Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

21st October 1873

Appeal Case

Stirling (Appellant) V. Overseers Of Cleator (Respondents).

This was an appeal on the part of Mr. John Stirling, late of Bridekirk, against the rating by the overseers of Cleator of a piece of ground alleged by them to be used as an iron ore quarry by the appellant.

Counsel for the appellant: Messrs. Thurlow and Dickinson, instructed by Messrs. Brockbank and Helder, Whitehaven Counsel for the respondents: Messrs. MacOubrey and Henry, instructed by Mr. McKelvie, Whitehaven.

Mr. Thurlow said this was a case of appeal from a rate laid on the 10th April last. The first meeting of the Assessment Committee after that date was on June 10th —

Mr. MacOubrey said he must ask for the notice of appeal, and must have it proved.

Mr. Thurlow said he was going to observe that the rate was made on the 10th April, the next meeting of the Assessment Committee was on the 10th June, and the next Quarter Sessions were on the 1st July. He had Mr. Helder there, who would prove the notice of appeal he gave the Assessment Committee, and after that he should be in a position to prove the case.

Mr. Helder (sworn) produced the notice of the days on which the meetings of the Assessment Committee would be held.

Mr. MacOubrey said he must have the notice proved, and the only way to do so was by producing the original notice, or calling the man who served it. Had Mr. Thurlow got the original notice?

Mr. Helder said they attended the committee meeting, and appealed, and were heard.

Mr. MacOubrey: And they rejected your valuation?

Mr. Helder: They did not give us relief, and therefore we came here.

Mr. MacOubrey repeated that the person who appealed must prove the notice of appeal.

Mr. Helder said notice of appeal was served on the Assessment Committee on the 19th September, 1873. He produced a copy of the notice given to the Assessment Committee.

Mr. MacOubrey: It must be shown that it was posted or served.

Mr. Helder: I served it personally upon the Clerk to the Assessment Committee, and the notice to the church wardens and overseers was served by my clerk, Mr. Hooper.

Mr. Hooper, sworn, said that he served a duplicate of the notice personally upon Mr. Leech, one of the churchwardens, and upon the overseers.

Mr. MacOubrey said he should now contend that his friend was too late in his appeal. The rate was made on the 10th April. On the 10th June the appeal came before the Assessment Committee, and they rejected it. Between the 10th June and the 1st July, the opening of the Quarter Sessions, there was abundance of time to give notice of appeal — 21 days — and the other side did not do it. He said that they ought at least to have sent in their grounds and notice of appeal.

The Chairman: When were the sessions?

Mr. Henry: On the 1st July.

The Chairman said sufficient notice could not be given.

Mr. Thurlow said that in answer to Mr. MacOubrey's last objection, he merely had to say that, by the 1st section of the Union Assessment Committee Act, twenty-one days' notice must be given before an appeal. The Assessment Committee sat on the 10th June, and the Quarter Sessions were held on the 1st July. They could not give notice because there were not twenty-one clear days.

The Chairman said he should make a note of Mr. MacOubrey's objection, but he did not think there had been time for a notice of appeal.

Mr. Thurlow said that, having proved the notice of appeal, he must call upon the respondents to begin, as was customary in these cases.

Mr. MacOubrey said that the respondents put in the rate-book, and then the appellant began.

Mr. Thurlow quoted "Archbold's Quarter Sessions," to the effect that in cases of rate appeals the respondent usually began. It was he who made the charge against which the appellant appealed, and he must, therefore, prove it. The rule which appeared to be generally established for poor rate appeals was that where the appellant objected to the rate altogether the respondent began. That, Mr. Thurlow said, he believed was quite decisive, and was well-known law. He therefore called upon Mr. MacOubrey to open his case.

Mr. MacOubrey: I open the case, and simply put in the rate-book.

Mr. Thurlow quoted "Burn's Justice" in support of the former opinion he had given.

