




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
25th March 1875
Charge Of Molesting A Miner
Thomas Stephenson, Robert Wordsworth, George Peart, and James Renney, miners, were charged that on the 13th day of March instant, at the township of Brigham, they did each of them unlawfully molest the complainant, James
Tunstall, by then and there besetting the house in which the complainant resided, with a view to coerce the complainant, being a workman, to quit the employment of the trustees of John Harris, deceased. — Mr. Wicks appeared for
the defence. — The complainant deposed that he was a coalminer, in the employ of the trustees of the late John Harris. On the 15th March he was at home at Brigham. He had been working at the pit ever since he was a boy up to the previous Saturday
night. He was not a unionist. He was working with his father in the garden on Monday until four o'clock, when he came out of the garden into the house where he lived. There he saw the four defendants, with about 150 other men, coming along together.
He knew the defendants, who were coalminers. Thomas Stephenson and Wordsworth, worked at Mr. Fletcher's pit, and Peart too, he thought; but he never saw Renney before. On Monday they all came into the yard. These
four were the ringleaders, and as many more came in as could get in. Renney came up to witness, and asked him if he was not a "blackleg," and witness said he was — he did not deny it. He meant he was not in the union. Thomas
Stephenson made a rush, and knocked witness off the wall where he was. When witness fell Wordsworth shouted out, "Be into the _*_*_*, and give him plenty with your clogs." Stephenson asked witness what he wanted, and witness said he
wanted nothing, but he was going to pick Stephenson out for what he had done. Stephenson said he cared nothing for witness, or for the law, and Peart then came and rang a big bell in witness's face, and witness had to turn out of his way, or the bell
would have struck him in the face. There was nothing said about being a blackleg, beyond what witness said, excepting that the crowd all called out "blacklegs," and so on. They said they would lay wait for witness and others if they went to
work next morning. Robert Wordsworth said that. He said he would coal-tar the doors and windows if the witness went to work next day. The men were all coalminers. Renney came on to witness's father's doorstep, and invited witness out to fight, and
made four attempts to strike at witness with a brass instrument which he had in his hand, and as he could not get any of them to make a row, he spit in witness's father's face. Stephenson came and challenged both witness and his father to fight.
Witness went into his father's house until the men went away, and then he and his father went out for a walk. They got a letter from Mr. Fletcher, of Brigham Hill, to come to Mr. Waugh's house, and they went and saw young Mr. Waugh, and
went to Cockermouth that night. Nothing happened next day, except what some "women folk, who were not very clever," did. — Cross-examined: In consequence of the letter witness got from Mr. Fletcher, he went to Mr. Waugh. Believed Mr.
Waugh was solicitor for Harris's trustees. Got up on Monday morning at a quarter past five. Generally went to work at half-past four. Had not been drunk the night before. Witness's house was next door to his father's house. Stephenson had a big drum
with him, and all the time he was assaulting witness he had the drum on. He was "riving" it off his neck to fight witness. Peart had a bell, and rung it, and Renney had a brass instrument, and Wordsworth was "egging" them on. Would
not swear that Wordsworth was in the yard. The crowd came from the direction of Greysouthern. Witness was standing on the wall when the crowd came. He got up to see who they were. When the crowd got to where he was he did not take off his hat and
hurray. Witness was standing on the wall, and said the crowd was to give them a good shout, as they had come. Witness's step-mother did not throw bread out of the window, and say, "Take this you hungry _*_*." Did not see any water thrown on
the men by her. Did not know there was to be a mass meeting at Great Broughton next day, and that the band were going round to get people to go. — Benjamin Wren deposed that he was at Brigham on the 15th. He was a collier, working at Nebgill. He
was sitting on the wall with James Tunstall when Thomas Stephenson came by, and knocked Tunstall off the wall. There were perhaps thirty or forty persons in the yard then. Wordsworth said they were to "down" Tunstall, and said,
"Into the blacklegs with your clogs." All four of the defendants were in the crowd. Benjamin Wren, Elizabeth Moore, Elizabeth Tunstall (wife of the complainant), Thomas Tunstall (father of the complainant),
Jonathan Harrison, and Isabella Wren, gave evidence substantially the same as that of the complainant, and corroborative of his statements. — Mr. Wicks then addressed the Bench for the defence. He said the Bench would not fail
to have noticed that the information was laid under an Act of Parliament (the Criminal Law Amendment Act) which provided for those found guilty under it a very severe sentence. Section 10 referred to offences of violence and molestation, and this
information was laid under sub-section 3. Now, he did not think that the evidence that had been alluded on the part of the prosecution brought this case home to the defendants. It seemed clear to him that if they were besetting any person's house they
