Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th February 1875

The Outrage at Westray Pit

Confession Of Two Of The Prisoners

Robert Ireland, miner, Great Clifton; Joseph Sprott, miner, Clifton; and Robert Smallwood, miner, Flimby, were placed in the dock, charged with having cut the rope at Westray Pit, with intent to murder some person or persons unknown, on the 30th of January last. — Mr. Wicks, of Cockermouth, appeared for the prisoners. — Mr. William Fletcher and Captain Drane left the Bench when the case was called upon, they being shareholders in the Company to which the pit belongs. — The first witness called was.

William Sprott, who said he was a coalminer, and lived at Great Clifton. He was brother to the prisoner Joseph Sprott. He remembered Saturday, the 30th January. Went to the Westray pit, and found David Nealy, a fellow-workmen, there. Took a pit lamp belonging to Thomas Miller, and examined the rope. The cages were then standing at meetings. Found the rope cut about a foot or 18 inches from the drum. It was not quite cut through, but nearly so. The rope was composed of four strands, and three and a part of the fourth were cut. He called the attention of the engine-man Miller to it. At day light some footprints were found about. He shouted on the other men to come. On the evening of that day he saw his brother, the prisoner, and he (witness) said it was a bad job or a shame, he could not remember which. His brother gave a laugh and said, "No bad job," or "No shame at all." He (witness) had gone to the pit that morning with the intention of going down to work. It was his duty as an onsetter to go down first. His brother told him about a week before that he should always examine the rope before he went down, but he did not give any reason why he should do so. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said he left his house about six o'clock in the morning. It was in consequence of having been told by the overman that he examined the rope, and not because his brother told him. Both ropes were cut. He had been warned more than once by his mother to examine the ropes. He had also been warned several times by his brother. He did not know the reason why he was so warned, only his mother said somebody might cut them. They had rules at the pit, but he had not a copy with him. He was not present when the police inspected the rope the first time. He was there when Inspector Smith examined the rope. He was alone when he first found the cut. He did not call the attention of the police to the footprints.

Thomas Miller said he was an engineman at Westray Pit, and on the morning of the 30th of January he went to work about ten minutes past six o'clock. He was accompanied by the last witness. They found David Nealy there, and Sprott took a lamp and went to examine the rope. He afterwards heard him shouting out that the rope was cut. He (witness) examined it, and found the rope cut. The rope was all right the night before when he left at four o'clock. He ran the cages down to the meetings before he left. Two men, named Richardson and Dykes, came to go down the pit. In the ordinary state of things they would have ridden down with Sprott and Nealy. After the rope was got clear, the men went down with another rope. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said it was part of his duty to examine the ropes. It was either his duty or that of the banksman, Joseph Pearson, to examine the ropes. It was on account of the strike that they were more particular in looking at the rope. The rope appeared to have been cut by a saw. It was mended that morning at eight o'clock. The same rope is at the pit, and it is mended with a clasp. It was the duty of the engineman to run the cage up and down after standing an hour. The rope would have been apt to have broken if the cage had been used without any one in it. The cages are always used twice empty after standing before the men are allowed to ride down.

David Nealy said he was a shiftsman, and lived at Great Clifton, and worked at Westray Pit. He remembered the morning the rope was cut. He went to the pit about six o'clock in the morning. He did not find any one there. Miller and Sprott came twenty minutes after him. They were still jealous of something being wrong, and Sprott was told to look the rope beside the barrel. He (witness) and John Burnett examined the drop-ropes. He recollected Sprott examining the rope on the day in question, when he said the rope was cut. He afterwards went up and down the yard, and found some footmarks. He (witness) had gone to the pit that morning for the purpose of riding down. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said nothing had been said to him about the ropes. The cut in the rope was discovered before it came to his part where he was examining the ropes. He did not see any clog marks, but there were several marks of boots or shoes.

Isaac Dykes, coalminer, Great Clifton, said he remembered proceeding to work at Westray Pit on Saturday morning, the 30th of January. Joseph Richardson went with him. When they got there they found William Sprott, David Nealy, and Thomas Miller, the engineman. It would have fallen to his lot to have gone down the pit first if he had been there along with the other three. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said he knew all the prisoners, and was on good terms with them.