Mr. MacOubrey asked if it was intended to be laid down as a proposition of law, that were the churchwardens and overseers assessed a man to the relief of the poor, and he appealed against the rate, the overseers and churchwardens were bound to show that he was really entitled to be rated.

The Chairman thought the distinction was this, that where an appellant had any property, and was liable to be rated, it was for the respondents to show the liability, if he objected to be rated at all; but if the appellant objected to the amount of the rate, he would have to begin. In this case the appellant denied that he had any property to be rated, and therefore it devolved upon the respondents to show that he had such property. The first ground of appeal was that the rate had not been publicly allowed, in due course of law, and the next ground of appeal was that the property was by law exempt from such rate, so that Mr. MacOubrey would see that he must clearly prove that the property was liable to be rated, before calling upon the appellant.

Mr. MacOubrey said that if the Court would reserve the point, he would begin. The matter in hand was a very simple one. The property sought to be rated was what he would call a space of ground, in a district of the parish of Cleator, called Crossfield. The real question, in his opinion, was a very simple one, and it resolved itself into this — that the real matter of dispute arose out of the liability to be rated for a piece of land under which large wealth undoubtedly had been found. The real question was, no doubt, opened out by the fact that mines were not liable to be rated. A man might dig into the earth, and bring up coal, iron, silver, or anything he could find in the bowels of the earth, and was not obliged to pay one farthing to the relief of the poor in respect of these. Now, he said this place in dispute was an open quarry, but the appellant said that it was not an open quarry, but a mine. He said that the respondents rated the appellant for the acre of land; but they said that they had nothing on the acre of ground, and that they got the contents of this deep chasm by means of a subterraneous passage, and therefore they were miners. There was an open quarry, and an old shaft near it, belonging to the same owner, and he thought he would utilise the shaft by running a drift from it to the bottom of the quarry, where the ore lay, and then he should have a mine, not a quarry. The real facts of the case were within a nutshell. The question was. Was this an open quarry, or was it a mine? If it was a mine, it was not liable to be rated to the relief of the poor, but if it was a quarry, it was liable. That was clearly the only question. He should now proceed to call witnesses.

John Alexander Dixon, examined by Mr. Henry, deposed that he was a mining engineer of considerable experience. Had been a mining engineer for something like ten years. During the last five years had been taking a more active part, in connection with an eminent mining engineer of the district — Mr. Dixon — supervising about twenty-five iron ore mines. Had lately surveyed the quarry at Montreal, the property of the appellants. Made the plan produced. The quarry was open at the top, and the dimensions there were 83 feet by 47 feet. The lower part or base of the quarry was 134 feet by 80 feet. The greatest depth of the quarry was 75 feet. It was quite daylight on the floor of the quarry. Saw men working there by daylight. Artificial light was not required. In his opinion this was a quarry. On one occasion he went down by means of ladders and on another down the shaft. The ore was blasted trailed along a drift-way to the shaft, and lifted to the top. The ore could be taken out of the quarry without the drift, but in his opinion it was more convenient that the drift should be used. The length of the drift was 80 or 90 feet. Thought the shaft existed before the quarry was opened, but was not sure. Knew an iron ore quarry of Mr. Ainsworth's near the appellant's. It was a similar quarry. The open top of that quarry would be about 100 by 200 feet. Had made an estimate of the annual value of this quarry, and put it at £6,500. About a dozen men worked in the quarry, and the output was about 50 tons of ore, valued at £80, per day. Ore was selling at upwards of 30s a ton. — Cross examined by Mr. Thurlow: Went down the quarry about a week ago. Went down the shaft. Saw one small pillar at the far end of the drift. The ore originally came to within about 30 or 40 feet from the surface of the earth. Had never seen ore brought up the hole. In Mr. Ainsworth's quarry there was a tramway along which the ore was brought up. Formed his conclusion as to the quantity of ore being got daily from the number of men at work, and the information he got from them. Was not aware that a large portion of the ore was taken out before the surface opening was made. In going down a shaft used artificial light. —

By the Court: The ore was taken along the drift-way and up the shaft by artificial light.

