29th July 1874
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Accidents
Sir,
Up to the present the persons connected with the funds collected for colliery accidents remain silent. This may be wise policy ; it is for their consideration alone. Only this let us say to them — they mistake us much if they expect for one moment
we will now leave the subject till we have a full explanation of how every sum was expended that was placed in their hands for the great mine disasters of Lundhill, Hartley, Oaks, Talke-o'-the-Hill, Cymmner, Risca, and all the others to which vast
numbers of our fellow citizens contributed to the aid of the survivors. With this I enclose the copy of a letter I have received from the Rev. Sir L. T. Stamer, rector of Stoke-upon-Trent, and crave that you will afford it a place. I have also a
letter from one of the Committee of the Oaks fund, making a similar charge against the Mansion-house authorities.
Yours,
House of Commons.
A. MacDonald.
"To Alexander MacDonald, Esq., M.P., Stafford.
"Cliffville, Stoke-upon-Trent, July 23, 1874.
" Sir,
Having acted as Chairman of the Finance Committee of the Talke Colliery Accident Relief Fund, I am able to give you some information on the subject referred to in your letter to The Times of the 20th inst.
"On the occurrence of the accident of Talke, on the 13th of December, 1866, a meeting was at once held at Stoke, and it was decided that an appeal should be made on behalf of the sufferers, and that its object should be extended so as to secure not
only what was requisite to meet the distress arising out of this one calamity, but should be sufficient to establish a permanent fund for the relief of similar cases hereafter.
"It was this twofold object that all the subscriptions received by the local committee were given. Undoubtedly they were larger than they would have been had it simply been proposed to provide for the Talke sufferers.
"Concurrently with this, there issued an appeal from the Mansion-house for the relief of the sufferers in the Oaks and Talke explosions conjointly. It was very largely responded to. I forget the exact amount, but I believe it exceeded £20,000.
"Our committee confidently relied on receiving a proportionate share of this fund ; but on communication with the Mansion-house authorities we were asked to furnish them with an actuary's estimate of the cost of relieving the survivors killed at
Talke, and a return of the money we had received. The Mansion-house Committee would make up any deficiency, but no more.
"I was instructed to reply that our appeal had been founded on the intention of doing much more than relieving this incidental distress, so that we could make no estimate of what we should require ; our object being to get as large a sum as
possible, in order to establish a permanent relief fund. The Mansion-house Committee persisted in their view of the case, and it was only under strong pressure that, 11 months after the accident, they gave us a contribution of £1,500. I think they
gave the Oaks Committee about double that sum
"The balance remaining must have been very considerable. I remember it was drawn upon for the Glamorganshire explosion some years ago, but there must still be a large unexpended balance.
"I agree with you that an inquiry ought to be made as to the way in which the surpluses of all these funds have been dealt with.
"At this moment the sum apportioned to this district from the Hartley surplus has never been employed as intended ; and there is a sum of £600 with interest that has yet to be accounted for.
"I send you reports of the Permanent Relief Fund which we have established with the surplus of the Talke Fund, which may interest you.
"If I can give you any further information I shall be happy to do so.
"Yours faithfully,
"Rev. Lovelace T. Stamer. Rector of Stoke-upon-Trent."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| MacDonald, Alexander | | | |
| Stamer, L. T., Sir | | | |
| Stamer, Lovelace T., Rev. | | | |