Joseph Richardson, coalminer, Great Clifton, said he went to work with Dykes on the 30th of January. William Sprott, David Nealy, Isaac Dykes, and himself, would have been the first four to have gone down. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said he was a non-unionist. He had been in the union 15 weeks. He was on good terms with the prisoners.

Andrew Muir, shiftsman, Great Clifton, in the employ of the proprietors of Westray Pit, said he sometimes worked there, and sometimes at other places. On the morning of the 30th of January he went to Westray Pit for the purpose of riding down. When he was about 50 yards from the pit he was told by Isaac Dukes that the ropes were cut. When he got there the rope was pointed out, and it was cut. It was the rope attached to one of the cages. On the 26th of December he saw the prisoner Ireland on the road going to Lowther pit. He said, "What do you think of yourselves?" and afterwards said, "You are a set of nice-looking —." After they passed he called after them "black-legs." Ireland was then out on strike, and he (witness) was at work. He had called out the same name after him twice since. He afterwards said to a man who was working at some houses that he was to take a bucket and knock his brains out. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said he could not say who would have had to go down first. He could not say whether the rope would have broken with the empty cage or not. William Sprott called his attention to some footprints in the yard, which went towards a field.

William Neens, coalminer, Great Clifton said he knew the two prisoners Sprott and Ireland. On Saturday, the 30th January, he went to Westray pit for the purpose of going to work. In the ordinary course of things he would have been amongst the first or second batch to go down. He (witness) was not on strike, but the two prisoners he named were. He found, on going to the pit top, that the rope was cut, and the men were prevented going down. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said the rope might have carried the empty cage up and down the shaft.

Mr. James Spence, Great Clifton, manager of the pits for the West Cumberland Iron Company, said he had had sixteen years' experience as manager of pit work. The drawing produced was an outline of Westray Pit. It was supposed that the cages were hanging in the shaft. The distance from the drum to the pulley-wheel was twelve yards, and from the pulley-wheel to the flat sheets was eleven yards one foot, and from the flat sheets to the top of the cage, where it was supposed it was standing, was twenty-four yards. The cut in the rope would be about fifteen inches from the drum. That was the rope working on the lower pulley. He had seen marks of cutting upon the rope working on the higher pulley. The marks were about three or four feet from the pit mouth. The cut would be about three-eights in depth. The weight of the cage suspended from the lower pulley was nine cwt. It was weighed last night. The other cage would be about the same weight' they were the same in construction. He had had some experience in testing the carrying power of pit ropes. Had examined the rope on the lower pulley to make an estimate of its carrying powers. The weight of the rope itself from the pulley-wheel to the rope-barrel would be 2 cwt. 2 qrs. 8lbs; and from the pulley-wheel to the flat sheets would be 2 cwt. 1 qr. 20lbs; and from the flat-sheets to the top of the cage hanging half shaft would be 5 cwt. 1qr. 4 lbs. He estimated the weight of four men and gear at 6 cwt. Therefore the rope, pit cage, and men would be about 25 cwt. 1 qr. and 4 lbs. Treating this rope as new, its breaking strain would be about 24 tons, and the portion uncut would have carried about 18 cwt., if it had a fair pull at it. The depth of the pit shaft from the flat-sheets to the eye was 27 fathoms. In his opinion the result of any person falling with the cage would have been very serious. No doubt it would have been certain destruction to the men riding in the cage. On Monday he was shown some footmarks by the men at the pit top. On the Saturday morning the foreman went to his house and told him about the rope being cut, and he gave information to the police. — In reply to Mr. Wicks witness said he saw the rope after it was cut. It was the rule to run the cages up and down the shaft twice after they had been standing an hour. He was not prepared to swear that the rope would have carried the empty cage, although he believed it would. The ropes were examined every day whether there was a strike or not. The footprints were not very distinct.

