Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th March 1875, Page: 3, Column: 3

Failure Of Industrial Partnerships In The Iron And Coal Trades

Experience has proved, up to the present moment that partnerships of industry are utterly inefficient for the purposes of their formation ; and the signs of the times point to the conclusion that, in the forms they have hitherto assumed, they are likely, before long, to become numbered among the things that were. This is a sweeping and unmeasured declaration, but there are, unfortunately, only too many proofs of its truthfulness. There are undoubtedly cases in which co-operation has proved highly successful and advantageous to both employers and employed; but it has reached this measure of successful operation only after it was purged of many of the elements required to form industrial partnership — so much so, indeed, that although the one has hitherto been used as a synonym for the other, they are likely from this time forward to go different ways, and so become perfectly distinct from each other. Co-operation has taken many different forms, and has been promoted with many diverse objects; but industrial partnerships, properly so named, have everywhere, and in all cases, ostensibly aimed at improving the relations of employers and employed, by making their interests to some extent identical, and by placing safeguards in such positions as to prevent suspensions of labour. Let us see how far the great central and paramount idea has been realised. The principle of industrial partnership was first adopted at the Whitewood and Methley collieries, near Normanton, by Messrs Henry Briggs, Son, and Co., with the ostensible view of preventing strikes, and other complications that are constantly recurring in the relations of employers and employed. Its initial application was undoubtedly attended with great success. Papers were read before the Social Science Congress and other learned societies, in which its virtues and merits were extolled and it was considered that the antidote had at last been found for the greatest bane that had ever afflicted industry. The general conditions of the industrial partnership scheme were :— 1. The rate of ordinary wages paid to the labourer, and of salary to the manager shall not exceed the average of remuneration ordinarily given for similar work performed in the same district. 2. Out of the first available proceeds of the business there shall be paid a rate of initial, or preference interest and profit upon invested capital, according to the risks to be encountered, from 5 up to 10 or 15 per cent. per annum, and in ironworks or collieries not to be less than 10 per cent. 3. If, after the payment before specified, and after a sufficient reservation has been made for restoration within a reasonable time, of capital invested in dead works or in depreciable stock, a balance of divisible profit remains, then such shall be divided as a bonus in the form of an equal percentage over the aggregate amount of capital invested and of wages or salaries earned during the twelve months, or other convenient period in which such profit has accrued. This project seemed calculated not only to secure perfect justice for both sides, but also to meet every exigency that could possibly arise. The advantages derivable from the system of industrial partnership adopted at the Whitwood and Methley collieries were thus set forth by Messrs H. Briggs, Son, and Co. :— 1st. The attainment of a direct personal incentive to every operative, not only to do his own duty, but to see that others do not neglect theirs. 2nd. The prevention of disputes between employers and employed. 3rd. The giving of a direct interest to each workman in the careful use of materials, and in the adoption of the most economical methods of working, and of improvements in machinery whereby labour is saved. 4th. The securing of a permanently settled and superior class of workpeople. 5th. The increase of the productive power of works, arising from the hearty co-operation of the workmen. During the first six years of the industrial partnership, the workmen at the Whitwood collieries received an aggregate bonus of over 40 per cent. upon their earnings, or an average of over 6½ per cent. per annum, in addition to the usual average rate of wages paid throughout the district for similar work. A number of the more thrifty workmen were also enabled to become shareholders in the company, so that they received not only the bonus due upon their labour, but a correspondingly large bonus upon their capital, in addition to the usual trade allowance of 10 per cent interest. From the outset, however, the project had many enemies and detractors. It was incompatible with trades unionism, and therefore trades unionists set their faces against it. Neither did it accord with the notions generally entertained by employers as to rights of meum and iuum in industrial affairs, and hence capitalists also gave it the cold shoulder. How much the Messrs Briggs suffered on the one hand, and their workmen on the other, in consequence of these inimical influences, will