Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

10th February 1876

The Fatal Explosion In Melgramfitz Colliery

Adjourned Inquest

(By our own reporter)

The adjourned inquest upon the bodies of David Roper, 25 years, and William Souter, 18, coalminers, who were killed in Melgramfitz Pit, was held at the Punch Bowl Inn, Greysouthen, before Mr. Hayton, coroner, and a jury, of which Mr. Thomas Paisley was foreman, on Tuesday last. Mr. Edward Waugh, of Cockermouth, attended to watch the proceedings on behalf of the Company, and Mr. Wicks was present as the representative of the relatives of the deceased.

Mr. Waugh said before opening the inquiry, he had to state that he appeared for the proprietors of this colliery, the West Cumberland Steel and Iron Company, and he wished to state that it was the desire of the Company to give every facility to a full investigation, and the whole of the men in the colliery would be at the command of the coroner and jury. It was the wish of the Company to ascertain if anyone in their employ had been guilty of an offence, and if so that they should be punished.

Mr. Wicks, of Cockermouth, said he appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased, and would be very glad to give every facility he could for a full investigation.

The first witness called was Joseph Frizle, who said he lived at Greysouthen, and was a coalminer, and worked at Melgramfitz Pit. On Friday morning, the 28th of January, he went to work in the pit about twenty minutes before six o'clock. He went direct to his working, which was on the left hand side of the slope break, and next but one to the working where the deceased men were. His working would be about 60 yards below where the deceased, William Souter, was working. About five minutes after he had begun work he (witness) heard an explosion, which put out his light. He sat down behind a tub which he was filling, and waited a minute or two with a view of saving himself, as he had heard that the explosion sometimes returned. He heard a footstep coming down the slope away from the direction of the workings of deceased, some two or three minutes after the explosion. He (witness) cried out "Hallo," and the deceased, David Roper, who replied, "Hallo." He (witness) then said, "Is that you, David?" when he said "Yes, it's me." He (witness) said, "What's happened now?" "Hasta got burned?" and he said, "Oh, yes," as if he were in pain. Deceased was then close by where witness worked on the dilly top. All was then in darkness, and he could not see deceased. Witness went away to the other break top, and deceased was crying out for a light, and he (witness) saw a man going with one. After the light was brought he saw both of the deceased men on the break top. They were running towards where he was, and David cried out for a "sark," and he (witness) gave him his. He could not get it on in the usual way, because the skin was hanging from his arms, and some one assisted to wrap it round his breast. William Souter was much in the same state. He (witness) then rode up the shaft, and went to Workington for the doctor. He next saw the deceased men in their own house in bed at Greysouthen. David was very quiet, but Souter was rolling about and crying, "Oh, my belly." He (witness) had been a coal hagger for twelve months, and previously he was a sinker. He had been working at Melgramfitz Pit since March, and this was the first explosion that had taken place since he went to work there. He had no idea how this explosion arose. Previous to working at Melgramfitz he worked at Lowther Pit, and when there he was burned from an explosion of gas. He had seen nothing in Melgramfitz to lead him to believe that there was gas in the pit during the whole of the time he had been working there. By the Inspector: Before going to his work he saw the fireman, Henry Carruthers, down the pit. He was on the road, and said, "Good morning," and went on. They sometimes met the fireman at the station in the pit, and if they did not see him there they were in the habit of meeting him on the road. Carruthers had always been the fireman on that side of the colliery since he went there. He (witness) was working with candles, and had been working with naked lights on that side of the pit during the whole of the time he had been there. He had never seen gas in a pit, and he did not think that he could tell if gas were present. He did not use powder where he was working, nether was there any used on that side of the pit. He knew nothing of the mode of ventilation. By a Juror: The pit had been off work two days before the accident, on account of there being no trade. By Mr. Wicks: He always met the fireman down the pit. He had never had a copy of the rules. The explosion shook the loose shale by the side of the working. There were no caution boards in the pit that he had seen previous to the accident. He had since seen caution boards there, and they were placed on the outbye side of his working, and of the working where deceased was working. They always used naked light previous to the accident, and since too, in the presence of both the overman and deputy overman. There was no box for the fireman, but simply a board to sit upon. Carruthers had a lamp with him on the morning of the accident. He never met him with a naked light at that time of the morning, but had during the day. When he heard the explosion he saw no fire, but the report was a very loud one.