At this stage of the proceedings — twenty minutes past six — the Court was adjourned until ten o'clock on Wednesday morning.

Second Day — Wednesday

The Cleator Appeal Case

The hearing of this appeal was resumed this morning at about half-past ten o'clock.

Edward Crumpton, examined by Mr. Henry, deposed that he was an engineer and architect of fifteen years experience. Understood quarrying, and had had the supervision of quarries for getting stone for bridges and culverts. Had inspected the quarry in question. Took the photographs of the quarry produced. The photographs were taken from the bottom of the quarry about noon on Saturday last, looking south and south-east. Made the sectional diagrams produced, and they were correct. The weather on Saturday was rather dull. Found photography useful in his business, and had learnt it. Went down to the quarry by the shaft and drift. Went without a light, and groped his way along the drift. Found about twelve or fifteen men at work in the quarry. The men in the quarry were working by day light. No artificial light would be required in witness's opinion to work the quarry. Could see and speak to the man when at work from the top. They were removing additional surface soil from the top last Saturday for the purpose of exposing more ore. There were no pillars to support the rock within the quarry area. There was a piece of ore left standing between two drifts which formed the letter Y, and the piece of ore standing was the piece between the arms of the letter. The shaft was also used for getting ore from mines north of the quarry. There were a series of underground workings extending north of the quarry. There was a complete network of workings between the quarry and the shaft, and the ore got from them was brought up the shaft. These were mines. They were the property of Mr. Stirling. Saw Mr. Nelson go down the series of ladders, shown on the photograph, into the quarry. In witness's opinion the locus in quo was a quarry and not a mine, because the ore was got in the light of day, and the overlying strata had been removed. Would call a mine, working underground to get any kind of mineral or to blow up a fortification. — Cross-examined by Mr. Thurlow: It was not now witness's business to inspect mines. Was a civil engineer, and his practice was chiefly on railways. Was not a mining engineer. The quarry was about 80 feet in depth from the original surface. Had been down the quarry twice, and on both occasions went down and came up by means of the shaft. The distance from the shaft, along the drift, to the place in dispute, would be about 50 yards. It was not as light in the shaft and drift as in the quarry. The men at the bottom of the shaft were not mining, they were merely loading the tubs as they came in. They had candlelight. If the place were witness's he would take the ore up the shaft, and if there were no shaft, he would form an inclined plane for the purpose. Did not care how the surface was bared, if it was away, and there was light enough to work, he should call it a quarry. The side of the quarry was very irregular. It varied from outwards at the foot to perpendicular and outwards to the top, as shown in the sectional plan.

James Nelson, examined by Mr. Henry, deposed that he was a contractor for railways and public works. Had been ten years partner in the firm of Nelson and Company, Carlisle. The firm had owned, and been lessees of quarries for the purpose of their works. Was employed by the appellant two or three years ago to remove between 9,000 and 10,000 cubic yards at this place. This was done by an inclined plane, for the purpose of baring the ore. Made an inclined permanent railway from the adjoining branches of the Cleator Railway to the iron ore. This was laid with the object not only of taking away the excavated earth, but to take away the ore upon. If there had been any intension of working the quarry as a mine, there would have been no necessity for baring the ore at all. Made the railroad by the instructions of the appellant, and was paid so much a yard for it. Thought the place was a quarry, because it was a large open space, worked by daylight, where no artificial light was being used, and where ironstone was being quarried. The place was worked as a quarry where blasting was used. Descended the quarry on Saturday by two ladders, and saw the men working there by daylight. A further quantity of earth was then being removed from the top. The effect would be to widen the area of the quarry. Saw no pillars in the quarry. — Cross-examined by Mr. Thurlow: Was not a mining engineer. Never inspected a mine — inspected a quarry. When the men were taking the earth away from the top, it did not occur to witness that they were doing it for their own protection. The earth was being sent down a hole into the bottom of the quarry, to be lighted by means of the shaft. In excavating the earth, under the contract, witness touched the ore on one occasion. About two years ago witness saw the stratum of limestone being quarried from the top of the iron ore.

