27th October 1877
Colliery Explosions
Colonel J. D. Shakespear, R. A., writes to us :— "Whenever a colliery explosion occurs a conclusion seems jumped to at once that it would not have happened had not somebody neglected his duty, or that naked lights were used when
safety-lamps only ought to have been used, or that some foolish man opened his lamp or struck a light. Those are the causes usually assigned, as if comprising all causes. Now, any one of those causes may produce an explosion, but, in addition to them,
there are several other means by which fire-damp may be exploded. To understand the question, we must first understand the nature of the gas called by the unscientific name of fire-damp, and the circumstances under which it will and will not explode. At
least three-fourths of its composition is carburetted hydrogen, which accounts for its lightness in comparison with air and its accumulation upwards ; the remaining one-fourth is composed of other gases in varied proportions. It is, therefore, an
uncertain compound. When unmixed with air or mixed in such proportions as, say, three of gas to one of air, it will not explode, but produces drowsiness or suffocation, and puts out the flame of a lamp for want of oxygen. When fire-damp is diluted with
from 15 to 30 times its volume of air it causes the flame of a lamp to enlarge, and to appear as surrounded by a blue envelope. In this state it flickers or burns rather than explodes. When, however, the atmosphere in a mine becomes in the proportion of
about eight of air to one of fire-damp, then the danger is extreme, for the mixture is then explosive in the highest degree. From the foregoing, it will be seen that it is not fire-damp alone which produces such dire calamities, but rather fire-damp
rendered dangerously explosive on becoming mixed with air in certain proportions. Perfect immunity, then, from accidents, requires that the explosive mixture shall never be made. But is that possible ? I venture to think not, because fire-damp, while
passing from an unmixed to a harmlessly diluted state, must in this course of change arrive at the danger-point, and should the mixture then be travelling at the rate of a five-knot breeze the danger of explosion is very great, as the flame then burning
in any safety-lamp is liable to be blown through the wire gauze and so fire the mine. But let us imagine that by good luck the fire-damp in its highly explosive state is not exploded in its transit through the mine to the upcast shaft. What will happen
on its arrival at that point when a mine is ventilated by furnaces as is the Blantyre ? Why, an explosion of course of perhaps many millions of cubic feet of fire-damp, extending through, perhaps, miles of headings. So much for fire-damp itself. Now I
must say a few words as to safety-lamps. It is a total fallacy to assume that safety-lamps give immunity from explosion, for in real truth they do more than lessen danger. When there is no danger then a safety-lamp is a hindrance ; and when there is
danger, then it gives only more or less safety according to circumstances. For instance, a good safety-lamp is safe in the most explosive fire-damp when all is still ; but motion produces danger. Thus, in highly explosive fire-damp — i.e. eight of
air to one of gas — a man running, or even walking, quickly, or a lamp dropped, or spun round in carrying, might fire the mine ; or suppose one mesh out of the 20,000 or so in a Davy lamp got accidentally enlarged from, say, one-sixtieth to
one-fortieth of an inch, all might be lost in a single second. The public will understand the sensitive question involved in avoiding an explosion in circumstances when all is ripe for it on hearing that, when lights must be put out to avoid risk,
blowing them out is so strictly prohibited, that any one caught attempting to do so would be dismissed. I may here mention that many a life is lost by those stunned by the explosion lying on the ground inhaling the choke-damp and after-damp, as miners
style carbonic acid gas and the products of explosion. Having now mentioned several modes, other than naked lights, by which fire-damp may be exploded, it only remains for me to point to what may give the greatest safety where all is unsafe. In the first
place, ventilation by furnaces, an old-fashioned and generally exploded system, ought to be abolished by Act of Parliament, and mechanical ventilation by fan substituted in its place, as instances are recorded where fire-damp passing with the current of
ventilation to the up-cast shaft has exploded the mine. I can myself name an instance. As to safety-lamps, the most sensitive to gas, and of the very best construction, regardless of cost, only ought to be permitted. You will be surprised to hear that
the making of miners' safety-lamps is often the means of living to needy old miners, and that the trade frequently offer their safety-lamps in quantities at 52 per cent. discount. Now, as most safety-lamps can be purchased at from 3s. 6d. to 9s. 6d.
each, it is self-evident much handicraft cannot be given to their make. No safety-lamp gives immunity ; but the best is far safer than the worst, while the cheapest are often selected because they are the cheapest. Having given the greatest attention to
this subject for some years, I venture to write with some authority, well knowing that I am ably supported by men of great ability and practical knowledge."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Shakespear, J. D., Colonel | | | |