12th August 1874
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Accident Funds
Sir,
In your impression of the 4th I see you publish a letter under this head, dated from the House of Commons, and signed "Alexander Macdonald," animadverting upon a statement made by me in the Court of Common Council held on the 30th ult.,
relative to funds raised in 1866, when I was Lord Mayor, by a committee consisting of myself, Messrs. S. Morley, R.C. L. Bevan, Sir Sydney Waterlow, George Moore, J. P. Cassiot, R. N. Fowler, and others equally
well known, for the sufferers by the "recent colliery explosions."
The writer seems to consider that he has surmounted great difficulties in ascertaining who could give information on the subject, to furnish which he professes to think there is great reluctance on the part of those who could do so, and takes credit for
"at least having got an acknowledgement that there is a balance of £7,000 in hand from the Oaks and Talk Funds," and then deals out the fearful threat of his intention to ask in Parliament for a select Committee to inquire into the
working of all these funds.
It is not for me to enter into the question between Mr. Macdonald and the Lord Mayor (Sir A. Lusk) as to the correspondence which has passed between them on the subject, but it is sad to see so much energy wasted upon what might have been
very easily accomplished, for it is quite manifest that Mr. Macdonald need have had no difficulty in ascertaining who had the management of the fund raised at the Mansion-house, as he says he was in communication with the Rev. Sir L. T.
Stamer, the chairman of the Finance Committee of the Talk Colliery Relief Fund, who, as such corresponded with the Mansion-house Committee, and attended there, I think, more than once with a deputation, and also with a member of the Oaks Committee.
Surely these gentlemen could have informed him with whom they corresponded, and in all probability have furnished him with documents supplying the information he required.
All the transactions of the Mansion-house Committee (as of every other committee formed at the Mansion-house for charitable objects) were from day to day made public by your reporter, who attended every meeting and published the proceedings in the daily
papers, and these might have been referred to by Mr. Macdonald.
The total sum received by the Mansion-house Committee, including £295 16s. 2d. for interest on deposits of the subscriptions as they accumulated, was £25,251 12s. 4d. Of this, £1,500 was paid to the Talk Relief Committee, £11,697
to the Oaks Committee, £5,000 to the Ferndale Committee, and £39 18s. gratuities to the secretary and attendants, leaving a balance of £7,014 14s. 4d., of which £6,900 was invested in Consols, and £114 14s. 4d., composed of
sums paid in since the investment, still remains in the bankers' hands. The £6,900 invested now by re-investment of dividends amounts to £8,957 9s. 6d. Stock, in the names of the trustees.
The conditions upon which the public intrusted their subscriptions to the Committee were plainly set out in the advertisements inserted in all the papers, and contained this clause :-
"That the funds raised be devoted to the relief of the families of the sufferers by the recent colliery explosions, and that, in the event of public benevolence furnishing funds more than sufficient to meet the requirements of these objects, the
balance will be retained in the hands of trustees as a nucleus of any similar subscriptions that may be thought necessary at some future time to raise for the purpose of meeting a like calamity."
No similar subscription has since been raised to meet a like calamity, and therefore the balance remains to be appropriated.
The Committee had no discretion as to the disposal of the balance, and however "pertinent" Mr. Macdonald may deem his question, "On whose recommendation did the Committee lock up the money ?" it is clearly unnecessary.
I will only add that I am quite willing to afford any further information relative to the fund raised under my management, and the Committee will, I know, be ready to deal with the balance of the fund according to the terms of their trust ; and I may
assure Mr. Macdonald that there will be no reluctance, on the part of those concerned in raising any of the funds in connexion with the Mansion-house, to furnish every information concerning them.
Yours respectfully,
Lambeth, Aug. 11.
Thomas Gabriel.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bevan, L. | | | |
| Cassiot, J. P. | | | |
| Fowler, R. N. | | | |
| Gabriel, Thomas | | | |
| Lusk, A., Sir | | | |
| MacDonald, Alexander | | | |
| Moore, George | | | |
| Morley, S. | | | |
| Stamer, L. T., Sir | | | |
| Waterlow, Sydney, Sir | | | |