|
25th March 1875 "The Missing Link"Rigg v. FittonThe defendant, who is the manager of the Jane Pit at Workington, was sued by the plaintiff, who had taken a contract to do certain work in the shaft, for the balance of his contract, and also for extra work done, and not included in the contract. The amount claimed altogether £13 4s. Mr. Guy appeared for the plaintiff, and Mr. Webster for the defendant. Plaintiff said he entered into a contract with the defendant in December last to take two sets of pipes, and the brattice down to the water, out of Jane Pit shaft, for the sum of £18. The shaft was 140 yards deep, and there would be about 60 feet of water in it. There was what they called the third set of pipes under water, but he had nothing to do with them. His Honour: Did you get the agreement in writing? Plaintiff: No. His Honour: Then it is very foolish to make these agreements without being in writing. (Addressing defendant) Did you put it down in any book? Defendant: No. His Honour: Then you are equally to blame. Plaintiff continued to say that he had been paid £8 14s on account, and there remained £9 6s upon the contract, and remainder was for extra work. The defendant had to find all the gear, and see that the work was kept going. In reply to Mr. Webster plaintiff said the agreement was that he had to take out all the pipes down to the middle "lugs." The second set had, however, not been taken out, as the chain broke. He had taken the whole of the brattice out down to the water, and also the pipes to the same point. The second set were in the chairs when they broke, and they went to the bottom of the shaft and had not been recovered. He believed the breaking strain of the chain was 10 tons. They were only taking out three lengths of pipe at the time when the chain broke, and their weight would only be about 30cwt. There might have been one of the bolts left in the flange of one of the pipes that prevented the three coming away, but he was not there at the time. He believed that one of the links in the chain was badly welded, and that was the cause of it breaking. His Honour: According to your own showing you have not taken out the pipes that you agreed to do, and you will either have to sacrifice the £13 or finish your work. Plaintiff: It will be impossible to get the pipes out now, as they are at the bottom of the shaft amongst the water. Mr. Guy contended that as his client had no control over the engine that was pulling the pipes out, he had no right to be made responsible for the accident. Mr. Webster said the plaintiff or his men had found that the pipes would not come away, and had got the engineman to "jerk" the engine so as to lift them. He had two of the links of the chain in court to show that they were perfectly sound. The links were produced, and appeared in good order, but the plaintiff said the one that had broken, and which had the flaw, was taken possession of by the defendant and taken into the office. Defendant denied that he had the link, and stated that the one he picked up was from the head gear. The one that had broken was at the bottom of the pit along with the pipes. His Honour observed that if the defendant was prepared to show that the chain was broken wilfully, then there was an end to the case. If it was an accident, both would have to suffer. Mr. Guy said he had more witnesses, and called George Daglish, who stated that he was working in the shaft, and did not know of any jerking. He did not hear any of plaintiff's men telling the engineman to put the power on to the chain. He saw Mr. Fitton lift a broken link and take it into the office the day after the accident. He did not know where the link came from. Joseph Clarke gave similar evidence, and His Honour ordered a non-suit to be entered, without costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||