Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Mine Inspectors Reports

Article from the Mine Inspectors Reports, 1878, Page: 240


The Charge against a Colliery Manager at Swansea

The Certificate Suspended

Source: 1878 Mines Inspectors Report (C 2321), South Wales District by Thomas E. Wales, H.M. Inspector of Mines

"The Charge against a Colliery Manager at Swansea.

"The Certificate Suspended.

"The inquiry instituted by the Home Secretary into the conduct of Evan Foster, manager of the Ystradfawr Colliery, Ystradgynlais, was continued at the Guildhall, Swansea, on Saturday. Before Mr. H. C. Rothery, the Commissioner appointed to make the inquiry, assisted by Mr. Thomas Cadman, Inspector of Mines for the South-West District, as assessor.

"Mr. C. H. Glascodine appeared for the Home Office, and Mr. W. Robinson Smith defended Mr. Foster.

"Mr. T. E. Wales, Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines for South Wales, was called, and stated that he had received notice of an explosion which took place at the Ystradfawr Colliery in September last. He visited the pit on the 9th, and then found some gas there in Bowen's level. He spoke to Mr. Foster about it, but that gentleman did not think he was called upon to clear away the gas, because Bowen's level was not then in work. The quantity of air which passed through the pit was 15,000 to 16,000 cubic feet per minute, and of that probably only 8,000 feet would be diverted into Bowen's level where the gas accumulated. The air which passed through that level, and the airway leading thereto, was wholly insufficient. Mr. Wales then explained how the pit was ventilated, and pointed out that the accumulated gas could easily be removed.

"Mr. Smith then ably addressed the Court, and argued that Mr. Foster had done all that he thought it was necessary; that he had been diligent and attentive in the discharge of his duties, and that there had been no wilful neglect. He had endeavoured to the best of his ability to do his duty as manager of the Ystradfawr Colliery.

"Mr. Glascodine also addressed the Court, after which an adjournment took place.

