|
17th January 1879, Page: 3, Column: 5 The Abercarne ExplosionContinuation Of The InquestEvidence Of The Night Fireman[From Our Special Reporter] Abercarne, Thursday. The inquiry into the cause of the terrible explosion at Abercarne was resumed at the Crown Hotel here, to-day, before Mr. Coroner Brewer. Mr. Wheelhouse, Q.C., M.P., appeared on behalf of the Home Office ; Mr. J. E. Ward, solicitor, for the Ebbw Vale Company ; Mr. Walter Morgan, solicitor, Pontypridd, instructed by Mr. Samuel Davies, for the miners of South Wales and Monmouthshire, and the widows and relatives of the deceased miners ; Mr. Jordan, mineral agent, for the Ebbw Vale Company ; Mr. Pond, the manager of the colliery, and other officials and engineers interested in the inquiry, were in attendance, Mr. Phineas James, Mr. Foster Brown, Mr. J. T. Green, of the Celynen Colliery, and other gentlemen were present, together with a large attendance of the public. Some conversation having taken place as to the way in which witnesses should be called, Mr. Ward suggested to the coroner that the two day men should be called, before the night fireman had completed his evidence. Mr. Morgan said they were not here, and to save time he suggested that they should proceed with the night fireman's evidence. Mr. Wheelhouse wished to say, once for all, that this inquiry was not a matter of time. Time they must give, and were prepared to give to it, and anybody and everybody whom it was necessary to call, must be called to enable the coroner and jury to elicit the truth. The Coroner: We must do that. Mr. Wheelhouse : Our business is, even at the sacrifice of time, it may be, to get out all the truth. It was very little consequence in what way witnesses may be called, but it was important that the inquiry should not be unnecessarily shortened. Mr. Ward : It will be a convenience to have some arrangement in calling witnesses, and it would be a convenience that the day firemen be called before the night fireman or overman have completed their evidence. Mr. Morgan remarked that on speaking of time, he referred to the time that his friend (Mr. Ward) occupied in speaking. The men referred to were not here, and hence they must go on the best way they could. Summonses were issued, in order that the witnesses referred to be brought. Mr. Wheelhouse wished to say further that the other day there was a witness called who, when about to be sworn, desired to give his evidence in Welsh. Now he (Mr. Wheelhouse) was very anxious that no evidence should be in any way suppressed, and if a witness wished to give his evidence in his native tongue they had no right to exclude his evidence. They would call all persons who were able to speak anything of purport to this inquiry. He would, therefore, mention that it would be necessary for the coroner to provide an interpreter in sufficient time to interpret all that any witnesses, who spoke in Welsh, might say. It may be that other witnesses felt themselves competent to give evidence, but would prefer to do so in their native tongue. A man may be more at ease in speaking in his native tongue. It is very undesirable to exclude any witness who can give evidence. Elijah Lewis, fireman, was re-called, and was examined by Mr. Morgan. He said : I was fireman in Nos. 2, 4, and 17 districts. It took me five hours to go my round. Commenced with No. 4 district, and proceeded along, putting up marks of danger or safety as the case may be. If there was no colliers in, out a mark to show that I had passed that spot. It was the day of the month, and it indicated to the colliers that the spot was clear or safe. If a collier was working in a place, no mark was then put. A collier would work from two to ten; that is, "a shift" of eight hours. When a man left, assuming I had examined the spot before his leaving, then no mark would be put up there. The next shift would go on at five in the morning, and there would be no mark by me. The day fireman succeeds me at six o clock. There would be no place that would be left uninspected by a fireman from seven in the evening to three next day. Never heard Waters say that he was not able to finish his inspection until after three in the day. Cannot say which way the day fireman did his duty; but he ought to go the same round as myself. Finished No. 4 in about two hours, and finished about eight o'clock. Next I examined No. 17. It took me 1½ hours to examine this district, that would be about eleven o'clock, because it took time to go to No. 17. Then would go back to No. 4 district again. It was my nearest way out. Stayed about an hour in No. 4 to take supper, unless I was called upon. Then went to No. 2, and travelled the wind road. Generally speaking, got to No. 2 about 5 o'clock. That is the earliest time I should get to No. 2 at each examination. There were sheets across the headings of Thomas