28th November 1874
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
Sir,
I assume that Lord Kinnaird, in his letter to you of the 24th inst., refers to "Ansell's Fire-damp Indicator," which is a most ingenious scientific instrument, but one that cannot, I believe, ever come into real, practical, daily use.
In January, 1867, his Lordship advocated, in your columns, its general adoption, in a manner which the mining public who understood the subject deemed to be indiscreet. Myself and others explained, also in your columns, that his proposition could not
i.e. carried out.
I duly appreciate Lord Kinnaird's anxiety to preserve human life, and I have no doubt many persons will be led away by his statements ; but he must forgive me for saying, which I do with great respect, that it seems to me to be manifestly unfair
to the Home Office and to colliery owners and managers that persistent charges of gross neglect should be made against them by one who has not shown that he is competent, by full knowledge of the subject, to form an opinion as to the prevention of
colliery explosions.
Surely the terms "prejudice and defective legislation" cannot apply to all owners and managers of collieries yielding "fire-damp." I consider the words "fleeced the public for the last two years" are quite unworthy of the
writer, and will certainly not lead the "masters" to listen patiently to Lord Kinnaird's violent lecture, which seems to be an unfortunate attempt to set class against class.
I am, Sir, your most obedient servant,
John Brown, Civil Engineer.
Hednesford, near Stratford, Nov. 26.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brown, John | | | |
| Kinnaird, Lord | | | |