Whitehaven Herald
Article from the Whitehaven Herald, 16th January 1879
Robbery And Violence
Second Day — Tuesday
(Before Mr. Justice Lindley)
His Lordship took his seat on the Bench shortly after ten o'clock.
John Knox (19, miner, imperfectly instructed) and Thomas Lynch (18, miner, imperfectly instructed) were charged with feloniously stealing from the person of Jane Lynn, a purse, a quantity of pawn tickets, and the sum of 5s.
4½d., and also with using personal violence towards her, at Whitehaven, on the 10th November last.
Mr. Henry prosecuted; the prisoner Knox was defended by Mr. Shee and the other by Mr. Mattinson.
Mr. Henry, in opening the case for the prosecution, informed the jury that the prosecutrix was an unfortunate, but in this country such people were no proscribed class, and were as much entitled to the protection of the law as any class. According to
the prosecutrix, the circumstances of the case were as follows :– About half-past one o'clock on the morning in question Jane Lynn was going from a house in Bardy-lane, near the Quay, Whitehaven. Coming to a place called Mount-steps, which rise
very rapidly from the Quay, she met the two prisoners. Knox immediately put his arms round her neck, laid hold of her, put his hand into her breast and abstracted her purse and the other things the prisoners were accused of stealing. The two prisoners
then ran away, followed by the prosecutrix, who came up to them on the Wellington steps, up which the prisoners had been prevented from escaping by the gates being shut. She tried to get her money back from Knox, but he set upon her and abused her in a
most shameful manner, struck her with his fist, knocked her down, and then again struck her and kicked her. While the prosecutrix was lying exhausted with the ill-usage she had sustained, Lynch cried to Knox "Have you got it?" — meaning
her purse. Knox answered "Yes," after which Lynch shouted "Let's away." Both prisoners then ran away and escaped into a ship. The prosecutrix gave information on the afternoon of the same day to P.S. Reid, Whitehaven, when
she exhibited two wounds on the head, both of which were even then bleeding. Knox was apprehended on the 14th by the sergeant on a warrant, and about four days afterwards Lynch was also taken into custody, charged with aiding and abetting the other in
committing the robbery. The fact of the assault was spoken to by a boy named Graham, as well as the prosecutrix, the boy's attention having been called to it by the screams of the woman. This boy knew the two prisoners, but when first before the
magistrates he stated that he did not know them, because he was "frightened to tell the truth." Other people spoke to the noise created by the woman, and the running away of the prisoners, among them being C. McGrath, seaman, and
Fisher Williamson, customs house officer, the latter of whom she told she knew "one of the men." — Mr. Mattinson, in addressing the jury on behalf of the prisoners, endeavoured to throw discredit upon the story of the woman,
pointing out that the woman's story as to the theft was entirely uncorroborated. Speaking more particularly of Lynch, even assuming there was a robbery committed by Knox, that did not criminate Lynch, unless there was proof of concert, and such proof
was out of the question. — Mr. Shee then adduced evidence in support of the defence, proving by two women (one a prostitute) that the prosecutrix "was full of drink," and had no money to lose that night. — Mr. Shee and Mr. Henry
having addressed the jury on the evidence, his Lordship summed up. Although there were several grounds, for drawing distinctions between Knox and Lynch as regards the actual part taken by them in the robbery; although there were differences between
them, inasmuch as according to the evidence for the prosecution Lynch did not at first offer any violence, the legal effect of that would amount to this: that if the jury were of opinion that the two prisoners were bent on robbing the woman, it did not
matter which took her purse if the other was present encouraging and ready to help the other to escape. There might, of course, be a difference as to the violence which was used towards the woman afterwards. — The jury returned a verdict of Guilty
against both prisoners. — His Lordship, in passing sentence, said he did not think it was possible for anybody to doubt the truth of the statement of the prosecutrix. They were both liable for the consequences of the robbery; at the same time
there was a difference between them. Knox had been by far the worst because of the way in which he ill-treated the woman upon the Wellington steps. There was this to be said about the offence, and he mentioned it because it did make a little difference
in the sentence which he was about to pass upon them and that was they did not appear to have ill-used the woman to any extent until they found themselves in a corner on the Wellington steps. Had the violence taken place at the time of the robbery he
should have ordered them to be flogged. As it was he sentenced Knox to fifteen months' imprisonment and Lynch to nine months' imprisonment, each with hard labour.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Graham, — | | | |
| Henry, — | | Solicitor | |
| Knox, John | 19 | Miner | |
| Lindley, — | | Justice | |
| Lynch, Thomas | 18 | Miner | |
| Lynn, Jane | | | |
| Mattinson, — | | Solicitor | |
| McGrath, C. | | | |
| Reid, — | | Police Sergeant | |
| Shee, — | | Solicitor | |
| Williamson, Fisher | | | |