Sanders and Henry Russell, to turn the wind in. There were danger marks there. No fall had occurred there, but there was a squeeze, and the "collar" had given way. Did not hear Sanders or Waters say there was a fall there. The place was not worked at the time, owing to soft coal. There was no gas in this heading. Travelled the wind-road every night. There are two headings running parallel one to the other, viz., Tom Sanders' and Henry Russell's heading. Dancer marks were placed on both, to keep anyone from working there. Went in through Russell's heading and came out through Sanders'. Was able to go, as the air travelled from one to the other. There was a wind-road from Sanders' heading to Aberdare's heading of about four feet square over the fall. Perfectly understand you. (Witness explained what he had asserted on the plan.) The extent of the wind-road referred to was six feet collar and nine feet arm. Was in error as to the spot indicated. This wind-road was recently repaired by "Ikey" Sheppard and "Tom the Stronger." Recently means three months ago. The Coroner: You call that recently? Witness Yes. There was no fall in Sanders' wind-road, only a squeeze. Sheppard was working in Sanders' heading, near the fall, ripping top coal, and was doing this when I walked over it. I never saw a fall that I could go under. Sanders might have gone under a squeeze. Did not notice that the squeeze came very low. The wind goes around the face of the coal at the end of Aberdare's heading. Was there twice on the Tuesday night. Went there a second time because I heard men "cogging." William Brace's stall was the topmost in working. Two stalls beyond that had been abandoned three months before. The top one of the two was bashed up. The other was left open for the ventilation. We used to send air to old workings sometimes, for the purposes of ventilation. There was no airway in No. 4 district that I could not go through. Passed through every airway every night whether there was a fall or otherwise. Don't remember a single instance in which I could not go through all the airways. Never was prevented in going through any airway. The airway register was referred to, and witness swore that this entry was correct. On the 6th of September the quantity of air passing in No. 4 district was 19,380 cubic feet per minute. The average was kept up with tolerable correctness until Monday before the day of the explosion, when the quantity sunk to 13,940, which increased to 15,300 cubic feet per minute on the morning of the day of the explosion. Mr. Morgan objected taking an average of the week before, because it did not apply, inasmuch as the week before the explosion the quantity of air was less. Mr. Ward wished to say that dividing 15,300 cubic feet between the 36 men employed in this district, it gave 412 cubic feet per man per minute. Mr. Morgan considered Mr. Ward was wrong in his calculation, besides it was necessary to know how many horses were in the pit, because he was informed that one horse vitiated as much air as 10 men. Mr. Ward said he took his data from Mr. Waddington Smyth's book. Mr. Morgan replied that he could quote books as well as his friend. Witness could not give the number of men working in this section of the colliery. The air-measuring station was some distance below the double doors between the two stations. The air was taken in two places, and I stood on one side and held the anemometer in my hand. By Mr. Ward: There was nothing to cause any obstruction to the air on the night of the explosion, and the whole of the district was properly ventilated. In such a place as Colley's road and Rees's road I could not pass over the fall until Monday. This was not a main airway. Mr. Morgan: Witness told me that he never was obstructed by any fall. Mr. Ward: In a main airway — this was a stall. Mr. Morgan: In long work every stall is an airway. Examination continued: There was a sufficient quantity of air passing through the old rubbish stall, leading up to Colley's road. My time, between eight o'clock in the night and three o'clock in the morning, I should be at the beck and call of anyone who wanted it. That is to say, I was continually inspecting, excepting when I was eating. Was so engaged the whole of the time. Make one regular systematic inspection, and then if I notice anything like danger I go back again. Mr. Morgan protested against the leading way in which Mr. Ward put his questions to witness, leaving the man to say simply, "Yes or no." The Coroner said he should put the questions in that way if Mr. Ward did not do so. Mr. Morgan was prepared to leave it to the Coroner, if he said Mr. Ward's mode of questioning was right. The Coroner said he was not a counsel, but all he desired was to get at the truth. Mr. Morgan: I do not think you do elicit the truth by allowing Mr. Ward to put words in the