrelling with a man named James Hoskins, near my door; and Jenkinson took his coat off two or three times to fight Hoskins, and
challenged him. Hoskins told him to go about his business. Deceased held Jenkinson's coat when he took it off. Hoskins was sober. Whilst Jenkinson and Hoskins were talking, a man named James Trembath came out of a house near to where deceased was
standing; and Jenkinson and Trembath began at once to fight. Several men, including deceased, got between the men; and I saw William Trembath, who was on the road, go towards deceased and knock him down. When Rowe fell, William Trembath kicked him
about the head. I only saw him give one kick. Deceased was lifted and brought into my house by three men, within three minutes afterwards; and he then appeared to be dead. William Trembath had a pair of clogs on at the time. When I saw deceased was
dead, I went to the door and shouted to him that he had done the job now, as the man was dead. By the Juryman: I was about 12 or 13 yards from where the fight was going on. I was quite sober, having just got out of bed. — By Mr. Atter: At the
time I saw deceased struck and kicked, there was nothing to intercept my view. I saw James Trembath on the ground just before deceased was knocked down, but I didn't see deceased kick him. Deceased was quarrelsome on Sunday morning with James Hoskins,
but not with Trembath. — By a Juryman: I never heard of any quarrel the night before between Trembath and deceased. — Henry Daniels, miner, Moor Row, said that on Sunday morning he saw Jenkinson strike Hoskins on the side of the face, and
knocked the pipe out of his mouth; and deceased interfered, and told Hoskins that if he wouldn't fight Jenkinson, he would have to fight him. Hoskins told them both to go away, as they were too drunk. Jenkinson then took his coat off, and challenged
Hoskins to fight. A man named Postlethwaite, who was also present, was taking his coat off, when James Trembath came from the door of his house, and knocked Postlethwaite down. Jenkinson then struck Trembath, and they had a scuffle, in the course of
which Jenkinson fell and was kicked on the leg by Trembath. William Trembath then took hold of the deceased by the neck, and they also had a scuffle, when deceased fell. While on the ground William Trembath gave him a kick. While William Trembath and
the deceased were scuffling, witness did not see either of them strike, nor did he see any blow given that would knock deceased down. — By a Juryman: I think deceased was too drunk to stand. — By Mr. Atter: I did not see deceased interfere in
the fight between Jenkinson and James Trembath. I never saw the latter lying on the ground. Deceased was very quarrelsome that day. — James Blewatt, miner, Moor Row, also gave evidence as to what passed in the scuffle between the deceased and
William Trembath. The latter was preventing deceased going to take part in a fight between Isaac Jenkinson and some others. Deceased hit William Trembath in the face, and Trembath thereupon struck him, also in the face, and knocked him down; and whilst
deceased was lying on the ground, Trembath kicked him. He kicked him directly he fell. Witness could not say whether deceased spoke after he was kicked. He was at once carried into his lodgings. Witness could not say whether deceased was then alive
or dead. — By Superintendent Bird: Could not say where deceased was kicked, though he saw it and heard it. — By Mr. Atter: The blows between deceased and William Trembath were given at once. — Dr. Eaton, Cleator Moor, gave the results
of a post-mortem examination he had made on the body of the deceased on Monday. He said that on the left side of the cheek, behind the ear, there was a dark mark of bruising, which was about 1¼ inches long, about ½ inch broad at the upper
end, and tapered to the lower end, where it was about ¼ inch wide. Its upper edge was on a level with the lobe of the ear, but it was not a straight line, being curved at the anterior corner, and the anterior edge was about 2 inches behind, where
the ear at its lower end joins the cheek. Beneath the skin at this part I found the muscles and sub-cutancous fat oozing dark blood, and infiltrated with soft clots. The depth of the infiltration was down to the bone, and involved portions of the
splenius and streno-mastoid muscles. The doctor described in further detail the results of the post-mortem, and ascribed the cause of death to the concussion of the upper portion of the spinal marrow, and the consequent effusion which existed, and in
juries to, or compression of this portion of the spinal marrow. Witness was of opinion that the mark on defendant's neck might have been caused by a kick from a person wearing clogs similar to those produced. Witness did not think the injuries on the
deceased's neck could have been caused by falling on to a stone or other hard substance. — Daniel Wilkinson, labourer, Moor Row, also gave evidence as to what took place previous to the fight between Jenkinson and James Trembath. The latter kicked
Jenkinson on the back of the head, and after wards on the leg whilst on the ground. Witness afterwards saw William Trembath kick deceased on the back of the neck. He did not see any blows struck between deceased and the elder Trembath. The former
appeared to be in drink at the time he was lying on the ground. — By Mr. Atter: There would be a score or more of people about the deceased at the time he was kicked. I was about 10 or 12 yards from him. I interfered between Jenkinson and the
younger Trembath, for the purpose of stopping a kick, but before I did so, a man named Edward Phillips got me by the neck. — Inspector Smith, Cleator Moor, stated that on Sunday morning last, he proceeded to Moor Row, and saw the dead body of
Martin Rowe. Witness noticed a mark at the back of the left ear, and, after making inquiries, he apprehended William Trembath, and charged him with causing the death of Martin Rowe that morning at Moor Row. Witness had Trembath conveyed to the lock-up
at Cleator Moor, and afterwards went to his (Trembath's) house, and asked his wife to show him the clogs her husband had been wearing that morning. She gave him the clogs now produced, from a small cupboard in the house. They were wet at the time with
dirt. Witness took the clogs to Cleator Moor, and the prisoner in reply to his (witness's) question as to whether he knew the clogs, admitted they were his. He replied to the charge of causing deceased's death, "I don't think I hurt him."
