Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th December 1876

The Fatal Colliery Accident at Moor Row

The Coroner's Inquest

(By Our Own Reporter.)

The adjourned inquiry by Mr. J. McKelvie, coroner of the district, into the cause of the death of the three men whose untimely end while in pursuit of their daily employment at the Crossfield Company's No. 8 pit, near Moor Row, on the 25th ultimo, we briefly noticed in our last impression, was held in the Railway Hotel, Moor Row, on Tuesday morning.

Mr. Helder appeared on behalf of the Crossfield Company (of which Mr. John McKenzie and Mr. W. Burnyeat, jun., were present), and Mr. Webster for the engineman. Mr. Willis, H.M. Inspector of Mines, was also present.

It appeared that on the morning of the accident, about six o'clock, all the men were out of No. 8 except four — Edward Phillips, Edward Kelly, Edwin Blanchard, and John Thomas. The men ascend by a cage, which has the ordinary safety apparatus — a disconnecting hook for disengaging the cage in case of overwinding and bringing it to a standstill in the guides, and what are called "eccentrics," by means of which, when the cage has been disconnected with the rope and is falling, springs operate so as to bring into immediate play a contrivance for clutching the guiding-rods and saving the cage and its contents. The cage is hoisted and lowered by steam-power, and under the Metalliferous Mines Act it is necessary that the engineman shall have an indicator — a machine with a dial and pointer, which shows the position of the cage in the shaft. The top of the shaft is in full view of the engineman, so that he can see, also, when the cage has arrived at the surface. It did not transpire, otherwise than by inference from the remarks of Mr. Willis, the Government Inspector, whether it would have been of any avail, in this particular instance, if the cage had been observed by the engineman to arrive at the surface. Mr. Willis seemed to say that it would; but with the large winding-drums now in use at most of our collieries, a single stroke of the engine lifts about 60 feet. Mr. Willis, however, would know the arrangements at this particular pit, and would, no doubt, be right. The engineman on the shift in which the accident occurred was a young man named William Anderson. The four men above mentioned got into the cage to ascend. The signal was given to lift; the cage was lifted a few feet and lowered again, as there was not enough steam to lift the four. This would seem not to have been an uncommon occurrence, for the man Phillips immediately surmised the cause and jumped out of the cage. He thereby, fortunately, saved his life. The cage was again lifted, and this time it was doomed to go further than necessary; it emerged from the shaft, shot up the works with its living cargo, came into violent collision with the top, was disconnected, and went down to the bottom again like a shot. The "eccentrics" had not acted — at any rate, not successfully. Besides the other precautions, there are what are called keps, which cover the shaft; but it appears that these were not put in use when men were riding the shaft, but were used more particularly for the cage to rest upon when laden with ore. It was possible the keps might have saved the cage; but it was also possible that the cage would have broken through the keps. There were two witnesses of the accident at the pit top, and one of the immediate consequence at the bottom; and one of the men at the top, at the request of the engineman, immediately went into the enginehouse and saw that the indicator, which it was impossible could have been altered, showed the cage as being three or four fathoms from the surface. The Government Inspector came down. The indicator had been left in the same state as at the time of the accident, and he examined it. He found that there was a break in the workings — in what is called the "worm" which would cause a slip and account for the accident. These facts being placed before the jury, they very properly returned a verdict which inculpated no person either for negligence or anything else.

The first inquiry was touching the death of the man Thomas, and the verdict having been returned in his case, the further inquiry was merely a repetition of the evidence and the verdict in both of the other cases.

The first witness called was Isabella Watson, wife of George Watson, Moor Row, platelayer, who identified the body of Thomas.

Edward Phillips, Moor Row, miner at the Crossfield Company's No. 8 pit, the man who escaped, deposed as to the ascent of the cage and its sudden descent, and that when he then looked into the cage he found the men quite dead.