"The learned Commissioner, on the reassembling of the court, very ably explained the working of the pit, and the means of ventilation which were adopted. He also referred to a legal question which had arisen during the case. Mr Glascodine wished to put in the depositions which were taken before the magistrates of Ystradgynlais when Mr. Foster was charged there with a breach of the 1st and 2nd General Rules of the Mines Regulation Act of 1872, and fines were imposed. Mr. Smith objected to the deposition being put in, and he (the Commissioner) upheld the objection. Any statement made by Mr. Foster before the magistrates or anywhere else, and properly sworn to, might be received, but the depositions unsupported by oath could not be put in evidence. After he had given at great length the arrangements for ventilating the pit, &c., the learned Commissioner said :— Then these questions would arise — Was Mr. Foster justified in allowing the accumulation of gas to continue in Bowen's level as he did for five or six weeks? Had he the means of getting rid of the gas? Was he justified in allowing the men to work with naked lights in such close proximity to this gas? As regarded the third point, there could be no question that Mr. Foster was not justified in allowing the men to work with naked lights with almost a certainty — he would not say a probability — that at some time or other the gas would be ignited, and those who were employed in the pit would be either killed or injured. As regarded the getting rid of the gas, Mr. Wales had explained very clearly to the Court with what facility it could have been disposed of. It was a very simple process, and would have been effectual for the purpose. If that process had been adopted, all the air which passed under the existing arrangements during the day from Bowen's level through the airway, would instead of that have passed through the adit and the face of the level, and would have carried away all the gas into the airway. Mr. Foster could not pretend to be ignorant of this accumulation of gas. Indeed, his advocate admitted that he was cognizant of it, and therefore Mr. Foster had shown either very great incompetency or gross negligence in not having taken some such means as those pointed out by Mr. Wales for the purpose of getting rid of the gas. The Court thought, therefore, that the first charge against the defendant was fully established. He could not, however, pass over that part of the case without referring to the terms of the notice which, by the Act of Parliament, the defendant was compelled to send to the Inspector of mines for the district. In stating in that notice the character of the accident of the 6th of September, Mr. Foster describes it as a slight explosion of gas in the roof of a level heading where men were timbering under a piece of ground that had fallen down to the height of about ten feet from the floor. The obvious intention of Mr. Foster in sending that statement was to induce the inspector, as he induced Mr. Lloyd Davis, the manager, to think that the explosion of gas arose from a portion of the roof having then and there fallen, by which an escape of gas had suddenly taken place, and not that it had arisen from an explosion of gas which had been allowed to accumulate in the mine for a space of something like six weeks at least. Mr. Foster had shown in that respect a want of fairness and honesty which the Court would have been very glad to have seen absent from the case. The second charge against Mr. Foster was that on the 9th of September, and on days immediately preceding, although inflammable gas had been found in the mine within the preceding 12 months, he neglected to enter or cause to be entered a report to the effect in a book kept for that purpose at the mine, contrary to the second General Rule of the 51st section of the Coal Mines Regulation Act of 1872. It was certainly true that the duty of keeping that report book fell upon the fireman, but for what purpose was it kept ? Assuredly for the information of the manager, and for the information of the Inspector when he visited the colliery. In looking at that book he found that, from the 9th of September back as far as the 24th of July, the only observation which the fireman made was 'Safe,' and sometimes he believed it was 'All safe.' On the 24th of July a fall of roof occurred in the north-east heading, and that, he presumed, was the fall which had caused the suspension of work in David Bowen's level. On the 9th of September Mr. Wales having received the notice of which he (the Commissioner) had spoken, proceeded to visit the mine, and although he found on entering the pit a report signed by Thomas Bowen, the fireman, certifying that all was safe, he discovered when he entered Bowen's level that there was a quantity of gas there; and this, be it remembered, was at 10 o'clock in the morning, after a current of air — such as it was — had been allowed to run during the night round the face of David Bowen's level, and to carry away such portion of gas as it could. Mr. Wales called the attention of the manager to the presence of gas at this place, and he observed that he did not think he was called upon to report it, because the heading did not form a portion of the present workings. The Commissioner then referred to a case against Humphrey and Brough, where it was held that it was not enough to ventilate the working places, travelling roads, &c., but it was necessary to ventilate such places as would render the working places dangerous in the event of an accumulation of gas. It was of no use for Mr. Foster to say that he was not bound to keep Bowen's level clear, because there was no working there. After this and down to some time in October, there were entries in the fireman's report book to the effect that gas was found in Bowen's level. It was not pretended that Mr. Foster was ignorant of this gas. All that was said was that he did not think it necessary to report it, and that, further, the report book was kept by the fireman, and not by the manager. If the report, however, was made for the benefit of the manager, it was his duty to see that the reports were entered correctly. If the fireman stated that which was not true it was the duty of the manager to inquire into the matter. The third charge is that in June last several explosions occurred in the mine attended with personal injury to those employed therein, and the defendant