Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

22nd March 1877

The Late Dynamite Explosion at Egremont

The Adjourned Inquest Yesterday

(By our own reporter)

The adjourned inquest on view of the remains of Henry Mather and James Green, the two iron miners who were killed by an explosion of dynamite in one of the Ehen Mining Companies pits near Egremont, on the 12th inst., was held yesterday (Wednesday) evening at the Robin Hood, Egremont before Mr. J. McKelvie, coroner for the district, and a jury. Mr. Willis, one of Her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines was present; and Mr. Helder watched the inquiry for the company. Mr. W. Burnyeat, jun., also attended the inquest.

The first witness called was Felix McDonald, a miner, who was working in the pit about 40 or 50 yards away from the place where the explosion occurred, and who was stunned by its affects. He deposed to having seen the men go into the pit, and to having seem them about half an hour before the explosion. He was in their working an hour before.

William Wilkin deposed that he was a miner, and worked in the pit where the explosion occurred. He knew the deceased, Henry Mather and James Green. On the 12th inst, he was working near where they were working — perhaps 36 yards away. He was working at the bottom of the steer — the hurry where they tipped the metal from. There was no one in the working but the deceased. He had seen both the men before the accident happened. Could not say how long before — perhaps twenty minutes. He was then in the working. There was no one in but the men, and Mather was tipping metal over to witness. Green had been away, and might have been back about half an hour when the explosion happened. The deceased had fired no shots before this. Witness could not say what they were doing. He only heard one explosion, and it happened as if a great quantity of dynamite had gone off instead of an ordinary quantity. Did not know of his own knowledge what quantity of dynamite the men had down the pit. When the explosion took place witness crossed to the other side of the shaft, and went to the under-gaffer for a light. James Kitchen and Witness went up a portion of the way, but could not get to the working. Witness's light was blown out, and they could not get far on account of the smoke from the explosion. There was no metal brought down, so that the dynamite had not exploded in the holes bored for it. It was not in a place where Witness would expect the men to have been boring. — By the inspector: The dynamite was kept 27 feet from the working. It was not kept in a canister, but a wooden box. Was not present wither Mather was found near where the other man was found? Witness was a labourer at the mine, and did not use dynamite.