Hugh Marron, Todholes-road, Cleator Moor, a miner at the pit, deposed that he came up the shaft about three minutes before the accident — in the last ascent before, and that he was standing at the top waiting for the next lot of men. He heard the signal given to the engineman from below that some men wanted to be drawn up. The engineman lifted them, may be six or seven feet, and then lowered, as he hadn't steam. They were then brought up. The speed was no faster than usual. When the cage came to the mouth of the pit, it was drawn up to the striking bar. The rope then became unfastened, and the cage went down to the bottom with the men in it. There are keps at the mouth of the pit which should have come across the mouth of the pit and prevented the descent of the cage, but these keps were wedged back, and so could not act. Did not know how long they had been wedged back. When the pit is drawing metal the keps are always open for the cages to rest upon. The Inspector said that the keps were not for the purpose of preventing the cage descending. They might have done so had they been there, but it did not necessarily follow that they would have prevented it. Witness: The keps had always been wedged back in the afternoon and night shift when drawing up men. He did not know the reason why. There was no banksmen at the pit mouth. There was generally a banksmen there. He would be late in coming that morning, that was all. When the accident happened the engineman came out with a light immediately, thinking the cage was sticking at the top of the pit. He asked witness where the men were, and he told him they were at the pit bottom, cage and all. He said according to his indicator the cage should have been four fathoms from the surface. Witness looked then and there at the indicator, and found that the pointer wanted between three and four inches of being up to where it should have been if the cage had been at the pit mouth. Where the engineman sits, had there been a light, he could have seen that the cage was at the pit mouth. There was no light except the light witness had in his hand. There is usually an oil lamp to give light at the mouth of the pit, and witness didn't know why it wasn't lit that morning, except that the engineman did not think there was any danger. From the time the cage came up and struck the bar till the time he came out the engineman would have no time to touch the indicator or interfere with it, in witness's opinion. The cage witness was in came up quite safely, and he did not apprehend any misfortune. Generally, when riding up that shaft with Sanderson he had had no occasion to find any fault with his driving. When the cage went away it disappeared fast, and witness heard a noise as if it was striking, but that did not seem to stop it any. It went right down.

James Thomas Hall, Wath Brow, miner at the pit, and Thomas Hall, Wath Brow, labourer at the mine, gave evidence, but of an unimportant character. They were also present at the pit top about the time of the accident, of which the first named was an actual witness. James Thomas Hall swore positively that none of the deceased men had any lights; Thomas Hall said they had all lighted candles, and that he had complained before of the engineman driving him too fast up and down the shaft.

John Finlay, Cleator Moor, engineman, who relieved Sanderson, the engineman at the time of the accident, deposed as to the state in which he found the indicator, which was as described by a previous witness, and that it was not interfered with in any way from the time he went on till the arrival of the Government Inspector. — This witness gave his evidence reluctantly, and with an amount of positive incivility.

John McKeller Main deposed that he lived at St. Bees, and was a mining engineer. He was manager and mining engineer to the Crossfield Company. The Company's No. 8 pit is fitted with patent cages. There are eccentrics, which would stop the cage in the event of the rope breaking or the detaching being knocked out. The rope is also fitted with a patent detaching hook. The engine had always worked satisfactorily up to this time. William Sanderson had been in their employ since about March last. Was not at the pit at the time of the accident. Got there about ten o'clock, when his attention was called to the indicator of the engine. Noticed that the pointer was three or four inches from the top mark, showing that the cage was about three fathoms from the top. It took two minutes to take the indicator to pieces with proper tools, when they examined it, and it would have to be taken to pieces to tamper with it. When they examined it with the Inspector they did not find out anything, because they could not make a complete travel of the shaft, owing to the slides being damaged; but on the Tuesday they could travel the whole length, and they then found that the indicator was at fault, and did not show when the cage was at the pit mouth. The pointer of the indicator was grazing against the dial at one or two points. When they took the dial off they found all round the worm and between the worm and the pinion metal dust like filings, as if the worm and the pinion had been grating against each other. That was not a sufficient cause in itself for the indicator not working properly. The fault lay in an injury in one of the threads of the worm. That would account for it. The rope is detached when five feet from the cross-bar. It is the duty of the banksman to light the lamps on the pit top. The banksman should have been there at six o'clock that morning. There was no night banksman, as they did not draw metal at night. It is a common practice, he believed, in this district to wedge back the keps when men are being lifted. If the banksman is there he does not wedge them back. Perhaps some of the first men who came up would wedge them back. It was quite likely had the keps been out they would have stopped the cage, but there was a possibility that it might have broken through. There was a man appointed to examine the cages regularly to see that they were working properly. But he depended on keeping the bolts, joints, and springs in good working order. There were indications of the springs having gripped 14 feet or 15 feet on one side, and 7 feet or 8 feet on the other side. The grip marks appeared to have ceased all at once. From his examination of the fracture of the worm, he should think that it had been suddenly done, and not gradually. There was nothing to lead them to suppose there was anything wrong with the indicator before the accident, and it could not have been ascertained without an examination of the worm of the indicator. After the accident he examined the eccentrics on the cage, and found all the bolts tight. The spring seemed all right, also. He had not formed any opinion as to how the gripping ceased to act at a certain distance. He had found that none of the patent cages are to be depended upon. — The foreman of the jury suggested that if there had been a double set of keps, one higher than the other, it would be much safer. Witness said that no doubt another set of keps would, and they were now making arrangements for something of that kind in one or two instances. It was difficult to conceive all these precautions except by experience; but they endeavoured to do whatever they could for the safety of the men.