At this stage the case was adjourned to admit of the county business being dealt with. On the resumption of the case, the first witness called was

Richard Pickering, examined by Mr. Henry, deposed that he was a civil engineer, at Whitehaven, and had had considerable experience in quarries during the last twenty-five years, and in superintending public works. Examined the quarry last Wednesday. Thought it was a quarry because it was worked in open day by sun-light, and because the surface had been stripped off in the ordinary way of making quarries. Saw the quarry from the top of the narrowest part. Could see all the men working. It was a common thing quarries to under cut the stone so that the upper part projected through it was not commonly done in Cumberland. The quarry belonging to Mr. Ainsworth was rated. It was about double the length, double the width, and thirty feet deeper than Mr. Stirling's. The ore was taken out, until very lately, by means of an inclined plane.

Henry Charlton, of Whitehaven, manager to Mr. Phillips, contractor for the Whitehaven Wet Dock. Had had sixteen years' experience in the management of contracts. Had inspected the iron ore quarry in question. It was a quarry in his opinion.

John Fairhurst, manager for Messrs. Wood and Co., of Bradford, a firm employing a large number of hands, deposed that he had seen the place, and it was, in his opinion a quarry.

Mr. MacOubrey said that he had other witnesses on the point, but he should not call them, as their evidence was of a similar nature to that already heard, and he would here close his case.

Mr. Thurlow said that before proceeding any further he said that it was for the respondents in this case to make out a perfectly clear case that the appellant was entitled to be rated. He was that had not been done, and now that their case was closed they could bring forward no further evidence. As the Court was perfectly well aware no mines, except coal mines, were rateable. Therefore, although quarries were rated, and very properly rated, it was perfectly clear that before the respondents could show that the appellant ought to be rated for this mine, they ought to prove clearly that the place in dispute was not a mine, but a quarry, and he submitted that so far they had not proved it in any way. He would just call the attention of the Court to the evidence brought before it, and he would ask whether the mode of working the quarry, or hole, or mine, or whatever they liked to call it, was the real test as to whether it was a mine or not. They had not had as yet any evidence adduced that any ore had at any time been removed from the surface of the mine — he believed that was indisputable. They had evidence that the ore had never been brought up through the hole which was in dispute, and they had also evidence that on the contrary it had been brought up along the drift, and up the shaft in the ordinary mining way. He put it to the Court whether or not — as the evidence now stood — the whole of the operations did not show to their mind conclusively that this place had been worked as a mining operation all along.

The Chairman said the Bench were unanimous in the opinion that Mr. Thurlow should proceed with his case.

