17th December 1874
The Colliers Strike In West Cumberland
The colliers' strike in West Cumberland, which commenced last week, continues. The resolution of the men, which was adopted at the Maryport meeting on Wednesday, to allow the collieries to stand idle until the masters consented to refer the dispute to
arbitration, was communicated to the coalowners on Thursday, by Mr. A. Sharpe, of Maryport, the miners' agent. The following day Mr. Sharpe received a letter from the masters, stating that the only reply they had to make to his communication was that
they adhered to their resolution to reduce the wages of the workmen ten per cent. In answer to this, Mr. Sharpe wrote stating that he would convene a meeting of delegates from the different districts on Monday to take the letter of the masters into
consideration, and expressing his regret that the employers had not offered more favourable terms, and thereby averted what was likely to prove a "severe struggle." The Whitehaven collieries are not included in the strike, and coal is being
sent from them to various places where the pits are standing idle. Coal has also been sent into West Cumberland from Scotland and Newcastle, but the determination of the miners to cease working was arrived at so suddenly that a number of persons,
especially at Cockermouth, have been put to great inconvenience in consequence of being unable to obtain a supply of coal. It is expected, however, that during the present week such arrangements will be made for obtaining coal from a distance as will
obviate this inconvenience. Meanwhile, the effects of the strike, although it has just commenced, are beginning to make themselves felt amongst some of the workmen and their families.
Meeting at Maryport
A large meeting in connection with the colliers' strike in West Cumberland was held in the Athenaeum, Maryport, on Monday last. Mr. Andrew Sharpe occupied the chair. There would not be fewer than 1,000 pitmen present, the commodious hall, ante room,
and galleries being literally crammed. A delegate from each of the collieries represented the whole of the district, except Workington, Harrington, and Whitehaven.
The CHAIRMAN opened the meeting by expressing his regret that there was no better prospect of a settlement of the dispute between the masters and men than there was when they met on the previous Monday. The strike was in resistance of a reduction of
wages to the extent of 10 per cent.
A letter was read from the secretary of the West Cumberland Coal Owners' Association, declining the offer on the part of the men to refer the dispute to arbitration.
The CHAIRMAN said that this was a result they did not expect, as he considered that arbitration, by one or more unconnected with either party, was the only way of doing justice to so important a matter. He further stated that there had been no change in
the Belfast coal market, which was said to rule the price of Maryport coal, to warrant the 10 per cent reduction in the men's wages. "Our only object," he continued, "in keeping reporters from our meeting last week was to make more room
for our own men, who are most interested. We are not afraid of publicity, for we rely on the justice of our cause for public sympathy; and we trust the privilege conceded to the press on this occasion will bring our cause favourably before the world.
It has been represented that colliers earn extravagant wages; but it must be borne in mind that if, in some rare instances, a man earns 10s a day, others are getting only 4s and 6s 6d may be taken as a fair average. Then there are times when the pits
are not working, owing to want of shipping and other causes, and this reduces the average to 4s 6d the year round; and surely this is not too much for a man who is exposed to the dangers attending work in the bowels of the earth. We consider we have
been unfairly treated by this short notice. In Northumberland the masters give the men time to consider a reduction and consult with them. If all masters considered their own interest, they would confide more in their men, so as to secure their
attachment to their employers. All present who are acquainted with pit work must be aware that 10 per cent is but as a drop in the bucket to what colliers have in their power to waste of the masters' property, or to save, when a right feeling is
preserved. Had the masters manifested a more kindly spirit towards the men on the occasion of this unfortunate misunderstanding, I have no doubt the whole of us would this day have been at work. We have always been willing to listen to the masters, and
if they could give any reasonable grounds for the reduction, we would be satisfied. I would wish to impress upon you the necessity of united action in this struggle. If there is no unity among the men, we can't maintain our position. The masters
combine to keep up the price of coal, and to keep down the wages of the men; therefore, they can't blame us for uniting in support of our own cause; and if faithful to one another, we must win in the long run. Coal owner's, coal merchants, and
coalminers are all equally interested in the result of this dispute. We have plenty of advice from out-siders, to the effect that we ought to resume work at the reduced rate of wages, but we are the best judges of our own cause. We are perhaps the
first to suffer, although there may be perhaps 500 in the district who are able to stand out for an indefinite time. That we are all better when working we are ready to admit, but when a dispute of this nature arises, it behoves us to stick together,
and then whether we succeed or not, no one can upbraid us with betraying the cause." The Chairman concluded by exhorting the men, as Christians, actuated by a religious principle, to resort to no violence or act of outrage that would bring disgrace
on the honourable struggle they were engaged in. He then called upon the delegates from the several collieries in the district to state to the meeting what resolution had been come to in their lodges.