P.C. Dalziel said he was stationed at Great Clifton, and received information of the ropes having been cut about eight o'clock in the morning. He went to the pit and was shown a cage rope that had been cut. He was also shown some footprints by Robert Kennedy. He traced the footprints over a fence into a field to a gap into another field, and then to a gate opening on to the turnpike road. The footprints commenced about 20 or 25 yards from the barrel. The surface of the 25 yards was quite loose stuff. He traced them from a fence in Wheelbarrow Lonnin, in the direction of the pit, as pointed out by the dotted line on the plan. He was present when Inspector Smith apprehended Ireland the same day, about three o'clock in the afternoon. Upon that occasion Ireland produced a pair of boots which he said he wore the previous day. He took possession of them, and went with Inspector Smith to compare the boots with the marks. He found them to correspond in every particular. They resembled the marks. The right boot had eight nails at the toe, and in the footprints and in the boot he found the fifth nail wanting. The inside of the footprint was sparrabled as far as the toe-plates generally extend. The boots were taken to the marks and compared, and found to correspond exactly. There was also a saw taken possession of that was found in Ireland's house. The pieces of rope produced were those that were cut. — In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said he traced the footprints continuously in the direction of Clifton, and to within half a mile of that place. The Inspector spoke to Ireland first. He saw the Inspector searching the house. They had no search warrant. When the prisoner said the boots produced were those he wore he night and day before, it was in reply to a question put by Inspector Smith. The boots were found in a front parlour, Inspector Smith found a saw in the back kitchen. He did not ask for it.

Inspector Smith said he was stationed at Workington. On Saturday, the 30th January last, he went to Great Clifton in company with Constable Dalziel, in consequence of a complaint that had been made of a rope having been cut at Westray pit. He was shown a pit-rope which had been cut. The rope was attached to the cage and the drum of the engine. P.C. Dalziel pointed out some footprints some 20 or 30 yards from the pit-top. The first distinct mark they saw was near Mr. Hetherington's, in a lane. They traced the marks along three fields, from within 25 to 30 yards of the pit. There was some short distance on the grass field where they lost the trace of the footmarks, but took them up again. They traced the same footprints returning. On the same afternoon he proceeded to the prisoner Ireland's house, and asked if he had any objections to show him the boots that he wore the day and evening before. He said he had not, and going into a room gave him the boots produced. He afterwards compared them with the footprints and found them to correspond. At the toe there were eight nails, and the fifth nail was wanting. In comparing the boot and the print they corresponded exactly. He then apprehended the prisoner, and charged him with the offence. After apprehending the prisoner he asked his father if he had any objection to a search of the house, and he said no. In a place under the stairs he found the saw produced. He then brought Ireland to Workington. During the time of his remand he had been desirous of making a statement. On Saturday last Mr. Barker, of Workington, called at the police-station and produced an authority to see the prisoner. In consequence of that he brought the prisoner into the court-room. Mr. Barker questioned him as to where he was between four and nine o'clock on the 29th of January. Mr. Barker said, "You know, Bob, I am doing all I can for you." He accounted for his time up till eight o'clock, and at that hour he said he was standing at the tank corner. He then left and went to Stainburn. Mr. Barker asked if anyone saw him on the road. The prisoner then said, "I may as well tell the truth; I know all about the cutting of the rope." He witness then cautioned the prisoner that if he was going to make a statement, he must understand that it would be taken down in writing, and might be used as evidence against him afterwards. This was done in the presence of Mr. Barker. He persisted in making a statement. They each took it down, and the prisoner Ireland signed them both. The following is a copy of the statement:—

"On Tuesday, January 26th, Joseph Sprott, brother to William Sprott, now working at the old pit, came to me during the afternoon, and he knew that I was blamed for breaking the windows that were broken. William Means and Andrew Muir, and he said, "What can we do to make matters equal." William Sprott said, "I was at Flimby a day or two since, and saw a chap who said that somebody should cut the pit rope." He said. "What do you think if we do it." I said, 'Well, Joe, it will be a terrible thing if we do that;' and he said, 'Oh, never mind.' I said, 'Joe, thou has a brother that works there;' and I said, "What a terrible thing it would be if anybody was killed, and he might be one of them.' And he said, 'We must try and make it so that no one will be hurt.' The meaning of us both was that as soon as the engine was removed the cage would break down the pit. On Friday, January 29th, Joseph Sprott and I went between eight and nine o'clock at night from Gatefoot to the pit, and went across what we call Gables, and up by Priest Hetherington's, and up another field to the pit. I took the saw from my father's house that the police have. I gave the saw to Joe, and he started to saw the rope, the furthest one from the drum. He afterwards left that and started with the other and cut it nearly half-way through. He then said, "Take the saw Bob," and I did, and cut it a little bit. Then Joe got the saw and cut the remainder, and we then came home."

