Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

Mine Inspectors Reports

Article from the Mine Inspectors Reports, 1878, Page: 237


Gross Negligence at the Dinas Colliery

Suspension of the Manager's Certificate

Source: 1878 Mines Inspectors Report (C 2321), South Wales District by Thomas E. Wales, H.M. Inspector of Mines

"Gross Negligence at the Dinas Colliery.

"Suspension of the Manager's Certificate.

"An inquiry of considerable importance to the coal-mining interest was held at the Cardiff Town Hall, on Tuesday, by Mr. H. C. Rothery, Wreck Commissioner, assisted by Mr. Thomas Cadman, Inspector of Mines for the Monmouthshire District, as assessor, into the conduct of John Chubb, the certificated manager of the Dinas Colliery, owned by Messrs. Coffin and Co., and situated at Llantrisant, Glamorganshire. Mr. Thomas Williams (Williams and Lewis, solicitors, Merthyr) conducted the case in behalf of the Home Secretary, who instituted the investigation. The defendant was represented by Mr. W. Simons, solicitor, Merthyr. At the opening of the proceedings the defendant handed to the court his certificate of service.

"Mr. Williams, in opening, read the statement of the case against Mr. Chubb, which was in effect as follows :— 'As to Dinas Colliery, there are two pits from the surface, one known as the lower pit, which is the down-cast pit, the other known as the middle pit, which is the up-cast pit. The lower pit, passing through the 2 ft. 9 in. seam of coal, proceeds to the 4 ft. or Polka seam. The middle pit passes through the 2 ft. 9 in. seam and the 4 ft. or polka seam, and descends, to the 6 ft. seam. It is alleged that John Chubb, the certificated manager, by reason of incompetency or gross negligence, is unfit to discharge his duties, and that he has been convicted of an offence against the Coal Mines Regulation Act. The allegation is founded upon the following circumstances :— That he contravened and did not comply with the first General Rule contained in the Mines Regulation Act, by not producing or causing to be produced in the mine an adequate amount of ventilation to dilute and render harmless noxious gases to such an extent that the working places of the shafts, levels, stables, workings, and the travelling roads to and from such working places were in a fit state for working and passing therein. That he contravened and did not comply with the second General Rule contained in the Act, by not recording or causing to be recorded without delay in a book kept at the mine for the purpose, and to be signed by the person making it, a true report of the condition of the mine so far as ventilation is concerned. That he contravened and failed to comply with the 60th Special Rule applicable to the mine, by not immediately suspending or causing to be suspended all operations in the mine or part thereof, and removing all persons therefrom, and preventing any person again entering until the danger had been removed, and the mine or part in question had been restored to safety. The violations of the rules are in respect of the hard heading in the 4 ft. or Polka seam, and of William Moore's heading in the 2 ft. 9 in. workings, except as far as the general inadequate ventilation of the mine may have contributed to the matters of complaint. The third allegation is that on the 7th of August last John Chubb, as manager of the Dinas Pit, was convicted by the stipendiary magistrate for the district of Pontypridd of an appeal against the Act by contravening and failing to comply with the first General Rule, and fined £10 and costs.' Mr. Williams went on to state that between 300 and 400 men were employed in the colliery, and that the defendant, as the certificated manager, had the daily control and management of it. He explained at length the general system of the ventilation of the colliery, and the condition in which it was found by the assistant inspector. Having pointed out that Mr. Chubb had already been fined £10 by the magistrates for his first violation of a rule, he argued that there was also a distinct failure to comply with the second rule in question. He admitted that it was not the duty of the manager to make the entry personally, but he contended that it was clearly his duty to ensure that those under his direction made it. These were regulations provided by the Act of Parliament which were of the highest importance to the individual collier, who otherwise might not be able to judge of the state of the mine. The same argument applied with respect to the third allegation. There might, Mr. Williams added, be special circumstances under which the overman might neglect his duty, and the manager might not be aware that the danger existed; but in this case Mr. Chubb was perfectly aware of the accumulation of gas. He also submitted that the conviction in the first instance was sufficient to warrant the cancelling or suspension of the manager's certificate.