witnesses' mouths. Cross-examined: There was a general squeeze in Colley's road, but it had settled down before the explosion. The squeeze in Russell's place had settled before Wednesday morning. Don't think the squeeze interfered with the ventilation after the Sunday morning. Have worked in the Abercarne Colliery 17 years, and under various managers. The roadways and travelling ways are much the same now as 17 years ago. Every care has been taken with the roadway. Have had no complaints from any man that his place was too warm, or that he had not sufficient air. Always entered the result of my inspections in the books. Have always had a sufficient supply of timber for the purposes of this mine. Believe the windroads are as good now as six years ago, but there were not so many then as now. Russell worked in No. 2 six years ago. There were three overmen in Nos. 2, 4, and 17 districts by night, viz., Miles Moseley, Andrew Ashman, and Ephraim Watkins. Always met these overmen in the pit sometime during the night. By Mr. Wheelhouse: Never altered the area of the air measuring station in No. 4. By the Coroner: The overman was not always with me when I took the measurement of air. The overman worked out the calculations in the office. Was only examined by Mr. Pond when I was appointed fireman. No certificate of examination is needed. When I was at supper, Ephraim Watkins examined No. 2 district. By Mr. Wheelhouse: My first masters were Mr. Prosser and Mr. Edwards, at the colliery 17 years ago. There are old colliers who worked in the colliery before it came into the hands of the Ebbw Vale Company. It was explained that there was as great a difference between the present Ebbw Vale Company, Limited, and the old Ebbw Vale Company, which consisted of four gentlemen, as possibly could be. The change took place in 1864. In answer to Mr. Wheelhouse, witness said he knew colliers alive now who had worked at the colliery before the Ebbw Company had possession of it; but these men had worked in the colliery since. Knew of no collier who had left because he did not like the change of management. No one had ever told him that the colliery was unsafe. Colliers frequently leave and come back again. Three shifts of men take place every day. The colliery is never vacant of men, but has always men in it. The air is quite fresh during the entire working of 24 hours. It does not get vitiated. Repairs go on during the night shift, between ten to six in the morning. Men are withdrawn when repairs are going on. A Davy lamp is used in some cases, and a Clanny lamp in others. Never knew a piece of coal falling damage a lamp. When a lamp was damaged it would be sent to the lamp station. There are only two stations in the pit. Mr. Wheelhouse put questions suggested by the jurors, to which witness replied : I always signed the report regularly. If I found dangerous bodies of gas in any stall I always put up danger marks, and did not inform the men on the top of the shaft of danger. I trusted to the danger mark, and the day fireman saw the report in the book. If I met the men, then I told them. Perhaps I should, and perhaps I shouldn't. Practically I trusted to the danger mark, and reported it. Have, as a rule, trusted to the danger mark alone. Mr. Wheelhouse, addressing the witness, said : Now, let me tell you once for all, that so long as you are fireman at this colliery, or so long as you have to do with any pit, if you find any danger, never again consider that you have done your duty when you see any men if you fail to tell them and warn them of danger. It is your bounden duty to tell it to them ; and if, after what I have now said to you, you fail to do so, you will do a grievous wrong. Examination continued: Considered No. 4 district a more dangerous district than No. 17, and hence spent so much time examining it. Remember the last time that I noticed gas before the explosion was on the Sunday night. I never met Mr. Cadman, the Government Inspector, at any time during the night shift. Never at any time to my knowledge have I met him until I saw him go down the pit after the explosion. Have found a lamp in the pit unlocked. It was sent down the pit unlocked. Occasionally, this happens. Not very often. Perhaps once in six months this would happen. Have examined the men for keys, and matches and pipes. Never found a key on a collier, nor a lamp key where it ought not to be. Never remonstrated with a man for being in possession of a key. Never reported a man for any such defect. After a short adjournment for luncheon, the examination of Elijah Lewis was further proceeded with. In answer to Mr. Wheelhouse, witness said :— I never found a match in a man's pocket. Have found pipes more than once — twice, I think. When I found a man with a pipe I handed him over to the overman, and he was sent out of the pit. Did not see him down the shaft again