24th September 1878
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
The suggestions of Dr. Hawksley in your columns of the 17th inst. to use reflected light in coal mines was practised about 100 years ago, only instead of the electric light of our day being used, the sun's rays were deflected to a mirror at the
bottom of the shaft, and from thence reflected into the headings. The light, however, so obtained would not penetrate any distance, so many are the angles, curves, ascents, and descents in a coal mine ; in addition to which the dust in a dry mine and the
murkiness in a wet one soon dimmed the mirrors.
Important as the matter of a safe light is, the question of avoiding gas in an explosive state is very much more so, and I am convinced the exigencies of coal mining cannot be too generally known with a view to lessen in number the sad calamities,
resulting in such wholesale slaughter, that have occurred during the last ten months. These accidents are terrible from the number of lives lost on each occasion, but it may be fairly stated that for each life lost by explosions three are lost by other
means in coal mining every year.
No doubt the Mines Regulation Act of 1872, together with the general rules framed under that Act, is very explicit, but there seems to be a most important omission, as I will explain in a general way.
The Act and rules are most elaborate in their application to existing workings, roadways, &c., but leave unnoticed the mischief that may be gathering in those parts of a mine which have been abandoned.
When work is going on there is ventilation, and should gas accumulate there is every chance of immediate detection, whereas in abandoned workings, where all is still, gas may, and frequently does, accumulate for hours or days unawares to any one until it
suddenly appears in the working places. It might be urged that common sense would prompt an examination of such places, but very numerous and explanatory rules have a tendency to deaden the thought of some people into a belief that there is nothing
required beyond obedience ; that done, responsibility ceases, they are apt to think.
Now, I do venture to urge that undivided attention and incessant vigilance ought ever to be on guard over gas and ventilation. Yet among the rules for the persons who, more than any others, have charge of such matters is the following :— "And
shall at least once in every week travel through the whole of the airways necessary for the ventilation of his district of the mine," so as to insure the safety of all persons in the mine.
Now, that implies danger ; but who shall say at what time ? Yet visits at intervals of not less than seven days are deemed sufficient. Thus, all may be apparently well on a Monday, but terrible mischief may be brewing which it appears is no one's duty to
discover for days. Meanwhile the omission may lead to a calamity of no mean proportions.
In my humble opinion, gas explosions can never be considered thoroughly taken in hand until every part of a mine, including old workings, is visited and tested daily, and I am convinced that to reduce the number of such accidents requires the increasing
vigilance, care, and attention of persons having that duty alone to perform. "Everybody's duty is nobody's duty."
Your obedient servant,
J. D. Shakespear.
Scientific Club, Saville-row, Sept. 19.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hawksley, —, Dr. | | | |
| Shakespear, J. D. | | | |