James Kitchen deposed that he lived in Egremont, and was a miner, and worked at Ehen pit. He was there on the day in question, about sixty yards from where the deceased men were working. He was the shiftsman. He had seen Mather and Green that morning about quarter past twelve. Saw Green last on the pit top. He was going to go down, and had some dynamite with him. That was about three quarters of an hour before the explosion took place. He did not go down the pit with Green. No shots had been fired by the men in the meantime. Witness at the time of the explosion was on the side of the shaft opposite to the explosion, and he went right across to the other side. The first man he came to was William Wilkin, who asked what the heavy shock was. Witness went up to the steer, and Felix McDonald was there, and seemed to be stunned. Witness asked him what was the matter and he did not know, unless the dynamite had gone off in his bogy. Witness knew that the report was more than that of one cartridge, and he went to the place where the deceased were working. Witness went up the working as far had he could get. The smoke was coming in quite a cloud, and there was no air. He got as far as he could, and then shouted. There was no answer, and witness and another man again tried to get to the men, and could not. He went back then, and went to the top of the pit, and told Mr. Stout, the manager, he thought there was an accident. He told Mr. Stout all about it, and said that he was afraid there was something wrong, and then went down the pit again. He and another man went up the road again to the place where these two men were working. The other man was before witness, and witness told him to go to the dynamite box, and when he went there he found the remains of one of the men lying. As soon as he saw the body he turned back to witness, and said, "here's one of them here blown to pieces." That was close to where the dynamite was kept. Mather's body was lifted up from the place some 27 feet from where the dynamite was kept. It was not blown to pieces like the other. It was against the corner of a pillar. The explosion was very loud. The deceased were men who had been using dynamite before and understood working with it. Witness could not account for the explosion in any way. He had no idea how it occurred. — By the inspector: Did you not know the quantity of dynamite green had. He had a package with him, but he might have had many things witness would not have taken notice of. He had a package of the usual size. Could not say what that was exactly. Never took particular notice of the number of pieces in a package. Dynamite was kept in paper packages covered with oilcloth. — The Inspector: Do you sometimes shoot them in the tub? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: Did not someone tell you it was a piece that had gone off in the tub? — Witness: The man who told me that was lying stunned on the steer. — The inspector: McDonald said it had gone off in the kibble he thought. Does one dynamite sometimes go off in the tub? — Witness: No, I never knew of anything of the sort. — The Inspector: what do you suppose put that into his mind, then? — Witness: Because it came so suddenly upon him. He could see the men's lights from where he was. — The inspector: Have you used dynamite yourself? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: Have you ever known pieces to go off in the tubs or in shovelling the ore? — Witness: No, I never did. — The Inspector: When you have broken the paper of one dynamite have you ever put the rest of it away anywhere? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: You use it carefully? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: In a packet of dynamite are there any caps? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: They are in separate packages. — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: And with fuses? — The Inspector: have you ever known a cap to go off? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: Not except in a fair way? — Witness: No, I never did. — Mr. Helder: Have you ever had an accident with dynamite yourself? — Witness: No. — Mr. Helder: Where these two men careful men? — Witness: Yes, apparently they were careful men. — The Inspector: In preparing your shots do you always prepare them down the pit? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: Use a candle? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: tell us if you have ever known a piece of dynamite or a cap to go off without being fixed? — Witness: Well, I never did. — The Inspector: Not in the preparation of it in anyway? — Witness: No. —The Inspector: Or from a spark from a candle, or from a candle touching it? — Witness: No, I never knew one go off except from fair means. — Mr. Helder: It was in the place where they kept the dynamite? — Witness: Purposely, clear of all danger. — Mr. Helder: They kept the dynamite at some little distance off. — Witness: It was in a place that turned out chiefly stone, and it was left for a short time, and this dynamite stood in it. — By the Inspector: Could see nothing of the box, but a bit of the ironwork after the explosion. — The Inspector: Was there anything else kept in the box? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: nothing but dynamite? — Witness: No, unless there was a candle or two. — The Inspector: what is the practice in getting dynamite from the store? Do you simply go and say you want a package of dynamite? — Witness: Yes; whatever you want you go and inform the storekeeper of it. — The Inspector: And he gives it? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: Suppose if you go today for a package, and he gave you it, and you only used two pieces, and went tomorrow for another package, would he give you it? — Witness: No, he would not, unless I told him a lie. — The Inspector: He would inquire if you had used the former lot? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: Has the storekeeper any means of knowing what you use except what you tell him? — Witness: I don't know. Very likely the storekeeper would be led to give it, but they are only allowed one package at a time down the pit. — The Inspector: One would blow up as much as two? — Witness: Yes. — By the Coroner: The dynamite is kept at Moor Row, a mile and a quarter from the pit, and Green must have been there to get what he had.

In reply to the inspector, Mr. Burnyeat said that a representative from the dynamite company had been down, but he was not there then.

