24th June 1878
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
About 1,000 men and boys are killed every year on an average in colliery accidents of all kinds. An average of only one miner out of four of those killed every year is killed by an explosion of any kind. Shaft accidents, falling of roof, or falling of
coal kill three times more than all the explosions put together. About one miner out of 10 killed has the luck to be killed in a great explosion. The mortality among miners from diseases connected with their employment is greater than that of the
ordinary population. For instance, out of 10,000 deaths of the general population of those aged 15 years and upwards, there die of consumption at the age of 45, 263, and at the age of 55, 186, while of miners there die of consumption at 45, 1,206, and at
55, 1,394.
Dr. Farr, in his evidence before the Commission to inquire into the conditions of mines, calculates that at the age of 20 the general expectation of life is 44 years, while in four great mining districts it was as follows :— Staffordshire,
33 ; Durham and Northumberland, 32 ; Cornish district, 35 ; Merthyr, 31 years. To show this difference in the value of life in money, Dr. Farr says that the rate for insurance among the general male population at 20 of £100 would be £1
12s. 5d. (reckoning interest at 3 per cent., and without expenses of management), while among the miners it would be an average of £1 17s. 6d., or 5s. 1d. more per annum ; or the single premium for the general population would be £35 14s.
11d., while the miners would have to pay £39 4s., being only £3 9s. 1d. more than the general population. The annual premium of £1 17s. 6d. amounts to 8¾d. per week, which would not be a great burden upon a miner's wages, and would
secure £100 at his death, from whatever cause.
The statistics, moreover, show how comparatively small a percentage of deaths among miners results from accidents of any kind — a very small percentage from explosions, and much smaller again from large and sensational explosions, which alone
attract the sympathy and charitable donations of the benevolent. Insurance for themselves in this way might be carried out on a large scale at each pit by the agency of the masters, and the money deducted from the wages, as one mode of provision.
A second mode would be by a tonnage rate on each pit to provide a fund for all accidents, and which on an average throughout the kingdom would not be more than £15 per pit.
A third mode, however, appears to be by far the best as well as cheapest, and that is to create in each coal district a "Permanent Miners' Relief Fund," which at a cost of 3d. a week, the price of a pot of beer, or 1s. per month, and a small
subscription from the masters, would produce enough to pay for all casualties and for relief in sickness and old age.
The Northumberland and Durham Permanent Miners' Relief Fund had in March last 70,000 members and an income of £45,000. There were 134 deaths, and 82 widows and 165 children were thrown on the fund during the year. The calculation is that a widow
will be on the fund 13 years and a child six years. The cost of each widow is £130 and of each child £31 4s.
The West Riding of Yorkshire Permanent Relief Fund was established in January 1877, and in December numbered 3,941 members. There were five deaths, leaving four widows and 12 children, and there were 394 minor accidents. It has invested £4,100, its
receipts from donations and subscribers being £4,827. No public appeals to charity would have been made for any one of these cases of death and minor accident because they did not happen in a great explosion.
Your obedient servant,
June 20.
W.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Farr, —, Dr. | | | |