Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

16th December 1875

Alleged Excessive Assessment On Mines

After the ordinary cases had been disposed of.

The magistrates took up the appeals against the decision of parish assessors as to the amount of taxation which should be levied on certain appellants who sought relief, namely, the Salter and Eskett Park Mining Company, the Eskett Iron Ore Company, the Parkside Mining Company, and the Whitehaven and Cleator Railway Company.

Mr. John Musgrave appeared for the appellants. Mr. Parry appeared to watch the interests of Messrs. Baird and Kelton, miners, Lamplugh: and Mr. Lumb for the London and North-Western Railway Company, Messrs. Baird and Kelton, and the overseers of Salter and Eskett.

Mr. Musgrave said he would suggest to the Bench and Mr. Brockbank that, as one guiding principle would be applicable to the cases of the three mining companies, they be taken together. Having settled the principle of rating, they could then fix the separate amount which they might think it right to arrive at finally. It would be very tedious to the Bench to hear four cases separately.

The Clerk: Yes, the principle when once decided will act on the others.

Mr. Musgrave: That is why I suggest that the three mining appeals be heard together.

The Clerk: Yes, let the principle be settled in one case, and then as to the others it becomes a question of amount.

Mr. Musgrave: Just so.

Mr. Lumb said he was agreeable to that.

Mr. Musgrave: I think we will take the Eskett case, and then the Salter and Eskett.

Mr. Lumb: I appear for the overseers of Salter and Eskett, and I also appear, sir, to watch the interests of the London and North-Western Railway Company, and of Messrs. Baird and Co.

Mr. Musgrave: We are talking of a mining case. You appeared in that cattle case five minutes ago, in which I have no interest, and why should the London and North-Western or others feel themselves affected by this reduction of assessment. Mr. Musgrave was proceeding to hand in the notice of assessment.

The Clerk: This only gives notice of assessment you are not called upon now to pay the money.

Mr. Musgrave: Is not the rating to be proved before you.

The Clerk: No, I think not. It is a mere question of amount. If you were summoned for an order to pay the money, it would have to be proved.

Mr. Musgrave said he appeared on behalf of a body of miners who are residing in the parish of Salter and Eskett, and others in the parish of Arlecdon. With regard to the assessment of mines he should ask them to exercise a little patience, because the subject was one of very great importance, not only to the parish but to the manufacturing interest of this district. The grounds on which they appeared before them were shortly these. The subject of rating these mines had already been heard before the Assessment Committee, which was the first tribunal, and it had been disposed of there unsatisfactorily. The next tribunal was the Court of Petty Sessions, or before the magistrates at Quarter Sessions. In the option of the appellants. Now, in the first instance, the appellants preferred to go before this Court, because they were highly impressed with the belief that they had in this locality considerable experience of the working of the mines, and especially the coal mines and the iron ore mines. He, therefore, would ask them patiently to hear them on both sides, that they might endeavour to arrive at a fair principle of valuation. The ground of appeal was that the rate of assessment was illegal, excessive, incorrect, and unfair, for that they (the appellants) were over-rated in respect to the value of the said mines and hereditaments. The second appeal was a repetition of the same thing, that they were over-rated and over-valued; and the third was similar, with the slight variation that "the property in respect to said premises occupied by us is excessive in comparison with other tenements in the said Union.

Mr. Parry observed that he appeared on behalf of a mining company, and he did not think Mr. Musgrave was entitled to bring their name at all forward here, because they were not properly brought before the Assessment Committee, and therefore, could not be introduced into this Court.

Mr. Musgrave said he intended to make a comparison with other rated premises in the Union; it was perfectly legitimate for him to make a comparison, and if it were, not so the provisions of the Act would be completely defeated.

The Clerk: Is there a good case of that? You do not go the length of saying he cannot product other evidence than that which has been before the committee.

The Clerk said it had been held that an appellant may appeal to the Sessions against a rate made in conformity to the list containing his appeal, and to the grounds in respect of which he had failed to obtain relief.

Mr. Musgrave: Well, we failed to obtain relief. I hold it to be a perfect fallacy.

The Clerk: Well, there is the Act.

Mr. Musgrave: Do you mean to say if you do not compare your case with that of somebody else, you cannot do so here or at the Sessions. We did not get the relief we are entitled to have here, and we want you to know the whole case that you might give us that relief.