William Sanderson, the engineman, gave evidence in accordance with the foregoing, and Dr. Eaton deposed to the cause of death as discovered by the post-mortem examination — rupture of the heart.

A Juryman (Mr. Woolcock) said he thought it ought to be explained through the Press that Dr. Eaton, in making the post-mortem examination did not act upon his own authority, as some of the people supposed. He had heard it said that they were going to try to put Dr. Eaton out of some of the works on the supposition that he made the post-mortem examination on his own authority, and he thought that it was not fair that such an opinion should be allowed to prevail without contradiction.

The Coroner: Dr. Eaton acted under strict order from me, as it was necessary to have such an examination.

Mr. Woolcock said some said that the Coroner, even, had not power to order a post-mortem examination without the consent of the jury.

The Coroner: Oh, yes; the Coroner himself has power to order a post-mortem examination if in his opinion it is necessary, and in this case I considered that it was necessary. Don't think, however, that post-mortem examinations are ordered out of mere curiosity.

Mr. Woolcock: I only asked the question for information.

The Coroner: And I am very glad you did. It has given me an opportunity of clearing Dr. Eaton.

Mr. Willis said he might say that he examined the engine shortly after the accident, with a special view to looking at the indicator, which was stated to have gone wrong. The indicator is a description that is very much in use, and is supposed in many respects to be a very great improvement upon the old style of indicator that we had. It seemed in a condition, as had been stated in evidence, as if there had been considerable wear upon it, and that one thread of the worm was injured, and that there had been considerable pressure of the pointer on the dial. He thought it was quite possible that the accident to the worm was coincident with the indicator going wrong, although the appearance of the injury to the worm was not such as he would have expected in that case; it was a clear break of the worm, an inch long by a quarter of an inch deep, or something like that. When he saw it and felt it, he did not set much store on it, because he didn't think it was the cause of the indicator going wrong; but he had no doubt, now, that it was the cause. The wearing of the worm and the little tooth of the wheel would bring it not to have sufficient "bearance," and would thus, at some time or other, and at this time he supposed did, cause one tooth to go over the other; and he thought that, probably, was the cause of the indicator going wrong. Then he looked at the shaft top with a view to see what contrivances were in use for preventing this kind of accident. He found that there was a detaching-hook, and also those eccentrics that had been so much talked about. These had always been considered as indications that the owners were doing everything possible in their power to prevent such accidents. What was called a detaching apparatus was simply what its name implied — it did nothing more; then after detaching the rope it left to the eccentrics the saving of the cage. Now, one of the jury had pointed out what appeared on the face of it to be a very good suggestion — that was to put keps higher up. But they should not forget that in introducing new things they very often introduced things only to be looked at; and the great probability was that even if keps were put higher up they would be neglected, and when they were really wanted they would not be there. The kind of detachment in use, he must say, he did not like, and the apparatus for checking the cage he never did like. They had been known to act so as to save life; but they had also been known to cause death by wrongful action of the safety apparatus. There are hooks now that not only detach the rope, but hold the cage by the same operation. There are three or four that seemed to him to be very efficacious; he could not say that one is better than another. These he had known to fail — that was one of them, not the other three; but any of these would set aside the necessity of having keps raised above the surface, which, as he had already said, he was afraid would come to be neglected. He might say also, as to the indicator, that there is a possibility of these indicators going wrong simply by wearing, in the first place, and by not being attended to, as was the case with this one. On the same day he made experiments with others, and one he had shifted about by a man under his directions in any direction he liked. There was another place where the designer had been at fault, and the pointer did not move at all till the cage was lifted or depressed, as the case might be, for 50 feet in the shaft. This knowledge led one to think it is not the best kind of indicator; and from his present knowledge and the result of this accident, would lead him to make a recommendation to the company to alter the form of safety hook, and to fake off the safety action from the cage altogether. Although that was taking a responsibility upon himself that he did not like, still he was quite satisfied that they might result in danger. There was also another recommendation that would be made, and that was besides the present indicator, to have also the old form of indicator, so that if there is an accident, the probability will be that they will not both go wrong at the same time. With these alterations it was probable an accident of this kind will not occur again. There was another thing should not be forgot — the accusation of oiling should not have been permitted for so long a time. Those who had charge of the engine should have seen to this. One of the witnesses said he oiled it during the week some time, and they were obliged to believe he did; but it did not seem to have signs of having been oiled for six months. The grease about it was hard, and had to be cut out — in fact, it didn't look like grease at all, but had the appearance of metal. He (the inspector) did not know that he had anything further to say. He thought the evidence had brought out all that was necessary to be known, so far as he was concerned — so far as he wished. It did not appear to him that the brakesman had been a sharp man. He did not think he could have seen that the indicator was going wrong, but he thought that it was his duty to look out when the cage was at the surface. No doubt the indicator was there for that purpose, and was to be looked at; but in driving an engine, as in doing other things, they must exercise a fair amount of sharpness and common sense, and look all about — in fact, have as many eyes as possible to try and prevent an accident. He thought there was nothing more he could say. If any of the jury were desirous of asking him anything, he would be glad to answer them.