neglected to report the same to the Inspector of mines for the district, contrary to the 39th section of the Act. The Court had heard the evidence of a boy named William Watkins, who said that whilst working in the mine some time in June last he was burnt about the head by an explosion, that he left the pit immediately, and that at the top he saw Mr. Foster and showed him where he had been burnt. Mr. Smith had contended that William Watkins's evidence was not to be believed, but he (the Commissioner) failed to see why it should be disbelieved. If the statement were untrue Mr. Foster might have been called to deny it, and to prove that he had never seen the injuries which Watkins received, or that Watkins had spoken to him about them, but Mr. Foster had not been called for the purpose and the charge remained simply upon the evidence of William Watkins. The Court could see no reason to doubt his statement. A man named Howell Johnson had told them that on the 21st of June last, whilst he was at work in the mine, an explosion took place, and he was burnt. He went on to say that he left the work at once, and was away eight or nine days. It was true that Howell Johnson had not pretended that he had told Mr. Foster or Bowen, the fireman, of the injuries which he received, but he was away from his work and Mr. Foster must surely have known that he was absent. He had not told the Court that he had made any inquiry about the absence of Johnson, and it was clear that he knew he was away from his work. On the day after the accident Johnson sent to the colliery for oil. That stood undenied, and the Court must, therefore, conclude that there had been two explosions, at any rate, in the month of June, and it was not even pretended that these explosions were reported. Nor could they allow Mr. Evan Foster to escape on the assumption that the injuries sustained by William Watkins and Johnson were too trifling to need report, for the Act of Parliament distinctly laid down that where any personal injury was caused to a person in or about a mine by reason of an explosion, it was the duty of the manager to report the circumstances to the Inspector for the district. It was also his duty to report when a 'serious' injury was caused in any other way than by an explosion. There was a distinct difference between an explosion by gas and an injury caused in any other way. In the first case, where any person was injured a report must be made; and, in the second case, that is only necessary where serious injury is caused. There was no doubt, therefore, that Mr. Foster had violated the 39th section. The fourth charge was that on the 6th of September and the days immediately preceding and succeeding that date, although the mine was, by reason of obnoxious gases, dangerous and unsafe, he (Mr. Foster) did neglect to prevent persons entering the mine until the danger had been removed and the mine was in safety, contrary to the 40th sub-rule. It was proved that Owen Owens and William Watkins were at work within a few yards of the spot where the gas was accumulated, other men were allowed to work in the airway and to pass within three or four yards of the gas, and these were matters for which there was no justification whatever. It was Mr. Foster's duty to have suspended all operations in that part of the mine until the gas had been removed, and he could have removed it without difficulty. It was very improper on Mr. Foster's part to have allowed the men to work with naked lights under these circumstances, and if there had been any necessary duties to perform the men should have been furnished with safety lamps. It had been argued that the sub-rule 40 applied to firemen, and that the removal of these men was a duty incumbent upon the fireman, but how could that possibly be ? Mr. Foster knew of the employment of these men at that particular spot, and knowing also as he did of the accumulation of gas, it was his duty to give orders to the fireman to remove the men, and not allow them to work there again until the gas had been removed. With regard to the two first offences, Mr. Foster had been proceeded against upon them before the Ystradgynlais magistrates, on the 4th of November last, and was fined £2 10s. in each case. Those convictions were not denied. It therefore only remained for that Court to say what, under the circumstances, it ought to do in regard to Mr. Foster. Notwithstanding what had been said by Mr. Smith, they could not forget that the lives of many people were in the hands of Mr. Foster, and the Act of Parliament said that the Court should cancel or suspend the certificate of a manager if they found that he was, not only by reason of gross negligence, but by reason of incompetency, unfit to discharge his duty. The Court considered that there had been in the present case either gross negligence or incompetency. If Mr. Evan Foster knew the danger to which he was exposing the lives of his workmen by allowing the accumulated gas to remain in David Bowen's level, and allowing the men to work there, he was guilty of gross negligence. If, on the contrary, he did not anticipate any danger from it, he had shown gross incompetency. It seemed to the Court that he could not in either case be allowed to shield himself under the excuse that he had done what he did to the best of his ability, but that his ability was very little. Taking into consideration all the circumstances of the case, and also the high character that Mr. Foster had received from Mr. Wales, as having been, so far as he (Mr. Wales) had been able to see, a prudent, careful, and efficient officer, the Court would, instead of cancelling his certificate as they might otherwise be disposed to do, suspend it for the space of six calendar months.

"Mr. Glascodine applied for costs, which the learned Commissioner refused to allow."


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bowen, David    Miner  
Bowen, Thomas    Fireman  
Brough, —      
Cadman, Thomas    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Davis, Lloyd    Colliery Manager  
Foster, Evan    Colliery Manager  
Glascodine, C. H.    Solicitor  
Humphrey, —      
Johnson, Howell    Miner  
Owens, Owen    Miner  
Rothery, H. C.    Wreck Commissioner  
Smith, W. Robinson    Solicitor  
Wales, Thomas Errington    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Watkins, William    Miner  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print