Witness previously cautioned him as to making any statement. — Some conversation here took place as to the evidence given, Mr. Atter complaining that the witnesses had been selected by the police. — The Coroner thought sufficient evidence had
been given to enable the jury to decide; but if Mr. Atter wished anyone called, he was perfectly willing to take his evidence. — Superintendent Bird disclaimed any intention of picking the evidence, and said there were several other witnesses whom
the Coroner had not yet called. — Mr. Atter expressing a wish that James Hoskins should by called, this was done. — James Hoskins, miner, Moor Row, said that on the morning named deceased wanted to go into William Trembath's house, and his
wife barred the door against him. Witness went to Rowe to try and get him home; but he refused to go, and took off this coat and wanted to fight witness. Witness proceeded to speak as to the fight that subsequently took place between James Trembath and
Jenkinson. The former was kicking the latter as he was getting up, and William Trembath came forward, took deceased by the collar, and said, "That'll do, Martin." Witness heard no threats. Afterwards he went to where deceased was, and he was
the first person to lift him up. Deceased said "Oh, I didn't think this of you." Witness and two others then took him home. He must have died before they reached home. — By a Juryman: Trembath didn't go away after he kicked deceased;
he stayed a good while. — By Mr. Atter: Believed the Trembath's were related, but could not say what the relationship was. — James Trembath was called to state the relationship between himself and William Trembath; the latter was a first
cousin of his (witness's) father. — Superintendent Bird said there were two other witnesses. Postlethwaite and Jenkins, in attendance; but the Coroner and the Jury did not think it necessary to hear more of the case. — The depositions were
then read over to the witness, and the Corner summed up the evidence, explaining the difference between murder and manslaughter, and he advised the Jury that there was no evidence of malice, either expressed or implied, on the part of William Trembath
against deceased, and therefore the case would be one of manslaughter. — The Jury at once returned a verdict of "Manslaughter."
The deceased, Martin Rowe, was a single man residing in Scalegill road. His remains were interred in Egremont cemetery on Tuesday afternoon, the funeral being very largely attended. The prisoner, William Trembath, is a married man, with a family of six
or seven children. He will be again brought before the Whitehaven Bench on Monday.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Atter, — | | Solicitor | |
| Bird, — | | Police Superintendant | |
| Blewatt, James | | Miner | |
| Bouch, John | | Juror | |
| Braithwaite, Joseph | | Juror | |
| Brockbank, — | | Solicitor | |
| Burns, Christopher | | Juror | |
| Byers, John | | Juror | |
| Daniels, Henry | | Miner | |
| Eaton, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Fife, John | | Juror | |
| Gowan, Charles | | Juror | |
| Grey, George | | Juror | |
| Hartley, Henry | | Juror | |
| Hoskins, James | | | |
| Jackson, William | | Juror | |
| Jefferson, H. | | Magistrate | |
| Jenkinson, Isaac | | | |
| Johnston, James | | Juror | |
| Phillips, Edward | | | |
| Postlethwaite, — | | | |
| Richardson, —, Mrs. | | Innkeeper | |
| Rimmer, J., Rev. | | Magistrate | |
| Robson, Joseph | | Juror | |
| Rowe, Martin | 27 | Miner | |
| Smith, — | | Police Inspector | |
| Smurthwaite, Thomas | | Juror | |
| Spencer, —, Maj. | | Magistrate | |
| Stick, — | | | |
| Stout, James | | Juror | |
| Trembath, James | | | |
| Trembath, William | | Iron Ore Miner | |
| Vivian, Ralph | | Miner | |
| Wakefield, John | | Juror | |
| Webster, John | | Coroner | |
| Wilkinson, Daniel | | Labourer | |
|
|