that shift. The men have mostly "'bacca on them. They are allowed to carry "'bacca." In doing so a man would run his head against the overman and me. Could not say why men carried pipes and tobacco without matches. When I left the colliery on the morning of the explosion, I left it as I considered, safe and free from gas. Never worked with a naked light. Had no key for the lamp — only a pricker. Could not open the lamp after it was locked in the lamp-house. Between the day shift and the night shift there might be an hour or two when there would be no fireman in the pit. James Harris is the fireman who attended to my district by day. I read the report of the day fireman every time before I went into the pit. If anything was wrong, then the first thing I should do was to go to the place left as unsafe, and if still unsafe, then I put up the danger mark. James Harris stopped the men on the Monday morning before the explosion. It is not the custom to report danger after it has been cleared away. Mr. Wheelhouse again cautioned witness always to report danger, even though it may have removed for a time. Examination continued : When the gauze of a lamp becomes clogged it is sent back to the lamp-station to be cleaned. Then another would be supplied to the man. This concluded this witness's examination. Mr. Wheelhouse suggested that one of the old men who had worked in the colliery before it came into the possession of the Ebbw Vale Company, should be called as a witness. John Marsh was called. He said: I am an overman, and at present I am looking after the Cwmcarne pit. Have been three years as an overman. Was down the Cwmcarne pit the day of the explosion, and was one of the first to go down. Knocked for the cage to go up, and to bring down more men. There were four other men who went down with me. Was about 40 yards from the top of the pit when the explosion occurred. Heard a regular shaking of the fencing around the top of the pit. Gave an alarm, and said "My lads, there is an explosion, or some occurrence that is not right." There was not much of a noise, not a great report. Retreated from the spot and went around a building where I saw dust and chips fly up from the shaft. This was not two minutes after I heard the report. Said to the engineer "Let's get up steam, as the engine may be wanted," as it was all up below. The engineer declined to let me down, fearing lest there might be another blow up from below. It was nearly an hour before I got down the pit. A messenger came from Abercarne to say there was an explosion down below. Got a lamp ready, and four others went down with me. Proceeded along to Lee's heading, and there found three bodies — two of whom were John Games and Rees Howells. Before I got to them I smelt there had been fire, and it became very warm. Could not say whether they were burnt much. Not a great many falls appeared, because I got along pretty well. Next found the body of John Lewis, and he and the others were brought up dead. In Michael's heading there were three more dead bodies. Saw traces of burning about the timber. Could not tell which way the blast had come. Measurements were taken regularly of all gas that came up the pit. I believe every half-hour. A great deal of gas came up that pit, and often we could not get inside the fencing of the pit in consequence of the quantity of the gas it gave off. Over a thousand feet of air came up the shaft per minute. By Mr. Ward : I was the only man who brought a dead body to bank at the Cwmcarne Colliery that was the body of John Lewis. Have worked in the Abercarne Colliery for about 28 years. By Mr. Wheelhouse : Have been from the works for a period of four years during the 28 years. Mr. Rogers had the works at the time I went there. He was followed by Mr. Blackburn. The Ebbw Vale Company had it from Mr. Dickenson Know of differences in the management since the Ebbw Vale Company took it. There was only one explosion before the Ebbw Vale Company had it — that was a little boy killed. Have heard of no complaint of the management during Mr. Pond's management. Never heard any complaint by overmen and firemen. Have heard men complain, and if they left on a Monday they would be glad to coma back again before Saturday night. Had not felt any greater fear since the change of management. Gas is still coming up the Cwmcarne shaft in great quantities. I am now in the employ of the Ebbw Vale Company. Lee's heading is about 900 yards from the Cwmcarne shaft. Everything required for ventilation was supplied, and the ventilation was good, and the management was the best and the safest possible. At a quarter-past four the Coroner said that he now proposed to adjourn the inquiry until 10 o'clock this (Friday) morning. A juror asked if another witness could not be taken, but the coroner declined.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||