|
26th September 1878 A Careless CollierImportant ProsecutionStephen McGlennan, collier, Ribton-lane, Whitehaven, was charged with a breach of the Mines Regulation Act by having been in a part of William Pit with an unlocked safety lamp; he was also charged with having a pipe in his possession. — Mr. Lumb prosecuted. He started the case against the prisoner, who was, he said, a coal hewer in William Pit, and he asked the bench, if they found the charges proved, not to inflict a pecuniary penalty, but to make an example of prisoner, and imprison him. There were upwards of 150 men and boys employed in the pit, and the whole of their lives might have been sacrificed by prisoner's conduct. The employers had reason to believe that several of these cases were taking place owing to the conduct of the workmen; and he asked, for that reason, that where a case was proved to their satisfaction, they should impose a term of imprisonment without the option of a fine. — William Harker, manager of William Pit, said he knew the defendant, who was a coal hewer, and worked in the Delwell district of that pit. He had been a driver in the pit for a long time, but he had only been hewing coal for a few months. On Friday last witness was in the Delwell district, where safety lamps were used. It is 1,000 or 1,100 yards past the locking station, on the inbye side. Just past the station there is a caution board, with a signal lamp fixed up beside it. The board contained a notice that no naked lights, unlocked lamps, or tobacco pipes were to pass that place. Witness went into the Delwell district about half-past six in the morning. He examined defendant's lamp, and told him it was unlocked. Defendant said in reply, he expected the lamp was locked. Witness then examined him to see if he had a lamp key in his possession; he did not find a key, but he found the tobacco pipe produced. Defendant had no tobacco in his possession, and the pipe was cold. He said he had forgotten to leave his pipe. Witness produced a lamp similar to defendants; and, in reply to the Chairman, he said the lamps could be opened with nails, but he found no nail in defendant's possession. — The Chairman: How do you account for it? — Witness: Well, he said he expected it was locked — In reply to further questions by the Chairman, witness said the defendant must pass the locking station to get to his work, and there was a man on duty there for the purpose of locking lamps. Witness produced of the by-laws in force in the Whitehaven colliery, and said there would be about 200 men and boys in William Pit that morning. It was of the utmost importance that these rules should be rigidly carried out. — In reply to Mr. Brockbank, witness said there was danger in having unlocked lamps in the place where defendant was. — John Rothery, another official in the pit, said he was with the last witness on the morning named, and corroborated his evidence as to what took place. There must have been some means of opening the lamp. — Defendant said the lamp must have shaken open when hanging on the belt. — Witness said that would not shake it open; but if it did, defendant should have blown the lamp out, and gone to the lamp station with it. — In reply to Mr. Rimmer, witness said he never saw a lamp shake open; and the lamp would go out first besides. — Mr. Harker, in answer to a question, said a lamp might shake open if the screw was bad, but not with a good lock. — Mr. G. H. Liddell, colliery viewer for the Earl of Lonsdale, said he knew the district in William Pit alluded to. There was nothing specially dangerous about it, but safety lamps were used there. The rules ought to be rigidly enforced, and he considered a fine was of no use. There was danger in taking a lamp top off; it was almost a crime to do so when men's lives were at stake. He (witness) could not say there was gas there; but there might have been. — Joseph Davidson, the lamp locker at the station alluded to, said he locked defendant's lamp on the 13th inst. He left no pipe with him; and pipes should be left at the station. Some times he had a score of pipes left with him. The rule was well known in the pit. — In reply to questions by the Bench, witness said that amongst so many lamps he could not swear he had locked defendant's lamp on the morning named. He locked 42 or 44 that morning. It was possible he might not have locked it if defendant did not go for it. Defendant could get past him without having his lamp locked. — Defendant said Davidson locked his lamp; and as to the pipe, he had been out fishing, and got wet, and he put on another coat, which had the pipe in the pocket. — Mr. Brockbank asked what was the theory of the prosecution, for defendant seemed to have no motive for having a pipe in his possession, unless, indeed, his mate had the tobacco and he had the pipe. His mate ought to have been searched as well as defendant. — The Chairman said it was not a case for the penal section of the Act, and they thought it would be sufficient to impose a small fine in each case. There was no proof that defendant did not know the lamp was unlocked, and though he had a pipe in his possession, he had no tobacco, and it was not proved that his companion had any. It was a fault that he was not examined at the same time. A penalty of 15s would be imposed in each case, but if defendant or any one else were brought up on a similar charge, they would be sent to prison. It was a very dangerous practice; it was alarming to think of the explosions that occurred in every part of the country almost except here.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||