12th March 1880
High Court Of Justice, March 11th
This was an action brought by the Burial Board of Egremont, in Cumberland, to restrain the defendants from improperly working their mines under the cemetery, which was established by the Burial Board upon land purchased from Lord Lonsdale.
Sir WHITEHORNE, who appeared for the defendants, now moved that the plaintiffs might be ordered to produce their purchase deed and such other documents as would show whether the plaintiffs were entitled to the mines and minerals underneath the
cemetery. He stated that the defendants had obtained from Lord Lonsdale the right to work minerals in the district, and in working their mines they had most unfortunately sunk a shaft so near the surface as to let down into the mine one of the coffins
from the cemetery. This event they regretted exceedingly, and they had immediately made arrangements for sinking their shaft so much deeper that it would be impossible for such an event to occur again. If the plaintiffs would produce their title to
show that they had purchased the mines and minerals under the cemetery, the defendants would at once submit to an injunction against them and would pay the costs of the action; but it they had not so purchased the minerals, then the defendants would give
the most ample undertaking not to work their mine in such a manner as to do any injury to the cemetery. It was submitted that under the practice of the Court the Judge had power to make an order for production of documents at the earliest moment, where
it was evident that it would be for the benefit of all parties and would put a stop to the litigation.
Mr. BRISTOWE, Q.C., and Mr. T. A. ROBERTS, for the plaintiffs, opposed the motion on the ground that the defendants had no right to the production of the plaintiffs' title until after the defence had been filed.
The VICE-CHANCELLOR said this case involved a general principle of law. The plaintiffs alleged that they were in possession of this land under a conveyance to them in fee-simple. They had therefore shown prima facie case that they were entitled to the
land down to the centre of the earth, including, of coarse, all mines and minerals, and no one had any right to interfere with them. The defendants, notwithstanding this right, had bored a shaft through the ground underneath the cemetery, and it was for
them to show that they had a right to do so, and his Lordship could not at this stage of the proceedings order the plaintiffs to produce their title. But he would add that that, as matter of expediency, it was most desirable that the defendants should
know at the earliest period whether the plaintiffs had a right to the minerals, or whether, in purchasing the land, that right had been reserved. If there had been no reservation of minerals, then of course the defendants' case was at an end, and it was
for the interest of both sides that this fact should be ascertained. In the circumstances he felt bound to refuse the motion, that the costs would be coats in the action.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bristowe, — | | Q.C. | |
| Lonsdale, Lord | | Land Owner | |
| Roberts, T. A. | | | |
| Whitehorne, —, Sir | | | |