Mr. Thurlow said that his client did not come into that court with the intention of robbing the poor. This question was a matter of principle with him, and therefore he had thought it better to appeal. Towards the end of 1869 Mr. Stirling took a lease of this property for 21 years, and in November he sunk a shaft — No. 7 on the plan — and worked it with considerable success till September, 1870. He then found that as he was making a drift in the mine the ore reached nearly to the surface, near where what he called the shaft No. 9, and which the other side called a quarry. It was then that he sunk the No. 9 shaft as a ventilating shaft. That shaft was the same size as No. 7 shaft, or thereabouts. As the miners got nearer the surface, Mr. Stirling began to consider the question whether it would be advisable to work the mine from the surface, and he had also to consider whether there was not some danger from Keekle, a river running close by there, and a river rising very rapidly in rainy season. Mr. Stirling therefore entered into an agreement with Mr. Nelson, the gentleman who had given his evidence to them to-day, to remove the upper part of the surface close round this shaft No. 9. The surface was removed, and nearly all of it, or to a very large extent, used as an embankment to prevent the river Keekle from overflowing. Immediately after Mr. Nelson's works were completed, Mr. Stirling came to the conclusion that it would not be advisable to work the mine from the top, and it never had been worked from the top, and not an ounce of ore had been taken from the surface at any time whatsoever. It would very naturally happen, as the support was taken away, that the hole at No. 9 shaft would become larger and larger, and this had occurred all along, that was to say since 1870, when they began to work the place. He should call evidence to prove that as the miners worked underneath this place the shaft had been getting wider and wider, and that was what the other side called a quarry — that was to say, nothing more or less than a shaft originally used as a ventilating shaft, and not used as a shaft for hoisting ore. This shaft, he said had got gradually wider and wider until it had become what they say in the photographs. He had got photographs, which he thought would give the Court rather a better view than those the other side had put in. There was no doubt that there was now a large hole. The whole business had cost a great deal of money, and the Court might depend upon it that if Mr. Stirling could have worked the place as a quarry he would have done so. There was such a demand for iron at the present time that the rating would be little or nothing at all in comparison. He thought that when he called his evidence he should have quite sufficient to show that the shaft was simply made larger by the gradual taking away of the iron ore underneath, and the earth consequently falling in on all sides. This was the real history of the shaft and the property generally up to the present time. Now it appeared that on October 10th, 1872 ¸for the first time this mine was rated, and it was on that occasion that Mr. Stirling protested against the rate. He found he was too late to appeal, and he paid under protest. The next rate was made on the 10th April, and was also paid under protest. Mr. Stirling appealed to the Assessment Committee, and they said very properly that they were there to try whether property was under-rated or over-rated, and not to try the question of principle, and that Mr. Stirling's proper remedy was at the Quarter Sessions. Mr. Stirling took that advice, and was now before the Court. So far, he thought they had got to the present state of things. He must now put before the Court the proposition as to whether he should cal the evidence he intended to call on behalf of the appellant to prove the case that he did when he first commenced to speak; that was, that he considered that the respondents had not proved that this was a quarry within the meaning of the Act. He thought before doing this that he should call the attention of the court to the case as stated in Bunrus' Justice (Queen v. Sedgeley) inasmuch as that was really upheld in the Queen v. Brettle.

The CHAIRMAN asked if Mr. Thurlow had seen the case Rex v. Dunsford?

Mr. THURLOW said that was another point he should have to go into. In the Queen v. Brettle, where the appellants were rated to the relief of the poor for clay pits underground; the excavations were the same as those used in coal mines, and Lord Tanterden said that his opinion would be the same as the opinion he gave in the Queen v. Sedgeley. Now that case determined that they were to look to the mode in which the article was obtained, and not into the chemical or geological character of the material. He thought they would be bound by that as to whether this was a quarry or a mine, and he should ask if the respondents had in any way proved that iron ore was obtained in any way like a quarry. Certainly most people's opinion of a quarry was, that it was an excavation dug in the earth, and having the material wheeled out to the surface in small quarries by means of wheelbarrows, and in larger ones by carts going down an inclined place, or, where the decent was very steep, by trucks placed on rails on a steel inclined plane, and drawn up by ropes. He should now call witnesses.