"The Commissioner observed that to justify such a decision it must be proved that the manager was unfit to discharge his duty, apart from any such previous conviction.

"Mr. Simons urged that the effect of the magisterial inquiry and the present one could not be made cumulative, and that the simple question the court had to consider was whether there had been negligence and incompetence or not. He also submitted that as Chubb had already appeared before the magistrates with respect to the second allegation and they had dismissed the case, it was not competent to have a reinvestigation of the charge. He contended that when a matter was considered by a competent tribunal and disposed of it could not be re-opened. Mr. Simons added that, with respect to the last charge, he contended that the responsibility of his client on that score was reflective. It was an offence of omission, and he did not know how his client could enforce a rule where the overman had committed a negative offence. How could Chubb take means to withdraw the men when the offence was perfected before he knew of it.

"The Commissioner said that argument was on the assumption that it was a sudden discovery, but he would take a note of the objection.

"Mr. Williams then called witnesses in support of the allegations.

"Mr. William Galloway, Assistant Inspector of Mines for the South Wales District, deposed to being acquainted with the Dinas mine, and described its various workings and the system of ventilation. Upon his visit on the 14th of June he entered the 2 ft. 9 in. seam with a Clanny lamp, and on getting to the 'William Moore's' heading found at first a small cavity containing a little explosive gas. On going farther on he found a larger cavity, and was about to raise his lamp up to see whether it contained gas, when Chubb, who accompanied him, cautioned him not to do so lest his light should be put out. He examined the cavity carefully, and found that it contained explosive gas in a stratum 12 in. thick at one end and 2 ft. at the other. The cavity was about 5 ft. wide and 20 ft. long. The gas was about 4½ feet from the floor. It was the principal outlet for the workmen from that part of the colliery, and for the coal, so that there was passing and repassing continually. The effect of this traffic would be that the gas would be liable to be dislodged and drawn downwards. There was no practical difficulty in clearing this place, and if the mine had been properly ventilated it should have been free. On returning to the down-cast shaft, and going past the point where the fan was situated, Chubb told him he could not proceed further with the 'Clanny' lamp, which is put out when in the midst of noxious gas. A 'Davy' lamp was given to him, and they proceeded through the canvas partition to the face of the heading, and as they passed along Chubb told him to keep down his lamp, and he at once discovered they were in explosive gas. About half way towards the face they met a man conducting a horse and tram. The driver had no light at all. Witness asked Chubb the reason of this, and he replied that it would not be safe to let the man carry a lamp. At the face of the heading he found two or three men at work. The air at this point was also explosive. He examined the air coming along the wooden air pipe from the fan, and found it contained a considerable quantity of gas, but still it was not explosive at the mouth of the pipe. He then requested Chubb to put out the lights and withdraw the men. They groped their way out in the dark until they reached the fresh air again. The explosive gas was continuous all the way. Chubb told him he had experienced great difficulty with this place for some time. Witness considered that this state of things must have existed from the time when the heading reached the point where the canvas partition was. It would take several months to drive the heading this distance. This portion of the mine was not fit for men to work in. It was highly dangerous. There was no other way for the men to pass except through the explosive gas. There was no difficulty in ventilating this part of the mine to render it quite free from gas if proper means had been employed. Witness asked Chubb why he had allowed it to get into this state, and he said he had been much troubled with it. Witness suggested that if he further contracted the entrance to the 2 ft. 9 in. seam he would improve the state of the air, and Chubb said he was afraid of interfering with the ventilation of the 6 ft. seam. Witness cautioned him on no account to allow the men to go beyond the canvas partition until the working was cleared of the gas. On a subsequent visit the defendant told witness that the workings were cleared, and the men were able to return to work. If an explosion had taken place the machinery in the shaft and the pit head gearing would have been destroyed, so that egress and ingress to the pit would have been prevented, and probably the men would have been all killed. On the 25th of June, when witness again visited the mine, he examined the report books, and on going through them found no entry whatever as to this accumulation of gas in the 2 ft. 9 in. heading. (Report book produced.) He had seen larger accumulations of explosive gas in mines, but had never seen men working in it. He certainly thought that the men should have been withdrawn.

