|
25th February 1875 The Rattening Case at Westray PitJoseph Sprott, miner, aged 30 years, and Robert Ireland, miner, aged 26, were charged with having feloniously cut certain ropes attached to the cage used in Westray Pit, near Workington, with intent to murder William Sprott and others, on the 29th of January. The evidence of the prosecution went to show that the case arose out of circumstances connected with the strike of about 1,000 colliers, who had left their employment in the west of Cumberland, leaving about twenty pits idle; while only three pits, of which the Westray Pit was one remained working, it being worked by non-unionists. On the 30th January, among the men working at Westray Pit was William Sprott, brother of one of the prisoners; and he, on going to his work on the 30th January, at six o'clock in the morning, was joined by the engineman (Miller) and by other workman. It was Miller's duty to examine the rope every morning, and see that it was all right before any men descended the pit. On this occasion William Sprott took Miller's lamp; and upon examining the rope, which was a flat rope about four inches wide, consisting of four strands, he found that three of the strands had been cut through, apparently with a saw, and the cages were hanging by that single strand. Although this was sufficiently strong to support the weight of the cage, it was proved by the manager of the colliery that if four men had in the ordinary course got into the cage to go down into the pit the rope must have broken, and the men would have been precipitated a distance of 18 yards, if not to the bottom of the pit, which is 56 fathoms deep. Footprints were subsequently found near the place, which led to the apprehension of Ireland, who, while in custody at the police-office, made a confession, in which he stated that he and the prisoner Joseph Sprott went between eight and nine o'clock on the night of the 29th January, and after cutting one of the ropes with a saw, apparently through, they cut the other in the manner already described. Sprott, when apprehended, signed this statement, to which a postscript was added that when they cut the rope they had no intention of doing any harm. They knew it was the duty of the men to examine the rope every morning. The statement made by Ireland contained the following passages:— "On Tuesday, January 26, Joseph Sprott, brother to William Sprott, now working at the old pit, came to me during the afternoon, and he knew that I was blamed for breaking the windows of William Means and Andrew Muir, and he said, 'What can we do to make matters equal?' William Sprott said, 'I was at Flimby a day or two since, and saw a chap who said that somebody should cut the pit rope. He said, What do you think if we do it?' I said, 'Well, Joe, it will be a terrible thing if we do that;' and he said, 'Oh, never mind.' I said, 'Joe, thou has a brother that works there;' and I said, "What a terrible thing it would be if anybody was killed, and he might be one of them.' And he said, 'We must try and make it so that no one will be hurt.' The meaning of us both was that as soon as the engine was removed the cage would break down the pit. Andrew Muir, a non-unionist, was called on behalf of the prosecution, and stated that in December last Ireland had shouted to him and another man named Means, who was also a non-unionist, called themselves blacklegs, and said, "What do you think of yourselves?" His windows were broken on the 19th January. — William Means, the other man referred to, corroborated this evidence, and said that he also had had a pane of glass broken in his window. — In cross-examination of the witnesses for the prosecution, it was shown that the rope was examined every morning, and that more particular attention had been paid to the examination since the strike took place, under apprehension that something might be done. The cut was very plain to be seen, and the cast which it gave to the rope enabled anyone readily to see that there was something wrong with it. — They learned judge told the jury, before the case for the prosecution was concluded, that before they could find the prisoners guilty of an attempt to commit murder they must find that they cut the rope with intent to cause the death of some of their fellow-creatures, and his lordship intimated his opinion that there was no reasonable evidence to lead the jury to come to the conclusion. — Mr. Campbell Foster said that under these circumstances he should not proceed further with the charge of attempting to commit murder, but would go on with the other counts in the indictment. — The foreman of the jury said that the majority of the jury thought that it had been done more to frighten the men and to top the works than with a view to commit murder. — The prisoners were thereupon acquitted upon the first count in the indictment, and were then charged with having cut the rope with intention to damage the machinery of the colliery. Upon this, they withdrew their plea of not guilty, and pleaded guilty. — Mr. Fawcett addressed the Court in mitigation of sentence. In a moment of irritation the prisoners had yielded to temptation to cut the rope, not with the intention of injuring any person, but only of injuring the machinery. He called witnesses, who gave both prisoners very good characters. — The learned judge, in sentencing the prisoners, told them that the Act of Parliament under which they were indicted did not contain a single word about unionist or anything of that kind, and had no bearing upon the relations between employer and employed except so far as to protect property and machinery of those who were employers of labour. He commented upon the serious and painful nature of the case, and sentenced both prisoners to twelve months imprisonment with hard labour, observing that he would have given them a more severe sentence had it not been for the good character which had been given to them by witnesses called on their behalf.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||