Mr. JONATHAN SIMPSON, Bulgill, expressed his sorrow that the masters had not acceded to the proposition to submit their dispute to arbitration. He said the masters had, on this occasion, made a great mistake by presuming on the want of unanimity among
the men, and thinking that the pits would not be idle one day. When the advances in wages were compared with the advances in the price of coal, the present reduction of 10 per cent., was out of all proportion. In December, 1871, an advance of 5 per
cent., was given; in February, 1872, 5 per cent.; in June, 5 per cent.; in July, 10 per cent.; in August, 10 per cent.; and in September, 10 per cent. Since that time a reduction had been made in the last two advances, and when the tubbage was taken
into account that took away more than the men got. The total rise in wages altogether might amount to 50 per cent., while the rise in coal, from 1871, was 145 on round coal, and 190 on small. If the masters would give the deputies an opportunity by an
interview to compare notes with them, he felt satisfied they would be satisfied of the injustice of the proposed reduction. The speaker advised the men to conduct themselves properly, and not to get excited and wild, but to look the question fairly in
the face. If they decided to go to work tomorrow, he was ready; if they determined to stand out for three months, he was equally ready.
Mr. ROBERT FAULDER, Dearham, said he was sorry he had nothing encouraging to tell the meeting. The resolution come to at the lodge he represented was to the effect that, seeing the masters had refused to refer the dispute to arbitration, the men had no
alternative but to leave off work. They thought that the reduction of 10 per cent., in their wages was so unreasonable and inconsistent with the reduction in the price of coal that it ought to be resisted. (Cheers.)
Mr. WILLIAM COULTHARD, Ellenborough, submitted that the facts and figures produced by former speakers were such as to convince all reasonable persons that the demand of the masters was unjust. At a meeting of the Ellenborough Lodge, 49 voted for
standing out, and only one for accepting the masters' terms.
Mr. WILLIAM GRIMSHAW, Aspatria, said it was a grave question they had met to discuss, and worthy of their most deliberate consideration. The heat of their minds in the Aspatria Lodge was to resist the reduction of 10 per cent., although they were not
very sweet on arbitration. It had been said that a collier now earned as much as a professional man. He knew nothing about professional men, but he had been told that it took nine tailors to make a man, and he suspected that it would take nine
professional men to make a collier. (Laughter & cheers.)
Mr. KELSICK, Flimby, said that at his lodge it was resolved to resist the 10 per cent., reduction, unless the proprietors could prove that they had reduced the price of coal in the same ratio. "I have read of a young general," said he,
"who, with 500 men confronted a king's army with 20,000 and by their determined bravery overawed them. Let us show our mettle on this trying occasion. Three " cannels" and a bit of bread would keep them, as the same did Bruce when in
prison. Let them show courage and their struggle would be crowned with a glorious victory. Talk of the depression of the coal trade! He recollected when Mr. Wilson paid £50 a year for carting the small waste from the bank; and for this he was
now getting 30s per wagon. (Cheers.)
Mr. JOHN CARRUTHERS, Clifton, reported from his lodge that they were wishful to stand out against the reduction. He called upon the men not to disgrace their names, and cause their children to blush for them, by submitting to what they felt to be an
injustice.
Mr. JOHN TUNSTALL, Dearham, said the subject they had next to consider was an important one, and the stake they were contending was for life and death to them. "If," said he, "we had resisted the masters 30 years ago, we should be more
respected by them today. We all seem to be unanimous in resisting the reduction. Let there be no black sheep. When the time comes we must act in unison, and then we shall become brighter and better. If it is ruled by the lodges to fall, let us fall
like men with our faces to the foe. You, Mr. Chairman, have appealed to our religious principles. Now I've been thinking of a scheme to get out of this difficulty. When the cattle plague visited this country, national prayers were put up, and we were
spared our beef. When the Prince of Wales was thought to be dying, national prayers were again put up, and the Prince was restored. What, think you, if we have a national prayer for our 10 per cent? (Cheers & great laughter.)
The CHAIRMAN summed up the various reports and said that if a good united prayer were tried, it might soften the hearts of the masters, and induce them not to exact the pound of flesh from the men.
Mr. DAVID CAIRNS quoted some statistics of prices for cutting coal in the high and low seams, the average of which was short of 2s 8d per ton, while coal at the pit mouth was selling for 13s. He then quoted the following extract from the Belfast
correspondent of the Colliery Guardian of December 3:— "The supply of English, Welsh and Scotch coals is larger. Prices, which had slightly risen during the prevalence of the strike in Lancashire, have now fallen to their original figure,
and their current prices are now as follows viz.:— Cumberland, 17s 6d to 18s 6d; Crosby, 18s 6d to 19s 6d; Scotch, 14s to 15s; hand picked 16s to 17s; Welsh through and through, 15s to 16s; large do., 20s; Lancashire, 26s to 27s. A large quantity
is being sent on consignment."
Mr. SIMPSON now moved that the whole meeting resolve itself into committee to consider what resolution was to be adopted; and after an hour's deliberation, the following resolution was adopted without a dissentient voice:— "That this meeting
considers the proposed reduction of 10 per cent. Unreasonable, and pledges itself to accept no reduction without the same be submitted to a board of arbitration, and that a letter be sent to the coalowners' secretary informing them of the decision."
This concluded the proceedings.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cairns, David | | | |
| Carruthers, John | | | |
| Coulthard, William | | | |
| Faulder, Robert | | | |
| Grimshaw, William | | | |
| Kelswick, — | | | |
| Sharpe, Andrew | | Miners' Agent | |
| Simpson, Jonathan | | | |
| Tunstall, John | | | |