|
30th April 1874, Page: 3, Column: 4 Local Law CaseCourt of Chancery. — Yesterday (Before the Master of the Rolls.) Vaughan v. Smithson This was a suit to enforce specific performance of an alleged agreement to supply the plaintiff with large quantities of coal from the South Durham and Eldon Collieries. The plaintiff was Thomas Vaughan, ironmaster and manufacturer, of Middlesbrough, Yorkshire, and of Bishop Auckland and Darlington, Durham. The defendants, five in number — Messrs Samuel Smithson, George Roper, H. F. Cradock, Ralph Ward Jackson, and Wm. Charles Ward-Jackson — were the owners of the before mentioned collieries, where they carried on business under the style of "The owners of the South Durham Collieries." The contract in question was partly verbal, but the draft agreement and letters that had passed between the partners were principally relied on as evidence of it. The draft agreement was the plaintiff's allegation, agreed to on the 20th March, 1872. It stipulated that the defendants should supply the plaintiff during the term of seven years with a minimum yearly quantity of 160,000 tons of coal, and a maximum of 280,000 tons. The agreement was to take effect from the 1st July, 1872; the price to be paid for the coal was 5s. 9d. per ton of twenty hundred-weight. There were numerous provisions in the agreement to enable the contract to be worked out, the stipulations being of a most minute nature. One clause provided that if the defendants could not supply the stipulated quantity, they should allow the plaintiff the sum of 6d. per ton on the quantity less than the minimum. Subsequently to the draft agreement being drawn out, the defendants wrote various letters discussing its clauses ; but they eventually declined to carry it out, alleging that they preferred selling their interest in the colliery rather than the produce of it. The plaintiff charged that there was a valid and subsisting agreement, and prayed that it might be specifically performed. There appeared for the plaintiff Mr. Fry, Q.C., and Mr. Proctor; for the defendants were Mr. Southgate, Q.C., and Mr. Chapman Barber. The Master of the Rolls, in giving judgment, said he was not disposed to make contracts unless he was satisfied that the parties entirely intended to make a contract, and not a negotiation. He thought this was a very strong case in favour of the defendants, and that what they intended was negotiation, and not a contract. But although it was not necessary, yet His Honour preferred to put his decision on a broader ground than that. A contract for the sale of ordinary goods, either by instalment or by one delivery, was not a case for specific performance by a Court of Equity, but one for damages for breach of contract. It was, in his opinion, totally out of the question to seriously ask a Court of Equity to enforce the machinery by which a contract was to be carried out. If he made a decree, there would be a summons in Chambers every week, and motions to commit for small breaches of this voluminous agreement. The Court would have to regulate every detailed act of management, and that under the ordinary jurisdiction of specific performance, which really contemplated the performance of a specific act generally in the execution of some document, such as the gravity of a lease. His Honour did not think it his duty to extend the jurisdiction in the manner asked, and dismissed the bill with costs.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||