The Clerk: You may ask for relief here, but you cannot being in another mining company by way of comparison.

Mr. Musgrave said it could but reasonable be contended that if another mining company gets a proper reduction in the Court Sessions, that the Eskett or other companies could not appeal here. He could not think that any such law was ever held.

The Clerk said the case which had been handed in on the other side, and which had been perused by the magistrates and himself, was dead against him. He did not see how Mr. Musgrave could get over it, for it was the very point.

Mr. Lumb said he would raise the same objection as Mr. Parry, on behalf of the London and North-Western Railway.

Mr. Musgrave: You follow suit. You are not in this case. I cannot agree that that case is applicable entirely. I think if it comes to a matter of evidence, we will show that the question was raised before the Assessment Committee of the inequality of the rating. It was the very ground of objection.

The Clerk: Give us proof.

Mr. Musgrave. We will give you evidence.

The Clerk: You may give evidence to show that you are over-rated.

Mr. Musgrave: I do not wish to put the comparison before the Court to show reason why the rating of others should be increased. We simply say the others have been fairly rated, whereas we have been unfairly rated.

The Clerk: The magistrates cannot deal to-day with those people whose rates are to be raised unless you give them notice to bring it before the Court.

Mr. Parry: Can you go out of the parish for your comparisons?

Mr. Musgrave: I can go over the entire Union. I again say that it is not my wish, or the wish of my clients, to get the rating of other mining proprietors increased.

The Clerk: In that case Mr. Parry and Mr. Lumb have nothing to do but to keep quiet.

Mr. Parry said his client did not wish in any way to be brought into this case. That was the reason he made the objection, and quotes the case to the Court.

The Clerk: You are out of the case now.

Mr. Parry: Very well, sir.

Mr. Musgrave observed that he had no intention to injure anyone, he merely wanted to get relief for the mining firms on whose behalf he appeared, and his object in addressing them was to obtain that relief without injury to others, he hoped. In fact he thought it would be rather beneficial than otherwise to them. In the first place, the Eskett Mining Co. Mr. D. B. Robinson's iron mines were assessed for 44,317 tons at 4s per ton; amount of assessment, £6,652 1s. The rateable value they had nothing to do with. The Salter Mining Company, Thomas Dixon the owner, was assessed for 83,000 tons at 4s per ton; amount of assessment, £12,450. Parkside Mining Company, John Postlethwaite, assessed for 51,189 tons, at 4s per ton, amount of assessment, £7,615 17s. These three mining companies were called on to make a return of the rents paid for their mines for 1874, and accordingly each of the companies made a return of the head rent, and of the amount of iron ore raised, and the rent which they paid to the landlords for these mines. They never desired to conceal what was the actual rent. The Eskett Mining Company paid a rent of 1s 3d per ton of 20 cwt., Parkside paid 1s 6d per 34 cwt. (which is about 10½d per 20 cwt.), the third was 1s 6d per 3½ cwt. He need not tell them that landlords, in letting their royalties, will endeavour to get the best rent they could from a good tenant, and he thought he need not say that the Eskett Company are a very influential mining Company that any landlord would be glad to let mines to, and he might say the same for the other Companies he represented. He thought the Parkside Mining Company might be trusted as fair and reasonable tenants, that the three Companies would be treated as making an honest, straight-forward contract in this matter, and there is no collusion. He would wish the magistrates to consider it a bona fide letting, and the overseers of the parish might properly consider it in the same light. Now, if he asked them to concur in that view they got a step towards their decision, and he ventured to say that it would not be contradicted that this was a bona fide letting. They remembered the new Act passed for letting for assessing mines, and the difficulty there was of getting that Act of Parliament passed. It was the general opinion throughout England that such would be the difficulty of assessing a mine that it would lead to endless litigation and great trouble; but some more advanced people said, "No, there is no difficulty insurmountable in this matter. If you pass the law there will be no witnesses, there will be intelligence brought to bear on its execution." Various persons had published books on the subject, and the members of Parliament said, "No doubt the assessment can be fairly made, and the justices and the judges will ultimately come to a decision that may be satisfactory." It was the difficulty presented to Parliament, it was a long time before the Government took the subject up, and when it was taken up it was followed by a warm discussion about the mode of assessment. In order to hold Assessment Committees, and to enable the magistrates to arrive at a decision, there were certain clauses put into the Mining Act by way of guiding such bodies in arriving at a just conclusion. It was troubling the lawyers more than any other to know the meaning of those directions inserted in the Act of Parliament.