The foreman asked whether, in the case of the two indicators, they would not both be liable to the same accident?

Mr. Willis said it was hardly within the bounds of possibility that they could both go wrong; and in the case of one being at fault the other would act as a check.

Mr. Webster: It has been suggested that a bell be rung when the cage gets a certain distance from the surface.

Mr. Willis: That is frequently done; but there are some — wise men, too — who object to the bell. The objection is this, that it is another piece of machinery added to the indicator that might possibly go wrong and might not ring; and the tendency of the engineman is to listen to the bell, and if it didn't happen to ring at any particular time the cage would go over the top.

Mr. Helder (to Mr. Willis): You always found the Crossfield ready and willing to adopt any suggestions for the safety of the works?

Mr. Willis: So far as I have had experience of them they are always ready to adopt any suggestion that is made to them.

The Coroner then summed up the evidence, and pointed out especially, owing to the remark of Mr. Willis, that no matter whether or not it should strike anyone that things might have been better done at the time of the accident than they were (and suggestions were always more ready to be conceived after an accident than at the time), if the jury were of opinion that the engineman acted to the best of his judgment, even supposing his judgment should have turned out to be most unfortunate, he could not be held responsible for any consequences of that judgment. The evidence before them was copious and sufficiently satisfactory, and he did not think that any blame was attached to any one; but that would be for the jury to decide.

The jury were then left to confer together as to their verdict, and, after a consultation of about half an hour, the foreman announced that they had agreed upon a verdict of "Accidental Death." At the same time they wished to strongly recommend a more general supervision of the machinery, and that a banksman should be present when the men were arriving at the surface.

The Coroner: Mr. Main is here, and I dare say he will take your recommendations into consideration.

Mr. Main: I will do all I can, as I have done hitherto, for the safety of the men; and I will see to the suggestions the jury have made, and also the suggestions Mr. Willis has made.

Mr. Willis: I will write to you about those things.

Mr. Main: Very well.

The inquiry then terminated.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anderson, William    Engineman  
Blanchard, Edwin   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Burnyeat, W.    Mine Owner  
Eaton, John, Dr.    Doctor  
Finlay, John    Engineman  
Hall, James Thomas    Miner  
Hall, Thomas    Labourer  
Helder, —    Solicitor  
Kelly, Edward   43 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Main, John McKellar    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page
Marron, Hugh    Miner  
McKelvie, John    Coroner  
McKenzie, John    Mine Owner  
Philips, Edward    Miner  
Sanderson, William    Engineman  
Thomas, John   35 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Watson, George    Platelayer  
Watson, Isabella      
Webster, —    Solicitor  
Willis, James    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Woolcock, —    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Crossfield (Iron Ore)  Crossfield (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
30 Nov 1876  Fatal Mining Accident Near Moor Row, Three Men Thrown Down A Pit Shaft (Whitehaven News)
02 Dec 1876  3 Men Killed At Whitehaven (Ulverston Mirror)
07 Dec 1876  The Fatal Colliery Accident at Moor Row, The Coroner’s Inquest (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Crossfield, No. 8 (Metalliferous)
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print