John Smith, coalminer, Great Broughton, said on the 28th ult., he went down the pit about a quarter to ten minutes to six o'clock. He saw the deceased that morning down the pit, about 300 yards from the bottom of the shaft, about five minutes after he went down. They were on their way to their working. He went along with them towards their working, which was past his own on the same side. Their working would be about 60 yards further on than his. About 20 minutes after he had left Roper and Souter he heard a crack. He (witness) had a naked light at the time, but the explosion did not affect it, neither did it affect him in any way. After the explosion he heard someone shouting, when he picked up his clothes and ran out of his working to where he had left deceased. He did not see them there, but he heard some running down the dilly, and he followed them. He came up to them and Joseph Studholm, Robert Richardson, and Thomas Dawson, at the break top. Joseph Frizle was just leaving them to go for the doctor' Souter was shouting out "O, dear;" and David was wrapping a shirt round his body. He (witness) gave him his jacket, and he put it on and buttoned it round him. Roper said, "Thee take a light, and I'll follow thee." He (witness) went to the bottom of the shaft with David, and afterwards went to the pit top with him, Souter afterwards came up the pit whilst he (witness) was on the top. There was some one with him, but he did not know who. The deceased then went into the check weighman's office, and remained there about 20 minutes, when they brought a cart and took them home. He had worked about eight or nine months at Melgramfitz. He never knew of any explosion in the pit during that time. By Mr. Wicks: He went into his working that morning without leave from anyone. He had gone into his working without permission, but he had seen the fireman on the roadside, and he would have told him if there had been anything wrong. The fireman had always a lamp with him. He was not sure that he saw him that morning, but he would think that he was there as usual. By the Inspector: The explosion was loud, and rather shook the place where he was in. The pit had not been working for two days. There were boards put up now that no one had to go beyond the break top with open lights. There were no boards up before the explosion. Before the explosion they always worked with open lights; but they were now working with barrel lamps, or safety lamps, as they called them. By Mr. Wicks: He never saw Carruthers at the pit top to say whether the men should go down or not. He was always near the bottom of the shaft, and if there had been anything wrong he would have told them. He had heard him tell the men when there was a fall in any of their workings. He had not seen Carruthers in the pit since, and he thought that "Jack" Graham acted in his place. He had seen him every morning since. Graham was overman before the accident. By a Juryman: It was the duty of the fireman to examine the pit before the men went into their workings. He was not sure that he was there that morning. By the Foreman: There was a mark in the working every morning to show that the fireman had been there. On the morning of the explosion the day of the month was marked on his spade, and that was the usual mark.

At this stage a short adjournment took place. Upon the re-assembling of the jury, Mr. Wicks asked that the certified copy of the rules of the colliery, in use at the time of the accident, signed by the inspector, should be put in. Mr. Waugh said he was afraid that the only copy would be at the Home Office. The Coroner said the Inspector could sign the rules if he thought that they were the same as had been certified. The Inspector then signed the rules, and they were put in.

Joseph Studholm said he was a coalminer, living at Little Broughton, and worked at Melgramfitz. He ran the dilly. On the morning of the 28th he went down the pit about twenty minutes before six o'clock. He saw the deceased down the pit a short time after he went down. They went upon the top of the dilly, and he followed them. Souter came down to the dilly bottom to get a tub, and took it up with him towards the working. He had his candle on the tub end. Roper was up at his own "spot." He heard a "crack" about three or four minutes after he saw Souter go up the dilly. He was at the top of his own dilly at the time. He could not tell the distance he was from Souter's working at the time. He had an open lamp with him when the explosion took place, and it blew the light out. He felt no effect from the explosion except the wind. He afterwards saw Roper and Souter on the break top, the former was shouting "Fetch a light." Both men were burned all over, and they were bared down to the waistband. By Mr. Wicks: He was standing on the top of the dilly at the time, in the middle of the air course. He passed Carruthers at the break bottom that morning. He had a safety lamp with him. By Mr. Waugh: Roper and Souter went up the dilly to doff themselves before Souter took the tub up. He could not see a light in the working. Souter had been up about ten minutes before he came down for the tub. When the deceased left him Roper had a light but Souter had none. Candles were kept in the workings by the workmen, and the deceased might have had candles in their working. He had seen two or three men undress at one spot and in one working.

Thomas Stephenson, coalminer, Overend, near Greysouthen, said he knew the deceased men well. He remembered them being brought home last Friday week. They were brought by a horse and cart, about half past six o'clock in the morning. Their bodies were burned from the waist upwards. He had seen worse burns to outside appearance. He attended upon them all Friday and all Friday night up till their death on Saturday morning. William Souter died about half past five o'clock in the morning, and David Roper about twenty minutes or half an hour after.

The Coroner asked if either of the men said anything to him about the accident. Mr. Waugh thought that they would have to show, in the first place, that the man who made the statement was in extremis, that he believed that he was dying. Witness said Roper was quite sensible up to three minutes from his death. He could warrant that Roper told him something about the accident early in the night. He could not say that Roper thought he was dying when he made the statement. The other man was out of his mind the most part of the night.