"On Monday morning the 8th February, the prisoner Ireland was brought into the magistrate's room, in company with the prisoner Sprott. He said, "I wish to correct a statement made on Saturday night in the presence of Mr. Barker. All I wish to say is that when we cut the rope we had no intention of doing anybody any harm. We knew that it was their duty to examine the rope every morning."

(Signed.)  Robert Ireland
  Joseph Sprott
Witness:  Robert Bertram
  William Smith

Inspector Smith continued to say, in consequence of that statement he apprehended Sprott, and when he was brought to the police-station the statement made by Ireland was read over to him, and he said it was quite correct, and he signed it. When Ireland saw Sprott first he said, "I have told all about it, Bob." Sprott said, "hista, Joe?" Sprott made a statement respecting a third party, and in consequence of that he apprehended the prisoner Smallwood. He said, when apprehended, "I was not near the pit at the time." He afterwards made a statement to that effect, which was taken down in writing, and signed by him. Both men were cautioned before they made their statements.

In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said no cast had been taken of the footprints. When he went to the house he spoke to the prisoner Ireland's father. The prisoner did not hesitate to let him see his boots, and the father told him where the saw was. Re-examined: He measured the prints and found the length to be 11½ inches across the tread of the foot, width of heel, 2¾ inches; length of heel, 2¼ inches.

Superintendent Bertram said on Monday morning he was present when Sprott and Ireland were brought into the court and amended their statement.

Mr. Thomas Barker, accountant, said on Saturday last, being a friend of Ireland's he was asked by his friends to do what he could for him, believing him not to be guilty of such an offence. He requested Mr. Henry Fletcher to give him an order to see Ireland in the presence of a police-constable. He obtained an order, and saw the prisoner Ireland, who made a statement which he witness took down. He read the statement which was virtually the same as the one taken down by Inspector Smith.

At this juncture the Court adjourned to enable Mr. Wicks to consult the friends of the prisoners to ascertain what line of defence he should set up. Upon the Court re-assembling, the Chairman said there was no evidence against the defendant Smallwood, and he would be discharged. The police would very likely call upon him to give evidence against the other two prisoners.

Mr. Wicks objected to this course, and observed that he did not think that they had the power to do so. They might call him at the assizes.

Mr. Milburn, the Clerk, thought they had the power to call Smallwood, but he would take a note of Mr. Wick's objection.

Robert Smallwood was then called, and stated that he was a miner, living at Flimby, and on the 27th of January last he met the prisoner Sprott in Flimby. He said, "Well, Bob, have you not got to work here yet?" He (witness) said, "No; there's no more at work than what there was before." Sprott then said, "We have made it up to cut the Westray Pit rope."

In reply to Mr. Wicks, witness said Ireland was not present.

This being all the evidence, Mr. Wicks said he would reserve his defence, and the prisoners were committed to take their trial at the forthcoming Assizes.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Barker, Thomas    Accountant  
Bertram, Robert    Police Superintendent  
Burnett, John      
Dalziel, —    Police Constable  
Drane, —, Capt.    Magistrate  
Dykes, Isaac    Coalminer  
Fletcher, William    Magistrate  
Hetherington, —      
Ireland, Robert    Coalminer  
Kennedy, Robert      
Means, William      
Milburn, —    Clerk  
Miller, Thomas    Engineman  
Muir, Andrew    Shiftsman  
Nealy, David    Shiftsman  
Neens, William    Coalminer  
Peatson, Joseph    Banksman  
Richardson, Joseph    Coalminer  
Smallwood, Robert    Coalminer  
Smith, —    Police Inspector  
Smith, William    Police Inspector  
Spence, James    Manager  
Sprott, Joseph    Coalminer  
Sprott, William    Coalminer  
Wicks, —    Solicitor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Cookson Colliery  Cookson Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print