The Clerk said unless Mr. Musgrave could convince him to the contrary, he would advise the magistrates that no portion of these Acts applied to iron mines, but to tin, lead, and copper, and the only part that related to iron mines was the third section.

Mr. Musgrave remarked that he was very much obliged to him for what he had said, but it was the very argument he was going to bring before them. He was not, however, so practised as the magistrates' adviser. He wanted to cut the knot at once. The Assessment Committee had applied a rule which he did not believe in at all, and which he hoped the magistrates would refuse to follow. They wanted to apply a rule of thumb when they ought to apply a rule of law, and he believed the magistrates would feel themselves justified in discarding the 2nd section, and adopting the principle of the assessment of coal mines. The principle upon which they would have to decide was the Act of Elizabeth, which had made mines rateable. Now, if they came to a decision according to law, their duties would be easily accomplished. If he got them to take that view of it he would go to the next point. First, what was the amount at which mines should be rated, in order to be fair and correct in regard to the rating of this class of property in this Union, and especially in this parish? Well, it was this, wherever they could find a bona fide letting of a tenement in this Union, and in this district he believed he might say it should be adopted as a criterion and a basis for their fixing the gross and rateable value. Now, it was laid down in all the books he thought without any exception that the criterion of rating was the bona fide rack rents. If there were great improvements made, if a place were allowed to run into a dilapidated condition, and it became necessary to enlarge the premises at the heavy cost of the occupier, the overseers in that case would consider it perfectly legitimate to step over the lease and increase the rate. If the property was made twice the value by the improvement, they would increase the rate upon the principle that the property was altered. Otherwise he contended that the rent was a criterion of value, and they must have strong reasons for departing from that principle. Now, what was the rent in this case? The bona fide letting of the Eskett company at 1s 3d per ton, the Eskett Park Company at 1s 3d for half, and 1s 6d for the other half, and the Parkside Company at 10½d. All bona fide lettings. Upon what principle are overseers to fix by rule of thumb whether these should be rated at 4s? Well, two years ago there was a time of prosperity, of amazing prosperity, iron ore sold at 37s a ton, and he dared say as high as 40s a ton. A grand time no doubt that for miners, but he would remind them what wages got up to — double the amount of wages had to be paid and only half the amount of work done for it. When wages were doubled contracts had been made to advance, and the proprietors had to lose, for of what good were the high prices for new contracts when they had to finish the old contracts at lower prices, but with higher wages to pay. It was a misfortune, and firms had not recovered from that up to the present time, and therefore let them not be led away to suppose the great prosperity warranted a demand of 4s a ton. These times had passed, there was great depression now, and there was not a miner now who would not be glad to take half of 37s 6d for their ore, and a great deal less than that. He could bring evidence before them to show that persons are now glad to sell it at 13s a ton. He believed that he would be abusing the privilege that they granted him if he were to say more than this, but he should content himself with arguing the case putting the leases before them, and asking for their decision. He was not going to trouble them with evidence, but call upon them to decide this case according to the law of Elizabeth, and not according to the 7th section of the new Act. His contention was that it did not apply.

The Clerk: I agree with you so far.

Mr. Musgrave: If you look to the amount which these gentlemen have returned. I ask you to give them equal justice. Look at their leases, and charge them according to their regular rental. If you consider they were taken some time ago, so that there may have been an ultimate improvement from circumstances that would justify you in departing from the regular rent principle, them, I say, bear in mind you are not selling, and if you depart from the regular rental upon a principle, what is the reason you should rate them more than 1s 6d. It must be some legal improvement that would justify you. If it is so, then make us like our neighbours. There is the mine at Kelton Fell —

Mr. Musgrave: I will do you a favour if you let me.

Mr. Lumb: I object to having anything said about it. Messrs. Baird and Co., have received no notice as registered by section 19, and I ask you to take a note of the objection.