Dr. Strang, Workington, said he was called upon to attend the deceased men, at Greysouthen. He saw them first a little before eight o'clock. He attended Souter first, and found him in bed in great agony, tossing about. He was burned all over the head, neck, both arms, and the body, as far down as the waistband. There was also an extensive burn over the right knee. He was suffering from severe shock, and was somewhat stupefied. He then attended Roper, who was more quiet. He was also burned all over the head, neck, and body, as far down as the waistband. His legs were not burned. He was quite conscious, and complained most of a severe pain at the pit of the stomach. He was also suffering from shock, but to a slight extent. He again saw them between ten and eleven o'clock in the morning, and afterwards between ten and eleven o'clock at night. Souter was then considerably worse, nearly quite unconscious, and apparently rapidly sinking. Roper was still conscious, and complained more of the burns, the pain at the pit of the stomach having gone. Upon the whole Roper was more exhausted than when he saw him in the morning. The cause of death in both cases was burns and shock to the system. He did not tell Roper when he saw him in the evening that he was dying, and he was rather surprised that he had died so suddenly, as there were no signs of immediate sinking as in the case of Souter. By Mr. Wicks: He was doctor to some of the workmen employed at the West Cumberland Iron and Steel Company, but was not employed in any way by the Company, unless in the case of accidents. There was a verbal understanding that in the case of accident he had to attend the workmen. Since the appointment he had never been paid by the Company. Mr. Spence had spoken to him about it. By Mr. Wicks: When he saw Roper at night he was in a very critical condition, but as a practical medical man he thought that the chances were in favour of his recovery.

John Graham, overman at the pit, said he lived at Great Broughton, and went down the pit about twenty minutes before six o'clock on the morning of the explosion. It was his first duty to meet the man who was fireman and hear what he had to report. Henry Carruthers was fireman, and had been acting in that capacity since the 3rd of June last. He (witness) had been overman for about two years, and was in the pit at the bottom of the shaft when the explosion took place. He did not hear it. He inspected the workings of Roper and Souter about two hours after the explosion, and found a little fire-damp in Souter's place, but no gas. Carruthers, the fireman, was under him, and his duties were to descend the pit about half past three o'clock in the morning and inspect the working places. If he found anything wrong he had to stick up a card with the word "danger" written upon it, and report it to him (witness.) He did not see any danger card that morning, and Carruthers did not report anything. The pit was well ventilated, and he had never had any complaints. He had been a coalminer for 24 years. He had never known fire damp in Melgramfitz pit before. He had had a good deal of experience in fire. It was quite possible that gas had generated in Souter's or Roper's working between half past three o'clock, the time it might have been inspected by the fireman, and the time of the explosion. By the Inspector: Souter's place was not rising much, but going on a dead level. The seam rose end way on the coal about six inches to the yard. There was a "hitch" in Souter's working, and about eight feet of it bared, but there was no gas when it was opened out. They had the same "hitch" in other parts of the pit, and had never seen any gas. They had never used brattice in approaching this "hitch." They had never used lamps in the place before, as they never had any occasion for them. He had found Carruthers a careful man, and was well enough acquainted with gas. There was a blower in the place, and they could hear it 30 yards off. It was discharging a large quantity of gas.

Mr. James Spence, of Great Clifton, the manager of the West Cumberland Iron and Steel Company's Collieries, was then examined. He said that after the explosion on the 28th ult., he went down the pit. It would be then about half past seven o'clock, or nearly eight. He examined the place where the explosion took place, and found it filled with a sort of smoke. By the Inspector: Went into the farthest working, and found in it a little after damp. The general ventilation of the pit was very good. He had been a manager 16 months, and frequently during that time he had been down the pit and examined it.

This concluded the evidence, and the coroner having summed up, the jury returned the following verdict: "That the deceased, David Roper and William Souter, died from the effects of burns sustained in Melgramfitz Colliery, on the 28th January, but they did not find any one criminally culpable for their deaths."

The inquiry lasted from ten a.m. until six p.m.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Carruthers, Henry    Fireman  
Dawson, Thomas    Miner  
Frizzle, Joseph    Miner  
Graham, Jack    Overman  
Paisley, Thomas    Jury Foreman  
Richardson, Robert    Miner  
Roper, David   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Smith, John    Miner  
Spence, James    Manager  
Strang, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Studholm, Joseph    Miner  
Sutter, William   18 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Waugh, Edward    Solictor  
Wicks, —    Solictor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Melgramfitz Colliery  Melgramfitz Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
03 Feb 1876  Explosion at Melgramfitz Colliery (Whitehaven News)
10 Feb 1876  The Fatal Explosion In Melgramfitz Colliery, Adjourned Inquest (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Melgramfitz
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print