




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
13th December 1878, Page: 5, Column: 4
County Courts
Coal Cargo Dispute
Newcastle — Tuesday.
An action was brought by Messrs. Bolckow, Vaughan and
Co., Middlesbrough, against Mr. Geo. Reid, merchant,
Newcastle, to recover £35 19s 11d, the value of two cargoes of
coal. Mr. Parrington appeared for the plaintiffs, and
Mr. Sewell for the defendant. The value of the first cargo of
coal, £11 5s 11d, was admitted by the defendant, and the
claim for the second cargo was £24 13s 5d. As to the
second cargo, the defendant agreed to purchase from the
plaintiffs a quantity of coal, marked on the plaintiffs' price
list as "Tees Wallsend small coal, for blacksmiths, &c.,"
at 1s 6d a ton, less 2½ per cent discount, free on board at
Tyne Dock ; and plaintiffs were informed by letter that
the coals were intended to be shipped to Leigh. The cargo
was taken to Leith, and on being examined there, the coal
was found to be worthless. The coal was delivered to a
depot at Leith, and examined by three coal merchants, who
stated that the coal was not fit for blacksmiths' use. The
defendant claimed a set off of £48 3s, for the freight of the
coal from the Tyne to Leith, the expenses of examination,
and the defendant's loss of profit. — The Judge held that
the plaintiffs had not proved that the second cargo was
what the defendant agreed to purchase, and there fore the
plaintiffs could not recover the £24 13s 5d. He held that
counter claim for freight and profit set up by the defendant
was in the nature of consequential damages, and could not
be recovered by him. He gave a verdict for the plaintiffs
for £11 5s 11d, the value of the first cargo of coal.
— Mr. Sewell stated that the defendant would appeal against his
Honour's decision in not allowing the counter claim.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bolckow, — | | | |
| Bolckow, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Parrington, — | | Solicitor | |
| Parrington, — | | Solicitor | |
| Reid, George | | Merchant | |
| Reid, George | | Merchant | |
| Sewell, — | | Solicitor | |
| Sewell, — | | Solicitor | |
| Vaughan, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Vaughan, — | | | |
|
|