William Barrow Turner, of the firm of Messrs. Wadham, Turner, and Strongitharm, examined by Mr. Thurlow, deposed that he was consulting engineer to Mr. Stirling, and know the mines. In sinking the shaft No. 9 at the place now in question it was found that the ore came within 24 feet of the top. The Keekle ran over the mine about twenty yards from No. 9 shaft. The intention at the time was to lighten the weight on the mine to prevent the Keekle overflowing it, and there was an intention at that time to work the place as a quarry. They were rather deceived by the shaft No. 9. There was a thin shell of limestone under the surface, and overlying the ore. Found when the surface was removed that the limestone was thicker at the sides than against the shaft, and that they had bored through the thinnest part. Found that the cost of removing the limestone was so great that they began to consider whether they had not made a mistake in removing so much limestone, and sooner than throw good money after bad, they continued to ordinary system of mining, by means of drift-ways through No. 7 shaft. No. 9 shaft had gradually got larger and weaker owing to the mining operations going on underneath. The limestone naturally fell in of itself as the ore was taken away. The place had never been worked as an open work. The workings coming within 6 or 8 feet of the limestone, it had been usual to draw the pillars back towards the shaft, and as they did so the shell of limestone gave way. No ore had ever been brought out of the pit but up the shaft. The ore had never been worked from the surface. The mine being so near the river it was essential to prevent any shrinking as much as possible, and the fact of taking away the debris prevented the mine sinking, and prevented the overflow of the river. The operations carried on at this point were strictly in accordance with mining operations. Miners were employed, not quarrymen. If the limestone had been thicker it would probably have been supported by timber. The Mines Regulation Act would not allow them, in his opinion, to raise ore to the surface by means of an inclined plain as it would be dangerous. Mr. Ainsworth's quarry bore no resemblance to this mine; it was what he would call an "open cast," which was really a kind of quarry. It was a much larger affair than this — five or even ten times the size. The process of getting the ore and allowing the limestone to fall in, and then taking it up the shaft, would be pursued in the other seams in the mine and would be pursued till the mine was worked out. — Cross-examined by Mr. MacOubrey: The ladders were of great service. Scores of pits had ladders by which the men travelled in and out. In sinking a pit, men did not generally jump down 20 feet. They generally went down in a cage. Had known a man jump down. At one of the largest mines in Cumberland all the men went up and down by ladders, without a single exception. This was at Hodbarrow, Millom. The river had overflowed, and filed the mine twice over. In the open area in the bottom of the pit the men, in getting the ore, worked partially in open day. In places they were not able to work except by candlelight. Had never seem them in the open space, but only under cover. A little more surface earth had been recently taken away, to take off the superincumbent weight, and protect the men. — By the Court: Quarrymen's wages would be about 32s per week, and miners' about 45s.

Alfred Hodgetts, examined by Mr. Dickinson, deposed that he was the managing partner of Messrs. Fletcher and Hodgetts, and was also a mining engineer, and had 20 years experience in mining. Examined the locus in quo early in September. Saw men working in the burrowings underneath. Did not see that they could work beneficially in the bottom of the quarry. They could blast the floor, but it would be costly. Could see the men working from the top. Certainly did not consider this a quarry. The operations carried on there were those of a mine. Had seen numbers of iron quarries. The working was not at all similar in them to that in this. In a quarry it is usually the case to take off a quantity of the surface down to the iron ore. The workmen then commence on the top of the ore, and blast downwards, by which they get an immense advantage, 30 or 40 tons sometimes coming down at one shot. In this mine they began at the bottom, and worked with a roof over them as long as it would stand, and the blasting would be less effective. — Cross examined by Mr. MacOubrey: The men witness saw were working by daylight.

George Grey, examined by Mr. Dickinson, deposed that he had been connected with mining operations for 40 years, and had been in Mr. Stirling's service 12 years, ever since his mines commenced, and was that gentleman's underground manager. Knew the mine in question perfectly well, and heard Mr. Turner's description of it. Was prepared to say that in his opinion Mr. Turner gave a proper and true description of everything. The men worked in the mine three shifts of men in twenty-four hours.

Mr. MacOubrey: They could not have daylight at night as well. (Laughter.)

Mr. Thurlow: No, that is rather against you, isn't it. You lose twelve hours. (Laughter.)

Examination continued: The men do not work at the base of the pit; it would make a hole and water would collect in it. Did not think the men would work at the base of the mine. They would have no orders to do so. Knew the quarry Mr. Stirling had at Todholes, and it was not in any way like the place in dispute. No ore had ever been taken from the top of the pit now in question. Miners and not quarrymen were employed. — Cross-examined by Mr. MacOubrey: Todholes were originally a mine. Found it more convenient to make a quarry of it.