James Stout deposed that he lived at Moor Row, and was the manager of these mines. He knew the working where the accident occurred. Mather and Green worked there. They had two packages of dynamite. Each package contained five pounds in weight. The store book showed that Green had got two packages that morning at eleven o'clock. He only took one package down the pit — another man had the other. Witness gave him fuse and candles out, and he had only one package then. The other package might go to another man. He had not found out that another man had got it. There was no fear that it was lying about anywhere. There were 32 pieces of dynamite in the package, and three or four small ones that were called primers. — By the Inspector: If there were a piece of grit in the detonator, and a man inserted a fuse, witness thought it might go off. They would go off if touched with a pin. — The Inspector: Is the detonator more sensitive then the dynamite? — Witness: I consider the dynamite far safer then the caps are. — The Inspector: The caps are very touchy? — Witness: Yes. — The Inspector: You have never known one in your experience go off with fair usage? What opinion have you formed as to this? — Witness: I think it has been a candle or pipe, or some neglect. They had three holes ready bored for charging, and they had been making the charges ready. — The Inspector: Suppose Green had been preparing this, and a spark had gone onto it, it would not have been likely to go onto the cap would it? — Witness: Well, it might or it might not have gone on some of the dynamite. — The Inspector: Well, in that case, what? — Witness: A spark will fire it far sooner then a flame will. — The Inspector: In the case of a spark going on to dynamite, what would be the result? — Witness: It would explode it, and that would explode the whole. — The Inspector: That is if it had a detonator in? — Witness: Well, I can't say about that. I think as long as they are in an airtight wrapper they will explode at any time. — The Inspector: Are you acquainted with the change in frosty weather? — Witness: I believe it is most dangerous in frosty weather. — The Inspector: Have you sufficient instructions how to use it in frosty weather? — Witness: Yes, we have rules. — The Inspector: Do you soften it in the mine or out? — Witness: In the mine. A number of them put them in their breeches pockets, and they consider that to be the safest way too. — The Inspector: With regard to the detonator — do you ever use any means to unfreeze it? — Witness: No, the frost has no affect upon them. — The Inspector: Well, that is just the point that has been arisen lately. Have you ever seen the representative of the dynamite company when he has been round and has called upon you? — Witness: Yes, sir. — The Inspector: Has he ever mentioned any matter connected with the freezing of the caps? — Witness: No, sir. — The Inspector: Has he ever mentioned any matter as regards the law of taking packages into the mines? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: Has he ever told you why they put the dynamite up in five-pound packages? — Witness: No, sir. — The Inspector: Have you ever divided them? Do you know that five pounds is more then the permitted quantity of the explosive? — Witness: Yes, I see that it is four pounds under the Act. — The Inspector: Then have you been in the habit of dividing these packages? — Witness: Sometimes we give out half packages. — The Inspector: But for the purpose of complying with the Act, have you ever divided them? — Witness: No sir. — The Inspector: I suppose a pound would damage the men as much as five pound would? — Witness: Yes, a quarter of a pound would. — The Inspector: As a practical man, are you prepared to say that giving out four pounds would be a safer thing than taking five pounds? — Witness: No. — The Inspector: Would you think it a perfectly safe thing to open a package, and take a pound out? — Witness: No, sir; it would be more unsafe than the other. — The Inspector: In what respect? — Witness: Every company of men that wanted a package it would have to be handled, so that there would be twice as much handling. — In the course of further examination by the Inspector, witness said that the holes which had been bored were two feet and two feet six long, and would require eight or ten cartridges. He believed that both the men had been at the box when the explosion took place, and they were blown in different directions. Mather had 40 feet to be blown back in, and Green had only three feet six inches before he struck against solid rock. — The Inspector: You are only to have four pounds in a working place, if I understand the Act, and these men had been able to get ten pounds. — Witness: Yes, because one package would not do for them. — The Inspector: The Act does not contemplate that. Then you would contend that this is not a working place where the stuff is? — Witness: No, sir; it is a place where dynamite is kept. — The Inspector: I am afraid that the Act would recognise that as a store.

The Inspector, in reply to an intimation from the Coroner that he should like to hear observations he had to make, said he could only point out that the Act said that only four pounds of dynamite should go into any working. It had long been under his notice that this Company, for some reason of their own which they had no right to inquire into, made up the dynamite in five-pound packages. He could not but suppose that these had been taken down, but to some extent he had not been pressing about it, because as Mr. Stout said he thought there was more danger in dividing the packages. It was giving another opportunity of making a mishap more than there would be by letting the men take down five pounds. Of course he had no right to set aside the law in that way, but he had never felt it his duty to interfere. Of course, as far as he was concerned, he would be obliged to report it, but at the same time he was free to state that if he were asked by the Secretary of State for his opinion, he would not recommend any prosecution, though it would still remain with the Secretary of State whether there was to be one or not — it was altogether out of his (Mr. Willis's) hands in that respect. There was another point in regard to the detonators, which did not seem to be sufficiently known. Somebody, he forgot whom, had been making out lately that they were affected by frost as well as the dynamite itself — the detonating powder being turned into a sort of crystal, the least breakage of which would cause it to explode. That had not been fully gone into scientifically, as far as he was aware of. If it were true, it was probable that the act of putting in a fuse would be sufficient to break one of the crystals, and would set the detonator off. He could say on the evidence that there had been a great amount of care exercised by the management in dealing with the dynamite, but the mode of delivery was capable of improvement.

The Coroner then briefly addressed the jury, saying that it seemed to him that the only verdict they could return would be that the men were killed by an explosion of dynamite, but that how it was caused there was no evidence to show.

The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental Death."

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Burnyeat, W.    Mine Owner  
Green, James   23 Iron Ore Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Helder, —    Solicitor  
Kitchen, James    Miner  
Madders, Henry   21 Iron Ore Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
McDonald, Felix    Miner  
McKelvie, John    Coroner  
Stout, James    Manager  
Wilkin, William    Miner  
Willis, James    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Ehen (Iron Ore)  Ehen (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
17 Mar 1877  Dreadful Dynamite Explosion at Egremont, A Miner Blown To Pieces (Northern Counties Gazette)
22 Mar 1877  The Late Dynamite Explosion at Egremont, The Adjourned Inquest Yesterday (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Ehen, No. 1 Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print