were besetting the house of the complainant's father. Every one of the witnesses spoke to the fact that they were besetting Tunstall's father's house, and he submitted that the information was wrongly laid, and that it ought to be dismissed on that
ground, as it was a penal statute. Mr. Wicks then reviewed the evidence of the witnesses for the complainant, and said that there was no intention to molest the complainant. The defendants were going round for the purpose of getting the miners to
attend a mass meeting, and they went round by Greysouthen, doing what they had a perfect right to do, otherwise every German band that played before a house might be tried for besetting the house. (Laughter.) They found Tunstall standing on a wall, and
hurraying, and instead of their endeavouring to coerce him, he was endeavouring to coerce them from being members of the union. He invited them into the yard to play, and bread was thrown to them, and water was subsequently thrown on them. Stephenson
had a big drum on at the time he was said to have assaulted complainant; but he (Mr. Wicks) was told that Tunstall jumped off the wall. He thought it was a pity that this summons had been brought before the Bench. There had been very bad feeling
amongst the unionists and non-unionists, and he thought this case showed, on the part of the non-unionist, a worse feeling than had been shown on the part of the union men; and he thought, now that the strike was over, Tunstall would have done better if
he had joined his companions in work, without bringing what he called this frivolous charge into court. (There was some little applause in the crowded court at the close of Mr. Wick's address, but it was of course suppressed.) — William Moncrief
was the first witness called for the defence, and he deposed that he was a stonemason and lived at Brigham. He remembered the 15th inst. He was working in the quarry at Brigham on that day, and heard a band. He went out to see it, and joined the crowd
at the lower end o Brigham. He was present when they were near Tunstall's, and the first thing he saw when they came near Tunstall's was Tunstall's son James waving his hat and shouting to the crowd to come on, that they (Tunstall and others with him)
were blacklegs. John Wilson and Joseph Wilson were in witness's company at the time. Witness saw Wordsworth there. Saw the band go into Tunstall's yard, and it appeared as if Tunstall waved them in. Wordsworth was never out of witness's company
during the time the band was in the yard, and he did not do or say anything except to witness. — John Wilson, also a mason, working with the last witness at Brigham, deposed that he went with Moncrief to hear the band, and saw it coming down the
road. He deposed to what took place when the band arrived at Tunstall's, and said Wordsworth was never in the yard all the time, but was with witness. — Isabella Wilkinson gave similar evidence as to Wordsworth, and said that he had a bell which
he gave to Peart. — Edward Gray deposed that he was with the band, and that the band was out for pleasure, and not to collect people to come to the meeting. The band began to play at Brigham. Witness saw Tunstall on the wall before the band got
to the yard. Tunstall was waving his hat, and told the band when they got up to him that they were to play him a tune, and the band stayed and played him a tune. Wordsworth was playing with a bell, but he gave it to Peart before they got to the yard.
Some bread was thrown to the crowd, and a woman, who witness believed was Tunstall's mother, threw some water on the crowd. Witness did not know whether Tunstall was a union man or not, but he wanted a tune and they gave him one. Witness was in the
yard with the band, playing on one of the drums, of which there were two, Stephenson having one and witness the other. Tunstall jumped off the wall and no one knocked him off. Witness went with the band to amuse the people, and "liven them up a
bit." They went back to Broughton Cross afterwards to attend a meeting. — Another witness of the name of Grey also deposed that he saw the complainant throw bread from the house and jump off the wall, and that he was not knocked off. —
Thomas Tunstall deposed that he was with the band, and saw James Tunstall standing on the wall of the yard, waving his hat and calling. Witness was not near enough to hear what he said. The band and others went into the yard, and bread and water were
thrown to them. Witness did not know that Tunstall was a blackleg. Witness was a unionist. The band went to the meeting at Broughton Cross afterwards. William Cape, Joseph Corr, Hugh Macallan, Benjamin Johnston, Stockbridge Lawson, Daniel Ostle,
Braithwaite Johnston, John Webster, and William Roger, all gave evidence for the defence, of a character similar to that of the preceding witnesses, and the case for molestation having been closed, a charge against Stephenson, Renney, and Peart, for
assaulting the complainant, and against Wordsworth, for aiding and abetting in such assault, at the same time and place, was gone into. — The complainant gave evidence substantially the same as that which he gave in the opening case. Benjamin Wren
deposed that he saw Stephenson knock the complainant off the wall with his hand, and he attempted to take the drum off to get at him. Renney was threatening Tunstall with his brass instrument. — Elizabeth Moore deposed that she saw Stephenson put
his arm out to "fell" Tunstall. She heard Wordsworth encouraging the others, and saw Renney offer to push the trumpet down the complainant's throat, and he was near enough to do it. He touched complainant on the breast with the trumpet.