Henry Woolcock, examined by Mr. Dickinson, deposed that he was a mining engineer of experience, and had the management of the mines of Messrs. Hannay and Co., Ulverston. Had seen the place in question, and had made a model of it. Witness exhibited the modal and explained it. The place now in question was originally a shaft for ventilation purposes, and the surface had since broken down, as could be now seen. Did not know that any one saw the earth fall; it would be dangerous. When Mr. Nelson finished his excavations, the shaft at the place in question was about eight feet square at the opening.

John Jenkins, examined by Mr. Thurlow, said he was agent and general manager for Mr. Stirling¸ at Montreal. Knew the place in dispute. Had had twenty eight years experience of mines. Had heard the evidence of Mr. Turner, and the other witnesses who had seen the mine, and it was, in witness's opinion, correct. Paid the rate for Mr. Stirling under protest.

Richard Cousins, examined by Mr. Dickinson, deposed that he was a contractor. He had had 25 years experience. Had seen the place in question, and had seen how it was worked. Considered that it was mining, not quarrying.

William Dickinson, examined by Mr. Thurlow, deposed that he had had great mining experience, and having heard the evidence given that day, the place was, in his opinion, a mine.

James Davidson, examined by Mr. Thurlow, said he was a mining manager for Lord Leconfield. Had heard the evidence that day, and they way the hole was worked, and he thought it was a mine.

This concluded the appellant's case, and the Court then adjourned until ten o'clock this Thursday morning.

Third Day — Thursday.

The Cleator Appeal Case.

The hearing of this appeal was resumed this morning, with Mr. Thurlow's address on behalf of the appellant. The learned counsel very carefully commented upon the evidence, and recapitulated the history of the mine which he had given in his opening address. The learned counsel proceeded to quote definitions of mines and quarries, given in law books, in which a mine was described as "a way or passage underground." He also gave definitions from dictionaries of terms, and contended that the place in question was a mine and not a quarry, and therefore not liable to this rate. There was in this case no working from the top, it could not properly be worked from the top; there was no tramway down like there was in quarries, everything was done strictly in accordance with mining operations. He therefore asked the Bench to allow this appeal, and order the rate to be returned to the appellant. — Mr. MacOubrey addressed the Court on the part of the respondents. He laid stress upon the mode of working, and said his witnesses distinctly proved that no artificial light was used during daytime; it was worked by the light of haven, and only at night-time was artificial light required. If one single particle of anything was raised in the way of a quarry, then this place was rateable. The Bench retired at five minutes before twelve o'clock to consider their decision, and on their return decided that the rate must be confirmed. — On the application of Mr. MacOubrey, the Bench granted costs.

This concluded the business of the Sessions.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ainsworth, —    Mine Owner  
Brockbank, —    Solicitor  
Charlton, Henry    Manager  
Cousins, Richard    Contractor  
Crumpton, Edward    Engineer  
Davidson, James    Mine Manager  
Dickinson, —    Barrister  
Dickinson, William      
Dixon, John Alexander    Mining Engineer  
Fairhurst, John    Manager  
Fletcher, —      
Grey, George      
Helder, —    Solicitor  
Henry, —    Barrister  
Hodgetts, Alfred    Managing Director  
Hooper, —    Clerk  
Jenkins, John    Agent  
Leconfield, Lord    Mine Owner  
MacOubrey, —    Barrister  
McKelvie, —    Solicitor  
Nelson, James    Contractor  
Phillips, —    Contractor  
Pickering, Richard    Civil Engineer  
Stirling, John    Mine Owner  
Strongitharm, —    Engineer  
Thurlow, —    Barrister  
Turner, William Barrow    Engineer  
Wadham, —    Engineer  
Woolcock, Henry    Mining Engineer  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Crossfield (Iron Ore)  Crossfield (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print