"By Mr. Simons : At the time of his visit Chubb told him that he had given orders to put up a canvas cloth, which would have been an effectual expedient to clear away the gas. The driving of the heading from the 22 yards pit and the downcast pit would have improved the general ventilation of the mine, and he understood that the opening was completed a day or two after his visit. He had not found any disinclination on the part of Mr. Chubb or the proprietors of the colliery to abide by any advice he had given. In respect to the 2 ft. 9 in. heading, the ventilation generally was adequate, but not properly distributed, it was quite practicable to keep a mine free from gas. He remembered the second charge against Chubb of not recording the condition of the mine before the magistrates being dismissed. The overman was, however, convicted of it.

"Re-examined by Mr. Williams: There were no difficulties in the ventilation of the mine which a competent or careful manager could not easily have overcome. It was simply a question of expense.

"By the Commissioner: It was to save the expense of enlarging the wooden air-pipes that the ventilation was not completed. The neglect was, in witness's opinion, owing partly to a want of knowledge on the part of Chubb, and partly to a desire to get through as cheaply as possible.

"Mr. T. E. Wales, Government Inspector of Mines for the South Wales District, was the next witness. He said the Dinas Colliery was within his district, and in consequence of the report made to him by Mr. Galloway on the 14th of June, he communicated with the Home Secretary, who directed the proceedings which were taken before the magistrates, whose decision was communicated to the Home Secretary, which resulted in the present inquiry, he had heard the evidence of Mr. Galloway, and, assuming his facts to be correct, he considered that there would have been no difficulty in removing the gas. In such a state of things it was very dangerous for the men to be at work. He had never known men permitted to work when there was such a large accumulation of gas, and he did not think they should have been allowed to do so in this case. Considering the surrounding circumstances the accumulation of gas must, in his opinion, have been of long standing, and during the time the opening between the heading and six feet seam was being made there would not have been any difficulty in keeping the heading clear from gas.

"By Mr. Simons: The clearing away of gas would, to some extent, have devolved on the overman if it had come suddenly, but, if it had come gradually, it was the duty of the manager to see to its removal. The scheme that was being carried out would, no doubt, improve the ventilation. He was aware that Chubb had been under manager at the Dinas Colliery for many years, and his reputation, so far as he (Mr. Wales) was aware, had been that of a skilful and careful man.

"Re-examined: He considered that the means resorted to for the clearing away of the gas were very imperfect.

"By the Commissioner: A 'blower' might go on for weeks or months, but care would, in ordinary cases, be taken that the gas did not accumulate, and this should be done by proper ventilation. The mode adopted to get rid of the gas in the Polka seam was very defective, and had the gas exploded it would have been attended with very serious results.

"Mr. John Stockwood, clerk to the magistrates for the Pontypridd district, proved the conviction of Chubb in August last of a violation of the mining regulations. Two other summonses had been taken out against him, one was adjourned and the other was dismissed.

"This was the case for the promoters of the inquiry.

