15th June 1878
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
In your article of the 8th inst. on the Wood Pits Colliery explosion you say, "It is the opinion of many coal owners and mining engineers that the extreme limit of State interference with private industry has already been reached in regard to mining
by the provisions of the Mines Regulation Act."
No doubt there exists a very strong feeling that it has been so in a qualified sense — i.e., in reference to the labour part of the question, but as to mechanical appliances there is hardly that unanimity of thought, for many are of opinion
something could yet be added with advantage.
Judging by the tenor of the reports in The Times there can be little or no doubt whatever that the Wood Pits explosion resulted from the mine being ventilated by the old-fashioned mode of a furnace at the foot of the up-cast shaft.
Accidents have not unfrequently happened from that mode of ventilation, and it stands to reason they must always occur whenever the return air contains the right proportion of gas to explode (say eight of air to one of gas) and enters the furnace. A
train of gunpowder, for instance, laid through the mine and lit at the furnace would fire right back ; so would the gas, for their action is precisely similar.
By way of illustration, let us assume a room with a fire burning in it and the gas turned on but not lit. Of course the air in the room would become charged with the escaping gas, which, when ignited from the fireplace, as it certainly would be, would
produce a violent explosion, not unlikely demolishing the house. In a similar way a coal mine ventilated by a furnace would be exploded whenever an explosive mixture of air and gas travelling the air ways reached the furnace.
Now, as ventilation by fan is more effective than by furnace, and is free from danger, I venture to think that ventilation by furnace ought to be absolutely prohibited.
Under either system of ventilation air exhausted in the up-cast shaft is supplied by air travelling down the down-cast shaft, which, after passing through the various ramifications of the mine, reaches the foot of the up-cast shaft — if it then be
charged with gas, and enters a furnace, an explosion is the consequence. If, however, it simply ascends the up-cast shaft by the force of suction produced by the fan on the surface, it passes away harmless. There can be no question as to which is right
and which is wrong.
The safety of a mine when gas appears depends on a preponderance of air, and a fan can command from 100,000 to 200,000 cubic feet of air per minute — according to its capacity.
Let us suppose a fan to be giving off 100,000 cubic feet of air per minute, and a message comes from below that gas is appearing, then by increasing the number of revolutions of the fan more air is produced to dilute the gas, which would greatly tend to
safety ; whereas if the power of the furnace were increased in the circumstances danger would be increased also.
I hope this letter will fairly open the question of fan versus furnace for colliery ventilation. I write it only in the cause of humanity.
Your obedient servant,
June 13.
J. D. Shakespear.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Shakespear, J. D. | | | |