— Peart said he would smash witness's face with a bell if she would not let him get at Jim. — Cross-examined: Witness saw a little girl throw some water out. The old woman did not throw any bread that witness saw. — Elizabeth Tunstall
deposed that she saw Stephenson pull witness's husband off the wall, and make an attempt to strike at him. Witness saw Renney attempt to strike at complainant over his father's shoulder. — Mr. Wicks said he did not propose to address the Bench at
length upon the assault case, for it turned entirely upon what they did with the other charge. It seemed to him that Tunstall was the aggressor, and he thought the Bench would find that the best way of making peace would be to send the parties home, and
let them be friends. — George Peart, one of the defendants, deposed that he was with the band on the day in question, and saw Tunstall standing on the wall. He was standing up, shaking his hat, and said he was a blackleg, and that the band was to
play away. They went into the yard, and witness never saw Tunstall when he was ringing the bell, and never attempted to strike him with it. Did not know whether Tunstall was pushed off the wall or knocked off, or jumped off himself. Witness said they
had nothing to eat, and some of Tunstall's people stuck a loaf on a poker, and said the crowd were all hungered. Witness saw no one at the door but an old woman, "blockading herself with a crutch." Witness saw Renney there the whole time, and
he did not attempt to strike the complainant. Witness was ringing the bell which he got from Wordsworth. — James Renney, another of the defendants, deposed that he was present and saw Peart there, and he did not attempt to strike the complainant,
and that nobody did. Witness saw complainant come off the wall. He jumped off, witness thought, but it was likely they would make the thing as bad as they could. Witness did not see any attempt to strike complainant. Bread and water were thrown.
Witness had a trumpet. — Joseph Corr deposed that complainant jumped off the wall close to him. Benjamin Johnston deposed that he saw Tunstall when he came off the wall. As far as witness could see he jumped off. Witness was never above two
yards from him. — Stephenson, the defendant, deposed that he saw what took place. He did not pull Tunstall off the wall. He would not say that when he was swinging the drumstick he did not hit Tunstall, but he did not intend. — The
magistrates then retired to consider the cases, and on their return into court, after an absence of about a quarter of an hour, the Chairman said that the defendants were each of them charged with the offence of besetting the complainant Tunstall's
house, with a view to coerce him from going to his work. He need perhaps hardly say that that was an offence according to law of the very gravest possible character. In case it was made out in clear evidence, and the defendants had been convicted, they
would have been liable to a very severe penalty — to imprisonment for a very considerable time. The Bench had carefully considered the evidence before them, and after consideration they thought there perhaps might be a doubt in the case, which
might justify them in acquitting the defendants on that occasion, but he could not express too strongly the extreme regret of the Bench that a suspicion of such a grave offence having been committed should have been excited at all, and they did hope that
this would be a caution to the defendants and the rest of the neighbourhood, and in future they would live better friends. So far as the first charge went the Bench had given the defendants the benefit of the doubt, and they were, therefore, acquitted
on that charge. Then three of them were each charged, in addition to the other offence, with assaulting the complainant James Tunstall. The Bench had also carefully considered the evidence on both sides of the cases, and they certainly thought the
evidence conclusive, that they had been each of them guilty of what, in law, was an assault. They had each of them made themselves liable to a penalty of £5, but the Bench thought that the ends of justice might be satisfied with a small penalty,
hoping that it would lend them to live in a more friendly manner in the future. They were each of them fined 20s, including costs, with the alternative of fourteen days imprisonment, in default of payment; and Wordsworth, who was charged with aiding and
abetting in the assault, and was liable to the same penalty as the others, was also fined 20s, including costs. — Thomas Tunstall, of Dearham, stepped out of the body of the court and paid the fines. — The complainant and his friends were
received with hooting and derision outside the court, and the defendants with cheering, and a band of music followed by a considerable crowd, who stopped at intervals to cheer, paraded the streets of Cockermouth for about an hour after the Court rose.
The hearing of the case occupied about four hours and a half.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cape, William | | | |
| Corr, Joseph | | | |
| Fletcher, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Grey, Edward | | | |
| Harris, John | | Mine Owner | |
| Harrison, Jonathan | | | |
| Johnson, Benjamin | | | |
| Johnston, Braithwaite | | | |
| Lawson, Stockbridge | | | |
| Macallan, Hugh | | | |
| Moncrief, William | | Mason | |
| Moore, Elizabeth | | | |
| Ostle, Daniel | | | |
| Renney, James | | Miner | |
| Roger, William | | | |
| Stephenson, Thomas | | Miner | |
| Tunstall, Elizabeth | | | |
| Tunstall, James | | | |
| Tunstall, Thomas | | | |
| Waugh, — | | Solicitor | |
| Webster, John | | | |
| Wicks, — | | Solicitor | |
| Wilson, John | | Mason | |
| Wilson, Joseph | | | |
| Wordsworth, Robert | | Miner | |
| Wren, Benjamin | | | |
| Wren, Isabella | | | |
|
|