"Mr. Simons, addressing the Court for the defence, said there was no one who felt more keenly than his client the importance of such inquiries as these to colliery owners as well as those employed by them. Mr. Chubb, as was shown by the certificate which had been handed in, was a man of great experience in colliery operations, but he maintained that though he, as the manager of the colliery, was responsible for the effective working of it, there was a large amount of detail in carrying out the arrangements which must of necessity be left to the under-manager and to the overmen of the colliery. At the Dinas Pit he had the charge of from 400 to 500 men, and it was impossible that he could have more than a supervising eye and a controlling hand over the plans. To show Mr. Chubb's anxiety to get over the difficulty of ventilation, he would point to the fact that he had devised the heading in question between the two pits, and the ventilation was greatly improved. The fact that Mr. Wales and his deputy had been satisfied with what had been done was indicated by their not having thought it necessary to visit the mine since August. In opening headings of this kind there was always a danger of a sudden accumulation of gas, but he maintained that there was no evidence in this case that the accumulation was of long standing. That was only an assumption on the part of Mr. Galloway, but it was a point upon which a conclusion must not be jumped at. Though Mr. Chubb regretted there should have been any cause of complaint, it was significant that the magisterial view of the charge first brought against him was such that they had only mulet him in a fine of £10 instead of the full penalty of £20. And, with regard to the allegation that he was aware of the accumulation of gas before the visit of the Inspector on the 14th, he maintained that there was no proof of this, though the Crown might, if so disposed, have easily brought forward witnesses to testify to it. No act of Mr. Chubb's could have prevented the overman neglecting to record such a fact, nor could he by any means whatever be held responsible for the non-withdrawal of the men. It was quite unreasonable, and not contemplated by the statute, that the manager could be held responsible under such circumstances as these. With regard to the second complaint laid before the magistrates, he urged that it, having been since dealt with and dismissed, could not be revived, while for the first offence he had been punished. In conclusion, he urged that, as in any case it was evident that at least Mr. Chubb was not recklessly negligent, he was not deserving of the punishment it was now sought to inflict upon him.

"Messrs. Daniel John and Edmund Thomas, colliery proprietors in the county, were called, and gave Mr. Chubb a high character as an experienced and careful man at his work.

"No further evidence was offered for the defence.

"The Commissioner, after consulting with the assessor, gave an exhaustive review of the case in recording the decision of the Court. In the first instance, he referred to the points of law raised by Mr. Simons, whose arguments with respect to the finding of the magistrates in the two cases against Mr. Chubb, which they disposed of, the Court considered inconsistent. The simple duty that the Court had to discharge was to ascertain whether Mr. Chubb was or was not, either by reason of incompetence or gross negligence, or of his having been convicted of an offence against the Act, unfit to discharge his duty. With regard to the first allegation, it was clear that Mr. Chubb, being manager, was responsible for the proper ventilation of the mine. According to the evidence it was clear that he had not complied with the first General Rule, and, as no evidence had been offered in explanation of the circumstances sworn to (the Court could not accept the inferences made by Mr. Simons) they must find him guilty on that charge. There was no refutation of the statement that if an explosion had taken place in the state the mine was found by the Inspector not only would there probably have been a great destruction of property, but also the loss of many lives. Therefore the Court could but conclude that Mr. Chubb had been guilty of a very serious offence. According to the evidence of the two Inspectors, the mine must have been in an unsafe state for some time, and Mr. Chubb must have been aware of it, and as he had failed to see that a proper record of the fact was made by his subordinates, he had undoubtedly violated the second rule also. As to the third charge, the fact that the overman had neglected his duty by not removing the men from the dangerous workings was no excuse for Mr. Chubb neglecting his duty, and the Court, finding him guilty on each of the three charges, must order a suspension of his certificate for six months — the lightest possible punishment being inflicted in consideration of his good character.

"Mr. Williams did not press for costs."


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Cadman, Thomas    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Chubb, John    Colliery Manager  
Coffin, —    Mine Owner  
Galloway, William    H.M. Assistant Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
John, Daniel    Mine Owner  
Lewis, —    Solicitor  
Moore, William    Miner  
Rothery, H. C.    Wreck Commissioner  
Simons, W.    Solicitor  
Stockwood, John    Magistrates Clerk  
Thomas, Edmund    Mine Owner  
Wales, Thomas Errington    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Williams, Thomas    Solicitor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Dinas Colliery  Dinas Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print