Mr. Musgrave said Mr. Lumb was not properly before the court — all he had to do was to keep quiet. There was a mine at Lamplugh at which they used no machinery, the water runs out by gravitation, it was a very valuable mine, so valuable that a river had been made up to it for its own purposes. It had many advantages which these Eskett mines have not. A great deal of water had to be pumped up out of Eskett mine, and a very expensive operation it was. In addition to that they were placed in a locality with roads so bad that he did not know any part of this county in which they were worse. The roads were passing over hills and dales, and he believed no repairs were done to them since the memory of man. He did not know that they were made at the time of the flood, but they were so wretchedly bad that the Eskett Company had to use tramways and engines to remove the iron ore that was raised.

The Clerk: And for which you are liable to be rated.

Mr. Musgrave: I dare say, but are we to be rated at 4s a ton? Mr. Musgrave then proceeded at length to institute comparisons between the resources, expenditure, &c., of the mines which he represented in comparison with others, contending that the former were over-rated.

Mr. Lumb briefly addressed the Court on behalf of the overseers, and submitted that Mr. Musgrave's contentions about the rate of these iron ore mines were clearly wrong. His contention was that each iron ore proprietor was to be rated according to the rant reserved by their leases. If they looked at that from a common sense point of view, could they for a moment say it was fair. He asked the Bench not to lose sight of the very important fact that at the time these leases were entered into — about the year 1856 — there was very little known about the value of the Royalties, and he was sure that if the leases had been entered into a few years ago the terms would have been totally different. In the year 1856 they knew nothing about iron ore mines or their value, and it was only within recent years that their importance was recognised by the commercial world.

The Clerk: The real question is what would these mines let for at the time this rate was made.

Mr. Lumb: That is the sole question.

Mr. Musgrave: I beg your pardon, you must also take into account that it is a mine, and all the circumstances of it.

Mr. Lumb said it was remarkable that Mr. Musgrave did not produce evidence, lest they should have an opportunity of examining them minutely, and learning what were the profits.

Mr. Musgrave: Do not mislead the magistrates, because you cannot rate profits.

The Clerk: No.

Mr. Lumb: I do not want to rate profits, but I could get the cost of working.

Mr. Musgrave observed that they could not in any way take in the element of profit. For instance how would they proceed to rate the Bank of Whitehaven? There were some shops in King-street where people were making a thousand a year, but which were only valued at £50 for rating.

Mr. Lumb pointed out that in the Furness district they were rated at even higher figures.

Mr. Musgrave observed that in the Furness district there was a uniform rate of 2s 3d a ton. It was a known fact that the Furness ore was not to be compared to the Salter ore. It was of much better quality in every way for certain manufacturing purposes.

Mr. Lumb: Do you mean to say that these particular mines would only be let at 1s 6d and 1s 3d at the time this rate was made? In the Furness district the mines have all been uniformly rated at 2s 3d, and in the Cleveland district they have all been uniformly rated. I believe at 3s.

Mr. Musgrave: No, my belief is that it is 2s. They cut it out of the hill side — they have no mining there.

Mr. Lumb: The Cleveland ore is not to be compared to this. It is remarkable that the three persons who have appealed here to-day are the only ones who have objected or appealed.

Mr. Musgrave: That is not the case.

Mr. Lumb: I am told the others have paid without hesitation.

Mr. Musgrave: There is no other appeal before the Court to-day, but I utterly deny that there are no others are going to adopt the same course.

The Clerk: The assessment was reduced by the Assessment Committee from 4s to 3s.

Mr. Musgrave said that was so, but he saw no reason why they should not be assessed at as low a figure as other mines in the same district.

The magistrates then retired, and after a short absence returned into Court, when the Chairman announced that they saw no reason to alter their decision.

Mr. Musgrave said the lease of the Parkside Mining Company had expired on the 8th of October last. Half the amount would be paid by the old tenant and half by the new, and he asked the case to be adjourned, to see whether they would come to an arrangement, otherwise the magistrates would have to decide upon the point.

This was accordingly agreed to.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brockbank, —    Solicitor  
Lumb, —    Solicitor  
Musgrave, John    Solicitor  
Parry, —    Solicitor  
Postlethwaite, John    Mine Owner  
Robinson, D. B.    Mine Owner  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print