|
17th May 1877 The Accident at the Mowbray MinesDynamite As An ExplosiveThe adjourned inquest touching the death of Henry Muncaster, aged 37, a miner, married, who left a family, by an explosion of dynamite in the working in which he was employed on Tuesday morning week, at the No. 2 pit of the Mowbray Iron Ore Company, at Frizington, was held last (Wednesday) evening, at the Lowther Arms, Hensingham (in which village the deceased man resided), before Mr. W. W. Lumb, deputy-coroner. Mr. Willis, Government Inspector, and Mr. Robinson, Hazelholme, manager of the Salter and Eskett Park Mines, and agent for the British Dynamite and Nobell's Patent Explosive Company, were present during the inquiry. The first witness called was John Thompson, who said he was an iron ore miner, and was employed at the time of the accident — twenty minutes to one in the morning — in the same working with the deceased. Deceased said he was going for a drink, and to tie his clog with a bit of string, and went to another part of the working about eighty feet from where they were working. They were then boring, but were not ready for a charge. After deceased left him, there was an explosion, which left the working in darkness, and a man named Thomas Scott came with a light. They then saw the deceased, and went and got assistance. The deceased's legs were blown off, one arm was gone, and he was lying with his face to the ground, with his bowels out — in fact blown to pieces. Witness could not say what was the cause of the accident, because he could not see what deceased was doing; but as a miner of six years' experience, he would say that it might have been caused by a spark from the deceased's candle falling into the ammunition box. There was a box in the working in which they kept dynamite, caps, fuse, and candles together. The caps were in a tin box with a lid on it. Could not say how much dynamite there was. It was got from the store once a day by one of the company who were working together, and put into the box by him, so that the men who preceded deceased and witness would take the dynamite down on Monday. Mr. Willis at this stage asked if any one was here who represented the Company, and there was no reply. Mr. Robinson said Mr. Willis would mean the manager of the mines? Mr. Willis: I mean any body who will care for this man being killed. The Coroner said there was nobody there from the Company. Witness continued: After the explosion they did their best to get out the deceased man. The dynamite box, which was wood, and the tin box in which were the caps, were both blown to very small pieces. The dynamite box would be about 2 feet six inches, by 1 foot in width, and a foot in depth. It was never full. The workmen were restricted in the quantity they got. He did not know what each man was allowed to get. He had gone for it: but they never got so large a quantity at a time. The most they ever had was two packages at a time. Could not say how much was in a package. Mr. Willis: 5lbs? — Witness could not say. Witness was of opinion that the explosion might have occurred by the deceased putting his candle on the box when he was taking the string from around the dynamite packages to tie his clog. The string was no use on the dynamite, and he might take it. So far as witness was concerned the dynamite was not required for their work, and deceased had no occasion to be at it at all. Witness could not say what deceased was doing, except by surmising from what he said. Witness never knew the dynamite to go off mysteriously before. It was generally prepared by softening before it was used — sometimes by putting it in the breeches pocket, and sometimes by putting it into a warming pan like a glue pan — one pan within another with water between the two; and there was a pan full preparing at the time, which was not affected by the explosion. A Juryman: Would it explode provided a spark had fallen upon it? Witness: No; you can throw it into the fire, and it will not explode, but burn harmlessly. Mr. Willis: Have you ever done that? Witness: No, but I have seen it done. Mr. Willis: I advise you not to try it. Witness: There were no partitions in the box to divide the caps from the dynamite. The Coroner: Is that safe? Mr. Willis: I suppose the agent of the Dynamite Company would say it is not. Mr. Robinson: No, it is not. Witness, continuing his evidence, said there was plenty of good air in the workings. The candles gathered a "snot" — burnt material on the wick — and if it was shaken that might fall off into the box. The dynamite was wrapped up in paper, so that it wouldn't touch the dynamite. If a spark had fallen upon the dynamite unprotected by paper, in witness's opinion it would only burn away; but if a spark went into a cap it would explode immediately, and cause all the dynamite to explode. Witness did not think it was safe to keep the caps and dynamite in the same box. He did not know the practice at other mines in the neighbourhood in this respect. Friction might cause an explosion of dynamite, but witness did not know. He did not know the weight of the dynamite packages served out to them on the Monday. They were 10s a package. When they got two packages they carried them down the pit. Did not know whether that was according to law. The regulations were hung up, but witness had never read them. He did not think a man would get six packages at the store if he asked for it. Their practice was one of a company went to the store and got as much as they thought they would require till next day. They didn't get an order for it; there was a man at the stores on purpose. The deceased was a careful man. Witness had heard him caution two or three men about putting their candles so near