never, probably, be known. Failures are always less heard of than trials ; and the mortification and disappointment which the Messrs Briggs must nave experienced from the failure of this scheme has, no doubt, led them to say as little about it as possible; but, after all, the whole story is adequately told in the report issued for the half-year ended the 31st December last, wherein the directors declare their deep regret, "that they can no longer recommend the continuance of the system of industrial partnership, so far as respects the payment of a bonus on wages earned by employees. It is needless now to inquire into the origin of the altered relations between the company and its workmen, which have led the directors reluctantly to arrive at this decision; but, inasmuch as those employed underground are members of the Miners' Union, and act in all questions arising between themselves and their employers strictly under instructions from the executive of the union, it is evident that they are no longer prepared to recognise or carry out any special arrangement with the company. Indeed, it is understood by the underground workmen, and a deputation appointed by them has expressly stated it to be their desire, that they shall be in future on precisely the same footing as to their work, and the remuneration they shall receive for it, as the workmen employed at the other collieries in the district." Thus do the dreams of the visionary, and the aspirations of the philanthropist, and the calculations of the political economist, alike vanish into thin air. The bonus system was formally abolished by the shareholders at the company's half-yearly meeting ; and this system had of late been the only peg upon which the name of industrial partnership could be hung. In everything else it had become a misnomer. The success that had attended the principle of industrial partnership at Whitwood and Methley collieries, until the faith of the men was subverted by the union, led the Messrs Brings to introduce the same system into the works of the North of England Industrial Iron and Coal Company. This concern was founded in 1869 for the purpose of acquiring the Carlton Ironworks, formerly carried on near Stockton-on-Tees by Samuel Bastow and Company. Originally it comprised only two or three blast furnaces; but with an authorised capital of £250,000, the company proceed to open out ironstone mines in Cleveland and collieries in Durham, in addition to erecting at Carlton finished ironworks, on the Danks' system of rotary puddling. To each of these different departments of this great copartnery the principle of industrial partnership was applied. Unlike the Whitwood and Methley collieries, which have uniformly proved remunerative, and have paid to workmen as bonus more than £30,000 since the industrial partnership was established in 1866, the North of England Industrial Iron and Coal Company has had to meet heavy losses consequent upon fluctuations in trade, and the alleged failure of the Danks's system, on behalf of which they had incurred a very heavy outlay. It must be perfectly obvious that such a state of matters, while sufficiently disheartening to the employers, was peculiarly irritating to the workmen who had been induced to invest in the concern. Dissension and distrust crept in; and as at Whitwood and Methley, these rancorous feelings were fanned carefully by the union, until confidence in the partnership system became much shaken. This want of confidence was perhaps intensified by one of the rules for regulating the distribution of bonus on wages earned by those in the employ of the company, providing, as it did, that "as the firm refrain on principle from joining any combination of employers or capitalists, for the purpose of regulating wages questions, it is essential that all who desire to participate in the advantages of industrial partnership should in like manner abandon any connection with trades unions, and consequently no person in the company's employ will be allowed to take out a bonus book who is a member of a trades' union." Although the industrial partnership is still ostensibly in operation at the Carlton Ironworks, at the East Howe Colliery, and at the Aylesbury ironstone mines of the North oi England Industrial Iron and Coal Company, it has been abandoned openly at the South Belmont mines of the same company, where none of the men would even take out a bonus book lest they should be suspected of disloyalty to the union. There is only too much reason to fear that the recent discontinuance of the bonus system at Whitwood and Methley, will be followed by a renunciation of the principle at the works of the North of England Industrial Iron and Coal Company. Whatever the feelings of the masters may be on the matter, there have been numerous indications that the men have at the most but a half-hearted sympathy with the system. — Iron.


Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

East Howle Colliery  East Howle Colliery
South Belmont (Ironstone)  South Belmont (Ironstone)
Whitwood Colliery  Whitwood Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print