the dynamite box. Did not think any of the company would be so careless as to throw a bit of dynamite on the floor after priming, and if they did he thought the effect of its being trodden upon would be harmless; but he had never seen it done. Mr. Willis said he had heard of a case, and the result was an explosion. Witness: The caps would go off if deceased put his foot on them. Mr. Willis: The caps are very touchy things. They will go off if you look at them. Witness: If you touch them with a pin or anything, or affect them by friction they will go off. They are more delicate than the dynamite itself. The dynamite was prepared by softening with heat, because it was stronger when soft. It remained soft for about six hours. It would explode if gradually above a certain temperature, but not if thrown into a fire. By Mr. Willis: Was prepared to swear, if summoned as a witness, that he had had two packages at work at one time, but not on this occasion, and he could not name a date. Mr. Robinson said the packages were now being made 2½lbs, instead of 5lbs. Mr. Willis said it was high time they were. Witness, in answer to the Coroner, said it was a fact that he had had two packages, costing 20s, in a box at one time, but he could not give a date. Mr. Willis: If the law says you are only to take 4lbs down and you take a package of 5lbs, would that be a breach of the law? Witness: I suppose it would. Mr. Willis said he could summon witness for that offence, if he thought proper, notwithstanding that he was doing what he was told, for he ought to have objected; but then as witness said, one package would do as much harm as 10lbs. It was the law no doubt that they should not have more than 4lbs. Witness said a company of men would use two packages in the course of 24 hours, and if they ran short they had to borrow off another company, for the store was only open at a certain time. They would not break open a package for the men — if they wanted 3lbs they must take a 5lb package. Frederick Sheelar, Yeathouse, Frizington, the storekeeper, said he knew the deceased to be an experienced and careful miner. The packages were 2½lbs each now. It was about a month since they were changed from 5lbs. They generally dealt out four packages of 2½llbs to a company of men. He could not refuse the men 4lbs each if it was asked for; there was no law against it, but it was never asked for. Never knew of an accident at Mowbray from dynamite before. William Piele, of Frizington, manager for the Mowbray Iron Ore Company, said he had known the deceased for about 16 years. He was a very careful man. From inquiries he made he thought he might perhaps have cut the string off the dynamite with a knife, if he had one, or he might have burned it off; and if there was any glycerine about the case it might explode. He had known glycerine to exude so as to be seen through the paper. About two years ago, a companion at work with him was killed by an explosion owing to the exudation of glycerine in the warming pan after thawing. It would be better to keep the caps and the dynamite separate, and he had instructed the miners on many occasions to keep them separate, and had provided them with separate boxes since the accident. The Act, he thought, allowed them to have 4lbs for each man. Mr. Willis: It says nothing about each man. Witness: Four pounds would be of no use to a company of men. Mr. Willis: That is the reason I have never proceeded. I have known that it was going on for long enough. If you confine the allowance to 4lbs, there is not enough for work. I have mentioned the Act to the Companies I have had to deal with; but I don't know — I think we will have to. Do you think dynamite a safe thing? Witness: Well, it is safe enough. No explosives are very safe. I have known accidents before with gunpowder. Mr. Willis: But it is not so bad as this stuff. Unfortunately it killed men, but it was not so horrible as this, which blows men into mincemeat. After an accident I heard of a short time since it took three or four days to collect the pieces of the mans body. Witness: There is danger with all explosives. Mr. Willis: I suppose you wouldn't like to be brought before the magistrates for violating the law by taking 5lbs down the pit? Witness: Well, we are serving it out at present in 2½lb packages. A juryman remarked that the only difference it would make would be to oblige the men to go for it separately. Witness said there was no damage done in the pit by the explosion. Thompson was 82 feet distant, and was shielded by a breastwork left for a support. Mr. Robinson, the dynamite agent, at the suggestion of Mr. Willis, gave evidence as to the nature of dynamite. He said he had been agent in the district for seven or eight years. It contains about 75 per cent of nitro-glycerine, and 25 per cent of calcica for the absorption of the nitro-glycerine. That was all that was in it. It is not so dangerous as powder if it is handled with equal care; but the men got careless with it, under the impression that it is harmless. In witness's opinion in this case the caps must have exploded first. It was more than 20 to 1 against the dynamite exploding. He thought something off the candle had fallen against the caps, one of which might have been loose in the box. The Coroner then summed up, and the jury returned a verdict to the effect that the deceased died from the effects of an explosion of dynamite, which was accidentally caused by the deceased himself. The jury recommended that this Company, and any others who did not already do so, should cause the workmen to keep their caps and dynamite in separate boxes, with a view to the prevention of accidents.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||